Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you think there will be a second coming?

891 replies

LuluBellaBlue · 03/01/2020 18:29

This is inspired by the new Netflix show Messiah, about a second coming.

I really hope this doesn’t upset or offend anyone and people can share their beliefs and thoughts openly and without prejudice or judgement as I know this can be very sensitive for some people.

Following on from —binge— watching this series I did a bit of googling and it seems both Christian and Muslim regions predict this. (Not researched if any others do yet)

I’m not very well informed about different regions but the concept of this programme has really interested me, I find it fascinating that this could, maybe? actually happen!

Do you think there could be a second coming?!

(And what would it actually mean for the world? A rise in consciousness? Mass healing???)

YABU - no don't be so daft!
YANBU - yes, this could happen, why not?!

OP posts:
Animum2 · 04/01/2020 12:52

I have respect for those who need to believe in stuff like that but I can live without it, not an atheist but just a non believer

AlternativePerspective · 04/01/2020 12:47

@ PhilCornwall1 or the other one I’ve heard it’s that it’s a test of faith.

Fuck that.

I’ve also heard people say that if someone isn’t cured of an illness it’s because their belief in god wasn’t strong enough. Hideous.

PhilCornwall1 · 04/01/2020 11:41

Satan is the one giving you an illness, it's him who makes somebody murder.

Alternatively, bad things happen and not for a specific reason and is not controlled by some "higher" being, be it as people refer to them, god or his mate Satan. As I've stated on here, I don't believe in god, so obviously don't believe in the other.

Yes, sickness happens for a reason, I asked the reason why mine did, medical professionals couldn't tell me the reason as they actually don't ultimately know why it happens. That for me is good enough, I have just been unlucky, end of, nothing I can do about it.

It just makes me laugh when challenged about why someone's god would do something, there is generally the response "ah he didn't do that". Well that's convenient isn't it?

AlternativePerspective · 04/01/2020 11:40

If you do believe in God then by default you also have to believe in Satan. Satan is the one giving you an illness, it's him who makes somebody murder. except Christians say that the bad in the world is down to the fact that God gave us free will.

Also, if God is responsible for the good then he is also responsible for the bad. Amazing that when people go through hard times they say it’s all down to free choice/Satan/whatever other reason, but if good happens then it’s “hallelujah praise the lord!”

You can’t have it both ways. Either God is responsible for everything or *nothing.

Also, if God is all powerful then there wouldn’t be a Satan, because there wouldn’t have been the chance that a 3rd of the angels could have gone against him.

If God existed and wanted to defeat Satan, then he would. So I think that all throws the whole god exists argument out of the water tbh.

Somanysocks · 04/01/2020 11:27

If you don't believe in God then you can hardly blame Him for all the bad and sickness in the world.

If you do believe in God then by default you also have to believe in Satan. Satan is the one giving you an illness, it's him who makes somebody murder.

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 11:16

You said that two of the gospels are 'most likely written by eyewitnesses' - which ones ?

Sorry, I missed this. too busy contemplating Robin Hood

I say 'most likely' because we cannot know for certain, but from very early on the names were associated with the gospels - and this doesn't change across thousands of copies in existence. There's no clear reason to think these names were attached later. The gospels of Matthew and John could well have been written by the apostles Matthew and John - Matthew, as a tax collector would have been educated to such a level as to be able to author this gospel, and his emphasis on OT prophecy and theology chimes with his status as a Jew. John is likely to have authored John, after a period of reflection on his experience with Jesus - his theology stands alone among the gospels as something a little more reflective. Mark was a companion of Peter, and Luke as a companion of Paul would have known a great many other witnesses to the events and took great pains to create a historically reliable account in his role as a historian. Mark was most probably written around AD 60, Mat/Luke between 60-70, and John 90. The first three at least well within the time of eyewitnesses to corroborate or to condemn as utter bollocks. The later dating of the gospel tends to come from scholars who won't accept earlier dating because Jesus' prediction of the fall of the temple in AD 70 would then have to be prophetic. Obviously it is only with caution I accept these dates, and I do not base my entire faith on them. I would not lose faith if I was proven to be misguided in the dating and authorship of the gospels, because faith is so much deeper than that - but I stand convinced that the evidence is there and is robust.

PhilCornwall1 · 04/01/2020 11:07

@AlternativePerspective very well put. In the eyes of MN that would be a controlling relationship and the advice would be to LTB after all ducks were put in a row.

AlternativePerspective · 04/01/2020 10:59

No. But even if you do believe in a God, I’m genuinely baffled as to why and why you would want to follow him.

The God who is portrayed in the bible is one whose grace depends on your love for him on accepting him into your life, and only if you accept god into your heart will you receive the ever lasting life. The first commandment is about loving God and only god, and loving God above all else.

Can you imagine if this was a post on here from a person posting about how their parent insisted that they would only inherit if they loved them unconditionally above everything else and gave their life to them? People would say the parent was toxic and to cut them out. So if this isn’t acceptable for an earthly parent, then why should it be for a so-called heavenly one.

Personally I believe that most faith isn’t actually based on love, but on fear of what might happen if you don’t believe.

PhilCornwall1 · 04/01/2020 10:56

@LadyFlumpalot

That perfectly sums up the Bible! Grin

LadyFlumpalot · 04/01/2020 10:54
Somanysocks · 04/01/2020 10:49

There seems to be quite a lot of misunderstanding about the Second Coming where people say 'oh he would be sectioned'. It won't be just some bloke turning up and saying it, according to the Bible, whether you believe or not, it will be definite, it will be final, there will be no intervention by mortals. It will be the end of the world as we know it.

longwayoff · 04/01/2020 10:43

This is a pointless discussion. Faith is faith so it doesn't require evidence, just belief and the conviction that your belief is the correct one. Fact is fact. Evidence is required to establish it as such. The two can rarely combine.

PhilCornwall1 · 04/01/2020 10:41

That could all be put down to chance but i truly believe everything happens for a reason,

Well, if God does exist and makes sure things happen, I've got some fucking hard questions for him to answer and if he is responsible for my illness, he can get fucked!

DobbyLovesSocks · 04/01/2020 10:31

I consider myself to be religious - I was confirmed several years ago and I serve in my local church. I spoke with the vicar at the time of my confirmation as I have always had issues with the creed - specifically, born of the virgin Mary. She explained to me that words had different meanings back then - virgin would have meant young, unmarried woman rather than today's meaning of woman who has never had sex. this helped me when it came to making my vows.

As far as my beliefs go, I think there was a man called Jesus around at the time, historical records tell us this was the case however I think he may have just been a very talented person (magician, sleight of hand or doctor) and was able to 'cure' people who would otherwise have died. His teachings tell us to be kind to each other and happy with what we have rather than jealous of our neighbor which i think is just a nice way to live your life. You earn mega bucks then good for you, me Im happy with what I have (although if you want to bung me a tenner then yes please lol).

Its known that 'Christmas' was adopted by the church as a mix of the pagan winter festival and incorporating Jesus' birth. I don't know if historical records show that Jesus was born in Bethlehem. I have always questioned how we have a set date for his birth (25/12) but not for his death. No-one has been able to answer that one for me. I think if we question anything too deeply it starts to unravel and for me its just a nice story to believe in - it doesn't do me any harm. It's when religions hijack it for their own gain (extremists)

I believe in God in that i think there is a higher being looking over us all and making sure some things happen (greater good, fate whatever). For instance, if I hadn't have been offered a last minute place at a uni I hadn't even applied for i would never have moved to the town i now live in and met my husband. That could all be put down to chance but i truly believe everything happens for a reason, it may not be clear at the time and it may SUCK but it all becomes clear eventually. I do not think God sends us anything we cannot deal with.

Second coming, I'm not sure about. As PP have said, anyone claiming to be the son of god would be committed for insanity.

I do believe in heaven and hope that I will be reunited with all the family members i have lost over the years - though when i start thinking about form we will take (i.e do we stay the age we died at) my head starts to hurt

scarecrowhead · 04/01/2020 10:30

You said that two of the gospels are 'most likely written by eyewitnesses' - which ones ?

nowaypose · 04/01/2020 10:29

I don't even think there has been a first coming.

This.

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 10:28
Grin

I quite liked the BBC Robin Hood with Jonas Armstrong. Yes, it was a bit crap overall but he was Robin in my mind. Grin

Anyway. I've not tried to make out that there are contemporary extra biblical sources, I've only ever referenced the near contemporary sources in those terms, because they are still of historical value and considered by most scholars to be of such. I've mentioned the gospels as contemporary histories because the balance of evidence reveals them to be so, even while including bias. And a lot of ancient writings include bias of one sort or another. But I'm not going to roll out a contemporary letter from a Roman governors when there isn't one. Again, it would be highly unlikely for anything like this to exist about someone like Jesus, even allowing for how comprehensive the Romans were in their record keeping. The fact that he's included in Josephus and Tacitus speaks volumes about his existence. And I've referenced those sources, and the biblical writings, and the early Christian writings.

I'm not insisting on evidence that is not there, as you say, any theologian or historian would baulk at that. I'm describing what is there, and as a theologian I think what is there makes a very good case for his existence and certain facts about his life and death. Of course we must treat these things with caution, but to say there is no evidence is disingenuous and not in line with the majority opinion in scholarly circles.

decktheantlers · 04/01/2020 10:26

There will be a second coming
And I'm a Christian who has done my research. The sad part is it's really not about proof but belief. When it happens you will remember me 😂

DurhamDurham · 04/01/2020 10:23

I think if there was a second coming no one would believe it, there have apparently been people through the years who have claimed to be the second coming but they've been classed as mad or just ridiculed. So how would we know if it was the second coming and how do we know it hadn't already happened and we've had the person locked up in a mental health facility?
If there was a second coming they would have to do something big to get everyone's attention, a lot of healing the ill, feeding the hungry on a grand scale.
Then they'd probably be assassinated.
As we're on the brink of what could be another war it would be interesting if it happened now.

SaskiaRembrandt · 04/01/2020 10:19

And Robin Hood is real. Obviously. But not the Kevin Costner version of him. Are you saying he didn't have an American accent? Ha, next you'll be telling me Henry VIII bore no resemblance to Jonathan Rhys Meyers!

IncrediblySadToo · 04/01/2020 10:17

People scoff at older children still believing in Santa, they say they must lack intelligence & critical thinking.

...and yet, some of the people doing the scoffing believe in Jesus/God/second coming... all based on a bunch of toss, written by a bunch of old men to control the masses.

SaskiaRembrandt · 04/01/2020 10:16

Do you mean you want me to copy out portions from Josephus, from the gospels, the Pauline epistles, Clement of Rome etc? I can do that, I just know on these types of threads that could get incredibly tedious very quickly! I have made reference to the sources - what do you mean by saying I only use secondary sources? Is it because I provided links to writings about the sources? If so I apologise - I have to say I really struggle when people simply post a series of links, it's annoying! - but I felt that link did give a good overview of the sources in question without bias. I can see that as a historian that's not what you were after, but some might find it interesting. What would you like me to quote? I don't want to bog us down too much

Oh no, don’t post full transcripts, I don’t think normal people would enjoy that at all Grin Just links to places these things can be found.

But I've reiterated that the gospels are from eyewitness accounts - that two of them are most likely written by eyewitnesses, and the other two by companions of eyewitnesses. These stand the criterion of historical authenticity in that they can be tested robustly against the culture, customs, geography, climate of the exact time and area - even the names used have been proven to be consistent with names in that time and place, quite difficult to insert later on from authors detached by time and place. The evidence for Christ stands tall because of the sheer amount of writings, in Christian and non Christian sources, within a short time. As a historian, you will know how these things work in terms of antiquity, and I stand with my assertion that for an unknown messianic pretender there are a surprising amount of sources.

Again, what primary sources are you thinking I have not included or not read? I'd really like to establish what you mean by this so I can comment further. I'm sorry if I have not been clear enough..

What I’m asking for are accounts written while Christ was alive. For example (and I know he didn’t) something like Cicero writing a letter and mentioning that Christ bloke was still being a nuisance, or records of his encounters with the authorities. That type of thing. As you say, one of the problems with this period is that the records are often fragmentary or non-existent, but the Romans are unusually generous with their written accounts.
Again, I’m not disputing his existence, I’m inclined to believe there was such a person. But it’s not at all helpful to either Christianity or history to insist evidence exists when it clearly doesn’t. Every theologian I know would baulk at doing that. They would say on the balance of probabilities he probably did but would also agree that what evidence these is, is later and has to be treated with caution.

scarecrowhead · 04/01/2020 10:07

Which gospels are written by eyewitnesses? Mark is the eldest gospel, dating from around AD70.

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 10:01

Kong Arthur I saw that film - he went bonkers and climbed the Empire State building with Lancelot under his arm grin

Grin

And Robin Hood is real. Obviously. But not the Kevin Costner version of him.

Insideimsprinting · 04/01/2020 10:01

I'm interested in religion, from what I remember no one was convinced about jesus in his day and they crucified him as a result. It wasn't until after his death did they see what he was trying to do.
Secknd coming?? Who ever it was would probably be seen as batshit initially to until after the event and it was looked back on with hindsight.