Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you think there will be a second coming?

891 replies

LuluBellaBlue · 03/01/2020 18:29

This is inspired by the new Netflix show Messiah, about a second coming.

I really hope this doesn’t upset or offend anyone and people can share their beliefs and thoughts openly and without prejudice or judgement as I know this can be very sensitive for some people.

Following on from —binge— watching this series I did a bit of googling and it seems both Christian and Muslim regions predict this. (Not researched if any others do yet)

I’m not very well informed about different regions but the concept of this programme has really interested me, I find it fascinating that this could, maybe? actually happen!

Do you think there could be a second coming?!

(And what would it actually mean for the world? A rise in consciousness? Mass healing???)

YABU - no don't be so daft!
YANBU - yes, this could happen, why not?!

OP posts:
Defenbaker · 05/01/2020 23:21

@SirChing - your posts are really well thought out and interesting. I'm not sure why some people have been so harsh in their responses to you, as you've been pretty reasonable in your responses.

I have been searching for answers for many years, and although I could pick holes in some of your logic/arguments, I enjoy reading posts from someone who seems to have real faith. This is an interesting discussion.

ZenNudist · 05/01/2020 23:20

Cant vote for some reason but would vote yes. I believe in bodily resurrection in Christ and the coming of heaven on earth. I believe we sleep after death until the day comes. I believe that we will see him and mother Mary again.

I hope and pray that all souls will be saved even those that don't believe in Jesus.

All the major religions essentially worship one God (even the Hindu tradition if ypu look into it) but Jews and Muslims have different takes on Christ. I think we will all find a way to come together at the end.

I read a lot of the bible largely metaphorically e.g. the nativity, revelation, genesis etc but I do think Christ was resurrected as thats the best explanation for the way in which Christianity spread. That and the ability to experience Jesus that those alive today can access.

tiredvommachine · 05/01/2020 23:06

@SirChing..beautifully put!!
God used to speak directly to humans (like Moses etc) but over time we turned away. God was frustrated because he could see us winding up with Satan who by this point was really rather a cunt

I might use this in my songster devotion next week 😂

SirChing · 05/01/2020 23:03

@Butterfly98 Thank you. That means a lot Flowers

SirChing · 05/01/2020 23:02

@roisinagusniamh

SirChing you haven't really answered my questions though.
I still don't get how you know god loves you

By a physical feeling of love that I get when I pray. As if someone who loves me is in the room. I am not saying more as it is deeply personal.

So a homeless person would no longer be homeless if s/he believed in god?

Not what I said at all. I said that God loves them still. God can't make everything all right for us. He can support us and love us through it, but we have free will. We aren't playmobile people for him to piss around with.

And what exactly is s lady .. is it a higher female and a woman a lower femsle and only 'ladies' get your respect ??

Not at all and I have never said that. It's an alternative term meaning woman, adult female etc. There is no judgement attached to it. I just refer to people how they want to be referred to.

"they don't feel like they are so it would be inaccurate"
If a person doesn't feel like a woman maybe they are trans. Has that ever occured to you ?

Of course it has! I have nursed quite a few trans people. Like everyone else, they are addressed by their preferred terminology.

SirChing · 05/01/2020 22:56

@speakout

Of course Satan is a Christian invention. The whole lot of it is.

Referring to people who follow those beliefs as being sheep seems a little rude.

Don't you think that maybe some of the problem has been how people have abused the message of religion to justify awful behaviour towards others?

People who have been brought up in really religious families who have used religion as a stick to beat their kids with, totally missing out the message that love is the most important thing of all, are bound to grow up to dislike religion and feel that it fucked with their head and worldview (thinking of my ex husband here).

But that some believers use religion to do terrible things, is no indication of whether the messages of Jesus are valid or not, it's just an indication that the person behaving like that is horrible.

Same as people who use religion as an excuse for war. If they truly believed, they wouldn't be out there killing people in the name of the religion to start with.

I honestly think that people's personal experiences of religion colour their views so much, and it can be tempting to lash out at all those who believe, rather than the ones who may have used religion to hurt us. But we aren't all the same.

If I was a sheep, I would be a fundamentalist as the people who influenced me were. But I am not, because I see loads of stuff as metaphorical rather than literal. We don't all believe the same.

duffeldaisy · 05/01/2020 22:53

No idea on spirituality (am agnostic and don’t want to offend anyone’s beliefs), but it does seem that the idea of a Second Coming is a great way to stop people from organising themselves against injustice or suffering.

“Yes, it’s terrible now, but be patient and someone perfect will be along to fix it” means that people can patiently put up with all sorts because they have faith in something better. If there’s no-one coming then people are more likely to start solving problems and challenging bad governance themselves.

Butterfly98 · 05/01/2020 22:52

FFS calm down people and lay off @SirChing ! You are all grown adults but are acting like a pack of wild animals and should be ashamed of yourselves! As I said before everyone is entitled to their beliefs whatever they are!

roisinagusniamh · 05/01/2020 22:51

SirChing you haven't really answered my questions though.
I still don't get how you know god loves you.
So a homeless person would no longer be homeless if s/he believed in god?
And what exactly is s lady .. is it a higher female and a woman a lower femsle and only 'ladies' get your respect ??
"they don't feel like they are so it would be inaccurate"
If a person doesn't feel like a woman maybe they are trans. Has that ever occured to you ?

speakout · 05/01/2020 22:45

SirChing

You do know that Satan is a christian invention?

In fact christianity would have no relevance without satan.
That bogeyman under the stairs caertainly serves a purpose to keep the sheep in check.

SirChing · 05/01/2020 22:43

I just can't get past the idea that a non-believer who has devoted his life to helping the less fortunate will burn in eternal damnation whilst Fred West can go to heaven for a last minute deference to the lord

I struggle with that too. It doesn't seem fair. I have kind of just accepted that I won't know why in this life but hope to find out later.

SirChing · 05/01/2020 22:41

My question then is why does God/Jesus need to force us to make that choice, it seems totally unnecessary & cruel. And what happens to people who believe in other Gods? (like it says in the 1st commandments)

Again, I am not saying this is what I personally believe, I haven't decided on that, but the Christian theory is that all the other Gods won't show up as they aren't real. I'm not saying that it right and fair, just explaining the theology of people who take it literally.

So the only ones who show up are Jesus and the Anti-Christ. And loads of people will love the Anti-Christ as he is a deceptive bugger who will promise all things to everyone and people will be swayed by his promises of instant riches and really material, transient stuff. So Satan will be far more tempting for a load of people than Jesus stood there preaching kindness, but not promising to pay their mortgage off. So it comes down to people thinking about the greater good and choosing that, ultimately.

As to why this is necessary in the first place: I shall tell you the thinking about it but don't blame me if it sounds mad or it bores you shitless Grin

Ok, when Satan was in Heaven with God, when the Earth was made, he was really close to God. Then Satan thought it was unfair that he could only act on the powers and authority of God, and started to get arsey about it. They had loads of arguments and Satan kept pushing it and wouldn't accept that God was in charge by virtue of being, well, God.

So, Satan wouldn't do what God asked and was being a pretty rubbish angel, and he wouldn't be persuaded otherwise by God. So, God had to kick him out.

Satan came down to Earth and started acting in the opposite way to God. They kept arguing. In the end a deal was made. Satan knew that God doesn't control the actions of people on Earth. Otherwise they would just be like Gods personal playmobile people and what would be the point of them? So, he gave us free will, and had enough faith in us that we would follow him anyway.

Satan decided that he was FAR more appealing than God, and that people would want to follow him. So God said "fine, let's see what happens, if they follow you then you are in charge and if they follow me then I am".

God used to speak directly to humans (like Moses etc) but over time we turned away. God was frustrated because he could see us winding up with Satan who by this point was really rather a cunt.

In those days under Jewish law, people atoned for their sins through sacrificing animals. The bigger the animals, the bigger the sacrifice abd the absolution. All these being flogged in the Temple for vast amounts of cash, so the poor could never hope to atone like rich people could.

So, God sends Jesus to say "hang on, this is corrupt, everyone has access to God, not just the rich, who have been corrupted by greed at the hands of Satan".

God made a deal with Satan. That Instead of having all the souls of the people on the Earth who followed Satan, Satan could have his son instead, but he couldn't have The souls of anyone who ever believes that Jesus is the Son of God.

The souls of people who had followed Satan were separated from God permanently when they died. Satan thought about it, decided it was the ultimate two fingers up to God, and said "yeah, I'll trade all the human souls for your Son". So, Jesus gets crucified and is separated from God (hence "My God why have you forsaken me").

BUT what God knows and Satan doesn't, is that God has made Jesus special, so that he can actually come back from being dead. But Satan wasn't aware of that when he made the deal.

So Jesus comes back, Satan is truly pissed off as he has agreed that he will let go all of the people who believe that Jesus is the Son of God. People believe Jesus is real due to being resurrected, and anyone who believes gets to go to Heaven.

SO, Satan is still pissed off and trying to get people to not believe in Jesus, as part of his monumental hissy fit with God, but as per the deal, it's either God or Satan that get people. Hence people having to choose.

Apologies for the length, and I have probably got loads of that wrong, but it was how it was explained to me.

CustardDream · 05/01/2020 22:39

I just can't get past the idea that a non-believer who has devoted his life to helping the less fortunate will burn in eternal damnation whilst Fred West can go to heaven for a last minute deference to the lord.

flowerbombVR · 05/01/2020 22:31

What is happening here is people being smart with language.

Being kind to others... such a simple concept yet some look for flaws in others to make themselves look/feel better.
A constructive conversation can happen between individuals. Agree to disagree.
Live and let live.
Maybe that's the difference between those who have faith and those who don't Confused

Walkingdeadfangirl · 05/01/2020 22:10

@SirChing "if Jesus was stood in front of you, doing so massive miracle that left you in no doubt whatsoever about who he was"

If Jesus, Satan (+all other options) were stood in front of me (proving who they were) & each made their pitch with proof, then I would accept that. But apart from yourself I have not met any religious folks that would say that is what the second coming is.

My question then is why does God/Jesus need to force us to make that choice, it seems totally unnecessary & cruel. And what happens to people who believe in other Gods? (like it says in the 1st commandments)

SirChing · 05/01/2020 22:10

Rhetoric such as "weakness" or "perfect" are christian ideas

They are also concepts that exist far outside of Christianity too. We can have a weak knee and perfect teeth. They are words used within language so I am unsure what your point is?

No, I wouldn't apply such concepts to animals which are unable to self reflect. They are human concepts. Why would I?

Someonesayroadtrip · 05/01/2020 22:05

I used to believe in the second coming , I don't really believe in anything anymore but I don't spend a huge amount of time thinking about it.

My religion was big on the second coming. It was pushed that it would be "soon" although often said in the same breath that soon to us and soon to God mean different things. I had believe who believe they had received revelation that they would be around to see this "momentous" day.

We were encouraged to pay tithes (a 10th of all our income) so they we wouldn't be burned at the second coming. It would be an event so big that all the world would look at and know at the same time. Yet, apparently even at this great sight, many would still not accept.

Although, despite this soon happening event there was lists of that needed to happen first, the world getting more evil and more confused and I guess there is a lot of hope in things when you consider all the bad things and the idea that there is light at the end of the tunnel.

speakout · 05/01/2020 22:04

SirChing

Rhetoric such as "weakness" or "perfect" are christian ideas.

I don't buy the Koolaid.

Imagine a herd of elephants- just another mammalian species like sapien- would you apply such terms as "weakness" or " perfect" to them?
Or would you accept that they- like us- have behavioural vagaries which impact others? Would you consider most elephants to have "imperfections" or "weaknesses".

SirChing · 05/01/2020 21:54

Why are humans all "crap"? What a horriffic view of your species

Not really. I explained upthread that I think most of us that know we could do better in some areas, and that we don't act perfectly all the time. In my view, those weaknesses are just part of the human condition, and sometimes are what make us compassionate to one another.

Like when you meet someone and they have really annoying habits, because they aren't perfect, it may really get on our nerves because WE aren't perfect and don't have exemplary patience all the time.

I view low level crapness as a rather common trait to us all, and it's by not killing each other when X leaves the loo seat up for the millionth time, that love and tolerance grows. If we were perfect, the loo seat would never be left up, and if it was, it would never drive us bonkers.

SirChing · 05/01/2020 21:47

@ChestnutSmoothie Yep, it may well be twaddle. I wasn't there. A colleague who was very shaken up by it told me. Don't think they believed in anything up until then.

I have that example in response to a poster who wanted to believe that he dad had gone on to the afterlife. Hence it was tagged to her. I was telling her the incidents I had been told, and that has happened to me, in order to bring her comfort by explaining why most nurses believe in something.

I don't think saying the afterlife is twaddle would have brought any comfort somehow Grin

SirChing · 05/01/2020 21:41

@Walkingdeadfangirl

And I have to ask what kind of a God would punish people for things only it controls. A benevolent or a malevolent one?

I don't think that you WOULD be punished for that though. If God is real and knows everything, then he will know exactly why you don't believe and that he made you, and so would want you anyway.

I interpreted those bits of Revelations to mean that if Jesus was stood in front of you, doing so massive miracle that left you in no doubt whatsoever about who he was, and proved it to you beyond a shadow of a doubt (God knows how, literally, but apparently that's what Jesus will do when he comes back), if at that point, when it is absolutely obvious to you and you KNOW that it's true, then if you then turn away from him and say "Nah mate, not interested" then He can't make you follow him.

Sadly, those that don't, don't then get to go any further with him. They are left behind because that's what they have chosen, being fully aware of all the facts of exactly who Jesus is.

speakout · 05/01/2020 21:38

I am sorry if you felt me saying that I am a pretty crap human like all of us, was rude.

SirChing I guess it comes down to the christian idea that all humans are sinful, flawed, faulty, broken ( perfect to be scooped up by the church )
I don't see myself or others in this way.
I am a perfectly functioning homo sapien animal. Not sinful, not needing saved.

Why are humans all "crap"? What a horriffic view of your species.

SirChing · 05/01/2020 21:33

Blimey! Grin Right, one at a time:

God loves you? How does s/he show that love?
Why would he be on your side and not the side of some poor homeless person begging on the streets?

I feel God's love through the comfort that he provides me with when I pray, and the love that he has for us all by sending his son down for us. I am not going to go into details because it is personal, but when I am confused about something, I pray about it, and the answer is soon revealed to me in some form.

He is on my side AND the homeless beggar on the streets and everyone's side. Some choose to accept him, some don't. Some think He should prevent bad things happening but that isn't how it works (for long reasons which I don't feel like typing out but its to do with the deal he made with Satan when Jesus went to the cross).

Nope. SirChing You can't speak for all of us

I am sorry if you felt me saying that I am a pretty crap human like all of us, was rude. Apologies. I haven't ever met anyone who didn't think they were at least a bit crappy in some ways.

Whether it's by having bad habits, or addictions, or swearing too much, or telling white lies, or being greedy or jealous etc. I have genuinely never met anyone who didn't struggle with SOMETHING negative about themselves. I thought it was an inherent part of the human condition, and didn't realise it was rude or offensive to point it out. My apologies.

@ChestnutSmoothie Actually, the bit I thought was rude was you saying what my intentions where without asking me. It's rude to speak for someone and presume to know what they are thinking. It turned out you were right, but you didn't know that and I have explained why I was rude - in response to rudeness after a litany of rude comments made to me on this thread where people have openly said they are mocking me and have been called out by others for their rudeness to me. However, I shouldn't have been rude, so I apologise for my rudeness @speakout. It was unnecessary and mean.

Why shouldn’t stated beliefs about a reality we all inhabit be “picked apart”? I totally agree with you. When it comes to people being picked apart by them openly saying they are mocking you, then it becomes nasty.

What’s a “lady” to you, SirChing? I’d be fascinated to know

Its another word used to describe a female, like woman is. It's used by me where a person prefers that term. If they don't, and tell me that they aren't a lady, they are a woman, then I won't refer to them as such. They don't feel like they are so it would be inaccurate.

ChestnutSmoothie · 05/01/2020 21:20

GA colleague reported that there was a chap who passed away on a very snowy night. Before he died he kept sitting and gesturing to the window opposite his bed. After he died, there were footsteps in the snow walking away, underneath where the window was, but no footsteps walking to the window*

This is an example of lack of logic (out of many).

If the dead man was material enough to leave footprints in snow, how come he could drift through a closed window without smashing it?

If he wanted to leave a message, why do it in such an ambiguous way? Why not (if he could interact with the world enough to rearrange snow with his feet) sit up out of his dead body and wave at everyone? Walk out of the hospital leaving his corpse on the bed? Go and find someone with a camera who could record such an astounding event for posterity?

No. Best he could manage was footprints that could, in fact, have been made by anyone.

What was the gesture towards the window meant to signify? That he’d be going through it in a minute? How did he know?

Honestly...what twaddle.

Walkingdeadfangirl · 05/01/2020 21:17

@SirChing "I am confused what you mean re we don't get to choose our beliefs. No-one else can decide those for us, so it has to come from within"

Of course it eventually comes from within, but it is informed (normally) externally eg, research, culture, experiences etc. At no point does anyone make a 'choice' about their belief. Obviously you can fake it util you make it but that is a choice to 'try' & believe, not to actually believe.

Which is exactly what you described about your experience. You didn't choose to believe, you researched it, and rightly or wrongly, over time became convinced.

Many of us, like me, have researched religion and have not been anywhere near convinced enough to believe. So if there was a 'second coming' of a God and I was punished for not believing then that is on Gods head because I have had zero option to believe. God never provided adequate information and evidence to allow me to do so.

And I have to ask what kind of a God would punish people for things only it controls. A benevolent or a malevolent one?