Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you think there will be a second coming?

891 replies

LuluBellaBlue · 03/01/2020 18:29

This is inspired by the new Netflix show Messiah, about a second coming.

I really hope this doesn’t upset or offend anyone and people can share their beliefs and thoughts openly and without prejudice or judgement as I know this can be very sensitive for some people.

Following on from —binge— watching this series I did a bit of googling and it seems both Christian and Muslim regions predict this. (Not researched if any others do yet)

I’m not very well informed about different regions but the concept of this programme has really interested me, I find it fascinating that this could, maybe? actually happen!

Do you think there could be a second coming?!

(And what would it actually mean for the world? A rise in consciousness? Mass healing???)

YABU - no don't be so daft!
YANBU - yes, this could happen, why not?!

OP posts:
SirChing · 06/01/2020 18:32

Yeah. Imagine I saw a paedohile raping a child but chose to ignore the child's pleas because it would harm theirs and the rapist's free will. And just hoped that he'd get punished for it by god later (assuming he doesn't repent) God does that every day, many, many times

I have explained why he cannot. If you can't understand then I can't help you.

As an aside, if you are Speakout in disguise, I do hope you had a good Xmas in the end. I saw your post and thought the people who tried to hand you your arse about it were very unfair Flowers

SirChing · 06/01/2020 18:28

But how do we 'find out' the opposite scenario, that of him NOT turning up?

Well if it's true, I believe we will find out when we did.

Why can't some people life a good, moral life by being kind to others and forgiving without Jesus/God?

Who says they can't? Some of us have the ability to do that both with and without God in our lives, but find that following Jesus makes it easier for us to do so in the face of hostility.

It's like the earlier point about the Aussie fires, "don't send prayer, send aid", I sent both, it doesn't have to be one or the other.

You are presumably talking about the catholic church and the church of England because there are many other churches out there that are certainly not rich and have to carefully balance the books, but who still do a large amount for the community and homeless etc

I totally agree with this, though even the CofE churches near me run food banks, asylum seeker outreaches and provide job opportunities in their cafes for people facing struggles getting back into paid employment after health issues/homelessness etc. So while the hypocrisy of being a Christian but doing sod all to help anyone else does my tits in, that is far from true in lots of churches. Sure, people could set this stuff up without religion, but then it's the non believers who need to be asked why if they don't do so.

SirChing · 06/01/2020 18:18

Which is a bit of a shame for those who met him as Jesus and were helped or healed by him as they have lost their chance of heaven

Jesus was entirely human as well as simultaneously God. He was given his powers by God but was here in a human format. Therefore it wasn't God himself interceding otherwise it would have been purely God who was here.

Also all the people in the Old Testament who got direct help. He stopped the sun for Joshua. He led the Israelites through the wilderness. He protected Daniel from lions. He gave Samson super-strength and protected Elisha from children mocking his bald head by having them ripped apart by bears

Yep. Because one of the most fundamental tenets of Christianity is that the New Testament and birth of Jesus brought about a new covenant. In the OT, God and Satan used to speak to people directly, but people turned away and stopped hearing God so he sent Jesus.

Somanysocks · 06/01/2020 18:12

I have a problem with the church, preaching kindness and encouraging others to help the needy, when they have enough money to end world poverty.

You are presumably talking about the catholic church and the church of England because there are many other churches out there that are certainly not rich and have to carefully balance the books, but who still do a large amount for the community and homeless etc.

SirChing · 06/01/2020 18:12

It's not reasonable to pick one at random and just go along with it

Grin Sounds like AIBU!

Most people give it more thought than that, but if they don't, it's entirely up to them. You may think they ABU, I doubt that they care that you think that.

SirChing · 06/01/2020 18:09

Atheism isn't the claim that we have proof that no super powerful beings exist. It's the lack of belief in the guys selling their one

Well aware of that. But I wasn't responding to general claims of atheism, I was responding to a certain poster's assertions. I am well aware that the balance of proof lies with the person making the claims. And my general response was a) you can't prove something that is a matter of faith and b) the poster was demanding proof, forgetting that even if we could, why would we bother?

SirChing · 06/01/2020 18:00

Interrogate your sources' is the first thing any university student is taught

Well aware of that having two degrees thanks.

  1. you have zero idea about the written information I was provided with at the time
  2. YOU may feel unable to believe something as personal and intangible as faith without primary sources, but that doesn't mean you get to set the standard that others should demand that in their private life
roisinagusniamh · 06/01/2020 16:31

I find it fascinating too Speakball.
Why do people need Jesus in their lives?
Why can't some people life a good, moral life by being kind to others and forgiving without Jesus/God?

speakball · 06/01/2020 14:15

"how bored have you got to be to sit and pick holes in something that you totally don't believe in anyway?"

It's not Jesus, god etc I'm interested in, it's what people think of Jesus, god etc and how they are able to hold those beliefs when they are invariably contradictory, mutually exclusive and not backed up by evidence. That's fascinating

speakball · 06/01/2020 14:07

then God can't suddenly start intercepting things which happen on Earth as that means he is then reneging on his agreement with Satan in the battle for our souls

Jesus did a tonne of healing on earth. Did he inadvertently send them to hell by helping them and therefore reneging on this agreement he made with a creature he made (for reasons that I've not heard explained).

speakball · 06/01/2020 14:00

so it must be true that interfering even once would wreck everything for that person if not for everyone.

Yeah. Imagine I saw a paedohile raping a child but chose to ignore the child's pleas because it would harm theirs and the rapist's free will. And just hoped that he'd get punished for it by god later (assuming he doesn't repent) God does that every day, many, many times.

speakball · 06/01/2020 13:55

whether anyone believes or not we'll all find out eventually

How will we find out? I mean, obviously we'll all find out if he DOES turn up. But how do we 'find out' the opposite scenario, that of him NOT turning up? At what point would christians decide he wasn't coming back (ergo hadn't even been before.) Year 3000, 4000, 4000000?

SomeKindOfMonster · 06/01/2020 12:31

I stopped believing in God round about the same time I realised Santa wasn't real. It seemed obvious. I remember being quite young and through difficult times in childhood, hating God so much for the things that happened to me & my family, so I don't think we ever got off to a good start anyway.

I have a problem with the church, preaching kindness and encouraging others to help the needy, when they have enough money to end world poverty.

However, I do wish I believed in God. I think it must bring comfort to know that during hard times, someone is with you and esp in death, to know your loved ones are in a better place and that you will see them again. Sometimes I wonder if it's not a lot of pressure too though, to have pure thoughts etc sounds exhausting.

I seen something once and someone else did too, the same thing and at the exact same time. I have no explanation for it, but I still can't believe.

I think Jesus existed, but I don't believe he was the son of God.

I think a second coming, God and Jesus are incredibly improbable, but nothing is impossible.

LastTrainEast · 06/01/2020 11:26

I've always been fascinated by the Free Will/God can't intervene argument.
Obviously a good god could not ignore the suffering of so many children so it must be true that interfering even once would wreck everything for that person if not for everyone.

Which is a bit of a shame for those who met him as Jesus and were helped or healed by him as they have lost their chance of heaven.

Also all the people in the Old Testament who got direct help. He stopped the sun for Joshua. He led the Israelites through the wilderness. He protected Daniel from lions. He gave Samson super-strength and protected Elisha from children mocking his bald head by having them ripped apart by bears.

I think those kids would say that counted as interfering but it was for Elisha too.

Poor old Elisha. Did he know what he was losing?

LastTrainEast · 06/01/2020 11:03

@SirChing "what makes you think that people don't have the brains to decide for themselves?" well that's a common response, but most recruiting is of children/young adults of course who lack the knowledge and experience to know they are being misled.

It's important to let them know that what are presented as facts known to everyone are actually myth and propaganda and disputed by many other people. To encourage them to check for themselves.

I try and encourage people for example to read the whole bible. A lot of Christians got their theology from Christmas Carols and Nativity plays.

"Why do you feel the need to profess with certainty that which you cannot know for sure?" Atheism isn't the claim that we have proof that no super powerful beings exist. It's the lack of belief in the guys selling their one.

There have been 1000s of religions and quite a few current ones and none of them have offered any proof. At most one could be real so we know the others are scams don't we. It's not reasonable to pick one at random and just go along with it.

FramingDevice · 06/01/2020 10:30

So when kids are abused God is horrified and heartbroken too, and is having to practically sit on his hands not to do something about it, but he can't. The second he intercedes, it has a butterfly effect with massive ramifications.

^But God is gutted at what is happening, hears our prayers, and wants to be with us and love us, hoping that we turn to him so that we can eventually go home to him and have no more pain.*

That sort of made sense to me. Satan is in charge on Earth and has corrupted man by stealth. God can't intercede and break his agreement as then we are all Satan's. Thays what was explained to me anyway.

That's how it was explained to me why God can't intercede.

I could well be wrong about that, but I am pretty sure that's how it was explained to me.

My ex husbands family were all Baptists and quite into the nitty gritty of it all. Their minister explained it to me.

'Interrogate your sources' is the first thing any university student is taught. Not 'someone vaguely connected with an ex explained it to me, and I'm inexplicably happy to go along with this random's poorly-conceived mental gymnastics as an explanation for why a supposedly omnipotent deity is 'heartbroken' by suffering inflicted on the innocent that he can't or won't alleviate'.

JustASmallTownCurl · 06/01/2020 10:14

Happy to believe in Jesus, happy for others to enjoy their Trendy first world luxury beliefs.

Assuming you mean you do believe in Jesus, that doesn't sound like a very Christian view @thefingerpointer, it sounds snarky, judgemental and pious.

How do you tally up statements like that with love thy neighbour and the importance of being kind and loving?

CardinalSin · 06/01/2020 09:32

"I do believe in Jesus because there is historical evidence to back up the idea that there was a travelling preacher by his name and general description at the time."

Except that there isn't...

SirChing · 06/01/2020 09:00

@Equanimitas Because Satan was being a pain in the arse of an angel and getting right on God's tits, as far as I can remember it being explained. But as God loved him due to him being one of his angels, he didn't want to just annihilate him, but leave the door open for Satan to repent.

I could well be wrong about that, but I am pretty sure that's how it was explained to me.

Equanimitas · 06/01/2020 07:39

If God said "right, I'm in Heaven and you Satan are on Earth, let's see which one of us they come to", then God can't suddenly start intercepting things which happen on Earth as that means he is then reneging on his agreement with Satan in the battle for our souls

But, if God exists, he's omnipotent. Why would he need to make any deal with Satan in the first place?

JustAnotherPoster00 · 06/01/2020 07:30

Happy to believe in Jesus, happy for others to enjoy their Trendy first world luxury beliefs.

If you are taken ill how much confidence would you have in the doctor if he started practicing bronze aged medicine on you?

It is for God to decide who this is, based on his standards.

I dont know a single christian who follows biblical law, they tend to pick and choose. If youre going by gods standards and 'law' then you should follow them to the letter after all isnt this your god, how half arsed are you being?

‘Have you not read that which was spoken to you by God?’ (Matthew 22:31)

FenellaMaxwell · 06/01/2020 07:09

I don’t believe in a first coming. I do believe in Jesus because there is historical evidence to back up the idea that there was a travelling preacher by his name and general description at the time. I do not believe he was the son of god, or that he performed miracles.

cabbageking · 06/01/2020 06:50

The bible says there will be a judgement of the righteous and unrighteous.

It is for God to decide who this is, based on his standards.

TheFingerPointer · 06/01/2020 05:32

Happy to believe in Jesus, happy for others to enjoy their Trendy first world luxury beliefs.

SirChing · 06/01/2020 02:56

@Mimishimi Wow, that's amazing. So when this bloke turns up, will he be saying my name is Jesus and Kalki and etc etc. It could all be the same person but just understood differently.