Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to break up with boyfriend because he's always ill?

213 replies

namechange100002 · 26/12/2019 21:48

Name changed as I know this may be controversial and I have family on here. Sorry it's long but want to give full info.

Genuinely am trying not to be a dick, adore the bones of my boyfriend so I hate that I feel this way.

BF and I have been together for a year now. We are serious about each other, love each other to bits. Neither of us wants to be without the other. I have a child (KS1 primary age) from a previous relationship, he is very understanding and really likes her too - we were friends before getting together so he already knew her.

BF has lots of pre-existing medical conditions: depression (under control with meds at present), eczema, asthma and allergies. His eczema covers most of his body. The last six months it has been flaring up on and off constantly. Doctors not interested in curing him or finding the cause, just giving him endless creams and then antibiotic steroids when it gets infected. He tried going private but couldn't afford it once the bill went into the high hundreds.

Out of the last month I have seen him 3 days because his skin has been so bad, he's in pain and is embarrassed to be seen. He knows it doesn't bother me but wont even visit when it gets like this as he just wants to lie in bed at home. He's been hospitalised twice since september because it's become infected and borderline septic. He's been in work for about 15 days total in the last six months.

He doesn't help himself with his skin or his asthma. He eats junk food (doesn't like fruit/veg etc), smokes (5 or 6 a day), doesn't shower enough (says it hurts his skin) and barely leaves the house (due to pain/embarrassment).

I was meant to be meeting his family on Christmas day. He cancelled as his skin was bad. He's also cancelled on me for boxing day. I moved house last month and he couldn't come to that either. We went on holiday a couple of months ago and he spent 4 of the 7 days in hospital.
He isn't being proactive about getting it sorted, just deals with it getting bad when it does.

I can't make plans with him as they ALWAYS get spoiled or cancelled. He constantly lets me down.

I've tried to be really understanding and I see how much he goes through dealing with it. I absolutely adore this man, we get along so well and every other aspect of our relationship is great. I just can't see it getting better than this right now and feel very low after sitting alone on Boxing Day while my daughter is with her dad and stepmum.

I don't want to end the relationship. But I am finding myself so so resentful and alone, again. eats chocolate and cries at Christmas With The Kranks

So, honestly, AIBU?

OP posts:
Ilady · 26/12/2019 23:52

I don't think your being unreasonable at all in considering to brake up with him. He has several health issues which are effecting his quality of life and because this he is cancelling plans with you a lot. Along with this he is not willing to improve his diet which could help with his health issues.

A few years ago one of my friends was very friendly with this man. He was very heavy - I say 24/25 stone and around 6f 2inch tall. My friend was also heavy. She said to him we both need to lose some weight otherwise we will get diabetis. His attitude was so what if I get this.
My friend went on to lose over 4 stone. He did nothing, got heavier and now has a diabitic condition. He now has a small child.
Another friend of ours saw him recently and said he is a heart attack waiting to happen.

The reality is as a adult it your responsibility to look after your health. If you have a poor doctor you change doctors and get medical tests done when required. With certain medical conditions changing your diet can help improve things. It may not be easy to change your diet or give up some of the food you like but long term your health is more important.

Why should you be willing to keep giving up your plans or putting your life on hold for someone who is not willing to help themselves?

GroggyLegs · 26/12/2019 23:51

It's a really sad set of circumstances but he's okay with things as they are. If he wasn't, he'd make a change.

You're not, you expect more from a life partner. (As would I)

YANBU - time to say goodbye.

ProfessionalBoss · 26/12/2019 23:48

@beautifulstranger101 oh I've read her story, but the title says it all...

aibu to break up with boyfriend because he's always ill

I don't know what else to say...

bringincrazyback · 26/12/2019 23:48

YANBU to feel this way, but I think it'd be unfair to break up with him outright, without telling him how you feel and why, and giving him the opportunity to get his act together.

beautifulstranger101 · 26/12/2019 23:46

OP- you dont have to justify yourself. Its obvious to most of us that you love him but are finding this really, really hard which is completely understandable.

Its a lot to deal with- especially at the beginning and you also have a child to consider aswell.

You aren't obliged to be with anyone and if this relationship is just causing you constant unhappiness then leave. Unfortunately, love isn't always enough.

Uncompromisingwoman · 26/12/2019 23:45

Op,
Do you see your future as being a carer? The week that you have just described looks likely to be your future. Is that what you want for yourself? And given everything you have said about his repeated cancelling of things and his refusal to take responsibility for things like his diet is that what you want for your daughter? An adult in her life with health needs that are likely to dominate her needs and who refuses to engage in any possible solutions? These are not meant to be unkind questions - but when you're a parent it's not just the impact on you but also your child that our relationships impact on??
What does he do for you / give back to you to generate your care/concern?

ProfessionalBoss · 26/12/2019 23:43

@namechange100002 Please do not tell me I do not love him.

Well you are making it sound like you are a resentful unpaid carer, not a loving partner.

You say that you love him wholeheartedly and yet you are asking if you are being unreasonable to end the relationship because of his health problems, (which cannot be cured, and evidence of diet changes etc helping are anecdotal at best), if the roles were reversed and he was asking these questions, would you believe that you were loved?

ProfessionalBoss · 26/12/2019 23:39

@Alconleigh not everyone's MS will end with them being in a wheelchair, nevermind needing full-time carers. Yes the future is unpredictable, and of course the current government are providing little to no support, but for many, it's just something we live with, we make changes to our lives in order to minimise the impact of our illness on others.

Wheresthebeach · 26/12/2019 23:37

It doesn’t sound great, he shouldn’t smoke with asthma. That’s just nuts. I have eczema and every expensive dermatologist has told me diet has no effect on eczema in adults. I’ve been told repeatedly there is nothing I can do but treat symptoms. So he may feel helpless. Not saying you should stay, but if he’s listening to dr they will be saying there is no cure for eczema. I have discovered food triggers, but dr don’t believe me. He needs to be willing to try all sorts of things, rather than just suffer but its hard.

Doesn’t sound like it will be much fun for you and your daughter. You need to have time and energy for her rather than having to spend it all on caring for your boyfriend.

Fozzleyplum · 26/12/2019 23:36

OP, a lot of posters are focusing on the fact that your boyfriend appears to be doing nothing to help himself, and are citing that as justification for not continuing the relationship. The implication seems to be that you would be unreasonable to end the relationship if he was doing all he could and he still had as many problems.

I don't agree with that. You don't have a long shared past and IMO you are under no obligation to stay. You only come this way once.call me callous, but there is no way I would be committing to the limitations and disappointments this relationship entails.

beautifulstranger101 · 26/12/2019 23:36

Which brings me on to point 3 - what exactly is a partnership to you? As if it's unsupportive and uncaring, then I really do feel sorry for you...

The OP SAID she suggested he cut out dairy and he did it for three days then gave up because he he said he can't give up cheese. So what is she supposed to do? she's suggested ways to help and he won't do them. You cannot force someone to change their diet. Thats not "uncaring" whatsoever- its him not taking responsibility for his own health.
Smoking whilst being asthmatic is also really really unwise but again, she cannot make him give up.

She isn't ending this because of his illness- read her OP again. She's ending it because of his behaviour.

ProfessionalBoss · 26/12/2019 23:34

Oh and @beautifulstranger101 I do my share of the cooking and cleaning in our relationship, because marriage (and a partnership) should be equal, unless because of illness or injury, one partner needs extra help. So I most certainly would be saying the same thing if it was reversed.

Skyechasemarshalontheway · 26/12/2019 23:33

Diets won't fix all peoples causes of eczema.

My 18 month old has it bad all over he lives in clothes from the hospital. Bathed daily due to creams. His skin bleeds.

He's allergic to milk egg wheat nuts and soya so obviously doesn't have those yet his skin is still awful.
One tiny scratch and his skin bleeds.

My bil is the same. He doesn't have allergies but was taken off milk eega etc as a child his skin was still bad.

Sometimes even doing everything right can still not be enough. The ops partner may know this about his own skin already.

You definitely wouldn't be unreasonable to end the relationship as it doesn't seem like you have much of one regardless of why it's came about.

namechange100002 · 26/12/2019 23:32

@ProfessionalBoss

I completely accept your view that I am being unreasonable, I'm not questioning that and I appreciate your input.

However, please do not tell me how I feel about somebody. I love this person wholeheartedly, the rare one week I get off being a mum I spent at his bedside in hospital. I paid his excess bill after he was in a foreign hospital. I drive him to his doctors appointments. I apply cream when he needs it in difficult places. I clean my house meticulously to help with his dust alllergy. I hoover up his dry skin off the mattress every morning.

Please do not tell me I do not love him.

It's just that I also have a full time job and a young child to think about. And I'm struggling with the amount of care he needs considering how early we are into the relationship, and he doesn't take that level of care of himself.

OP posts:
ProfessionalBoss · 26/12/2019 23:31

It's not OP's responsibility to manage his condition. She's not his mum
Agree, and I'm a bit baffled by all of the posts suggesting she cook all his meals etc She isn't his mother- he's a grown man.
I doubt people would be suggesting he cook for her if the situation was reversed.

Points one and two - she is focused on his diet, she is the one bringing it up, if she wants to be a supportive partner then my suggestions would be welcomed.

Which brings me on to point 3 - what exactly is a partnership to you? As if it's unsupportive and uncaring, then I really do feel sorry for you...

Clearly, as I said, she doesn't love him, if she's willing to end a relationship over an illness with no cure, and should do him a favour and stop wasting his time...

Notitchynow · 26/12/2019 23:29

I felt a bit like this when DP’s eczema became really bad. He had always had it but it became extreme - the backs of his legs were like open wounds from scratching, he had to bandage his hands and legs every day. He resisted seeing a doctor because he’d visited one and got nowhere, his diet wasn’t the greatest (though he is now lactose free) and he wasn’t sleeping well or taking good care of himself.

I made him go back to his GP and she referred him to a dermatologist, who instantly diagnosed scabies. Turns out that the eczema wasn’t the primary reason for the itching after all. We both had to be treated (I had a persistent eczema patch too but only one spot) and his skin has now cleared up miraculously. He still has eczema but it is manageable now. Might be worth enquiring if an infection of this type could be making the eczema worse.

Alconleigh · 26/12/2019 23:27

It's very hard. I'm dating someone with MS and depression. He's great, and he absolutely does manage his conditions proactively, but I still have a terror of ending up as his carer. I think he'd love to marry me but I can't see the motivation from my side; this will sound brutal but I won't sacrifice my career because an austerity government would have me live on £3.50 a week to look after him, should it come to that. It's not like any financial help for him will ever be available from this government.

I also struggle with his libido being lower than mine due to said conditions. The sex we have is wonderful but it's not frequent enough and I feel like my last best years (I'm 43) are being wasted, sexually speaking.

Sorry, essay about me. My point was, I struggle and he absolutely does do everything he can. In Your situation, where he doesn't, I'd cut my losses.

beautifulstranger101 · 26/12/2019 23:24

It's not OP's responsibility to manage his condition. She's not his mum

Agree, and I'm a bit baffled by all of the posts suggesting she cook all his meals etc She isn't his mother- he's a grown man. If he can go out and get cigarettes and take away food then he can get his own food. I doubt people would be suggesting he cook for her if the situation was reversed.

Not to mention, taking on the role of "mum" in a relationship is the biggest turn off there is.

Wolfiefan · 26/12/2019 23:22

I have awful eczema. I’m now on immunosuppressants. YANBU. He needs a referral to a dermatologist. He needs to make changes and be pro active. He isn’t being. You can’t make him.

Branleuse · 26/12/2019 23:22

I think it must be incredibly difficult to have a full relationship with someone with so many health issues. It certainly wouldnt be for everyone.
Maybe youd be better as friends. It doesnt sound like hes got a lot to give an actual relationship right now

ProfessionalBoss · 26/12/2019 23:22

It's not OP's responsibility to manage his condition. She's not his mum.

I completely agree, she's not, and she's the one going on about diet and informing us of what he'll eat if she cooks it, so thank you for reminding her of that!

ReanimatedSGB · 26/12/2019 23:20

YANBU. FFS, how can he be 'wonderful' when you hardly ever see him; he keeps cancelling on you and doesn't appear to take any responsibility for himself or his health. Are you desperate not to be single or something? Bin politely and move on.

Bouledeneige · 26/12/2019 23:20

I think you should leave the relationship if you want to.

But I don't think a lot of people here realise that there's no cure for eczema and many of the suggestions here are not proven to work (except steroids and topical creams, avoiding biological washing powders, only wearing cotton or silk next to the skin etc). Recent scientific studies have doubted the benefits of emollients (though I liked them myself - so long as they are not left on to smother the skin). Not all patients respond to dietary interventions, the dairy link has not I think been proven, as I myself found out - mine got worse during an exclusion diet. I've certainly never heard a doctor recommending washing every day - agony, and not good for healing. So I'd be cautious about accepting that if he just did these things he'd solve his problem. Its an over active immune reaction. So end it if the relationships not working but don't blame him for having an incurable condition.

Bluebutterfly90 · 26/12/2019 23:18

Oh dear.
I do have some sympathy for your partner, as I suffered terribly with excema that would constantly get infected- and even had to be treated for septicaemia at one point because of it. Tried everything to fix it while being told from everyone that I wasnt trying enough as I would get better in hospital.
Turns out I had a serious allergy to something unusual in the house I was living in.

Still, if you feel like he really isn't trying I would bring it up with him and say how its affecting how much you want to be with him.
You both have my sympathy, chronic excema is a nightmare.

Havaina · 26/12/2019 23:18

if its chips he wants and he's presented with chips, his tastes might slowly evolve..

It's not OP's responsibility to manage his condition. She's not his mum.

Swipe left for the next trending thread