Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to break up with boyfriend because he's always ill?

213 replies

namechange100002 · 26/12/2019 21:48

Name changed as I know this may be controversial and I have family on here. Sorry it's long but want to give full info.

Genuinely am trying not to be a dick, adore the bones of my boyfriend so I hate that I feel this way.

BF and I have been together for a year now. We are serious about each other, love each other to bits. Neither of us wants to be without the other. I have a child (KS1 primary age) from a previous relationship, he is very understanding and really likes her too - we were friends before getting together so he already knew her.

BF has lots of pre-existing medical conditions: depression (under control with meds at present), eczema, asthma and allergies. His eczema covers most of his body. The last six months it has been flaring up on and off constantly. Doctors not interested in curing him or finding the cause, just giving him endless creams and then antibiotic steroids when it gets infected. He tried going private but couldn't afford it once the bill went into the high hundreds.

Out of the last month I have seen him 3 days because his skin has been so bad, he's in pain and is embarrassed to be seen. He knows it doesn't bother me but wont even visit when it gets like this as he just wants to lie in bed at home. He's been hospitalised twice since september because it's become infected and borderline septic. He's been in work for about 15 days total in the last six months.

He doesn't help himself with his skin or his asthma. He eats junk food (doesn't like fruit/veg etc), smokes (5 or 6 a day), doesn't shower enough (says it hurts his skin) and barely leaves the house (due to pain/embarrassment).

I was meant to be meeting his family on Christmas day. He cancelled as his skin was bad. He's also cancelled on me for boxing day. I moved house last month and he couldn't come to that either. We went on holiday a couple of months ago and he spent 4 of the 7 days in hospital.
He isn't being proactive about getting it sorted, just deals with it getting bad when it does.

I can't make plans with him as they ALWAYS get spoiled or cancelled. He constantly lets me down.

I've tried to be really understanding and I see how much he goes through dealing with it. I absolutely adore this man, we get along so well and every other aspect of our relationship is great. I just can't see it getting better than this right now and feel very low after sitting alone on Boxing Day while my daughter is with her dad and stepmum.

I don't want to end the relationship. But I am finding myself so so resentful and alone, again. eats chocolate and cries at Christmas With The Kranks

So, honestly, AIBU?

OP posts:
Jinglebellissimo · 27/12/2019 08:07

@managedmis I think if the op had just written that as her post and said Aibu to leave him she would have got more of a positive response.

sameasiteverwasantiques · 27/12/2019 07:56

You can't help someone that doesn't want to be helped.

TheBlueStocking · 27/12/2019 07:48

The food thing sounds like sensory issues. Very challenging habit to break if he feels genuinely repulsed by certain foods.

It sounds like you are essentially in a long distance relationship, without the distance. Very few people are satisfied in such relationships.

You would not be unreasonable to leave. It's your life to live.

SteelRiver · 27/12/2019 02:21

Lots of people seeming to underestimate an awful illness here. A different point of view. Disabilities and chronic illness seems to bring out the 'have you tried......? or 'I had a bad back once and ... worked for me' etc etc in everyone you ever speak to. It is incredibly patronising, demeaning and infuriating. In all likelihood, the person will have tried everything suggested and will have been to various doctors only to be told there is nothing more that can be done. It doesn't take much more than a little compassion to see how this can result in low mood, depression or anxiety, which can in turn lead to lack of self care, isolation and so on.

BrendasUmbrella · 27/12/2019 02:07

Not washing for five days when he's prone to infections that lead to hospitalization is staggering.

changeling82 · 27/12/2019 01:57

I haven't rtft so sorry if this has been said but I think your assessment that he isn't taking responsibility for his health is really unfair.

You say he isn't being proactive about getting it sorted but you mention "endless" creams suggesting he has been persistent about booking and attending doctors appointments. You also say that the doctors aren't interested in finding a cure. Can you not see how demoralizing that must be in the face of his attempts to find a solution? You also say that he's tried going private (despite low earnings by the sounds of things) and this obviously took some initiative and organisation and it isn't his fault if this route was blocked to him on account of the expense.

If it's painful to shower then I'd say it's fairly understandable that he doesn't do it as much as you might like (and from a little research it would seem that there is no unanimous consensus among experts as to how often bathing or showering should take place with eczema). and if leaving the house makes him feel awful I can't see any grounds for insisting doing so more often would improve his situation. Surely he knows what's best for himself.

His diet and smoking isn't ideal but is there any evidence improved diet and quitting the fags would lead to any massive improvements? I know sufferers who eat well and don't smoke. And how many of us live fully optimized lives in terms of our health decisions? Don't most of us have a few vices to help us get through the trials and tribulations of life.

That said, if the relationship is making you unhappy you have every right to end it without beating yourself up. But I would avoid any insinuation that it's even partly because he's not helping himself. From what you've written he sounds like he's made plenty of effort but also to some extent does what he feels works best for him and his health, as most of us would.

Aldidl · 27/12/2019 00:51

I suffer with skin problems, and was sympathetic to him right up to still smoking. So many things can affect it, if he isn’t willing to try the most obvious, then YANBU

jewel1968 · 27/12/2019 00:49

One of my kids had extreme eczema required hospital etc.... I learnt a lot about eczema and its cousins asthma and food allergies.

It is an autoimmune condition and stress is a big trigger as are food allergies. Water can be an irritant too so not showering is understandable.

I understand that it is difficult but suggest before making your decision do your research and have a frank conversation. Check how knowledgeable he is about his condition and get a sense of what he might be prepared to do to get it under control. I did find that doctors were not particularly helpful or knowledgeable and were not up to date on modern treatments. In my child's case it turned out to be mainly food allergies that took a while to identify.

Good luck.

Howmanysleepsnow · 27/12/2019 00:47

He’s presumably had eczema most of his life. He’s likely tried the diet changes. I know I have. They didn’t make any difference to me.
Yes, washing is painful. Just washing my hair cuts my hands when they flair. It’s not laziness it’s minimising (but not stopping) the pain.
If you want to be with him, be there for him and support him to see a dermatologist/ push for new treatments. If you don’t want to be with him, leave. But don’t pin that on his illnesses.

Prawnofthepatriarchy · 27/12/2019 00:46

Hit post too soon.

My DC has all the same health problems as your BF so I have plenty of experience. You don't seem to appreciate is that all these conditions become severe and chronic because they don't really respond to any treatment. Antidepressants can help but nothing actually cures depression.Your BF's eczema is clearly very severe indeed. And both asthma and eczema are worsened by stress.

At his worse, DC's skin would look as if he'd been scalded - bright red, cracking and oozing - and nothing really touched it. The consultant told us there was zero point in trying to avoid potential allergens in the home as DC reacted to so many things that we'd never manage to exclude them all.

Thinking that if only someone hadn't or had done something they wouldn't be in this mess is comforting. It's much more palatable than acknowledging the truth: that life is arbitrary and unfair; that medicine doesn't have an answer for everything; that we have very little control over anything - and that there's no guarantee that tinkering with his lifestyle would relieve your BF's very significant health problems.

CoolCarrie · 27/12/2019 00:36

As others have said he isn’t taking responsibility for himself and that’s the problem, he isn’t helping himself and you can only do so much.

managedmis · 27/12/2019 00:29

The only things he eats are ham and cheese toasties, crisps, pizza, chips, cheeseburgers, chicken and tortilla wraps. He will eat cottage pie or similar provided it has no veg and not too much sauce. He doesn't like any sauces or textures. He won't eat meat if it's in it's full form (e.g. chicken breast or steak), it has to be breaded/fried or as a burger.

^^
Just this would be a game changer

WarmthAndDepth · 27/12/2019 00:18

Imagine yourseif in 5, 10, 15 years time.
I knew DP had a propensity to depressive illness when we first met. Like you, deeply in love and feeling guilty and optimistic in equal measure, deciding that love might actually conquer all. 15 years later, so much of our life together has been about managing recurring episodes of depression and more recently anxiety. The kind of things which you have described experiencing in your first year together have occurred throughout our time together. There's still a warm core of love, but my life is so much smaller than it might have been. Had I the chance to give my 30 year old self a talking to, I wish I could have explained to her that this man had the makings of a wonderful friend, but that I would do well not to invest romantically as the compounded worry, frustration and resentment would erode much of the good will in time.
Sorry you are facing this dilemma, OP.

alexdgr8 · 27/12/2019 00:18

I think you are not suited as partners. best to go separate ways.

but I don't like the attitude of some replies, seeming to blame people for their illness. perhaps they have no real experience of chronic pain and illness close up.
of course a person with severe skin eruptions cannot and should not shower every day. it is nothing to do with being lazy or unhygienic.
also as for him letting down the OP, how do you think he feels, with his body, his life, constantly letting him down. kind of depressing, eh.

namechange100002 · 27/12/2019 00:13

Sorry about the showering thing, I know a lot of you have picked up on that. I didn't realise. I know my GP advised short cool showers using emollient wash so that's what I used to do but that's going back fifteen years now.

It's just sometimes he doesn't wash for up to five days at a time and in my head I believed that won't help with the infection side of things.

OP posts:
Sparkle2020 · 27/12/2019 00:10

Please ask him to ask his eczema doctor about dupixent! It’s an injection that I am on. My eczema used to leave me in hospital with sepsis multiple times a year and so suicidal. It totally changed my life. Sorry to hear you feel lonely but please don’t lay blame on his medical issues as I can’t even begin to explain how horrible those 3 conditions are. They put you in such a dark place. Showering is painful, it’s horrendously painful. Eating junk food is a comfort thing, as it is for many people. Please don’t say he’s not helping himself because when you wake up feeling like you can’t move in your own skin it is soul destroying.

Mulledwineinajug · 27/12/2019 00:10

Showering more often can dry out skin and worsen eczema.

I know that’s not what you’re asking.

WalmartMom · 27/12/2019 00:10

Your hanging on to "we really get on great" ordinarily.

No you don't.

This it. This is what it will be like when things go wrong (lose job, money problems, all the usual life issues) instead living/discussing/working out things together he will be indifferent to your role. This is how he is about life.

This is not a relationship at all. You have to get off the "but if only" we get over this we'll be fine. Pull out of that, get a clear head. If he picks up great. But don't give up. Set two way tasks and if he doesn't respond & is as sour as he is now. Get out before it drags you down.

You're clutching at straws here.

Prawnofthepatriarchy · 27/12/2019 00:09

YANBU to want to end a relationship that means you hardly see him and when you do you're more like a carer than a GF. If you'd been committed for many years you might be prepared to sacrifice your life for the sake of a much loved spouse. But this is the outset of a relationship and for all your brave claims of a grand passion, the truth is that you just don't care enough. And why should you?

YABU however to blame him for exacerbating his various conditions. People with MH problems are three times as likely to smoke and find it harder to quit. Just Google "smoking mental health statistics" to find a wealth of research.

Showers? Has he told you that frequent showers would improve his eczema? Because people with eczema are often advised to avoid too much exposure to water.

My son, who had very severe eczema, was advised to wash with a special emollient using a sponge. Long hot showers were out of the question.

NotAVirtue · 27/12/2019 00:08

As someone with severe eczema (amongst other things) I think you are BU in that you expect him to be able to magically cure himself through just eating better and stopping smoking. It really isn't that simple. Showering when your skin is flared is like being covered in acid. Going out and seeing people is difficult, even family and friends. What he needs is a referral to a dermatologist, proper allergy testing and then consideration for treatment like immunosuppressive or biologic drugs to get his skin under control. I'm not suggesting this is your responsibility to sort out but if you love him as much as you say you do, then you should be encouraging him to push his GP for a referral.
I don't think you are BU to find the whole thing exhausting. I have been in a similar position and am scared every day that my OH will have had enough and leave.

Prettyvase · 27/12/2019 00:05

What benefit is this man in your child's life? What does it add to her life? How does it improve her life? If someone is not prepared to help themselves and continually eats junk and heaven forbid, does not value personal hygiene then I would have to conclude that this person is not a positive addition to my child's life and conclude the relationship on that basis.

lisag1969 · 27/12/2019 00:04

Leave a find someone new. He may be nice. But you need more. X

BrendasUmbrella · 27/12/2019 00:00

I agree with the poster above who says you should not feel obliged to stay even if he does start to grow up and start participating in his own care.

Be careful if/when you have the talk. He might agree you can see him when he's ill just to keep you around, and you could so easily fall into the unpaid carer/surrogate mother role that so many women get stuck in. Think about what kind of future you want. You and your child.

BrendasUmbrella · 26/12/2019 23:55

Interested to what you think might cure his eczema? He should give up the smoking and obviously eat healthier but it is often linked to asthma and other allergies.

Perhaps nothing. But maybe something would help. Several dc's in my family have allergies which cause eczema and cutting out dairy, etc have helped a lot. If he's not open to trying anything, he is not likely to improve, and the OP has to look forward to a future of seeing him once or twice a month. It's not life for either of them. He isn't going to help himself, so she has to make her decision based on that information.

jamaisjedors · 26/12/2019 23:54

have eczema and every expensive dermatologist has told me diet has no effect on eczema in adults.

They might have told you that, but my lifelong eczema has improved considerably since I gave up dairy 2years ago.

It used to be so bad on my face that people thought I had severe burns.

It is a very frustrating condition, but it is also obvious that sugar, alcohol and other inflammatory things DO aggravate it as well as lack of sleep and stress.

Difficult to cut them all out but you can at least try.

I think you are in for heartbreak down the line OP with his helpless attitude.

Swipe left for the next trending thread