Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to break up with boyfriend because he's always ill?

213 replies

namechange100002 · 26/12/2019 21:48

Name changed as I know this may be controversial and I have family on here. Sorry it's long but want to give full info.

Genuinely am trying not to be a dick, adore the bones of my boyfriend so I hate that I feel this way.

BF and I have been together for a year now. We are serious about each other, love each other to bits. Neither of us wants to be without the other. I have a child (KS1 primary age) from a previous relationship, he is very understanding and really likes her too - we were friends before getting together so he already knew her.

BF has lots of pre-existing medical conditions: depression (under control with meds at present), eczema, asthma and allergies. His eczema covers most of his body. The last six months it has been flaring up on and off constantly. Doctors not interested in curing him or finding the cause, just giving him endless creams and then antibiotic steroids when it gets infected. He tried going private but couldn't afford it once the bill went into the high hundreds.

Out of the last month I have seen him 3 days because his skin has been so bad, he's in pain and is embarrassed to be seen. He knows it doesn't bother me but wont even visit when it gets like this as he just wants to lie in bed at home. He's been hospitalised twice since september because it's become infected and borderline septic. He's been in work for about 15 days total in the last six months.

He doesn't help himself with his skin or his asthma. He eats junk food (doesn't like fruit/veg etc), smokes (5 or 6 a day), doesn't shower enough (says it hurts his skin) and barely leaves the house (due to pain/embarrassment).

I was meant to be meeting his family on Christmas day. He cancelled as his skin was bad. He's also cancelled on me for boxing day. I moved house last month and he couldn't come to that either. We went on holiday a couple of months ago and he spent 4 of the 7 days in hospital.
He isn't being proactive about getting it sorted, just deals with it getting bad when it does.

I can't make plans with him as they ALWAYS get spoiled or cancelled. He constantly lets me down.

I've tried to be really understanding and I see how much he goes through dealing with it. I absolutely adore this man, we get along so well and every other aspect of our relationship is great. I just can't see it getting better than this right now and feel very low after sitting alone on Boxing Day while my daughter is with her dad and stepmum.

I don't want to end the relationship. But I am finding myself so so resentful and alone, again. eats chocolate and cries at Christmas With The Kranks

So, honestly, AIBU?

OP posts:
Willowcat77 · 27/12/2019 12:19

I hope things improve and you can stay together, I feel for both of you. You obviously love him, your description of his transformation when the eczema disappeared was really moving.

TheDarkPassenger · 27/12/2019 12:05

I was all ready to be like noooo argh because I have an autoimmune disease and bipolar so I know my partner has it hard. But you’re not breaking up because of that are you you’re braking up because he’s bloody irresponsible!

YADNBU

bionicnemonic · 27/12/2019 12:01

A change of diet could improve his skin and his depression. One last hoorah to push him into change? I’d be inclined to suggest both changing your diets for three months, cut out all wheat and milk, (no cheese!!) see how you both feel. They are starting to think some depression is a result of internal inflammation and this can be helped with less inflammatory foods. Lots of fruit and veg. He just has to be brave and try

FGSJoanWhatsWrongWithYou · 27/12/2019 12:01

Don't be his mum.

If he wants to find out about the potential impact of dairy, how long to try it for, etc etc then he can use google and forums the same as the rest of us here. You searching for him, gathering advice for him is encouraging wrong behaviours.

He has to take responsibility for finding his own particular eczema triggers. Don't turn into the controlling mum of an idiot child. Give him a chance to prove he can act like a grown man. You want to be in a relationship with a responsible adult man, yes?

jewel1968 · 27/12/2019 11:43

And going dairy free will only work if he has a dairy allergy. It will not be good for him mentally to exclude something and for it not to work. You should not really exclude anything without some allergy testing.

jewel1968 · 27/12/2019 11:41

And get him to ask for allergy testing.

Bluebutterfly90 · 27/12/2019 11:40

If his eczema tends to get better before going to the doctors I'd recommend taking pictures on a phone of it at its worst. Mine had a habit of clearing up a bit just before appointments - and that led to me being sent home as fine when I actually had a skin infection turning septic.
Not to be alarmist, but people do underestimate eczema, including GPs.
I hope he can get it sorted. Flowers

namechange100002 · 27/12/2019 11:34

@Sparkle2020 thank you, I have said to him to look into that now x

OP posts:
Sparkle2020 · 27/12/2019 10:58

Honestly OP I beg of you to get him to fight for a dermatologist and get on the dupixent injection!!! It is life changing

namechange100002 · 27/12/2019 10:49

Thank you to everyone who replied.

I spoke to BF last night and said

'I'm really struggling right now. After spending Christmas and boxing day mostly alone, the 10th time you've cancelled on me in the last two months, I'm feeling very down about things. You know I love you but unless you let me support you through this and actively try to change, I can't be with you any more. I'm definitely not perfect and I'm trying really hard to be understanding, but I feel so lonely in this relationship it hurts.

I'm doing the veganuary challenge this year with work, I want you to try going dairy-free with me as you didn't give it a chance last year and it's something the doctor suggested could help. I want you to cut down smoking. I'm not asking you to quit. But even just by 1 or 2 a day, it's not good for your asthma and that worries me. I also want you to make more of an effort - I'll buy you some cotton pyjamas and you need to change them daily. Even if you can't shower it's important to keep your skin clean. You need to keep up with your creams and lying in bed all day every day won't help. I saw how you were after being in hospital on holiday. I want that you. I've never seen you so happy and I know it's because your skin didn't hurt.

I don't think this is too much to ask and I would love it if you would try for me and for us. I'll help as much as I can.
I love you and I want to help you get better so we can make this work but I need to put myself and DD first as I can't carry on our relationship without knowing there's a future.'

He's said he'll do what I asked and he's sorry for how I feel. So that's good. Hopefully things might get better.

In answer to some other questions

  • no he doesn't have a dermatologist, the NHS have refused under the grounds that it's 'under control' - it isn't. But by the time he's well enough to leave the house to see the GP, it's not as flared any more.
  • he has a pretty good job admin based for the NHS which is why they are so understanding with all this time off. I do worry for his future though as they aren't going to keep him off indefinitely.
OP posts:
BellsAJingleTheRoastedChestnut · 27/12/2019 09:19

I think the comments have mainly been compassionate towards the OP's bf, but compassion doesn't mean she owes him an intimate relationship.

I hope none of you get any of these kinds of illnesses because I don't think you would be able to cope

I hope I never have to find out what it's like to be asthmatic. I do have eczema, but nowhere near as bad as the OP's bf. I don't imagine I would suddenly take up smoking and eliminate all fruit and vegetables from my diet, but who knows? I imagine his MH is a factor here. I had a parent who struggled with MH and alcoholism until the day they died young. Yes, of course I nursed them, as a daughter would, but I wouldn't choose to be in a relationship with someone who is addicted (booze in my parent's case, cigs in the OP's bf's) and in self destruct mode with poor diet. I would definitely remain friends if they let me and support them as a friend, but I wouldn't choose a romantic relationship or move in with someone going through similar. Been there, not through choice and I would never choose to do it again.

I do think if the op and he were married with dcs it would be a different story, but they are only just starting out on a new relationship, to the point he won't even let the op see him and cancels plans when he is unwell. I don't see how this can work as a new relationship.

TheBouquets · 27/12/2019 09:03

No-one choses to be ill especially not with incurable illnesses. There is no cure for asthma or eczema. They both change sometimes barely noticeable other times they are really bad often needing hospital treatment.
There have been so many heartless comments made on this thread. I have had some really nasty comments in real life too. I hope none of you get any of these kinds of illnesses because I don't think you would be able to cope.

NearlyGranny · 27/12/2019 09:01

What Sexequality says ^^

If his condition had developed gradually over years while you were married to him, that would be different. You haven't promised 'in sickness or in health' to this man, however, and the relationship is new and exploratory.

Is it impolite to ask what he's living on, Boss? Is he self-employed? Does he have a very understanding employer or is he relying on benefits? If he moves in with you, you may find he is no longer entitled to some of the support he may have been getting.

Think hard; you already have a child whose welfare you are prioritising.

pp12 · 27/12/2019 08:58

As someone this could be apart from smoking. I shower daily yes it hurts so much having one. Had weekly doctors, hospital and dentist appointment this year took until September to have two weeks off from them But YANBU if he can’t help himself the there is no point in trying.

Sexequality · 27/12/2019 08:48

You can leave a relationship for any reason at all: the smoking would do it for me.

Do not continue a relationship our of guilt of because you think you should help him. You will just be one increasingly resentful.

LadyTiredWinterBottom2 · 27/12/2019 08:44

Yeah l think diet could be really important here, l get patches of eczema if l eat food with high wheat content.

YANBU. It could get worse as he ages and you will have no life with him. He's not reliable, he puts his own needs first..it would be different if he developed these issues whilst you were in a LT relationship.

Will you lose him as a friend if you break up?

PollyPelargonium52 · 27/12/2019 08:38

You haven't done anything wrong. If he won't take action for his health he shouldn't be getting any sympathetic understanding. I have no time for people when their health problems are self-inflicted. Unless it is addictions/mental health issues of course.

BellsAJingleTheRoastedChestnut · 27/12/2019 08:33

Like managedmis, I would really struggle to maintain a relationship with someone who had that sort of diet by choice and who also smoked. I would gladly be a supportive friend and would stay in their life etc, but no, I personally couldn't be in a romantic relationship with someone who made those choices. The fact he smokes with asthma indicates he isn't in the right frame of mind to take care of himself well. No, that isn't his fault and if I was his sister, mother or friend, I'd gently be persuading him to stop and to improve his diet if i could. But when you're starting out in a new relationship, you already have a young child with someone else and you work full time, I 100% see why this would be off putting. I am sure you really like him, or love him as a friend and are very caring towards him, but for me, this wouldn't be enough in a romantic relationship.

That doesn't mean I wouldn't care about that person or want to help them, but that's different to having an intimate, romantic relationship with them and planning a future together.

NearlyGranny · 27/12/2019 08:30

YANBU. It's harder for him but he sounds as if he's given up.

Three days of trying to cut out dairy (a very common allergen) and then saying he 'can't live without cheese' is not suggestive of commitment to getting well. Neither are the smoking and junk food habits.

But worst of all is only working 15 days in 6 months. Add that to the above and you would find yourself breadwinner and carer as well as partner and that's clearly not what you want.

It may, however, be exactly what he wants. Have you asked him how he sees your future together? That could be a revealing conversation.

I would be inclined to say clearly what you want if you are to be on a serious relationship. That might include him stopping smoking, eliminating junk food six days out of seven, eating his 5-a-day seven days a week, seeking specialist support to get his condition under control, focussing on being able to work and socialise more normally. Oh, and showering daily!

If he agrees, why not take a break from making plans with him for a few months to avoid disappointment and allow him time to focus on his campaign? You could still be in touch and spend time together spontaneously when he is up to it. You could also see other people in this time to explore what other options you have!

It might be just the jolt he needs to be more proactive. It might be the eye opener you need when you see how hard he is willing to try for you - or not.

He has the choice here, so it's not controlling to give him an ultimatum. It just says that what's happening now is not enough for you - and why should it be?

He is free to find someone else to nurse and support him if he settles for things as they are. You are free to follow your heart and care for him if he does everything you ask and nothing improves. You aren't asking him to guarantee his future health, just to fight and sacrifice a bit more for it. He could benefit hugely.

Good luck.

jellyjellyinmybelly · 27/12/2019 08:21

Is he under a hospital dermatologist? Does he have access to a dermatology clinical nurse specialist?

It sounds like his eczema is completely out of control. Yes he could no doubt help himself more, but he'd never be able to get it anywhere near to normal skin without massive input from a good medical team.

Can you help him explore nhs options? Who has he seen so far and is he under regular follow up?

Imagine how much easier a relationship would be if his skin was always like how it was after his admission and IV steroids. It would be life changing.

Bigbopboo · 27/12/2019 08:16

Be honest. You do want to break up with him because of his illnesses. I would too. This is a new relationship and you are not getting much out of it. It is not fair on your daughter either.

BlueJava · 27/12/2019 08:15

YANBU. Sounds a tough situation for him, but it sounds like you will spend a lot of your life either looking after him or being let down by him. I think let him down gently as possible.

Gogreen · 27/12/2019 08:11

You heartless Bds!

How is it he is to cure his eczema!! Eating healthy and not smoking doesn’t cure eczema! Washing clothes regularly doesn’t cure it or wearing cotton clothes!

Not smoking doesn’t cure asthma either incase you didn't know!!

I’m pretty sure if there was a easy way to do it no one would have asthma or eczema!!!!!

Don’t blame someone for being sick when they didn't choose it or have tried so many things they know nothing is still working!

Leave him, it’s not gonna work between the two of you, you think he can fix this by eating healthy and not smoking, he can’t, so you will only be disappointed

Jinglebellissimo · 27/12/2019 08:11

The only things he eats are ham and cheese toasties, crisps, pizza, chips, cheeseburgers, chicken and tortilla wraps. He will eat cottage pie or similar provided it has no veg and not too much sauce. He doesn't like any sauces or textures. He won't eat meat if it's in it's full form (e.g. chicken breast or steak), it has to be breaded/fried or as a burger.

^^
Plus he smokes

I don’t think this is a case that OP is saying he should become a full on vegan - but someone who won’t touch anything except junk food is going to have further health problems in the future as well.

PicsInRed · 27/12/2019 08:10

All else aside, you have a child already, whose life is made materially worse by your involvement with this man. You aren't single and free to martyr yourself - you have a child to think of.

Your boyfriend has to go.

Swipe left for the next trending thread