Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s not polite to keep on and on offering food and drink after someone’s said no thanks

285 replies

micepies · 08/12/2019 14:07

At the moment, I am honestly feeling like it’s a battle when I visit certain people. I spend so much time fending off offers of tea, coffee, hot chocolate, cake, sandwiches and biscuits.

It’s turning me anti social as I don’t want to visit.

AIBU and a grumpy sod or should people respect no thank you?

OP posts:
ddl1 · 08/12/2019 15:39

The most extreme, however, happened not to me but to my mum as a young adult. She had lactose intolerance (I don't) and once was staying with someone who was convinced that she needed milk to 'build her up': she had recently had German measles and looked a bit 'peaky'. After a lot of nagging, she gave in and drank some of the milk. Let's just say that the results were not healthy either for her or for her hosts' carpet!

loseyourself · 08/12/2019 15:38

why the hell would that be a problem?

MistyCloud · 08/12/2019 15:38

@micepies 100% with you on this.

Would you like a coffee and a mince pie?

No thanks.

Are you sure?

I'm sure thanks.

I don't mind getting you one.

Er no it's OK I don't want one.

But the mince pies are soooo delicious! And the coffee is nice.

I am fine ta! Hmm

You'll thank me later! Grin

Ummm I am really OK!

Then the feckers go and give it to you anyway! Angry

My ex had this habit of insisting on carrying my shopping bag(s) when we were out.

Gimme your bag, I'll carry it.

No I can carry it - thanks anyway.

Let ME carry it, it's heavy!

I am fine honestly!

FOR GOODNESS SAKE WUMMAN!

Then he would yank it out of my hand and push me away and say 'I SAID I WILL CARRY IT!'

So fucking disrespectful! Hmm

Some see it as being 'helpful' or 'accommodating.' It's not. It's controlling and manipulative. And VERY irritating!

When you ask someone if you can do something for them, or offer to carry something or hold something for them, or get them something to eat or drink, and they say no; they mean NO! They don't want you over-ruling them, with what YOU want!

Basically, some people ask you what you want, listen to what you say, and then go and do what they want anyway! Totally disrespecting you and your decision. As I said, it's controlling and manipulative.

It's the same when someone asks you, what you want for your birthday (or Christmas,) and to give them suggestions. You give them a list of 9 or 10 things, (for them to choose any 2 or 3 to buy,) and they don't buy one single thing off the list of suggestions they ASKED you for.

Why ask someone something, and then do what YOU want anyway?!

So annoying!

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

Wow. Confused

You sound like one of the annoying pushy people who force things on people they don't want, because YOU want them to have it!

Bluntness100 · 08/12/2019 15:37

It's odd they will ask every thirty seconds for ten mins. Very odd. Most people will ask a couple of times. It's also odd that you wish to avoid your friends in case this happens. All round it's a odd frienship dynamic.

loseyourself · 08/12/2019 15:37

@DramaAlpaca I'd strongly advise you never to come to Ireland then

I was waiting for the Irish response and I do this myself (Irish too) do you want tea will be thrown out several times or other offers and the thing is I'll take you up on the tea offer 3rd time round. Why because I've stayed longer than I thought I would, I am happy and settled and it's quite sweet knowing that if I refuse the first time that's not the end of the hospitality.

Roussette · 08/12/2019 15:36

Butter If that was the case, I would just look at them in the eye and say 'Please do NOT ask me again, I do NOT want anything and I mean it'.

I don't know any friend who would ask 20 times in 10 minutes.

ddl1 · 08/12/2019 15:35

'What sort of worked up? They're hardly going to throw you out of the house because you've refused a second jaffa cake are they:? They're friends after all.'

Examples:
'I'm afraid you're going to eat just what everybody else eats here!'

'Now, make a clean plate; there's no need to be so fussy!'

'Not eating THIS?! Well, talk about spoilt!'

'Why are you eating this disgusting white bread? It's much healthier to eat brown bread!' (In my own home; and no, for someone with Crohn's disease a high-fibre diet is NOT healthy.)

'What's the matter? Do you think I'm trying to poison you?'

Admittedly, I've had very little of this in the last 20 years; and usually when it happened it either was when I was a child/ teenager, or from people who had known me when I was, and were still in 'bossy adult' mode toward me. But, especially when one has genuine medical reasons for not eating certain things, it can really damage the confidence, especially if someone persists with it.

ItsChristmaaaaaaaaas · 08/12/2019 15:33

This makes makes me laugh.

Have a cup of tea?
No thanks
Cake - have a slice
No thank you
I just made it today - it’s lovely, just a tiny piece
No thanks I don’t really like cherry cake
I’ll just cut a piece and put it here - it’s really lovely - your uncles favourite, god rest his soul
Actually, well ok just a tiny slice...

(May be followed up later by ‘did you see how much cake she ate? No wonder she has put on so much weight!’).

I have actually been ill after being forcefully offered very sweet goodies (with the best intention) even after explaining that my blood sugar won’t take it.

Mummyshark2018 · 08/12/2019 15:32

It's a good problem to have imo. Hate it when you're not offered a cup of tea. And please don't come to Ireland if you're that easily annoyed.

Butterisbest · 08/12/2019 15:32

Rousette
Ridiculous. My friends are worth far more than getting worked up about saying no to a biscuit.
Ok but what about when your friends don't fucking listen, what about when either your friends or family take no notice of you at all. How about when you've politely declined twice but they just keep pushing, trying to force you to take their hospitality. They don't LISTEN, they're just pushing all the time.
Op you are most definitely not unreasonable at all.

JacquettaW · 08/12/2019 15:30

@Mishappening That's me too! I also get the 'why don't you have a proper drink?' brigade

Roussette · 08/12/2019 15:26

The problem is if THEY get worked up about it
What sort of worked up? They're hardly going to throw you out of the house because you've refused a second jaffa cake are they:? They're friends after all.

krusty that is so lovely. I don't get the arsiness about it on this thread. My dear old Auntie who is no longer around, used to make cakes and lovely little sandwiches and offer them very regularly when we visited. I had some of what she offered and turned down the rest nicely. I wonder if some of the posters on this thread would've found it irritating, I certainly didn't because she meant the world to me. And she was so so pleased to see us.

elizabethdraper · 08/12/2019 15:24

In ireland is rude to accept anything until you have been asked 20 times.

And if you don't offer something every 5 mins you are a horrible host

northernlittledonkey · 08/12/2019 15:23

Can't you just have a cup of tea, or a glass of water or similar? Surely you then don't have to say yes to food unless you turn up at what you know is going to be their meal time?

ddl1 · 08/12/2019 15:23

'I won’t visit friends due to this

Ridiculous. My friends are worth far more than getting worked up about saying no to a biscuit.'

The problem is if THEY get worked up about it.

spanglydangly · 08/12/2019 15:22

That’s fine bling but it’s exhausting having to say no thank you twenty times plus in ten minutes

It's really not exhausting, is it?

Again as said by PP, don't visit an Irish household!

Mishappening · 08/12/2019 15:21

Try being a teetotaller - everyone tries to foist alcohol on you. Whenever I say that fruit juice would be lovely it nearly always engenders the response "Are you sure?" - well, yes, I am sure!

DorothyParkersCat · 08/12/2019 15:21

A couple of offers is ok, more than that is rude but believe me what you are describiging is nothing.

I used to date someone from a different culture and visiting homes abroad that was obsessive offering even in the face of repeated refusal with a reason 'not hungry' . It was worse because often what was offered was home made and accompanied with a hurt puppy look.

I absolutely hated going to any relatives houses because it was a wash, rinse repeat constantly.

ddl1 · 08/12/2019 15:21

'"I won’t visit friends due to this"

Oh get a grip. Honestly. "No thank you, I've just eaten" not hard is it?'

It is, if they refuse to accept your saying no, and get indignant and offended with you!

However, while I can understand avoiding big Christmas 'do's, where attitudes to non-eaters can be affected by Christmas perfectionism, if it is happening regularly whenever you visit them, I would think that the friends are being very obtuse, and perhaps it would be an idea to have a quiet word: 'I have a very small appetite/ I have some food allergies/ I have been advised not to eat certain things for medical reasons. I am not seeking to offend you, and am not criticizing your food which is excellent: I just have some restrictions of my own, and would be grateful if you could accept them and not take offence.'

SenecaFalls · 08/12/2019 15:19

I'd strongly advise you never to come to Ireland then

Or the Southern US. Smile

krustykittens · 08/12/2019 15:19

I think it is cultural. I am from Cork and my granny used to call a cup of tea with no food accompanying it, an 'English' cup of tea. When myself and my mother went home we always made sure we didn't eat for a few hours before the flight as we had to call into three aunties on the way to my Granny's and they would never forgive us for not eating something. My Granny always made sure an apple pie was baked, ready for me to have a slice the minute I walked in the door (I have no idea how she made her pastry and have never found anyone who could do it the same way) and my her neighbour, who had a bakery in her back garden, would always send round a plate of my favourite cakes. Food is part of being hospitable for me - I hope I don't bug people, but if being offered food more than once in my home made people avoid me, they can carry on, I don't want to know them. But then, I wouldn't keep neighbours on the door step either, which seems to be common in the Scottish Borders, where we now live. Food is an intrinsic part of most people's cultures.

JacquettaW · 08/12/2019 15:17

I understand all too well. I will always have a brew but I don't want to be fed up with various biscuits and treats. It took me a long time to lose the excess weight I was carrying and ever since, people seem to constantly want to feed me up.

TheNavigator · 08/12/2019 15:15

"No thank you, I've just eaten" not hard is it?

Of course it isn't, but you have competely failed to understand the OP's point. The issue is with people who won't accept "No thank you, I've just eaten", but continue to badger and pester trying to force unwanted food on you.

ddl1 · 08/12/2019 15:14

I strongly agree. I have some dietary restrictions due to Crohns disease and some people can't understand that it's not the same as a slimming diet that you can break 'just for one day, surely' (not that people should be pressed even for that); and it certainly isn't a rejection of their cooking or desire to have something fancier instead. A combination of treatment that works well for me so that I'm less restricted, and greater public understanding of dietary restrictions , means that things are much easier nowadays (also at my age people are less likely to try to 'reform' me). But for many years in the past I just didn't risk going out for celebratory occasions in case I was treated as 'fussy' and 'rude' for not eating everything; and even at home, guests occasionally took it upon themselves to criticize me for my restrictions.

Roussette · 08/12/2019 15:13

I won’t visit friends due to this

Ridiculous. My friends are worth far more than getting worked up about saying no to a biscuit.