Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s not polite to keep on and on offering food and drink after someone’s said no thanks

285 replies

micepies · 08/12/2019 14:07

At the moment, I am honestly feeling like it’s a battle when I visit certain people. I spend so much time fending off offers of tea, coffee, hot chocolate, cake, sandwiches and biscuits.

It’s turning me anti social as I don’t want to visit.

AIBU and a grumpy sod or should people respect no thank you?

OP posts:
ffswhatnext · 08/12/2019 17:17

I think you have to acknowledge cultural differences

I have friends from a variety of cultures and traditions start to become out-dated. They understand that it's not about being rude to refuse as they have gotten to know me and others. They understand that we have needs at different times. Sometimes yes is said to an offer, and they don't think others are being greedy or whatever. Other times no is said, but that invite remains open.

Cryalot2 · 08/12/2019 17:16

I am with Drama on this, although I live in the North. It is considered bad manners not to offer such to anyone who calls. Both dh and my famlies have always done such.
Even you are poor and have nothing you always offer something. It is also considered rude to refuse. The number of times I have taken and just drank half the cup of tea and ate the plainest thing I can just to be polite. I am wary owing to food intollerances, so have to be careful.
It is very much a sociable thing as well. Tea/coffee and a chat.
I have a friend with an ED and it is so hard, like you she also avoids friends because of such.
I only wish that was all I had to worry about

JigsawsAreInPieces · 08/12/2019 17:14

A family I used to know would offer a drink/snack and whatever your answer was, give it to you anyway.
If you then left it, you had "Asked for it and just left it” repeated to each other over and over again Hmm and if you ate it ”see, you did want it really” so you couldn't win.

Butterisbest · 08/12/2019 17:14

Obviously should read bloody rude. Or sodding rude

Butterisbest · 08/12/2019 17:13

Lunde
Is there a reason that you wont accept a cup of tea or coffee so that the person you are visiting can feel a tiny bit hospitable?
This is why the force feeders are very annoying, it's all about how they feel, it's got fuck all to do with their guests. They don't actually give a shit about their guests. As long as a force feeder has been able to force food and drink on a guest and it makes them feel hospitable. Its all about them feeling good as a host, ignoring their guests wishes.It's bloody rude

ffswhatnext · 08/12/2019 17:10

Why should we give a reason though?
You offer a person alcohol and they cannot because of health reasons. Why should they have to disclose any of their medical information?

Or they have an eating disorder but they don't want to discuss this with you. They are put in a bad situation either way for them. They either have to accept what's offered or lie,

I really don't see saying no to food or drink is in any way different to saying no to sex. If we say no we shouldn't have to say why, or worse give in after being badgered. No is no. I don't play stupid games and say no if I mean yes. If I meant yes I would have said so the first time I was asked. Or shock, horror I would ask the host if I could take them up on the offer.

You think that person is playing the game or are they giving in to simply make you shut up. That is not good hosting. Good hosting for me means that your guests are as comfortable as they can, as they fit around those that live there. They should be respected enough to listen to what they are saying and if it's no, then that's it. They should be at ease to ask if the offer is still available and the host gracefully accepts this.

Stegosaurus1990 · 08/12/2019 17:10

I agree. I often accept because it pleases people.

ReanimatedSGB · 08/12/2019 17:06

I think you have to acknowledge cultural differences before deciding that you are right and everyone else is wrong. If you are someone who, for whatever reasons, restricts what you eat and drink (allergies, certain meds, disordered eating or just good old-fashioned attention-seeker syndrome) then you need to accept that people from an excessively-hospitable culture will keep on offering you food and drinks because their expectation is that no doesn't mean no when it comes to refreshments. If these are not people you know well or are likely to see again, it's worth accepting a small bit of something or other and just not consuming it. If it's someone you are close to, or going to get closer to (a partner's family for instance) it's better to have a word with them about the fact that you can't have whatever they are offering and/or that you really do mean no.

But you also need to take care not to come across as a whiny martyr who thinks that eating and drinking is disgustingly self-indulgent anyway, let alone if it happens 'between meals'.

OhGrrrreat · 08/12/2019 17:05

My DM. She'd force me to eat or have a cup of tea at the very least even if I told her I'd just eaten. She's not so bad now and will generally accept a firm no but I've noticed she wants to be on the receiving end of the fussing.

I agree with PP who said it's the done thing amongst Asians to offer food even if it's declined umpteen times and then still go ahead and lay the table with an array of dishes (if the guest has come from afar then it's a necessity). South Asian food isn't the type you can quickly rustle up so it can be annoying.

My dsis is the type who won't even offer a cup of tea so I usually go and make myself one. I refuse to sit there parched for hours!

Gingerkittykat · 08/12/2019 17:04

Ive got to be honest OP, all the people i know who are annoyed by a polite offer of a biscuit, cup of tea or sandwich are extremely underweight women with issues around food, who constantly restrict their intake.

Nope, I'm both fat and diabetic, trying to eat better and sick of people pushing food on me.

It is worse this time of year with all of the tins of quality street, on Friday I caused offence because everyone was bought a small chocolate santa at a meeting and left it behind afterwards and I only took one sweet from the tin.

It's the same with doughnuts at meetings, no I don't want a fucking doughnut and I don't want to take one for later either. If you had not bought a tray of a dozen you wouldn't have any left to go to waste.

People don't get the message I don't want sugary food, the worst offender is the same relative who has been told the same thing repeatedly yet asks me how my diabetes is on a frequent basis. Please don't buy me sweets as a Christmas gift, and also don't buy me an easter egg.

Eating biscuits, sweets and cakes is not a treat for me, and in fact actively damages me. Right now I know I will be going to various Christmas events and eating a lot, I don't want to be pigging out all month.

RoLaren · 08/12/2019 17:04

The Iranian concept of 'Taarof' requires a guest to refuse food and drinks three times before accepting. It's seen as being greedy otherwise.

joyfullittlehippo · 08/12/2019 17:01

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ginghamtablecloths · 08/12/2019 16:58

I agree it's annoying. Some people love to cater for others and can 'fuss' for want of a better word. MIL was like this, it was as if she thought we were incapable of feeding ourselves in our own home. However, she was very forgetful so we gritted our teeth politely.

namynom · 08/12/2019 16:58

I think the people who say yabu have obviously not experienced the aggressive 20 offers in ten minutes kind of a thing. My mil is always angry when she has guests round that she's invited herself, won't take no for an answer, won't take maybe later for an answer, won't take I've just had one for an answer, won't take yes that's enough for an answer, and when I do say yes generally decides I don't like something half way through me eating or drinking it and strops off all huffy with whatever it is I've been enjoying to get me something else. It honestly is genuinely stressful going over to her house.

Asking a couple or three times over say an hour is totally normal and hospitable. Not leaving you alone for one second to enjoy whatever they've given you and have a chat is just intense and anxiety inducing.

Also no I don't have anything close to an eating disorder and have a very healthy attitude to food. I actually nearly always accept something to try and shut her up.

joyfullittlehippo · 08/12/2019 16:57

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 08/12/2019 16:55

blaue
^
Nope, we just know we're about to eat a big dinner and don't want to spoil our appetite. Or we've just had a big dinner and don't have any room left!^

Then simply say this
People seem terribly reluctant to say why they are saying no.

ffswhatnext · 08/12/2019 16:55

Is there a reason that you wont accept a cup of tea or coffee so that the person you are visiting can feel a tiny bit hospitable?

And what if the person doesn't like tea or coffee?
I'm not a big fan of tea. There are only certain ones I enjoy and none include the bog-standard tea. An ex-friend used to always offer me tea. I always declined saying I don't like it. Again, asked, again declined. When the friend went and made the tea was I supposed to sit and drink it to please the host? How would that help me?

All it says was well I say no thanks, I don't like it, but to placate you I will endure it.
I also have intolerances and allergies. Still, arseholes tried to push those things on me knowing the ramifications. To make them feel a bit hospitable we just eat/drink anyway?

Instead, how about understanding the meaning of no. No is no. No doesn't come with exemptions unless it's going to cause the person harm.

Why should we have to lower our own boundaries to placate someone else? Reducing your own boundaries can lead to a slippery slope of other boundaries lowered.

What if the host wanted to offer me a joint to be hospitable and I didn't smoke weed?

wanderings · 08/12/2019 16:52

Has nobody mentioned "constant offers of tea" being used in that video to teach children about consent?

I do think this issue is symptomatic of something bigger, which is often ranted about on MN: that many of us are socialised to be "nice"; never to refuse offers of food and drink, never to complain, never to stand up for ourselves, never to say something that might rock the boat, or be inconvenient for our hosts: so many of us won't assert ourselves, won't say what we mean, agree to things that we shouldn't agree to, and so on. Pushy sales people chuggers know this, and try to use it to their advantage. Is there a reason that chuggers are so successful that charities keep employing them, even though most people on the internet loathe them?

Perhaps I have strong views on this because as a child and a young adult, I was a total pushover, and was always agreeing to things, simply because I was afraid of being told off for being "rude" if I tried to fight my corner: I wouldn't stand up for myself ever, and I'm sure this held me back as a young adult. I don't find it funny when people in comedies are too weak to assert themselves, and end up agreeing to far more than is good for them.

I do a job where I regularly visit people in their homes, and I am frequently offered refreshments. But if I don't want them, I say no, without hesitation, and sometimes I have asked them to stop offering.

CointreauVersial · 08/12/2019 16:42

Ha! As soon as I saw this thread I thought of Ireland.

One of DH's friends pretty much foists a three-course meal on you, regardless what time of day it is, and whether or not you have said yes to the offer of food. She is just being hospitable, and I couldn't imagine getting worked up about it, or considering it "not polite". I think it's a caring gesture.

BlaueLagune · 08/12/2019 16:38

Yes people should respect a no thank you. There's something about wanting to be a host(ess) though and wanting to feed people is part of that. However, it's completely ridiculous to get offended because people won't eat something. MIL used to be like that, she'd ask you a million times if you wanted a piece of cake or biscuit.

I get that sometimes people have bought something especially for someone's visit and don't want it to go to waste but far better eg to buy individual portions that can be saved rather than one big cake in that case.

all the people i know who are annoyed by a polite offer of a biscuit, cup of tea or sandwich are extremely underweight women with issues around food, who constantly restrict their intake

Nope, we just know we're about to eat a big dinner and don't want to spoil our appetite. Or we've just had a big dinner and don't have any room left! I do not restrict my intake unreasonably, I eat more than most people I know.

midep · 08/12/2019 16:35

I loved my Irish MIL. I was up a ladder, wallpapering her living room at 9.30am one Sunday morning. When I'd turned down a glass of port for the fifth time, she changed tack and asked if I'd rather have a sherry.

She's much missed.

CherryPavlova · 08/12/2019 16:34

I’m just thinking of Mrs Doyle.....

SolitaryGrape · 08/12/2019 16:34

Ah, with @Lunde’s comment we’re getting to the heart of it. It’s nothing to do with the guest’s hunger/thirst etc, it’s about the host’s ‘needs’.

Lunde · 08/12/2019 16:32

Is there a reason that you wont accept a cup of tea or coffee so that the person you are visiting can feel a tiny bit hospitable?

TooSweetToBeSour · 08/12/2019 16:29

Ah cheer up OP, maybe your friend will cop on to your shitey attitude towards their hospitality and stop inviting you round at all!