Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s not polite to keep on and on offering food and drink after someone’s said no thanks

285 replies

micepies · 08/12/2019 14:07

At the moment, I am honestly feeling like it’s a battle when I visit certain people. I spend so much time fending off offers of tea, coffee, hot chocolate, cake, sandwiches and biscuits.

It’s turning me anti social as I don’t want to visit.

AIBU and a grumpy sod or should people respect no thank you?

OP posts:
Butterisbest · 09/12/2019 21:10

It's about fucking boundaries, do some people on this thread seriously not get this point.
If it's said politely, no thanks, I'm full, no, it's ok, no I'm not really hungry, aw that's very kind but I just ate, no we're just going out for dinner.
NO means NO.
I'm reminded of a very long running poster, her husband used to guilt trip her into overeating.
She finally managed to get away from him. Red, ring any bells for posters.
Op, it definitely not polite and borderline abusive for people to keep force feeding you. It's all about them not you.

PigeonInTheLoft · 09/12/2019 21:00

Sorry, I've NRTFT but just wanted to say you're not alone. I have a MIL, who I genuinely love, but her insistence on forcing food on me has caused me a great deal of stress over the years, even once to the point of tears (in private, in the loo!) where I ended up avoiding visiting her for a good few weeks afterwards.

I'm a small petite person, genetically. Mother and father both small people with small appetites. I am the same. I can't eat a lot. It makes me feel very ill. I don't do breakfast, rarely bother with lunch, small snacks and one modest meal at dinner time is all I need. I rarely do desserts. I also have awful IBS. Over-filling has me doubled over with spasms.

MIL knows all this.

At times she has left everyone alone on the food-harassing EXCEPT ME. On one occasion she even got it into a stomping mood because I refused to eat a 5 peoples indian takeaway leftovers from the night before AS WELL AS a totally fresh full dinner of quiche, chips and salad she'd just cooked that evening. Nobody else was expected to eat all that... just me. She insisted I had said I wanted to eat all that. I would NEVER have said that.

I've no idea if she behaves like this with me because it's a jealousy thing, as she's always been overweight and I've always been slim (not a brag btw, I still have a mum tum, cellulite and stretch marks like anyone else, I'm just small with it) or if she see's my refusals to eat until I'm sick as an insult towards her?

Either way, she has a bee in her bonnet about my lack of food consumption and its made me really dislike her at times. It almost feels abusive.

YANBU

Its polite to offer, but it's not nice to continue pressuring someone into eating when they don't want to.

EmmiJay · 09/12/2019 21:00

This is new to me 👀 all my friends and, of course family, are from cultures where we feast at get togethers even just visits (usually tea, drinks, snacks.) West Indian, Asian, Turkish etc.

joyfullittlehippo · 09/12/2019 20:50

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Mumtotwo82 · 09/12/2019 20:46

It annoys me more when they try to constantly overfeed my kids with cakes biscuits, sweets. I had to fend off sweets getting stuffed in my pockets and cakes for later. I literally just let the kids have a pack of sweets and a pack to take home from this person, it's like it's never enough. I don't get why people can't except a no thanks or no more thanks!

lboogy · 09/12/2019 20:39

Seems very European to not accept offers of food. You go to the poorest countries and they will offer you what little food they have. You sound very ungrateful. it costs you noting to be gracious and accept.

sunshinemode · 09/12/2019 20:28

Drama is right and not taking the piss at all. I have warned all my friends coming to someone’s house in Leland to accept at least a drink or run the risk of been seen as very stuck up particularly when they are English.

When I visit family in Bangladesh everyone is asked at least 3 times. It is considered polite to refuse a few times before accepting.

TriangularRatbag · 09/12/2019 19:56

Very annoying!

After three times it's usually better to accept the cup of tea or whatever's being offered and just not to drink it.

Katjolo · 09/12/2019 19:49

Definitely cultural. Perfectly normal amongst my family and inlaws to offer a slice of cake or biscuits etc. With s cup of tea. Never occurred to me that someone would be offended???

CountYourRoosters · 09/12/2019 19:31

I find if you just say no, they don't believe you and keep offering. But if you give a reason "no thanks, i just ate, I'm so full, no honestly i would feel sick if i ate anything" that will stop them!

bellocchild · 09/12/2019 19:27

It's hard saying no. I have a very good friend who actively avoids meeting in coffee shops, and always invites a fee friends round to hers instead, for coffee. Then she goes into Bake-off mode and presses us to eat large quantities of carbohydrate-heavy delicacies, almost a whole meal. We know she has spent time and effort on this largesse, and it seems unpardonably ungrateful to refuse, although we really don't want that much food at that time of day. Invariably, all present accept something and eat enough not to be rude...it seems better than hurting someone's feelings. We've tried saying 'don't go to any trouble' but she obviously likes doing it...

Rosebel · 09/12/2019 19:11

My BIL is a lovely person but dread visiting. He'll offer me coffee about 6 times an hour despite me telling him countless times I don't drink coffee. I usually just ask for a glass of water. Still get offered coffee though.
I have a huge Irish family and with them it's easier to accept something as they seen to feel guilty if you don't eat and drink constantly

joyfullittlehippo · 09/12/2019 19:09

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Shinyletsbebadguys · 09/12/2019 19:00

I can see both sides of it to be honest.

We are Welsh and frankly offering food is not that dissimilar to the Irish in the part of Wales we are from. However not quite so insistent but the cultural tendency is to try and feed.

Saying that I've worked really hard to lose weight , I'm just off 7 stone lost , and of course people would offer food constantly. I did always try and make it clear I want refusing to play the passive aggressive game and make a joke out of it that it was me not them.

I recognise it wasn't great but that goal was really important to me and very much my health. If you think of it going to three peoples houses a day and having a biscuit every time adds up. I'm honestly not obsessive but I also dont agree that I should have to eat to "be polite".

I would of course accept a coffee etc (it probably helps I am a big caffeine addict ).

Ultimately it needs to be about some level of respect. I do think hosts who take offence to someone being upfront and saying honestly I dont want any food thanks , that's about them being selfish. However the visitor should really accept at least a tea or coffee etc (or whatever you drink even water ) to show willing.

Nearly47 · 09/12/2019 18:56

Never had an issue with friends my own age. We talk, they offer me drink /food and I so thanks, second time with a reason why I am declining. They might offer again or offer something different. I might change my mind and accept it. No problems. We communicate.
Had some issues with older relatives. My gran would put food on my plate without asking ( apparently I was too skinny) but never made me angry and they never got angry at me either. It was like a dance we both new the steps. It seems you are out of sinc with your friends...

WhoisitnowRalph · 09/12/2019 18:51

I haven't RTFT but my late stepfather did this, and so does my DH. Its annoying not because I necessarily think it's rude to continually push food/drink onto people who have said no, but because it interferes with normal conversation.

I'll be having a nice chat with my brother or telling an aunt a story or marvelling at something dreadful one of my stepsons has done or relaying something fascinating to a friend, but we are constantly bloody interrupted.

Does anyone want another drink? Do you want lemonade instead? I can go and get you some? Does anyone want more gravy? Everyone all right for brussel sprouts? Roast potato anyone? More wine? Is anyone too warm? Cup of tea? Can I get you anything else? Have another Yorkshire pudding. Does anyone need more green beans?

None can ever finish a fucking sentence and all conversations dry up because the endless interrupting ruins people's train of thought. Just shut up and let people socialise.

namynom · 09/12/2019 18:37

@shumway but those are threads made by different people with different relatives. There is a happy medium of actually just listening to what your guests want and respecting their choices, rather than thinking you know better about what they should be eating/drinking.

Twofingers · 09/12/2019 18:35

Nobody could leave my mother’s house without a round of sandwiches and a piece of cake, not even the postman.

DanceItOut · 09/12/2019 17:38

I'm with you. As someone who has always struggled with weight I try to be quite strict and say no only to be repeatedly offered things with the phrase "one won't hurt" which I agree one won't. But when one is offered by everyone you visit especially this time of year it all adds up. Why can't people just accept a polite no thank you?

SteelRiver · 09/12/2019 15:00

I'm with you, OP. It can get very awkward at times. I don't drink tea or coffee so I just politely say no, thanks. I don't want to explain it, as people more often than not start exclaiming 'what, no tea or coffee, ever?' and generally look at me like I'm crazy.

If I offer guests something and they politely refuse I just accept that and ask them to let me know if they want something later.

shumway · 09/12/2019 14:54

Usually there's threads with people visiting inlaws over Christmas and complaining they've been left starving. Can't win.

Whattodoabout · 09/12/2019 14:50

My Gran is like this. I visited her once after I’d just finished lunch and told her as much but she kept insisting on me eating cheese toasties. She does make nice cheese toasties tbf but I was full, she’s a very hard woman to say no to.

SolitaryGrape · 09/12/2019 14:31

If someone says “I’m allergic to coffee but would love a glass of water” that’s a clear no to further offers of coffee.

It's a clear no to coffee, but not to associated offers intended to 'take the mean look off' a visitor sitting with a glass of water 'What about tea? Are you sure? Or I've hot chocolate? Cocoa? Ovaltine? What about this cappuccino in a sachet are you sure you're definitely allergic to that, too? Water looks fierce mean -- what about a Coke? Fanta? Orange juice? A smoothie? Or, if you really won't have anything but water, what about something with it? A biscuit? Some fruitcake? A scone? A yoghurt? A bar of chocolate? A sandwich?'

This is my mother, and my aunt, both born in rural Ireland in the 40s, but longterm city-dwellers.

And if you, say, eventually wearily agreed to a scone, you would be presented with a plate with at least two giant scones, already covered in jam and cream, because 'one looks mean'.

My mother also has form for offering things she thinks the visitor might expect but which she doesn't actually have in the house, and disappearing into the kitchen to either knock up a batch of scones from scratch and/or sending a child to the shop to buy some approximation of whatever it is she's offered some unsuspecting visitor. Who probably only wanted a glass of water... Angry

In Ireland you refuse twice and accept on the third offering

My mother would regard this as incredibly precipitate, the equivalent of someone literally snatching something out of the hand of the offerer. Grin

It is absolutely exhausting to be around. And we have never been able to train her out of it. I have been telling my mother for a good thirty years that I prefer a cup of tea by itself I don't like it with food but she still thinks it 'looks mean' and can't prevent herself from trying to press food I do not want on me.

joyfullittlehippo · 09/12/2019 14:02

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Bluesheep8 · 09/12/2019 13:25

DramaAlpaca

I'd strongly advise you never to come to Ireland then

Brilliant! I was thinking the same thing myself Grin