Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s not polite to keep on and on offering food and drink after someone’s said no thanks

285 replies

micepies · 08/12/2019 14:07

At the moment, I am honestly feeling like it’s a battle when I visit certain people. I spend so much time fending off offers of tea, coffee, hot chocolate, cake, sandwiches and biscuits.

It’s turning me anti social as I don’t want to visit.

AIBU and a grumpy sod or should people respect no thank you?

OP posts:
angelfacecuti75 · 10/12/2019 18:25

No think they are just trying to make you feel welcome ...

joyfullittlehippo · 10/12/2019 15:00

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

NaturalDisasters · 10/12/2019 14:49

I have an English SIL and she's lovely but is looked on as a bit of an oddball because (1) she'll refuse tea/coffee quite rudely if offered more than once per visit and (2) when visiting hers, if she offers "a cup of tea" then thats literally what you get. No biscuit or cake on the side. She has brought home to me the differences between Irish and English hospitality!

Irish here, but live in England, and I far prefer the 'just a cup of tea' approach, because it's a real relief to be able to accept a cup of tea knowing you're not about to have a slew of food pressed upon you, or that if someone offers you a biscuit, they won't be mortally offended if you don't want it.

I remember when my elderly grandfather came over from Ireland years ago to visit his sister, who'd lived in England her whole adult life. She brought him a cup of tea in bed one morning breakfast would have been following within an hour or so and he was so horrified by the look of the cup of tea by itself that he assumed she'd made some terrible faux pas, and thought he was doing her a favour by reminding her that she'd left off the biscuit or slice of bread he thought should have naturally come with it. She of course thought he was being a savage to want a pre-breakfast snack at 7 am. Grin

lindsayincroydon · 10/12/2019 14:13

Poor you ! Yes, it is very irritating.

Also, a lot of my friends simply refuse to accept that I am vegetarian.

They say Oh just try a plate of this stew/ meat sandwich/ tuna bake/ sausage roll (etc), it is so delicious.

I take a little bottle of soya milk with me, and anyone would think it is poison when I get it out for a cup of tea.

I wonder why some people, especially older folk, cannot accept other people's (polite) choices ?

Nimmykins · 10/12/2019 13:18

I have this with MIL and SIL. I’m perfectly satisfied but they insist on offering me more.

I’m very overweight and know when to stop. I know they think they’re being lovely but when I’ve said “no thanks” and then have a packet of biscuits opened and placed in front of me then it is upsetting.

FelicisNox · 10/12/2019 13:08

It's a bit annoying but nothing more than that.

To some people it's rude not to keep offering (in case of a change of mind).

You are not the overriding authority on what is and isn't good manners, it's a mixture of personal preference and upbringing.

TriangularRatbag · 10/12/2019 12:43

If I want a cup of tea I say yes when asked, rather than going through some choreographed rigmarole of refusal that I wasn't even aware was expected. Am I causing terrible outrage? Do they all gasp inwardly and bitch about me when I'm gone? "The rude grasping baggage! The greed of the woman! The cheek of her!"

I've occasionally even proactively suggested I'd like a cup of tea, or could I have coffee instead. It's amazing I've never been thrown out into the street for my appalling faux pas!

OhTheRoses · 10/12/2019 04:37

All this business of offering three times because it's rude for a guest to accept the first time and it's cultural.

I live in England and was brought up in England. It is perfectly normal to offer a cup of tea or another drink. If the visitor doesn't want it, it is perfectly normal to accept that. No simply means no. If the visitor really wanted a cup of tea they could say yes.

Keep life simple and stop playing games.

My house:

Hello Friend would you like a cup of tea.
No thanks
OK

Mother's house
Hello OhThe do you want a cup of tea.
No it's ok mum I'm not thirsty
Oh a coffee then, no thanks mum I'm not thirsty
I'm putting the kettle on
Oh ok mum, you have a cup of tea
I've made a pot aare you sure you don't want one
No thanks mum, and look at the time I'll be awake all night
I've some biscuits, have one - lovely with a cup of tea
Mum, what did I say about not wanting tea
Oh stop being a misery OhThe I'm only being sociable.

Er no mother, actually you are not. You are being controlling because you cannot respect that I don't want a cup of fucking tea and even if I did I'm not playing.

Knucklehead101 · 10/12/2019 04:07

Welp! It’s definitely the hermit life for me. Human beings are confusing 😢

namynom · 10/12/2019 03:03

This thread is so annoying, so many posters deliberately misunderstanding the point of the thread just so they can have a go at the OP

Not one person has said it's offensive to offer people food and drink.

Most people have agreed that it's actually okay to ask two or three times and then ask again if they stay a while in case anyone's changed their mind. You might even ask quickly 2 or 3 times again at this point if they've been there a while. This is all fine and normal, I do this in my own home. It takes up about 10 seconds of the conversation.

The stress and exhaustion of it all comes in when the host literally will not let up and as PPs have said disrupts the conversation so much that nobody is allowed to sit and have a chat.

PPs saying people are exaggerating and you can't imagine someone offering that much, that's fine you obviously don't know anyone like this and are very lucky you don't have to deal with it once/twice a week. But if you have never experienced it then why are you having a go at people who have that want to complain about it?

It's just wilfully taking things out of context and like a PP said it isn't rocket science, just be a normal person! When your friends or family come round offer them whatever you have and then let them decide whether they want it or not. Just because they're in your house doesn't mean you are now in control of their choices.

Hmmmwhatsthat · 10/12/2019 01:50

Another Irish person here, I have an English SIL and she's lovely but is looked on as a bit of an oddball because (1) she'll refuse tea/coffee quite rudely if offered more than once per visit and (2) when visiting hers, if she offers "a cup of tea" then thats literally what you get. No biscuit or cake on the side. She has brought home to me the differences between Irish and English hospitality!

ddl1 · 10/12/2019 01:34

'Good grief ! Thank fuck I don’t get visitors that often I’d never cope with the strain of thinking I’d offended them with the offer of too much/little food.'

Nobody sane would get offended over what someone does or doesn't OFFER them. It's the constant pressurizing and not accepting their refusal that can be upsetting to people. I think one of the PP stated what really is the problem: that for some people food = love. Food is food; it is not love. Accepting other people's wishes is love.

ddl1 · 10/12/2019 01:30

'Yes the thread is about forcing people to eat, but in some cultures/families it's very rude to refuse to eat'

Well, it shouldn't be. And I'm normally someone who strongly supports cultural diversity; but it doesn't excuse forcing people to eat. Waste - asking for food and then not eating it - could be considered as rude; so could accepting an invitation to a meal and then not eating anything (unless one was feeling ill). But making it clear from the beginning that one isn't hungry, or only wants a small amount, should be accepted.

ddl1 · 10/12/2019 01:25

'You sound very ungrateful. it costs you noting to be gracious and accept.'

It can cost you a LOT, if you have health problems that prevent you eating certain things. Before my Crohns was under control, eating something that didn't agree with me could mean my being really ill for a couple of days at least. My mother was physically sick all over the carpet when forced to drink milk, to which she had an intolerance. Someone with type 1 diabetes or a serious food allergy could quite easily end up in hospital.

Even without a specific health problem, being forced to eat when already full can be quite unpleasant. And the people we're talking about will often not stop at one offer; they will press and press, more and more.

'Ungrateful': While one should be grateful that someone is offering food, one has no obligation to be grateful to people for DEMANDING that you eat it, and refusing to take no for an answer. The people to whom I'm most grateful are those who take my word for it, when I say I do or do not want something.

And beyond the physical aspects of being pressurized to eat against one's will, or more than one wants, it is quite offensive to suggest that someone else does not know their own mind, or is being insincere about what they want to eat, especially if the people know each other well. I don't 'play games' and I don't like being accused by implication of doing so.

Savingshoes · 10/12/2019 00:24

My partner and in-laws do this. I feel backed into a corner with "are you sure?" Every 5 seconds.
Partner isn't so bad anymore but when ever we visit the in-laws they don't ever accept the first no thank you.
Initially thought it was a nervous/habbit thing but after getting to know them it's more a eating disorder deflection/ by proxy thing...
... they offer me a biscuit like some sort of dog and do not leave off the subject for a good few minutes "are you sure?" "Are you I'll?" "Do you want something else instead?"
A short time later "if I get X, do you want some too?" "Not like you to refuse desert/a snack?" Sometimes I say no thank you so many times I forget my trail of thought.
Weirdos.

Butterisbest · 10/12/2019 00:08

Toomuchtrouble4me
Why does someone saying no to you make them hard work?

Butterisbest · 09/12/2019 23:48

knucklehead101
If you bothered to read the thread you should have noticed it's not the being offered that the problem. It's the complete refusal of the hosts to take no thanks for an answer.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 09/12/2019 23:44

Bloody hell - you sound hard work.

Knucklehead101 · 09/12/2019 23:01

Good grief ! Thank fuck I don’t get visitors that often I’d never cope with the strain of thinking I’d offended them with the offer of too much/little food.

JaffaMum · 09/12/2019 22:51

YNBU. We need to be a more honest, up front society without these food mind games! No means no, if you actually want to eat the cakes then say it, if you only want a small bit take a small bit. Life would be much more simpler.

Butterisbest · 09/12/2019 21:46

Drizzzle
Yes the thread is about forcing people to eat, but in some cultures/families it's very rude to refuse to eat
Ok so it's better for a guest to be force fed than be made to feel comfortable. Just make them eat, no matter what the guest wants.The hosts feelings are more important than their guests, it's better that the guests are force fed and should be shamed and vilified by not eating. It's all ok then as long as the host has forced their guests to eat, even if they didn't want to.

joyfullittlehippo · 09/12/2019 21:37

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Drizzzle · 09/12/2019 21:22

Yes the thread is about forcing people to eat, but in some cultures/families it's very rude to refuse to eat. If you know you will be offered food/snacks at someone's house make sure you are a bit hungry before you arrive! Eating and drinking together is often about sharing community and being hospitable.

Butterisbest · 09/12/2019 21:13

@EmmiJay
It helps if you read the thread, it's about forcing people to eat.

mauvaisereputation · 09/12/2019 21:11

TBH I think it's a bit rude to refuse a cup of tea if you go round to someone's house, especially if you ALWAYS refuse it. If you say no and then stay a while, it's natural and polite for the host to offer again. I'd say it's also polite to have a bit of an "ooh go on" if you're offering something as often people do refuse the first time out of politeness. Obviously pressuring someone to eat is rude though!