Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s not polite to keep on and on offering food and drink after someone’s said no thanks

285 replies

micepies · 08/12/2019 14:07

At the moment, I am honestly feeling like it’s a battle when I visit certain people. I spend so much time fending off offers of tea, coffee, hot chocolate, cake, sandwiches and biscuits.

It’s turning me anti social as I don’t want to visit.

AIBU and a grumpy sod or should people respect no thank you?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Redarrow2017 · 21/01/2022 10:45

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Regardingtheduck · 21/01/2022 10:28

Because it irritated me the other day when I visited people amd they kept.offering endlessly and I googled it and up came this thread ....and then I was curious as to what the wise web folk currently think about the issue of persistent badgering in this context....and if I can take any tips or learn a new perspective for the next time....

Regardingtheduck · 21/01/2022 10:16

There is a great story of when Queen Vic received a guest who was offered a cup of tea. The guest from somewhere in the vast empire at that time - obviously did not know about cups and saucers so poured the tea from the cup into the saucer and then drank it from the saucer. Despite the big eyes of the staff, Queen Vic proceeded to do the same and drank in this way too....
Now what does that say about the height of manners is making the guest feel.comfortable rather than yourself as a host and what you think is appropriate.....

SpringSpringTime · 21/01/2022 09:59

Oh but I think different-it’s a cultural hang-over from when food really was scarce; feeding guests was a big act of generosity and guests in turn anxious not to put hosts out of pocket/appear greedy. It’s different in contemporary culture where we have a superabundance of food.

Regardingtheduck · 21/01/2022 09:55

Just realised " love" in a lot of cultures is less about enabling differing ways and more about protection and fielty. So by eating whatever is constantly offered and denying your own desire or will, is a way of unifying with the host and surrendering your will to theirs an act of becoming one with them. A suspicious outsider or enemy might not eat for fear of malice and see himself as different - this would convey separation to both the host and the guest . Eating the same food has been seen as a unifying exercise - symbolising a unified body.

SpringSpringTime · 21/01/2022 09:53

Coming at this the other way (because now I’m worried I’m rude)….guests to my house will get endless cups of tea if they wish but I don’t snack so I never offer anything to eat (unless it’s a meal). Am I rude?! I don’t want half a pack of stale biscuits hanging around for guests…need to find something to offer though!

Regardingtheduck · 21/01/2022 09:46

Social norms are different - I understand that but whose norms dominate the host or the guest? It becomes about social hierarchy then not "love".
Basically if you think you are higher in a social structure (an elder, rich, beneficial) your norms should dominate. This is what can irritate the lower rank person (child, poorer, seeker of benefit) as their will is subsumed into the will of the greater. Would love to know what an anthropologist would say.

Arnia · 21/01/2022 02:09

It's probably been said six million times but never come to Ireland Grin its rude to only offer once here. Social norms are a funny thing. it's late so I cba reading the full thread but I'm fairly certain I've repeated what many other have said to apologies and goodnight...

ddl1 · 21/01/2022 02:07

Why why why why why have you resurrected a teo year old ZOMBIE thread!

I was vaguely aware that I'd once been on a somewhat similar thread, but I only now realize that it's the same thread!

grapewine · 21/01/2022 01:21

@Whattodoabout

My Gran is like this. I visited her once after I’d just finished lunch and told her as much but she kept insisting on me eating cheese toasties. She does make nice cheese toasties tbf but I was full, she’s a very hard woman to say no to.
My Gran's like that. I'll stop by for a cup of tea, pre-arranged, and she'll have made my favourite lunch or waffles or something. It's very hard to say no. I rarely do because I know she does it because she loves me. But I do know not to eat before I see her.

She also makes care packages. I'm so lucky to have her still.

Dreamstate · 21/01/2022 00:41

I'm with you OP, I find it really disrespectful that they can take a polite refusal of no I'm fine thanks.

My dad is the worst he will literally force any man who visits to have a beer or two or three ..just so he can drink. And even if they say no several times he will keep at it. It infuriates me actually when I'm there to see it. Its like the guy said no stop forcing them.

My mum did the same throughout mt childhood to me here have another nan bread its okay mea while I'm getting overweight from too much food. Even as a adult if my sister and her only have say one, she will always tell me no have another yet she won't ever eat that amount of food she tried to force on me. I find it really stressful esp when I'm trying to lose weight and she even then comments and tells me to lose weight whilst telling me to eat more.

Urgh!!!! Screw cultural norms just bwcuase back in the day thats how it is...I think the whole thing is stupid pretending ro be polite when I asked first and then say yes. Just say yes the first time!

5foot5 · 21/01/2022 00:18

@Regardingtheduck

Why why why why why have you resurrected a teo year old ZOMBIE thread!

hibbledibble · 21/01/2022 00:17

Aggressive feeding of guests is the norm in many cultures. It causes offence to refuse.

This thread shows a lot of insensitivity to other cultural norms.

ddl1 · 21/01/2022 00:00

I don't mind even frequently repeated offers, so long as they're friendly; but I can't take it if people get upset or offended at my not eating everything that's offered. I have Crohns, and though it's under good control nowadays, there are some things that I can't eat. I haven't had big problems recently; but when I was much younger and had more restrictions, some people would accuse me of being rude/fussy/spoilt/suspecting them of 'trying to poison me'/ etc., and it really damaged my confidence. My mother was somewhat lactose intolerant and when she was a young adult she stayed with a couple who constantly nagged her to drink milk as it was Good For Her. Finally she was worn down by the pressure and drank the glass of milk and it wasn't good for her, and it also wasn't good for her hosts' carpet!

ShmeevilWeevil · 20/01/2022 23:50

HRTFT but
Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on Go on

Thirtytimesround · 20/01/2022 23:08

In Ireland it’s very polite to offer food and drinks over and over again. There are often jokes about it on sitcoms eg Father Ter.

In England it is very rude not to take the first ‘no’ as final.

🤷‍♀️

Drives me crazy so yanbu but magbe there is a cultural thingy here

Regardingtheduck · 20/01/2022 22:47

Yeah...I also have a.suspicion it's about control rather than a display of affection....food is cheap and most of us are fat. Its not like its a £10 pound note they are offering.

OhWhyNot · 20/01/2022 22:43

My Asian family would think they had down something wrong

My English nanny would have felt the same too and been disappointed she loved to make a fuss of people

It’s done out of kindness

Amoozbooze · 20/01/2022 22:25

I feel like you are making a mountain out of a mole hill! Just accept take something, glass of water or whatever, you don't even have to finish it it. Your host clearly feels obliged to serve you something. Why won't you take it, what is your problem? Have a glass of water and be done with it! Maybe you could even squeeze in a hobnob just to let them have the pleasure!

Regardingtheduck · 20/01/2022 20:57

It's just so boring, having someone ask if you want food after you refuse is imo the most innane type of smalltalk.

"Have some lunch!:
"No thanks I've just eaten - you carry on. I'll have some tea though.:
"Oh do try the vegetable dish!"
No thanks, I'm full....so how was your day?"
"What about just a tiny bit of the pie? Look I've got you a plate...."
"No really, I don't want to eat now. Did you go to x then?
"Here we go just a smidgeon...."

What on earth is happening ?!
They insist and insist....its just so dull. What a dull way to spend time ...not why I visited.
Next time I'm going to say:
" No really I've eaten and don't want anything but I'll take £20!!"
Maybe that will stop the broken record.

PeachyPeachTrees · 11/12/2019 22:40

YANBU OP!
It is nice to be offered. I say yes to tea/coffee.
I politely say no thank you to any cake, biscuits, pastries etc. Why is it so hard to accept that I just don't want it. "oh but I baked it especially this morning" sad face. If I go to a coffee morning at a friend's house it is so great to not be made to eat food I don't want. My friend (another culture) said "eat it, it will make you happy". Actually, having great conversation and a few laughs is what will genuinely lift my mood!

Itsonlymonday · 10/12/2019 21:32

Nope not annoying at all. In some cultures is the norm. When my parents first visited my in laws they were asked if they wanted to have wine. They replied no out of politeness (as in my culture that's what you do to start with but you'll get asked again) and they were shocked when nobody asked them again if they wanted wine even when my in-laws were drinking wine themselves. 😂

Nimmykins · 10/12/2019 21:23

Ahh yes @lindsayincroydon I’m vegan and family and in-laws don’t get it. Veggie since 1987. Vegan four years after I developed lactose intolerance. Everything I don’t bring has dairy on it.

OJZJ · 10/12/2019 20:47

I am an anxious person and get nervous even with close friends so in your eyes, i may be annoying and constantly offering but it's as a distraction or something to do with my hands etc also as a p.p has someone may say no out of politeness but be hungry or thirsty. Or you may only intend stopping five mins get nattering and stop....

Butterisbest · 10/12/2019 18:43

No think they are just trying to make you feel welcome...
You'd make a guest welcome by taking absolutely no notice of their polite refusal.
You think that trying to force food and drink onto a guest is welcoming.
You'd treat a guest like an imbecile that doesn't know their own mind, and you think that is how to welcome someone