Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family and ‘we’re only buying for the children now’

334 replies

NemophilistRebel · 18/11/2019 17:57

Am I the only one who thinks you skinflint?

Family member who has 3 children which we have always bought for along with the parents decides as soon as we have first baby that now we have children (1) we can buy for children only at Christmas and birthdays.

So that’s years worth of buying for their 3 and them not having an issue, and now they just buy for one.

Is this typical with CF family members ?

OP posts:
ezbem · 18/11/2019 20:35

Well can you imagine my face when my SIL said this.

(Baring in mind we never bought for adults just for kids, everyone only bought for the kids) so it's only her kids that have ever been gifted!

2 weeks after I had my DD. (The only other grandchild in the family that isn't from SIL)
"We've decided we won't be celebrating birthdays/Christmas/eid anymore or buying any presents so don't give us no presents please.

GrinConfusedHmm

TellMeWhoTheVilliansAre · 18/11/2019 20:32

I used to buy for all the nieces and nephews until I had my own children. Then I put a stop to it. I didn't realise until I had my own how much useless tat you accumulate with all the present giving. I think on my husband's side they all still do the giving to all the kids (except ours) but on my side we stopped it years ago.

Once I had my own children I had enough to be going trying to think of bits and bobs to buy for my own to be bothered trying to come up with something for 10 children on one side of the family. Never mind the expense of it.

Your SIL has the right idea. You continue to buy gif whoever you want to. Let her do the same.

PinkCrayon · 18/11/2019 20:30

We only buy for the children in my family. We all agreed it years ago and it works perfectly for us all. I don't think it's cheeky to suggest it at all. You sound petty.

Shookethtothecore · 18/11/2019 20:15

I would absolutely rather only buying for the kids rather than the absolute shite I get from my in-laws and the stress of buying something for my family who have everything they need. If I was a millionaire and could gift them the gifts they truly deserve i would enjoy it,but I’m not, so id Rather the kids have more spent on them

Autumnsloth · 18/11/2019 20:07

This seems reasonable to me. Money and time are tight, and they now have your child to buy for. They couldn't have suggested it earlier or they would be receiving without giving every year. I have the opposite dilemma - now I have a child I would like to start the presents for children only because I have neither the time for Christmas shopping nor the space for lots more stuff. Unfortunately I was vocally against this in the past and really would seem a CF if I now suggested it. Grin

charm8ed · 18/11/2019 19:55

rattusrattus20 I’m the same, I just buy for DC and my parents. I still see lots of relatives and have a lovely time but have knocked exchanging £10/£20 presents on the head.

LemonScentedStickyBat · 18/11/2019 19:53

All the adults have had presents for the same amount of time and it will now stop.
All the children will have presents for the same amount of time, from birth till 18.

I can’t see any unfairness or CFery no matter how hard I try! Would be nice if SIL would compromise on Secret Santa though.

rattusrattus20 · 18/11/2019 19:49

i'm in favour of anything that de-escalates christmas giving, it's the biggest con/waste of time/money ever.

Crunchymum · 18/11/2019 19:48

I have 15 nieces and nephews.

We do birthdays but not Xmas.

Birthdays are spread throughout the year!!!

Novembernickname · 18/11/2019 19:47

You'll be buying 2 presents less and they'll be buying one present less. So it's a win for you.

inthehammock · 18/11/2019 19:46

For me it is exactly all this griping and agonising and tallying is exactly that takes the pleasure out of the Christmas experience.

It seems that you're complaining your SIL has to be adhered to, but yet you won't be happy unless everyone adheres to what YOU want.

The last couple of years we have done children only with both sides, and I agree with PP, it's been an immense relief. I've actually enjoyed Christmas gatherings much more, we've wasted less time on opening presents and spent more time chatting, playing games, eating - lovely. On my side we are the only ones with children, so I do buy a token consumable gift for the adults to mitigate the unfairness, but we are all hard up and got to the point of just exchanging vouchers as none of us could think of real gifts we want or need. I've never had enough spare money to get amazing gifts (and I'd rather spend more on something decent on birthdays) and it's miserable trying to scrape together something when the recipient isn't that fussed either.

On the other side, we have fewer children than DH's siblings but it's never occurred to me to feel hard done by! If anything, I'm relieved we have fewer children so quite happy really Grin

monkeymonkey2010 · 18/11/2019 19:44

What difference does it make, though, in terms of fairness? If they really wanted to do that, they would have suggested 'adults until they become parents and then children INSTEAD of parents' as soon as they had their own first child
True - but how many of us actually have these kind of discussions as part of 'normal' life?
Most people only come to these realisations when it's 'too late' as such....and those of us who are child-free, predicted the 'future' and tried to make it fair from the start get labelled 'tight' Grin Grin

misspiggy19 · 18/11/2019 19:43

YANBU- I agree with you OP. Tightarses

Oysterbabe · 18/11/2019 19:41

Sounds good to me, I don't care about getting presents and 2 fewer to buy.

DilysMoon · 18/11/2019 19:33

YABU it makes total sense to me and we do this in our family. Theres a bit more of an even spread child wise 3/2 and 3/3 but the relief all round when it was suggested was palpable. As a pp said it's not only the expense it's the mental load as well, it's a huge relief to just plan and buy for each other kids. Plus do we as adults really need more stuff? We all get together and enjoy each others company over Christmas which is far more important imo. I also think it's fine for them to say this is what we're doing, end of discussion. It's their time and money. Perhaps also they don't want to receive "stuff", it's hard keeping on top of stuff with 3 kids in the house without people adding to it with unwanted gifts.

Ponoka7 · 18/11/2019 19:30

"They could have said years ago"

I think people are now only having the courage to do this with the, environmental/anti consumerism culture that's emerging.

No one should be stuck doing the same thing for 18 years, that's unreasonable.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2019 19:29

They know they're only buying for 3 people compared to you buying for 5....this may be their way of mitigating any feelings of 'taking the piss' that naturally arise when family numbers increase?

What difference does it make, though, in terms of fairness? If they really wanted to do that, they would have suggested 'adults until they become parents and then children INSTEAD of parents' as soon as they had their own first child.

MulticolourMophead · 18/11/2019 19:25

YANBU. Nine times out of ten it's those that have had the most benefit/have the most children that suggest this.

My sisters eldest is 18 this year and she thinks we should still buy for him as it wouldn't be fair to only buy for his siblings

My friend has a sister who suggested only buying for the DCs until they were 18. Then, when friend's youngest DN reached 18 and not receiving gifts, friend's sister declared she wasn't buying gifts anymore, despite the youngest children still only early teens. I think friend's mum stepped in and told the sister not to be so selfish. And the youngest carried on getting gifts until they too were 18.

Winterhater · 18/11/2019 19:22

I never understand these “it’s not fair that they only have one nephew to buy for not we have to buy for 3/4/26 nephews”. First of all, they gave their own 3 children to buy for as well as yours. You’re each buying for 4 children. Secondly, they have three children to support all year, you only have to buy them one gift each. If you think they have it easier, wait until you have your third...
Are you the ops family member?

monkeymonkey2010 · 18/11/2019 19:22

they're making it easier for themselves - and for you in the long run.
They know they're only buying for 3 people compared to you buying for 5....this may be their way of mitigating any feelings of 'taking the piss' that naturally arise when family numbers increase?

You may feel 'dictated to' but they've just made a sensible decision - for them.
If you want to continue buying for BIL etc cos it makes you feel good then do it - that's the spirit of giving a 'gift'.
Just make it clear that you respect their choice not to buy for adults and you don't expect/want anything back.
What happens if one year you just don't feel like it/can't afford it - are you then going to have that conversation where you tell BIL he won't be getting a gift he didn't want in the first place?

Then remember this for when you start feeling angsty over the money spent on dc gifts for xmas/bdays/easter etc, as that will increase as they grow older...and you will always be spending 'more' on theirs than they may on yours.

There's a fine line between respecting other's boundaries and asserting your own rights - so much easier with work colleagues Grin

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2019 19:16

Sounds sensible to only buy for kids . It’s not their fault they had kids before you . You sound entitled .

Of course it isn't their 'fault' (???) that they had kids first (although their respective birth dates/gaps might have had a big bearing on when this was likely to happen), but it is their 'fault' that they only decided to make it kids only after having several years of having kids and still expecting presents themselves as well.

It might sound a strange family-fairness analogy, but if we were instead talking about an inheritance, it would be the equivalent of parents of two adult children dying and leaving 55% of their money to their 55yo DC and 45% of it to their 45yo DC on the grounds that the elder one had been their child for longer. Would you say it's not the older one's fault that they were born 10 years earlier?

TrickyKid · 18/11/2019 19:14

I don't see the issue. Everyone ends up with less 'stuff'. We've always only bought for the kids in our family. If you feel hard done to just spend less on their dc.

Makesmilingyourbesthobby · 18/11/2019 19:13

I get it, my DSis who is the eldest had her child first for years she was the only one of us with a child all happily bought her DD and her and her partner gifts then me and my other DSis had our first children and we all bought for everyone that Christmas, following Christmas she texted me and other DSis how about we don’t buy each other kids presents anymore for Christmas after around 8 years of buying her child, me and other DSis like the exchange of gifts so we still buy each other’s and don’t want to leave DN out so both give her money as she older two but she went years not buying ours anything only been the last two three years she buys ours £5 gifts and she’s the one who has the most income but none of it surprises me with her she’s the same with everything I now have 3 DC eldest is 11 and Dsis has only ever came to two birthday party’s they have had 19 birthday parties between them only ever come to see them three times in total on they birthday

BritWifeinUSA · 18/11/2019 19:12

I never understand these “it’s not fair that they only have one nephew to buy for not we have to buy for 3/4/26 nephews”. First of all, they gave their own 3 children to buy for as well as yours. You’re each buying for 4 children. Secondly, they have three children to support all year, you only have to buy them one gift each. If you think they have it easier, wait until you have your third...

Thirdly, just reduce the cost of each gift if you feel it’s about who spends what. I was one of 5 and my DH was one of 9 - we were both accustomed to receiving smaller, lower value gifts from relatives. We now have 22 nieces and nephews and no children of our own. So we buy 22 gifts and get nothing back. By your logic that would be unfair. By our logic it isn’t, it’s just life.

HappyHolidays75 · 18/11/2019 19:12

Surely adding an upper age limit on when you stop buying for the kids (e.g. aged 16) evens it all out.

You will have less years left of buying, they will have more years (and maybe nieces and nephews not yet born).

Swipe left for the next trending thread