Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family and ‘we’re only buying for the children now’

334 replies

NemophilistRebel · 18/11/2019 17:57

Am I the only one who thinks you skinflint?

Family member who has 3 children which we have always bought for along with the parents decides as soon as we have first baby that now we have children (1) we can buy for children only at Christmas and birthdays.

So that’s years worth of buying for their 3 and them not having an issue, and now they just buy for one.

Is this typical with CF family members ?

OP posts:
Proseccoinamug · 19/11/2019 13:41

You’ve always had the option of doing the same. You didn’t have to buy for them and the children, that was your choice.

When you have children, they’re your priority. I’m not going to get into debt to exchange hampers with other adults.

RowenaMud · 19/11/2019 13:40

I know many people who save up all year because they're on lower incomes

So this is your suggestion for her?

She already sold her car because she can't afford to run it. She doesn't buy clothes. She doesn't go on holidays. Yet she should put money aside for Christmas. She is aware of the cost of Christmas because she struggles financially to cope with it.

She feels she is caught in a circle where this 'agreement' was made by her family and she is the only one who can't afford it. So she opts in or out of Christmas.

Your solution is what though? That she spends Christmas on her own? Tell her family that she can't afford any Christmas presents? That is easier said than done to be fair esp. because she can afford them just not the quantity of them.

RowenaMud · 19/11/2019 13:33

Sorry I meant to say they should have started it when they had children and all adults that don’t have DC get a present. That’s a fairer way.

Yes I agree. My friend says she would be happy not to receive anything but likes to give a gift to the children. Personally I think it would be difficult to watch everyone opening gifts and sit there without having anything at all to open and I think, over time, it might really make her sad.

LolaSmiles · 19/11/2019 13:29

She has a lot of contact with the children and they ask for quite expensive toys that are easily 50 pounds each so she now spends 320 pounds on gifts and receives 70 pounds back
Why keep monetary score cards for who gets what?
The issue is she's buying gifts beyond what she can afford, not the fact people buy for children.

I know many people who save up all year because they're on lower incomes. They have a much more extravagant Christmas than we do. It would be unusual for wider family to speculate or ask about her financial situation.

I'm afraid I've got limited sympathy for people who routinely spend more than they can afford to, won't change that behaviour, won't communicate with people and then complain about how unfair things are.

I'm still surprised how many people on here keep tabs on whether they get their money's worth back at Christmas. Fair enough if parents are treating kids/siblings very differently, but to keep track of price points because Phil has 2 kids aged 11 and 14 but Sarah had 4 primary aged kids and I have 1 so I'm hard done to seems to miss the spirit of Christmas.

charm8ed · 19/11/2019 13:24

Sorry I meant to say they should have started it when they had children and all adults that don’t have DC get a present. That’s a fairer way.

RowenaMud · 19/11/2019 13:19

They should have started it when they had children.

The problem with this is I have one friend who isn't in a relationship and doesn't have children. Three of her four siblings are married. they decided to do a secret santa among the family but continue buying for all the children

My friend buys for all her nieces and nephews (five in total). It doesn't sound like a lot of money but she earns very little. She is by far the least well off in her family. The result is she buys her secret santa gift for a sibling (maximum total 70 pounds) and also buys for the five children in the family. She has a lot of contact with the children and they ask for quite expensive toys that are easily 50 pounds each so she now spends 320 pounds on gifts and receives 70 pounds back. The 'system' just doesn't work and she is very reluctant to tell everyone that she can't afford it. Her family have to be well aware of it as she lives by herself and has a low earning job yet at Christmas, they seem to forget her position

In situations like the above, I don't think there is a solution other than stop all gift buying as if they drastically reduce the amount spent, people end up buying tat that nobody wants which is another waste of money. However if nobody bought a gift, she wouldn't receive any gifts herself either as she doesn't have anyone else who would buy for her.

charm8ed · 19/11/2019 11:30

They should have started it when they had children.

NewNameIsNew · 19/11/2019 11:27

This is super common. They waited until you had kids so I don't see the issue? It's not like they are doing it when you may never have kids?

We do this. We buy for nephews and nieces until they hit 18. SILs kids are younger so we'll be buying still once they stop.

Honestly I really don't understand the issue. Both families are purchasing 2 fewer adult gifts. It's equal.

username35932 · 19/11/2019 09:30

YABU since having children money has become a lot tighter for us. I would prefer an arrangement like this. Hate how materialistic Christmas has become.

Crackerofdoom · 19/11/2019 09:17

If you all spend say 20 quid on each other, you are losing 40 quid this year but gaining the same 40 quid back because you aren't buying for the adults.

Buy yourself a gift or ask DH to buy you an extra gift with the money if it means that much to you.

Or have another 5 kids to get your money's worth.

TellMeWhoTheVilliansAre · 19/11/2019 09:09

it’s not cfery if the person with one child suggests it.
It just feels like it when the person with all the kids drops it as soon as another has one

So, you don't want presents from others. Your SIL doesn't want people buying her presents. But you're pissed off that she suggested it instead of you?

The result is the same. Less presents being swapped.

I wouldn't even buy for all the kids. We never received presents from all our aunts, uncles, grandparents as kids. And my children don't receive from anyone other than santa and their godparent. We do a secret santa within our own family because the kids love going out and picking something for a fiver for their sibling.

I couldn't get upset over someone suggesting I don't need to buy them a present and they won't give me something unnecessary either.

QueenOfWinterfell · 19/11/2019 08:59

I wish it was the normal thing to do to only buy presents for children at Xmas. I think present giving has got seriously out of hand and so much stuff ends up in charity shops in January. It’s time Xmas was less commercial and consumer driven.

Rainbunny · 19/11/2019 08:56

That's what we do on my inlaws side and I actually love it. Frankly if any of us adults want something we can buy for ourselves and the vast majority of the time I don't want or truly like the presents I receive (of course I make a happy fuss about any present I do receive) but I would far rather not have people waste money on buying me something I will never use. There's too much crap in the world as it is.

user1480880826 · 19/11/2019 08:43

Buying for children only is fair enough. Adults who demand Xmas presents are a bit childish in my opinion.

You could have suggested the children only policy when they first had kids but you chose not to. That was your choice.

motherogod · 19/11/2019 08:38

I've 13 nephews and nieces (and 2 dcs) and always bought for everyone, but it was completely stressful and expensive. We changed to secret santa a few years ago for everyone including kids and I was delighted - it meant mine (younger than ns and ns) didn't have as many years of getting gifts from everyone but tbh it took the attention and stress away from presents and meant the run-up to Christmas was far more enjoyable. OP stop thinking about who gets what and just go with it - you can't force people to spend money if they don't want to and if you feel that strongly about it you could suggest a secret santa for everyone. Sorry but you sound greedy and grasping and more than a bit immature.

Lumene · 19/11/2019 08:35

It wouldn’t mean buying more, it would put you in exactly the same position as you were before they suggested children gifts only. Which is what you are posting complaining about having changed.

LolaSmiles · 19/11/2019 08:32

This thread has me thinking. At some point arrangements for change and unless you're someone who keeps score, who really cares?
Aunties and uncles doing presents for the "kids" in our family lasted until the final one was 18 so all siblings were equal on Christmas morning. Do I really care that someone 3 years older than me got 3 years more CDs/chocolate? No.

Now as adult children we tend to buy for our siblings and then only wider family children to save the gift giving stress. Do I care that at some point another relative might have got a present or two more whilst we started to transition to life with children? No.

Life situations change and with that gift giving does too. What's the alternative? The OP decides to suggest to her family that she should continue getting adult presents for the same number of years that she bought her family presents as adults and then it becomes children only after the scales are perfectly equal? Confused

NemophilistRebel · 19/11/2019 08:25

@salene - same as pp

OP posts:
NemophilistRebel · 19/11/2019 08:24

@Lumene it’s not about buying more see PP Hmm

OP posts:
Salene · 19/11/2019 08:24

If it bothers you that much why don't you suggest a family budget for buying gifts. So like £30 , you buy 3 small gifts for £10 each or a joint gift and they buy your child a £30 gift.

WhatWouldTheDoctorDo · 19/11/2019 08:20

I think it's pretty CF to accept gifts for adults and DC in your household for years from child free friends and relatives and then as soon as the child free relative/friend has a child suggest presents for DC only.

That's not to say DC only isn't a relief in the longer run though - we do that with d sad one siblings and now have four adults less to buy for which is great.

Lumene · 19/11/2019 08:17

Just buy something nice for yourself with whatever you would have spent on them. That way you are in the same financial and gift situation as now.

LolaSmiles · 19/11/2019 08:16

NemophilistRebel
But your logic is ridiculous there.

It's really silly to say that a perfectly sensible suggestion is fine from someone with no children, fine from someone with fewer children but the height of cheeky fuckery from the person who has more.

Someone will always have the most/least children. That's life unless you all want to sync your breeding habits in a way science hasn't created yet.

To decide an idea is cheeky based purely on who says it is bizarre.

Courtney555 · 19/11/2019 08:04

No they haven't understood.

It's not about just buying for the children now. That's fine. It's about them having children for the last however many years and happily taking presents for themselves as well. If they believed "once you have DC, the presents pass to them" then wtf have they been doing taking gifts for themselves as well all this time??

Greedy, cheeky fuckers. You can't do much about it now though OP.

NemophilistRebel · 19/11/2019 07:56

@Courtney555 yes exactly. Some people haven’t really understood Grin

OP posts: