Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family and ‘we’re only buying for the children now’

334 replies

NemophilistRebel · 18/11/2019 17:57

Am I the only one who thinks you skinflint?

Family member who has 3 children which we have always bought for along with the parents decides as soon as we have first baby that now we have children (1) we can buy for children only at Christmas and birthdays.

So that’s years worth of buying for their 3 and them not having an issue, and now they just buy for one.

Is this typical with CF family members ?

OP posts:
caringcarer · 20/11/2019 00:44

In both my family and dh family the adults buy for nieces and nephews up until they are 18. I did carry on buying for the ones still at uni but others in family did not. We buy for parents in law, my parents are both dead now, but not for brothers and sisters who are adults. I do buy a load of Xmas food for one sister who does not have much money though. It is difficult as I have 13 nephews and nieces on my side of the family but dh only has 3 nieces. If you can't afford to buy gifts you could make gingerbread men which the children in my family used to go mad over.

OnTheFenceWithMostViews · 19/11/2019 23:30

We do this with some friends.
( stopped even buying the dcs in family due to GPS going ott and lots being wasted)

Our friends buy for our 3 dcs.. Prob £10 each? They only have 1 dc so insoeand about £30. So no one is out of pocket so to speak..

pollymere · 19/11/2019 22:37

Suggest Family Gift instead so you both buy a present for your respective families to enjoy up to £20-30. I do this with mine and it levels the spending without it feeling unfair.

OhMyDarling · 19/11/2019 21:34

I agree with you. I had no friends with children when I had mine, my friends ceased buying me gifts and occasionally bought the children small gifts (eg selection box).

Now they have had their own, my friends issue me (And everyone else) with a gift list (nothing below £10) for their babies/toddlers and said they hope I don’t forget them as “they are still people not just a mum now”.
I think this is ridiculously deep in CF territory!

ToftyAC · 19/11/2019 21:32

YABU. Personally, I’d be relieved.

Flynn2019 · 19/11/2019 21:31

I have had my first child this year (on maternity leave) and have said to family that we are only buying kids this year. For a few reasons actually, the first being I can't afford to buy the adults but secondly even when I am back at work next year, I don't intend on changing this. Christmas is, for me about children and as adults when u want something u normally go out and buy it, u don't wait until Christmas for someone else to buy u it. I am lucky though in that all the other families only have 1 but next year my BIL will have 2 but I wouldn't moan. It could b the other way around and I could have more kids.

MutedUser · 19/11/2019 21:23

@scubadive some children have parents that can’t afford presents so the ones from family are the only presents they will have. Not all children have more presents than they know what to do with .

Alittlebitofthat · 19/11/2019 21:13

Ive one better than that... DH family all kids older now think early 20’s ours still little. It was announced week or so ago that we should all just not do presents anymore as theirs were to old to be buying for. Hold on I’ve bought presents for your kids for over 20 years now but now you’ve decided we shouldn’t do presents, what about my kids??? 1st world problem I know but it doesn’t seem right....

scubadive · 19/11/2019 21:03

I think this only children is crazy, children get more gifts at Xmas then they know what to do with. Why can’t adults have gifts too, they don’t have to be expensive but I think what ever money you have you should share across all family members not just always the children.

Zeezee82 · 19/11/2019 20:47

This has always been our family rule. You get presents until you have children. Parents buying for their own (grown up) children and daughter/son-in-law is the only exception

wrcm · 19/11/2019 20:38

I have 3 children and my sister has one. We decided years ago (think after i had my second daughter) that would just wouldn't do presents anymore. It's expensive enough trying to buy for your own kids nevermind everyone elses.

Cutesbabasmummy · 19/11/2019 20:30

I did write a similar post a few years ago and got absolutely flamed for it. We have 1 DS and one BIL has three kids and the other has 2. So we have to buy 5 gifts for the nephews. To be honest a few years on its good not to have gifts we dont want from them but forking out for 5 kids is really expensive.

tenbob · 19/11/2019 20:12

My tightarse SIL went one better and decided unilaterally that the whole family is now doing secret Santa for children

So after a over decade of us and other SIL buying Christmas presents for all 4 of her children, they now buy one present between our DC and DNephews

She is alllll class Hmm

RowenaMud · 19/11/2019 20:10

So basically if you have kids first and ask for kids only presents, you're 'stingey'

The thing is if you have kids first and ask for gifts only for the children, then obviously you still buy gifts for the person or couple who don’t have children. Accepting four plus gifts while returning one is tight.

RowenaMud · 19/11/2019 20:07

So basically if you have kids first and ask for kids only presents, you're 'stingey'. So you wait until your siblings have kids to suggest it and you're a CF for taking gifts in previous years, even though you didn't want them!

They could have said (as I do to childfree family members) please don’t buy us gifts, just get them for the children or alternatively give one gift to each household as suggested above.

Pericombobulations · 19/11/2019 19:56

I said this to my siblings as I was fed up of getting Christmas Eve purchases from the local supermarket, which wouldnt have been that bad, but when they called and asked what alcohol we drink, I specifically said dont buy us alcohol niether of us like it much, get us a box of nice biscuits or chocolate.

When they turned up bearing gifts, there was alcohol for us. Back in the regifting pile.

I therefore offered to only do children presents, with only one child myself, and sibling has three. Didnt care, would much rather that than being so much ignored, they cant even be bothered to listen to me say "dont waste your money buying us alcohol".

Lc2006 · 19/11/2019 19:55

It's not about them being tight or it being 'fair' though if they can't afford it, you can't have what they haven't got. They may be finding it increasingly hard now the kids are getting older to keep up with the ever increasing cost and simply cannot manage adult gifts as well. Even token gifts add up when you have 15 of them to buy.

LovePoppy · 19/11/2019 19:48

The ones who said it to us had a full time SAHP, and was just told to us in a ‘we’re doing this now’.

So....it should have been a negotiation?

canveyisland · 19/11/2019 19:35

IME I am now very careful of these instructions because I was caught out by someone telling me this and it was not the case. It made me look stupid and unkind and I have never forgiven them.

If you can't afford to buy expensive or too many gifts people really will understand.

SquashedOrange · 19/11/2019 19:35

once you have DC, the presents pass to them" then wtf have they been doing taking gifts for themselves as well all this time??"

But when does being given gifts, become taking gifts??

So basically if you have kids first and ask for kids only presents, you're 'stingey'. So you wait until your siblings have kids to suggest it and you're a CF for taking gifts in previous years, even though you didn't want them!

It never really occurred to me that people are taking note of who gives/ receives what and keeping a tally. It's horrible.

I used to love Christmas, now it's just a very complicated gift exchange. Confused

RowenaMud · 19/11/2019 19:34

One gift per household this year!', and get them a game or a family cinema membership, something they can all use. Or 'Only edible gifts this year!' and get them a hamper with things in that they'll all love

This is the most sensible suggestion I have read on this thread. As well as sensible, it is a lovely idea.

yasle · 19/11/2019 19:21

YABVU
Christmas is a ridiculous consumer fest
When my db suggested we only buy for kids, I was thrilled
Can't stand Christmas, I'd like to see it cancelled permanently.
I don't buy any adult anything, aside from my mum as she has no money and needs stuff.

Eckhart · 19/11/2019 19:19

They've told you what they're doing. You tell them what you're doing. They don't make the rules. If you think they're being tight and it bothers you, find a way to reciprocate. 'One gift per household this year!', and get them a game or a family cinema membership, something they can all use. Or 'Only edible gifts this year!' and get them a hamper with things in that they'll all love.

I do think you're missing the point of gifts a bit, though. You think they're being skinflints because they're buying less presents. I think you're being Scrooge because you're totting up the score and feeling hard done to.

Yestermost · 19/11/2019 19:15

We did this it's so much better. You all spend less and buy less shite.

nuxe1984 · 19/11/2019 19:10

My father was one of 12 children. Some of my aunts/uncles had several children, others had 1 , others had none. To make it fair for everyone, the adults all put the same amount of money in the pot which was then divided amongst the children. Parents then bought a gift from the "aunts and uncles".