Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family and ‘we’re only buying for the children now’

334 replies

NemophilistRebel · 18/11/2019 17:57

Am I the only one who thinks you skinflint?

Family member who has 3 children which we have always bought for along with the parents decides as soon as we have first baby that now we have children (1) we can buy for children only at Christmas and birthdays.

So that’s years worth of buying for their 3 and them not having an issue, and now they just buy for one.

Is this typical with CF family members ?

OP posts:
sweeneytoddsrazor · 20/11/2019 13:47

@furrytoebean I don't know in all honesty because we have always had a big get together. We have always dropped presents off before xmas so they go under the tree with all the others and we all spend xmas day in our own homes so don't see the kids opening their presents anyway. I would be more upset missing the get together than worried about what I had present wise.

furrytoebean · 20/11/2019 13:39

A present can be very cheap too. A box of chocolates is way cheaper than a trip to the cinema for lots of adults.

But the point is you all do something together to acknowledge that it's Christmas and include everybody.

I'm also assuming that you have kids, so 'let's just buy for the kids' is fair.

Would you still feel the same if didn't have kids and weren't having a big family get together but were expected to buy presents for all the kids but get nothing in return?

dellacucina · 20/11/2019 13:37

Ugh, wouldn't you rather not deal with receiving gifts you probably don't want?

ActualHornist · 20/11/2019 13:36

YANBU.

I’m the only sib with children so if we did this, my brother and sister have to spend loads more than us on a choice we made. We already do secret Santa between adults, but it’s nice to get a present.

We love each other and spend Christmas together and don’t police spends (although we do all tell mum to stop spending so much....) but Christmas is a time for giving and receiving gifts as well as spending time together and eating until you’re sick.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 20/11/2019 13:29

No I wouldn't be miffed because we would still be spending boxing day together having good family time, regardless of if we had a day out instead. And a day out can be very cheap sometimes it shopping and a meal, sometimes its a visit to a N T property, sometimes a cinema. Nowhere near expensive as a present for 1 adult let alone all of them . But it only works because we enjoy time together with no worries about who is a CF and who isnt. We realise we all have different incomes and outgoings and some have more dcs than others but we don't actually give a shit if someone spends £5 per child or £50 per child because we know its what they can afford and we know they have done it because they want to not because they are obligated to do so.

furrytoebean · 20/11/2019 13:13

You do get something for the adults though sweeny you all go out together, that's your gift.

That's what we do too.

If your family turned around and said Christmas is just for the kids you don't need a get together with the adults just the children get presents this year.
You'd probably be a bit miffed.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 20/11/2019 13:05

Feeling rather blessed right now that I am part of a family that love the whole getting together and soending time together because we enjoy it and love each other rather than bitching about who buys what and is it equal. For what its worth we buy for children until they are 21. The year my 2 sisters and I all managed to buy each other exactly the same jumper we decided to stop buying for adults (parents excepted) and have a day out together in early December instead. Parents obviously still buy for their own grown up DCs. We also manage to have a get together on a bixing day evening which can be any number from 10 to 30 depending on who is where. We all bring some food and drink and play daft party games.

Emeraldshamrock · 20/11/2019 12:10

Christmas is for everyone.
If it is not being reciprocal then pull back and treat yourself. 🎅

furrytoebean · 20/11/2019 11:20

I agree leigh

I've said this on another thread in the same vein but it's not about being grabby it's about being made to feel included.

I don't have kids and I find Christmas really hard. The emphasis is so much on the children and it can feel like you're a spare part.

I spend hundreds and hundreds of pounds on my nieces and nephews, and I don't see why it's seen as grabby to enjoy getting a gift back. It could be a box of chocolates from the pound shop, I don't care what it is just that I'm part of the festivities too.

Emeraldshamrock · 20/11/2019 10:50

How is that fair? We had planned to give niece and nephew a sum of money for their 21st, but won't now
You're dead right.
Your situation is a perfect example of how unfair it is.

notnowmaybelater · 20/11/2019 10:47

Raindancer411 I do that for the sibling who suggested just doing birthday not Christmas and it's better when you don't see your children's aunts and uncles often due to distance, because you actually know what your own kids like / need... However a lot of people enjoy buying gifts themselves so it doesn't always work.

Kazzyhoward · 20/11/2019 10:40

In theory, it's fine. What I find annoying is when there's an imbalance.

We stopped buying for our siblings years ago. Pointless just swapping presents that we can't afford, don't want, and don't have time to shop for.

But, we've given our niece and nephew presents every birthday, christmas, easter and money for holidays etc., for 18 years each.

Our own son is 10 years younger. They did the same for him. BUT, now niece and nephew are over 18 and we've stopped, they've suddenly decided "it's pointless to swap" and have completely cut our son dead other than a christmas and birthday card. So, we've had 36 years worth (2 times 18), but they've just had 10 (1 times 10).

How is that fair? We had planned to give niece and nephew a sum of money for their 21st, but won't now.

It's always the ones who've already benefitted that suddenly decide "not to swap" when it suits them!

Emeraldshamrock · 20/11/2019 10:33

@Leighhalfpennysthigh 😥🎁
It is very unfair.
My younger Dsis was the last to have her first DC 3 years ago, before that
I got her a thank you gift every year from my the DC.
Same with adult DC. DM only buys for the DGC but always got Dsis a gift, she said it is a €100 per adult DC. If you have DC she'll buy a toy gift from your €100.

Raindancer411 · 20/11/2019 10:33

Do what I plan to do, ask them to buy for their kids and put your names on it, and you do the same for yours :)

Ours is more to do with how hard it is to make time to hand over presents (they don't live close by)

CleansUpDragonPoo · 20/11/2019 10:18

@Leighhalfpennysthigh Wed 20-Nov-19 09:45:26
"Despite what MN seems to think, Christmas is not just for children. It is for everyone.

The year that I didn't receive anything, because my parents and my siblings decided that it was children only, was awful. It wasn't because I'm grabby and entitled, or as people think on here, childish, it was because I was single, childless and had no one to think of me throughout the year. Then I got to Christmas and my isolation was reinforced when no one thought of me then.

When you're in a couple, even if you don't exchange gifts, you do things for each other or treat each other - when you're on your own there's no one to do that."

I understand your point, it must have been really hurtful, and I hope this year you will feel more included. I think the family should have thought of you, how much effort would it have been to wrap up a Poundshop bath bomb or box of chocs for you?

Our Christmases were not lavish affairs and my mother had many faults, but every Christmas she would wrap a couple of small gifts and leave them under the tree in case anyone turned up unexpectedly or the children - us - brought someone home after being outside playing, just so no one was left out.

Yes, concentrate on the children, makes perfect sense, but make sure everyone else is included in some way. That's the real spirit of Christmas, being made to feel like you're loved and wanted.

Leighhalfpennysthigh · 20/11/2019 09:45

Can’t believe adults still expect gifts really, just not on my radar

Despite what MN seems to think, Christmas is not just for children. It is for everyone.

The year that I didn't receive anything, because my parents and my siblings decided that it was children only, was awful. It wasn't because I'm grabby and entitled, or as people think on here, childish, it was because I was single, childless and had no one to think of me throughout the year. Then I got to Christmas and my isolation was reinforced when no one thought of me then.

When you're in a couple, even if you don't exchange gifts, you do things for each other or treat each other - when you're on your own there's no one to do that.

Emeraldshamrock · 20/11/2019 09:38

My good friend is die her baby after 10 years trying. The baby is due early December.
She said she wasn't buying for nieces nephews after doing so for years.
They agreed to stop buying them all presents.
I hope her siblings remember all the years she gave their DC and spoil her baby for awhile.

Lilyflower1 · 20/11/2019 09:38

Where siblings have different numbers of children there is always going to be a disparity of present buying and expense. I do think it's a bit off for the OP's DS to stop the present buying after her children were beneficiaries for years but, heigh ho, that's life. In the future the OP will be quids in. She can spend a bit more on her own child's pressie as she has less outlay on that of her sister's DC.

My DS had three DC and I two but it didn't seem that bad to buy multiple presents when the DH and I were both working. What has hit us harder than differing numbers of offspring is the fact that my DS and her husband have two full time, decently paid jobs while I am retired and the DH was made redundant while expectations on their part were not lowered.

Only after six years has she suggested lowering the kids' pressies to £20 each and the oldest of our joint offspring is 30! The kids are all earning too!

The DH and I haven't been able to buy each other a present for years because of the general expense of Christmas! But, there you go. You sometimes have to pay your dues to the party gods.

Sceptre86 · 20/11/2019 09:21

We have the same issue with bil and sil. In that they have one kid and us two so my dh thinks we have to spend the same on their son as they do on both of ours. So £20 if they spend £10 each on ours. I think that is silly and we should spend as much as we can afford or want to give. In past years he would spend £30 whereas out kids would get £5 spent on them each. We have since decided to spend £10 on a present for nephew and they usually buy ours a toy each amounting to £15. This leaves us with more to spend on our own kids which we all seem to prefer.

Sceptre86 · 20/11/2019 09:13

I am the eldest of four and the only one with kids yet. My siblings buy for my kids but not me at religious festivals. As soon as they have kids I will do the same. It gets so expensive if you add adults in the mix too and I would rather buy for kids.

franklymydearidontgivea · 20/11/2019 09:07

We had this in our family, we always bought for children, but as we have no children BIL and SIL bought us a token present ( from sil usually absolute crap, £2 from the supermarket as she did her shop). When the first of hers turned 18, the following Christmas we said we would now only be buying for the other child. SIL response was to no longer send us her crap gift as we weren't buying for one of her children..... made her look like absolute crap as we had a family Christmas with DH's family(except her) it was noticed that DH and I were the only ones not to get a gift from her, she even have BIL a gift....stupid, silly, cow.

Bl3ss3dm0m · 20/11/2019 08:16

@LondonJax, You and your DS must be very illogical people. My DM always spent the same amount of money on my brother and myself. I now do the same thing; same amount of money on each of my 3 children, my children's partners, and my grandchild, this is not only logical, but fair! I feel so sorry for your DM that you think of that as a negative thing. If they had been solely monetary presents, would it have been fair if your DS got, say, £50, and you got £30? Wouldn't you have thought that there was some favoritism going on there?

scubadive · 20/11/2019 08:00

@Alittlebitofthat yes I had this too, very close friends with 3 children, older than my 4, we are godparents to each other’s children. I bought for theirs until they were 21, they stopped buying for mine when they were 9-16yrs, no announcement, just stopped buying, not even cards, very hurtful. Then randomly my eldest got an 18 card with money, 4 weeks after my youngest ones birthday who had not even had a card. Very hurtful, they have loads of money so that’s not the issue. I been single for a few years and really struggle with money but still kept buying. It’s hard to explain to your children why they are suddenly not getting presents anymore.

Whiteroverbaby · 20/11/2019 03:43

Christmas is about children and the magic of Christmas, not about money spent on presents for adults or not spent. I have a friend with 3 small children I spend £10 on each, I only have one child and she spends £10 on him.

CleansUpDragonPoo · 20/11/2019 00:52

@CockysGirl Tue 19-Nov-19 17:52:34
"YANBU - We have now been told that this year it is buying for children only - i have one DS, SIL's have 5, 3 and 2 kids respectively - costs us a fortune anyway and now we will just get presents for our one DS and nothing for us yet we have to buy 10 presents! I know it's all about the kids and not giving to receive but i know they won't spend anymore on my one DS and yet the ones with 5 kids always send us links on Amazon of what to buy their kids yet never ask what we or DS want! hmm"

Ignore the Amazon links and do a family gift instead, cinema membership or suchlike, and perhaps a small wrapped gift for each child to open eg selection box. Tell the inlaws you're setting an example for the children by saving the planet! If the inlaws don't like it and / or stop buying gifts for your child, so much the better. As so many others have said, we all have so much stuff it's ridiculous.

Swipe left for the next trending thread