Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family and ‘we’re only buying for the children now’

334 replies

NemophilistRebel · 18/11/2019 17:57

Am I the only one who thinks you skinflint?

Family member who has 3 children which we have always bought for along with the parents decides as soon as we have first baby that now we have children (1) we can buy for children only at Christmas and birthdays.

So that’s years worth of buying for their 3 and them not having an issue, and now they just buy for one.

Is this typical with CF family members ?

OP posts:
Dunnoburt · 05/07/2022 06:29

I'm an only child, aunt/uncle had 3 kids, we did children only at Xmas/birthday,........ I got 3 presents from them and they got 1 each from us! 😁😁🎁🎁

WhereIsVillanelleWhenNeeded · 05/07/2022 06:23

My brother has one DC as does my BIL and we have 2DC. I always get their DC something extra because I’m conscious that their parents are buying for two. We’re not all CFers.

Libertybear80 · 05/07/2022 06:15

It is what we said a few years ago. My kids still got presents. Their kids still got presents. Part of the reason we did it was because we knew some other members of the family were hard up and were making Christmas presents for adults. We thought this has got to stop. It's ridiculous!

Somethingneedstochange · 05/07/2022 06:11

Everyone's finances are different.Plus it's easier to buy for children than adults.

Sarbears28 · 05/07/2022 06:01

Yabu. Are you totally oblivious to the rise of cost of living? We this year are doing hand made cards and presents for all our family and have told them so. We simply can not afford to live never mind buy presents for others.

ChampagneLassie · 05/07/2022 05:32

Seems totally reasonable - and fair you all stop buying for adults. A seperate Q, i suppose is do you think its unfair that you have to buy x 3 and they only x 1. Would they spent equivalent amount on 1 as you're spending on 3? Unless you're agreeing budgets etc surely there could be discrepancies irrespective no DC. In my DP large family each sibling with DC buys a gift for one niece or nephew only.

caringcarer · 05/07/2022 05:24

This is what we do in my family as there are lots of cousins. We buy our own children a gift each and put from aunties, uncles and cousins. They do the same. I have 21 nieces and nephews on both sides of family and this way is affordable and no one gets left out. Plus we know what our own children would like. We have a £20 rule so gift must not be more than £20. This works well in families with lots of children and ultimately if parents have more children they pay put more.

Morverner · 05/07/2022 05:06

Lol, just realised zombie thread. Funny that the16yrold who brought it back to life will now definitely be in the adult "not getting a present" category. Wonder if it was a glitch that had them replying to their own comment 3yrs later?

Morverner · 05/07/2022 04:58

I find just buying for the kids far easier, can't afford to buy for everyone in these times. We have the least amount of children in our family and I know one relative who doesn't find it fair that we spend less on her kids per child than she does on ours. But if you have six children, it's a bit unreasonable to expect expensive gifts for each.
But I guess that's a different argument. Just buying for the kids is a good plan, tbh I find adult present buying, just for the sake of it really wasteful. I know I rarely get things that I actually use.

sillydancingwitch · 05/07/2022 04:39

I often only buy for children at Holidays. Christmas is expensive and mama has bills to pay. If you want something go buy it for yourself or ask. Maybe have a adventure instead of presents. Do we really need more stuff???

Sleepyquest · 05/07/2022 04:30

Boxowine · 05/07/2022 02:15

I think it's hilarious that Christmas Carol brought this out of the past. Xmas 2019 when all we had to care about was gifts for kids. We'll be living like mad max by the time Christmas rolls around this year.

This made me chuckle!
Also love how she sort of replied to her own comment from 2.5 years ago 😃

I just wanted to add that isn't always a money thing but a time thing. Buying for loads of kids and adults and wrapping is so bloody time consuming. But like you say, this year we will have to fight over a piece of coal(or tub of lurpak)

DuarPorte · 05/07/2022 04:29

ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE
ZOMBIE

ShandaLear · 05/07/2022 04:27

We’ve been doing this for years in my family. How much more stuff do you actually need? Just get them a family present - a board game or some books or cinema tickets. They don’t care - they’ll have tonnes of other things as well.

phishy · 05/07/2022 03:54

Zombie but in OP’s situation, I would have suggested stopping exchanging gifts with SIL and her family.

Sounds like the kids get plenty of gifts so they won’t miss out but it stops SIL/BIL CFery.

user1477391263 · 05/07/2022 03:33

There's nothing wrong with buying for children only - just a tiny token gift if money is very tight - but it is not fair to change the goalposts when it suits you and your family. If you all agree to only buy for people up to the age of 18, then it stops for each person once they reach 18 and it doesn't stop for any person before they reach 18.

I really, really cannot imagine overthinking things like this. What do you want--some sort of Family Gift-Giving Contract, complete with Term of Agreement dates and signed in each member's blood?

We are facing a cost of living crisis right now, and many of us are fed up of wasting time and energy buying unwanted gifts, receiving unwanted gifts, wasting money, and having our houses filled with clutter.

Boxowine · 05/07/2022 02:15

I think it's hilarious that Christmas Carol brought this out of the past. Xmas 2019 when all we had to care about was gifts for kids. We'll be living like mad max by the time Christmas rolls around this year.

Christmascaroll · 04/07/2022 16:35

In my family once they started having kids it went to just really small presents for adults and spend money on own kids and nephews/ nieces.
Such as Lynx for men etc.

Christmascaroll · 22/11/2019 23:44

This is what my family does. And as I'm 16 now I feel like I will be moving into the adult bracket soon. Everybody gets presents from grandparents as they buy for c/cil and GC. And but parents just buy for there own and nephews and nieces.
I'm only here dir the gossip but haven't actually had a child

dreichwinter · 21/11/2019 14:58

Ah, @Buggersticks we have one of those in our family!

Buggersticks · 21/11/2019 14:44

@dreichwinter yeah I know, but the one with 4 wouldn't buy anything for any of them (even his own) if he could find a way.

dreichwinter · 21/11/2019 14:31

Logically @Buggersticks the sibling with 2 dc has to buy 5 gifts and the one with 4 has to buy 2?
The one with 4 dc has got off lightly but does have to cover the costs of 4 dc during the year.

Buggersticks · 21/11/2019 14:27

We have one, my siblings have 2 and 4 and I'm probably going to sound mean but they only have to fork out for our one, we have to buy for their 6. It's not like our one gets extra, in fact he often gets less spent on him from them. It peeves me, but I don't say anything 😞

furrytoebean · 20/11/2019 15:08

sweeny

I agree the get together is the nicest bit.

I don't have any children and buy for all my nieces which I enjoy doing because I love them and because I don't have kids I'm able to spoil them.

We also all go away as a family before Christmas (when it's cheap) which is the adults gift to each other.

My nieces also buy me something (I have a favourite box of chocolates that they sell in the £1 shop that they get me every year).

We don't get to see each other over Christmas and I miss out on all the listening for reindeer, visiting Santa, hanging up the stockings bit.

I LOVE Christmas but I do always feel sad at this time at not having children so losing the magic.

I really resent being made to feel like I'm grabby for not saying 'oh Christmas is just for the kids let's not bother with the adults this year'

FrenchBoule · 20/11/2019 14:52

@Kazzyhoward it’s similar to these getting full works at the restaurant and insisting on splitting the bill when some had just one dish.

Years ago I caused uproar as I stated that I didn’t want any gifts ( lots of things useless to me) and I’d rather have a book voucher/soapbar instead ( something I like). I was called u grateful because somebody made an effort yada yada...

ginghamtablecloths · 20/11/2019 13:59

The attitude in your OP seems a bit mean but all sort of things have to be taken into account, not least finances.

We got the same attitude with my sister who had three children, all now grown up, one of whom has a child.

We had no children but were expected to buy for her three.

"I expect your sister will get you a little something", was suggested by a friend. Er no, nothing at all. We don't buy things in order to get things in return but we felt used, especially as we never got a thank you, ever. We only get presents for the grandchild now and that'll stop in due course.