Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family and ‘we’re only buying for the children now’

334 replies

NemophilistRebel · 18/11/2019 17:57

Am I the only one who thinks you skinflint?

Family member who has 3 children which we have always bought for along with the parents decides as soon as we have first baby that now we have children (1) we can buy for children only at Christmas and birthdays.

So that’s years worth of buying for their 3 and them not having an issue, and now they just buy for one.

Is this typical with CF family members ?

OP posts:
Emeraldshamrock · 18/11/2019 19:12

Yanbu. I have nieces and nephews from age 3 to 18. Dsis only has one DC the 3 year old I could never stop it now, my eldest is 11.
I owe her plenty of years.
If we eventually stop the others, I'll still get her a gift. Fair is fair.
We only buy DC and do an adult sibling secret Santa.

TellMeWhoTheVilliansAre · 18/11/2019 19:10

Unfortunately it’s not as easy as just buying for the brother anyway as it would likely cause some argument or low down resentment with SIL

So?

You've said above that you should be allowed spend your money how you like. Does that only go for you, but not SIL? She is as equally entitled as you to spend her money how she likes.

If she gets a snot on and displays "low down resentment" so be it. Sounds like you don't think much of her anyway.

You're talking about how you feel, and how the SIL feels about how the husband's spend their money. How do the husband's feel? I'd hazard a guess they're not as fussed as you two!

NemophilistRebel · 18/11/2019 19:08

Entitled to what?
As said countless times it’s not the monetary value that matters

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2019 19:08

My sisters eldest is 18 this year and she thinks we should still buy for him as it wouldn't be fair to only buy for his siblings

Hmm Will she also expect him to wait until his youngest sibling is old enough before he learns to drive or goes out with his mates to the pub?

Children should, where possible, get the same - but they won't get it all at the same time. He got 100% of his parents' attention for however long it was before his oldest sibling was born - that's something that the others (who will also not have their parents with them for as much of their lives) can never truly have.

Winterhater · 18/11/2019 19:08

Now would be a good to stop exchanging gifts altogether.
People can take the huff all they like but stand firm and they’ll get over it

dreichwinter · 18/11/2019 19:07

If the brother has asked not to be bought a gift it seems pretty unreasonable to buy him
one.
A gift is meant to give pleasure and you know for whatever reason this family have decided the adults don't want to receive gifts so getting one is unlikely to bring pleasure.
There must be other people or charities your husband could channel his gift buying enthusiasm into where it would be appreciated.

MutedUser · 18/11/2019 19:07

Sounds sensible to only buy for kids . It’s not their fault they had kids before you . You sound entitled .

NemophilistRebel · 18/11/2019 19:06

@Pottedtree hopefully no one is making Christmas a transaction Hmm

OP posts:
NemophilistRebel · 18/11/2019 19:05

Yes no adult is expecting to be spoiled with gifts I am sure. And this isn’t what I was saying.

It’s the rudeness of the way it’s said and the timing too.
We’ve always spent more on people’s children than the adults to be able to afford a token gift for them. It’s only little bit it’s a nice gesture

OP posts:
Pottedtree · 18/11/2019 19:05

Perhaps they wanted to say it years ago but thought you'd kick off and now that you have a baby felt relieved to be able to say let's just buy for kids? I find it far more cringeworthy to make Christmas isn't a transaction.... YABU

thunderandsunshine01 · 18/11/2019 19:04

Just make sure you have at least 5 kids to even the score Grin

In seriousness I am torn though. Personally I don’t like the whole ‘just for the kids’ thing, everyone likes to feel acknowledged at Xmas even if it is just token gesture gifts. But on the other hand, you shouldn’t give just to receive and i would probably find it difficult to let this bother me, and I wouldn’t be keeping tally of the gifts and eve brought them vs us

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2019 19:03

My DM used to do this weird thing when we were young - if she spent £30 on a gift for me, she'd have to spend the same amount on my DSis or put the difference in an envelope.

My DGM always used to do this to the penny. She'd spot something and buy it for one of us, which would invariably cost £XX.99, so she'd give the £9.99 present AND a penny to one of us and a tenner to the other!

NemophilistRebel · 18/11/2019 19:03

Unfortunately it’s not as easy as just buying for the brother anyway as it would likely cause some argument or low down resentment with SIL who everyone walks on eggshells around.

Suggested secret Santa but it was rejected (by SIL)

OP posts:
LondonJax · 18/11/2019 19:03

Well, as you can see @AnneLovesGilbert I actually volunteered to do exactly that. I was single, no kids. My Dsis's had children. I bought the kids gifts and had nothing in return. My choice - they were happy to buy for me.

But what I did have was over £100 in my hands (four adults, twenty years ago at £25 each). Which was a lot of money then. And I spent the lot on myself. So whilst I didn't get a gift to unwrap, I got what I wanted because I didn't waste my money on a gift for all the adults because it was 'fair'.

Milo90 · 18/11/2019 19:02

We all buy for the kids until their 18...once they have kids we then buy for their kids.. Its just always been a thing in our family... I'm 32 and no kids yet but don't expect Xmas or birthday presents.... On special occasions.. Engagement... New house.. I've received a gift or card but I don't expect anything

SourDoughSophie · 18/11/2019 19:02

My sil had three children, we had two. Average gift price £15, she always spent £20 as she felt guilty, even though it wasn’t expected.

To be honest, I’d stop it all now before you lose anymore money

GuyFawkesDay · 18/11/2019 19:01

Oh and I only have one niece but I spend a lot on her as we have 2.

NemophilistRebel · 18/11/2019 19:01

@LondonJax that’s exactly what my sister said to us when she had their babies and we didn’t and it was fine.
That’s NBU at all.

That’s not what I’m saying is happening here on the other half of the family though where they are BU

OP posts:
TellMeWhoTheVilliansAre · 18/11/2019 19:01

People are entitled to decided how they spend their own money. You said your husband now "can't" buy for his brother. Of course he can. He can buy a present for whoever he pleases. But his brother won't, or is very unlikely to buy him one back. If he's happy with that, then everyone's happy.

One family have decided they don't want to buy presents for the whole family anymore. I think that's perfectly sensible. Especially as the family is only likely to keep expanding.

Why not suggest a Kris Kindle/Secret Santa amongst the adults so each person buys for just one other person.

But, if you want to buy gifts for others just do it.

GuyFawkesDay · 18/11/2019 19:01

Maybe the parental leave pot is empty for them so this is why they're saying no this year?

We only buy for kids, apart from my DS who doesn't have any.

I don't want/needs gifts. I'd rather people didn't waste their money!!!

HappyDinosaur · 18/11/2019 19:00

I find this a terrible lesson for the children, it's not all about them getting as many presents as possible. I'd rather less was spent, or no present, as I feel this promotes greed. Each to their own though.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2019 18:59

We always bought for my sister that does not have children and she bought for our children not us.

My aunts only stopped buying for me once I had a child of my own - this is IMO a fairer way to do it.

Makes complete sense to me. Either buy for everybody or, once you have kids, they get your whole family's present 'allocation'.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 18/11/2019 18:59

YANBU. Nine times out of ten it's those that have had the most benefit/have the most children that suggest this.

My sisters eldest is 18 this year and she thinks we should still buy for him as it wouldn't be fair to only buy for his siblings Hmm

BennyTheBall · 18/11/2019 18:58

We only buy for the kids in our family. I’ve never actually thought about the number each family has.

LondonJax · 18/11/2019 18:57

I think YABU. We've done this for years. My siblings had children long before we did and one year said 'look we think it's daft buying for the sake of buying for adults. We'd rather you put the cash to a nicer bottle of wine or a posher box of chocolates or an evening out. So we've agreed that we're just buying for the children for now on. We'll carry on buying for you as you don't have children but please don't spend hard earned cash on us adults'.

Well the following year I also joined in with that, even though I was single at the time and didn't have a child. So I bought for four kids (my nieces and nephews) and didn't get a gift in return - my choice.

Why did I decide to do that? Well because buying for four adults is a PITA. They've got most things they 'need' and the things they 'want' can be expensive. My siblings were buying me nice things that I didn't need - the thing that made me contact them and say 'look, do the same for me next year' was that my DSis spent a lot of money on Lush items. Lush brings me out in a rash - so it was given away. What a waste of money!

We now have one DS and we keep the same tradition. No adult presents, only buy for the kids. Presents stop when they get to 21 years old.

But all this business about 'well you're buying for three kids and they're only buying for one' is daft. Do you add up how much each present costs? Get the Argos catalogue out on Boxing Day to check they've spent the 'correct' amount on your child(ren)? Because I don't. I let my siblings know what my DS would like for Christmas, lots of different price levels, they choose one or two items off the list and that's it. My siblings do the same. It's up to me if I spend £20 or £100 on each child.

My DM used to do this weird thing when we were young - if she spent £30 on a gift for me, she'd have to spend the same amount on my DSis or put the difference in an envelope. Then she'd explain that my gift was £30 but my DSis was only £25 so she'd made up the difference. Like we'd double check what each gift costs. Used to drive us insane! And what a way to dampen the Christmas spirit.

I have absolutely no idea what I'd like for Christmas this year. What I don't want is 'stuff' for the sake of stuff. I'd rather my family spent a little more on themselves and their own children than buy me 'stuff' that they think I may like.

Swipe left for the next trending thread