Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family and ‘we’re only buying for the children now’

334 replies

NemophilistRebel · 18/11/2019 17:57

Am I the only one who thinks you skinflint?

Family member who has 3 children which we have always bought for along with the parents decides as soon as we have first baby that now we have children (1) we can buy for children only at Christmas and birthdays.

So that’s years worth of buying for their 3 and them not having an issue, and now they just buy for one.

Is this typical with CF family members ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Doorsdoyle · 05/07/2022 10:52

Only have one sibling but I usually send him a hamper or voucher. He's got 4 kids and buying 6 separate gifts would be crazy. I spend about 100 euro on a voucher. I always ask him for a lidl voucher for us.

Thebeastofsleep · 05/07/2022 10:18

This is really common and what we do in our family - we buy for child free adults and then for the kids of family who have them. It's been this way in my family for generations.

10HailMarys · 05/07/2022 09:44

Well, the end result is that you all have to buy fewer presents.

I suspect the family with the three kids would have liked to have stopped buying presents for adults years ago (I think loads of families don't buy gifts for adult siblings; pretty normal) but if they'd said 'Let's just buy for the children' when you didn't have any children, obviously that would looked terrible, because then you'd have been buying gifts and they'd had been buying nothing. But now you have kids it makes sense. They're not being CFs at all.

There is always going to be some disparity in gift-buying if one family is larger than the other. Not really sure what you expect them to do about that. My brother has to purchase one joint present for my household each year, because there's just me and my DP and we only do Christmas for the adults in my family, not birthdays. I have to buy seven Christmas presents and six birthday presents for his household each year. That's not actually anyone's fault. It's not like he had six kids to spite me.

Bigboysmademedoit · 05/07/2022 09:05

My DC are much younger than their many cousins and I suggested this to my siblings when my 2nd was born (I have 4). In theory I was the big loser as I’d bought their 14 cousins for the previous 20 years and now mine wouldn’t get so I thought it would be better coming from me as I had nothing to gain. My eldest DS called me later to say thanks and confess she used to lie awake at night worrying how to afford everything. It’s meant we can spend a little more on our own if we want to instead of filling each other’s homes with unwanted items.

Mudblast · 05/07/2022 08:45

the7Vabo · 05/07/2022 08:24

Prior to last Christmas my in-laws did Kris Kindle between the adults with a spending limit & we generally asked eachother what we wanted. My sis in law decided to scrap it. It makes sense in that family as all four siblings are very pragmatic rather than sentimental and my husband and his brother used to shake hands in lieu of gift vouchers.
From now on it’s kids only, one couple don’t have kids and I’m going to gift them a little something even separately to say thanks for spoiling the kids, just to acknowledge it.
Sounds awful but I often dread getting presents. I’m drowning in clutter so I really don’t need more stuff.

Out of interest was it someone with children that suggested this?

FeelingwearyFeeelingsmall · 05/07/2022 08:44

YABU and grabby. Christmas isn't (or shouldn't be) a transactional swap shop where one household gives another £100 worth of unwanted tat in order to receive the equivalent value of unwanted tat in return. Presents should be given with love and for the mutual pleasure of the giver and receiver. Something given grudgingly or in expectation of getting an equivalent return isn't a present at all.

We have cut out presents for everyone but our adult D.C. and little kids. Christmas is so much happier and more relaxed now. We focus on a full house with good food, games, karaoke, lots of wine and fun. No one misses presents at all.

Mudblast · 05/07/2022 08:42

As a childless person i bloody hate the lets all just buy for the children rule sweeping through my family

If you try and object to it people think you are grabby (as explained above)

Slowly but surely every single group around me has done it, my friendship group, my cousins, my siblings. At christmas we used to get together and unwrap things together and feel a bit united. Now i buy many gifts and recieve nothing in return.

Often on christmas i may have been invited round but have to watch as the kids open presents, my sister and mother unwrap things from their spouses while i watch on. I had to fight to get an agreement i could buy my own parent's a gift. My sister said that it was too many to buy for and that its wasteful but i dont think realised the rule had meant I was made to feel awkward if i bought for any adult in my life, and while she might feel she gets enough gifts from her children, partner etc that others didnt get that. Whilst im sure for some people it does all seem a waste, there are people where they might have very little else

Its wasnt until i met dp that i realised how isolated that rule had made me feel.

Ultimately it wasnt about giving or recieving gifts, it was about feeling like i was being expected to have "grown out of" being a daughter, sister and friend and those relationships had been completely redefined as an aunt, godmother etc. That the adult relationships no longer mattered to people anymore and I was being left behind .
It meant there was no expressions of thoughtfulness, of i just saw this and thought youd love it, or lets do this together? It wasnt about the gift it was about feeling that i wasnt allowed to value my friends and wasnt thought of by them. Its similar when these days i get cards from the kids, (cute as they are) but no message from the parents who are friends of many years.

I completely understood it for my cousins group (even if that meant that i was buying 15+ gifts for occassionally someform of sympathy present eg a box of dairy milk from one couple) but it was hurtful when it was applied to my sibling groups, close friends etc.

the7Vabo · 05/07/2022 08:24

Prior to last Christmas my in-laws did Kris Kindle between the adults with a spending limit & we generally asked eachother what we wanted. My sis in law decided to scrap it. It makes sense in that family as all four siblings are very pragmatic rather than sentimental and my husband and his brother used to shake hands in lieu of gift vouchers.
From now on it’s kids only, one couple don’t have kids and I’m going to gift them a little something even separately to say thanks for spoiling the kids, just to acknowledge it.
Sounds awful but I often dread getting presents. I’m drowning in clutter so I really don’t need more stuff.

dottiedodah · 05/07/2022 08:21

Apart from the cost of having to buy something for Adults ,Its such a pain to think will Sue and John like this/have they got one like it ,hope they havent spent too much on us! We have only bought for DC for some time and likewise .YABU a bit I think

Tiani4 · 05/07/2022 08:16

Knittedfairies · 18/11/2019 18:04

...or buy one gift for them to share?

OP you said you have other childless Siblings

Why don't you and they agree that for a few years you and they will buy for each of you as adults and small pressie for baby (baby won't need much) and then when they want to buy bigger presents for baby they stop buying for you

Then your sibling with 3 DCs misses out of adult pressies but also - all of you siblings only buy

  • 1 present from per family between all 3 of their DCs
  • or just get them a selection box each at £2 each
  • or all the siblings get together and buy their DCs a bigger present at £20 from all the aunties and uncles and maybe nan and grandad too (so is £5 each for eg)

Then your sibling with 3 can look on in jealousy when all the other adults open gifts between each other and watch their DCs open small gifts or one big gift from family

MonteStory · 05/07/2022 08:11

I completely get it @NemophilistRebel My MIL has form for making unilateral decisions about stuff like this. You can’t complain without looking grabby (as this thread shows!) but I really dislike being told who to buy for and how to do it. That’s not how gift giving works.

We don’t do kids only but for some reason this year MIL decided adults would open their presents later. So it’s just loads of adults sitting round watching my kids open presents which I didn’t like. I will ask this year that everyone is equal. I don’t like the message “Christmas is for kids”. Everyone has the right to a nice day of nice food, relaxing, seeing loved ones etc. obviously they may not get that but festivals aren’t just ‘for the kids’

SleeplessInEngland · 05/07/2022 08:06

YABU for treating gifts as transactional.

Blaggertyjibbet · 05/07/2022 08:04

We always draw names from a hat. We do one secret Santa draw amongst the children and another amongst the adults. When the kids turn 18 they are included in the adult pool instead of just ageing out of getting a gift. That way each family only buys a number of presents that is proportionate their family size, and it is one decent gift instead of 10 small boxes of cheap chocolate.

CornedBeef451 · 05/07/2022 07:55

We do this now. I was the last to have kids but it was my idea. I also implemented stopping at 18 as I was buying gifts for adult children with more disposable income than me.

There's now great grandkids in the mix so I am buying for my great nieces and nephews but don't buy their parents anything. It's a bit odd as they (the adult nieces and nephew) don't buy my kids anything but my sister does so it all works out that way.

I privately also implemented a budget for each family as DB had 5 and DS had 3 so if I spent the same on each child it was costing me a fortune.

I'm just relieved to not be scrabbling for presents for adults when no one wants anything and we all used to end up with weird generic gifts.

SteamingHind · 05/07/2022 07:42

Beautiful3 · 05/07/2022 07:31

YABU. Cost of living has shot up, people are trying to reduce their out goings, to afford energy& grocery bills. We started this, only buying for kids in our family too. We don't expect anything. If people buy them a bag of sweets, then that's appreciated. You don't need to match what people spend on your children, just set an amount you can afford. You can just buy sweets and a card, I'm sure they will appreciate what ever you gift.

It hadn't shot up when she posted.

Highfivemum · 05/07/2022 07:39

skinny yes I do agree after you doing it for years for them. That’s families for you though. My friends DB only would buy for 2 of her DC ( she has 4) as he only has two !! Crazy.

TenoringBehind · 05/07/2022 07:36

We started doing this years ago because it seemed ridiculous to waste time and money buying things for adults that they almost certainly didn’t really want and which just sat in a cupboard until they were donated to a charity shop or school tomboys. Reduced some of the stress around Christmas too.

Squirrelsnut · 05/07/2022 07:35

We did this years ago and it's great. Less money, less stress, less waste. I don't need gift packs of shower gel and body lotion.

Beautiful3 · 05/07/2022 07:31

YABU. Cost of living has shot up, people are trying to reduce their out goings, to afford energy& grocery bills. We started this, only buying for kids in our family too. We don't expect anything. If people buy them a bag of sweets, then that's appreciated. You don't need to match what people spend on your children, just set an amount you can afford. You can just buy sweets and a card, I'm sure they will appreciate what ever you gift.

GinUnicorn · 05/07/2022 07:25

We have the same situation although we are now wondering how long it goes on for. SILs two daughters 17 and 15 usually ask for very expensive gifts (£40 region) we are hoping to stop once they are 18. Wouldn’t mind so much but they are very entitled generally.

BusyMum47 · 05/07/2022 06:51

Christ, we were thrilled when SIL suggested only buying for kids from now on & adopted it rapidly across both families!

At the end of the day, we buy for less people - result. All the kids still get the same amount of presents - result. We don't have piles of 'bought for the sake of it' tat - result. Winner all round!

I occasionally get mildly irritated that we have to buy far more presents than other relatives because we only have 1 child & they all have multiples but that's sadly Mother Nature's fault. 🤷‍♀️

FrecklesMalone · 05/07/2022 06:49

You don't have to buy presents for your nieces and nephews. That's up to you. Or you could buy them a joint present. I absolutely love not having to buy presents for adults. We do a secret Santa for the adults with a £10 budget. Who needs more stuff? Definitely not me. I hate clutter. A nice book and I am happy.

phishy · 05/07/2022 06:46

Hesma · 05/07/2022 06:30

Not so much them being CF, more you being grabby

How was the OP grabby?

Dancingwithhyenas · 05/07/2022 06:43

It is an exceptionally expensive time to be alive. I’d cut everyone some slack on presents.

Hesma · 05/07/2022 06:30

Not so much them being CF, more you being grabby

Swipe left for the next trending thread