Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do tenants have to pay council tax?

485 replies

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 10:01

It's a domestic property tax. But tenants don't own any property, so they're paying tax on something they don't own. They didn't use to have to pay rates, but they have to pay council tax. Why? NB council tax is not a tax for use of services so that argument doesn't wash. It is a tax where liability is created by the existence of a domestic property. Which tenants clearly do not own.

OP posts:
Purpleartichoke · 16/11/2019 15:40

Where I live, the property owner pays the taxes. So landlords just include the tax when they decide the rent. Tenants Effectively pay the tax either way, the only difference is the money passes through the landlord on the way.

CareOfPunts · 16/11/2019 15:38

You sound entitled and a bit of a scrounger OP.

It is what it is, you have to pay, no point moaning about . Take the government to court for breaking the law if you think it’s unlawful.

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 15:37

@MsRomanoff you're missing out. We not only get pie charts but they're coloured. It sure makes all the difference.

OP posts:
MsRomanoff · 16/11/2019 15:34

nah, just not a fan of disproportionate/regressive taxation and also frustrated that people paying it think they're buying something because the council sends them pie charts.

I feel left out. I dont get a pie chart.

I think you must very young. Because you have no idea about economics or finances. Tenants doesnt mean 'must be min wage' or does homeowner = rich.

However we do all use the same services.

You sound like a teenager who is going to stick it to the man

tillytrotter1 · 16/11/2019 15:34

For the same reason that tenants have to buy their own food, petrol etc., they use/consume the services provided. Are you suggesting that tenants empty their own bins etc.?

mumwon · 16/11/2019 15:33

@Thehagonthehill exactly - there use to be but that's long gone - unless you manage to scrape into the unliveable accommodation ie no bathroom kitchen & falling down I think op is a troll or one of those people who believe that homes should be free to everybody - problem with that is that even in socialist countries people still pay rent to the state (& probably the equivalent of council tax or rates!) God help her LL!

dreichwinter · 16/11/2019 15:32

It is also worth remembering that some of the wealthiest people don't work so having a range of taxes not just taxes based on earnings is important.
It is perfectly possible to have property taxes paid for only by the property owner, I currently rent a house in the USA were this happens, obviously the amount of rent I pay reflects this.
Meanwhile my tenant rents out my UK house and pays the council tax and the rent reflects that.
My tenant could buy a property but for their own reasons chooses to rent my house at present.
It is simplistic and untrue to suggest that everyone renting is unable to buy.

TriangularRatbag · 16/11/2019 15:30

Goodnight, I did say vaguely proportionate! That's pretty good. As I've said several times if you're expecting the tax system to be entirely rational and fair then you're quite new to the analysis of tax Grin

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 15:29

Yeah, based on rateable value, broadly speaking potential rent although actually a little more complicated, owners historically liable (and this was during rentier years so many more tenants), with some shifts towards some tenants effectively paying, in the vast majority of cases included in their rent, although even by the time they were scrapped ie as the proportion had grown, only around 40% had some form of liability. And rates were of course much lower than council tax and included water.

So yeah everyone now pays more tax and tenants pay more again. Most tenants didn't get a rent reduction at the time liability changed as rent capping had already ended.

OP posts:
Pussinboots25 · 16/11/2019 15:28

No one wants to pay council tax as its not something you see a direct benefit from, expect seeing your bins being emptied every week. I understand it covers police, fire service and local facilities such as libraries too

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 16/11/2019 15:27

Tenants have the sole legal right to use the property for the duration of the tenancy.

VED is added to rental payments under PCH car leasing, it is not paid by the asset owner but passed to the person with the legal right of exclusive use.

Who pays the VED on a lease car?
Many people wonder if you don’t own the car and hold the v5 how you tax the car?

When you lease a car most funding companies will tax the vehicle for you including the cost of the vehicle excise duty (formally known as Road tax) in your monthly rental.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 16/11/2019 15:26

For example, a tenant on minimum wage in a band A property here pays an additional 6.27% in council tax as a proportion of take-home pay after income tax and minimum pension payments levied against an asset they don't own. For someone on £50000, who is more likely to own the asset, council tax is 2.35% of what they take home after income tax and minimum pension contribution.

You seem to be under the impression that tenants are all very poor and homeowners are all very rich. This is not the case at all - plenty of poorer people have mortgages. Maybe they got the mortgage before they lost their job or got divorced or live in a very cheap area etc. Equally, many people prefer the flexibility of renting and actively prefer not to be tied down with a mortgage on a house in a fixed location. Have you seen the WEEKLY rents for some of those studio flats in Knightsbridge? They most certainly aren't poor people.

We 'own' our own home on an interest only mortgage, so effectively renting. Our council tax is about 6.2% of our family take-home pay after tax.

If what you're actually asking is why council tax isn't abolished and income tax increased to replace current CT revenues, then that makes a lot more sense, whether people would agree with it or not. However, assuming that only the poor rent and only the rich have mortgages is absurd.

SquidgeyMidgey · 16/11/2019 15:24

If they passed this tax to the landlord rather than the tenant the landlord would just add it on to your rent anyway.

OP I do understand your point about percentage of earnings paid in taxes, and it something that needs to be addressed, but any home-occupier should pay towards their bin being emptied. Also, you have quite rightly stated that most of a council's revenue comes from sources other than council tax, so you realise that the amount we pay is peanuts compared to what they actually need to run their services.

reginafelangee · 16/11/2019 15:22

Council tax pays for your council services - street lighting, bins, schools, fire brigade etc.

The tenant uses these services so the tenant must pay for them.

It really is that simple

Alsohuman · 16/11/2019 15:21

You’re wrong about non property owners not paying rates. In fact, according to Wikipedia, they were based on rental values when first introduced.

^As local government developed, separate rates were collected by parish authorities, borough corporations and county authorities. The County Rates Act 1739 ended the practice of separate rates being levied for individual purposes, such a highway rate and provided for a unified county rate.

Rates on residential property were based on the nominal rental value, reassessed periodically in revaluations. By the Rating and Valuation Act 1925, revaluations were supposed to take place every five years but in practice they were frequently delayed or suspended. Revaluations took place in 1928/1929, 1934, 1956 (but based on 1939 values), 1963, and 1973. A revaluation due in the early 1980s was scrapped by the Secretary of State for the Environment Michael Heseltine in June 1979, with Heseltine urging householders to tear up the forms already sent out by the Valuation Office.[1]^

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 15:18

@TriangularRatbag not really. The example I gave was for the lowest banding taking into account the 25% discount, excluding the rate for travellers etc ie most people won't pay less than that, but the minimum wage earner is still stuffed, relatively speaking. That they're stuffed by a tax raised against something they don't even own just adds insult to injury.

OP posts:
Elmo230885 · 16/11/2019 15:15

Thanks for the reply. I do agree that proportionally lower income people can end up paying more. There maybe is a fairer way of deciding the banding. When it is done purely on the property, then yes, it isn't fair on renters however I do believe they should still pay and it shouldn't fall to the landlord.

TriangularRatbag · 16/11/2019 15:13

It is vaguely proportionate to the size of their home, according to the banding system, if that makes you feel any better.

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 15:11

@MsRomanoff nah, just not a fan of disproportionate/regressive taxation and also frustrated that people paying it think they're buying something because the council sends them pie charts.

OP posts:
FFSFFSFFS · 16/11/2019 15:10

Should people who don't own houses not pay income tax then?

TriangularRatbag · 16/11/2019 15:10

So a non asset owner on a low wage pays 4% more tax than an asset owner on a high wage.

I'm not really sure what asset ownership has to do with it.

MsRomanoff · 16/11/2019 15:06

I'd feel better if it wasn't regressive and also if it didn't include non asset owners, as was the case prior to 1988

Ita got nothing to do with assets.

Do you believe all homeowners are rich?

Is that your issue?

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 15:05

So a non asset owner on a low wage pays 4% more tax than an asset owner on a high wage.

OP posts:
SafetyAdvice0FeedWhenAgitated · 16/11/2019 15:04

@Goodnightseamer are you ok? That's a lots of weird complaning about council tax... Are you having some money issues? Or landlord issues? There is lots of help available so just ask...

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 15:02

@Elmo230885 I'd feel better if it wasn't regressive and also if it didn't include non asset owners, as was the case prior to 1988. Introducing the personal liability flat element means that those on low incomes without assets have consistently paid a greater percentage of their wage in tax.

For example, a tenant on minimum wage in a band A property here pays an additional 6.27% in council tax as a proportion of take-home pay after income tax and minimum pension payments levied against an asset they don't own. For someone on £50000, who is more likely to own the asset, council tax is 2.35% of what they take home after income tax and minimum pension contribution.

OP posts: