Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do tenants have to pay council tax?

485 replies

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 10:01

It's a domestic property tax. But tenants don't own any property, so they're paying tax on something they don't own. They didn't use to have to pay rates, but they have to pay council tax. Why? NB council tax is not a tax for use of services so that argument doesn't wash. It is a tax where liability is created by the existence of a domestic property. Which tenants clearly do not own.

OP posts:
MepsiPax · 16/11/2019 17:12

They didn't used to have to pay rates,but they have to pay council tax. That is incorrect. When I first moved into my council property,back in 1983,there was a rates payment included in our weekly rent.

redchocolatebutton · 16/11/2019 17:08

I think of council tax as a fee for services that the inhabitant uses.
where I live now doesn't have council tax, however we get yearly invoices for refuse collection, street maintenance, flood protection plus yearly property tax.

OldSpeclkledHen · 16/11/2019 17:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

dottiedodah · 16/11/2019 17:02

If you live in a town and make use of the waste bins ,police services ,libraries and so on then you have to pay for them !(shock horror). I wasnt aware that Council tax was free at any time but not sure of this .You can apply for a reduction in council tax payments, if on a low income and have less than 16k in savings .

Wonkybanana · 16/11/2019 16:58

Jeremy, is that you?

Look OP, if it helps then, despite its name, think of it more as insurance rather than a tax.

People insure their houses and cars so that IF anything happens, the money will be there to put it right. Most people will never have to call on it. So if someone else's house burns down, your premiums will go towards their payout. If the same happened to you, then other people's premiums would be part of the money you get as compensation. What you're 'buying' is the knowledge that if the worst happens, you won't have to finds thousands of pounds to put it right.

So Council Tax - you're paying it so that IF your bins need emptying, they will be. IF you need to use a library it will be there. IF you have children and they go to school, there will be a school for them to go to. IF you need care in your old age there will be public funds to pay for it. Etc...

If you do turn out to need care in your old age, are you going to refuse to take it because tenants will have made a contribution to the cost?

Yes as a PP has explained, most fixed taxes are regressive. Unless you're going to abolish all taxes except PAYE, and increase the % rate accordingly, then there is no way round it. But somehow we have to pay for the things we take for granted. And as for the argument that council tax doesn't pay for these things because it only accounts for 25% of council expenditure, it's nonsense. It pays for 25% of the cost of schools, of lighting, of social care. The rets as you say comes from government, and much of it will have come from general taxation, you know, PAYE which is proportional to income.

mencken · 16/11/2019 16:48

this thread is impressive as the sillycow kneejerk anti-landlord brigade got there on the very first response. And no doubt are there at intervals throughout 13 pages of intermittent stupidity which I CBA to read.

don't like paying for services? Desert islands are available.

Chloemol · 16/11/2019 16:45

It to pay for bin emptying, schools, adult social care, etc. The total cost paid is also partly collected on behalf of Parish councils, go spend in on play equipment, cemeteries street lighting or anything else they do for thier Parish, plus part goes to the police and fire services.

It is not a domestic property tax, you are paying for facilities you use. Your landlord pays his on his property

BlouseAndSkirt · 16/11/2019 16:34

For example, a tenant on minimum wage in a band A property here pays an additional 6.27% in council tax as a proportion of take-home pay after income tax and minimum pension payments levied against an asset they don't own.For someone on £50000, who is more likely to own the asset, council tax is 2.35% of what they take home after income tax and minimum pension contribution.

The likelihood is that someone earning £50k is in a house with a more expensive band than A, so will be paying more CT that way.

The higher earning person also pays a smaller % of their income than the person on Minimum wage if they buy a highly taxed packet of cigarettes. For everything with a fixed cost the impact of that spend is less for the higher earner in % terms.

But they will be paying more income tax, in absolute terms and as a %, they will have paid SDLT to buy their property, they will pay Inheritance Tax on it when they die, or else it will be sold to fund their adult care...while the renter on Min Wage will have their care costs covered by the highest expense paid for out of council tax....adult care services!

Justajot · 16/11/2019 16:34

Money is fungible. The pie chart you get sent could easily show something else instead. If council tax covers 25% of the spending of your local council and your local council spends 10% of its income on refuse collection and 15% on libraries, then your local council could decide that "council tax pays for refuse collection and libraries" and send you a pie chart showing just those two services.

The tax I don't like is national insurance. It allows the headline income tax rates to look like 20% and 40%, but it's more like 32% and 42% when you consider employee NIC. There's not as much difference between 32% and 42%. I appreciate that there are nuances around the figures, I have simplified somewhat.

Sammyp235 · 16/11/2019 16:23

My council tax is £226 a month!! I don’t love paying it as I’m sure no one does but I use the services so I have to....

Therebythedoor · 16/11/2019 16:17

You do seem full of 'knowledge' but lacking in awareness of how the system works at the same time.

Therebythedoor · 16/11/2019 16:11

OP, have you got your knickers in a twist because you've just been told you are liable to pay council tax?

I only ask because I was faced with a similar line of incensed outrage from a younger resident when dealing with council tax enquiries last week. Council tax had come as a rather unwelcome surprise.

JassyRadlett · 16/11/2019 16:09

It’s just another money making scheme.

Yes, that is the point of taxation. To raise money to pay for public services.

Sammyp235 · 16/11/2019 16:08

It’s just another money making scheme. I don’t get the argument that those that rent shouldn’t have to pay? It’s for stuff like recycling, waste collection. Whether you rent or own a property, you still get the sand service.....!

Tistheseason17 · 16/11/2019 16:04

What a bonkers thread..

OP - if you want to live somewhere and not pay Council Tax - go and move somewhere where the landlord charges you more to live there but tells you no council tax fees.

People who live in houses pay council tax - whether they own or rent for the local services such as planning, transport, highways, police, fire, libraries, leisure and recreation, rubbish collection and disposal, environmental health and trading standards etc

I'm sure you'd want emergency services, right? Someone has to pay for them - why not you?

Inebriati · 16/11/2019 15:58

We used to get people coming into our shop demanding to know why they had to pay VAT on some of the goods.
We get people on Ebay demanding to know why we charge for postage.
I've also met people who believe that if you buy an item for £5, the seller gets to keep £5, and it makes them feel resentful.

I don't get the resentment. Systems aren't perfect and the more complicated they get the less perfect they become. They work tolerably well most of the time for most of the people that use them, and thats the best you can hope for.

To this end all you need to know is that if the landlord had to pay the council tax, yes?
Then they would pass the cost on to the tenant, yes?
And therefore the tenant would still have to pay council tax.

Except your system would disadvantage tenants who are not liable for council tax.
Which is why the system runs this way and not your way.

ivykaty44 · 16/11/2019 15:56

@Goodnightseamer
When I started work PAYE was at 30% and if I added 10% to my PAYE and didn’t pay council tax now I would be able to pay 42% PAYE and still have the same money in my pocket

ivykaty44 · 16/11/2019 15:50

@nrpmum There hasn’t been a road fund tax in UK since 1937
Roads are funded by council tax and general taxation

MsRomanoff · 16/11/2019 15:48

you're missing out. We not only get pie charts but they're coloured. It sure makes all the difference.

Not sure. People dont really yawn pie charts anymore they arent as great as people think. Maybe that's the issue?

You cant work out the angle on the one chart

Op what you are saying doesnt make sense. Anyone pays towards the seevicea they use. End of

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 16/11/2019 15:44

I think op is a troll or one of those people who believe that homes should be free to everybody

I can't comment on the 'troll' suspicion, but how nice would it be if real life were actually like an Enid Blyton book - where you walk through the forest, find a house you like and just decide to move in?!

electricwhisk · 16/11/2019 15:43

Why should the owner of a home worth £50000 in a deprived town in the north pay a tax and not someone paying £8000 per month rent in London?

willdoitinaminute · 16/11/2019 15:43

Rates didn’t include water, you had separate water rates. There are plenty of very wealthy people who rent.

mokapot · 16/11/2019 15:42

You are using their services: you pay for it: I’m happy to pay council tax for you but then I’ll just increase your rent
Wtaf? It’s a skivvy society these days

CareOfPunts · 16/11/2019 15:41

It’s not the only regressive tax we have. VAT is regressive as well. Personally I’d rather just see the likes of VAT and council tax abolished and increases in income tax. No one will for for that though because if people actually worked out how much they pay in tax they would baulk at it

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 16/11/2019 15:40

Also, if you own a house (even with no equity) and you sell it to move elsewhere - even if adverse financial circumstances forced you to move and it's to a smaller, less valuable house in a less nice area, you will be forced to pay stamp duty on the house you buy whilst getting nothing back from the stamp duty you paid to buy the first house.

You might buy a house and then personal/work circumstances beyond your control mean that you have to sell it and buy an identical house 40 miles away. In theory, you could end up doing this 5 times, ending up with an identical house with still no equity yet, but with an added 4 hefty chunks of 'moving tax' to pay based on 'assets' that they have never actually had.

Tenants can move freely as they wish once their agreed term is up (I realise that they are sometimes forced to against their wishes because the landlord refuses to renew) and NEVER have any similar 'moving tax' to pay.

In the spirit of fairness, are you going to campaign against stamp duty payable on anything but the increase in property sales/purchase value (which is still not an actual asset anyway until the mortgagee has gained any equity) - on the grounds that it's a tax that tenants are never forced to pay?

Swipe left for the next trending thread