Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do tenants have to pay council tax?

485 replies

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 10:01

It's a domestic property tax. But tenants don't own any property, so they're paying tax on something they don't own. They didn't use to have to pay rates, but they have to pay council tax. Why? NB council tax is not a tax for use of services so that argument doesn't wash. It is a tax where liability is created by the existence of a domestic property. Which tenants clearly do not own.

OP posts:
Zaphodsotherhead · 17/11/2019 14:34

North Yorkshire, Joannie455. Big house, cheap rent. I am trying my hardest to move.

Joannie455 · 17/11/2019 14:27

£168 with the discount is very high. What area do you live in and what is your CT banding? A late relative of mine lived in the London Borough of Havering and paid £148 (including single person discount) a month over 10 months for a small 2 bedroom bungalow, which was Band E.

Zaphodsotherhead · 17/11/2019 14:20

Sorry, I hadn't gone through the full thread. I will now, to find out what the reasoning is. It makes a sort of sense...

I still think £168 per month (and that's with the 25% discount) is steep on a NMW job, and one of the reasons I can't afford heating.

dementedpixie · 17/11/2019 13:45

It's been explained earlier I think. Something to do with 50% for property and 50% personal part. You get a 50% discount off the personal part so you still pay 75%

Zaphodsotherhead · 17/11/2019 13:42

I want to know why the single person discount is only 25% rather than 50%. As a single person, surely I use 50% less local services (ie, my bin doesn't need emptying that often), how can I use a quarter less?

Joannie455 · 17/11/2019 13:34

Tenants and homeowners have to pay Council Tax. Prior to CT, there was the hated Poll Tax and prior to that were the rates. All these systems have come under fire as being “unfair” or “wrongly targeted”, but what’s the option? Should the UK follow the example of the Channel Islands where everyone - irrespective of their property owning status - pays a form of local income tax for these services? Many would cute that as ‘Poll Tax 2’, where some would see it as a sensible option. Local services have to be paid for, but the contentious points include the waste of resources councils are guilty of: vanity and cosmetic projects, publicity materials, councillors ‘expenses’, to name but a few (I’m sure readers will think of many more). I’m not happy with CT and would prefer a system based on a local income tax, but that’s just my opinion.

MRex · 17/11/2019 12:00

(That was to @BillHadersNewWife)

MRex · 17/11/2019 11:59

I can't reply to you because there weren't any full sentences in your post. Unless you really think "no" was sufficient answer.

BlueEyedBengal · 17/11/2019 11:57

And we never see a policeman or roadsweep

BlueEyedBengal · 17/11/2019 11:56

I resent paying the council tax to my council. Bin collectors only round 2 times a month roads crumbling and untouched all year streets dirty and unwashed and full of weeds, and clubs and services cut or even stopped. All the while councillors live it up while the workers are cut or don't get a pay rise and my council tax goes up at least £10 every year. But you have to pay tenants or homeowners as they have you over a barrel, you will go to court or jail even if it is far from value for money.Envy

bigpat · 17/11/2019 11:13

It is NOT a "domestic property tax" and it doesn't matter how often you keep repeating it. Did you ask this question because you were looking for genuine answers? You've had them.

It's a tax levied on the residents of an area which helps the council pay for services provided to those residents.

You may have your own opinion on whether or not that's fair, but THAT'S WHAT IT IS.

BillHadersNewWife · 17/11/2019 11:11

MrX no...rentals would STILL go up if the fact that landlords had to pay the rates was going to impact them. They

MRex · 17/11/2019 08:30

@BillHadersNewWife - what an odd comment, that's just because your property prices are cheaper. I could get a mansion with loads of land in rural Wales for the price of a flat in London, still no relevance to council tax payments.

Baldcrusader · 17/11/2019 07:42

You're in the house you pay the council tax. If you cannot afford this, there is council tax benefit. Make the landlord pay it and watch rents increase massively across the board as landlords can't or won't absorb this.

coolwalking · 17/11/2019 05:24

Haven't read full thread sorry. In NZ landlords pay the rates (CT) which is of course included in the overall rent charge

BillHadersNewWife · 17/11/2019 05:01

Safari well that's not how it's worked out in Australia. We rent here...rentals are very reasonable despite the fact that tenants do not pay rates. The owner pays those. The rent for a 3 bed house, large garden in pleasant, safe market town is around the same as it would be in UK.

safariboot · 17/11/2019 03:13

I agree with the many people who have pointed out that because Council Tax is paid by the occupier (except if the property is empty), it can be varied based on the circumstances of the occupier. Hence the student exemption, single-occupant reduction, council tax benefit/support, and so on. None of this would be practical to administer if the owner paid it.

The result of making landlords pay the council tax would be that all tenants who aren't claiming benefits would effectively pay full price via their rent. That means a big rent hike for students and single people.

ivykaty44 · 17/11/2019 02:55

Tenants on HB would receive an increase in HB to cover it and councils could close down the whole department devoted to working out who gets what percent reduction based on what claim

HB only applies to non working age claims, UC pays the housing element, which is DWP.

Tenants wouldn’t be getting their tax relief on council tax if they are low earners as the landlord would just be sticking it on the rent and the landlord wouldn’t be applying for tax reduction as not applicable

PeterSteer · 16/11/2019 22:49

I’ve no vested interest but advise that CT is simply an occupiers liability.

scaryteacher · 16/11/2019 20:05

People rioted because the poll tax charges were extortionate for families and were not in any way dependent on wealth.

The CC charges were for the individual, not the family. You neglect to mention the Transitional Relief scheme, and the Community Charge benefit that were available.

People rioted because they could in some cases...not entirely due to the introduction of Community Charge!

Happyhusband · 16/11/2019 19:26

OP it is a tax for services rendered. You might remember the pathetic national reaction to community charge which tried to make it person based. The numerous exceptions and discounts on council tax are all person based not property driven. Send your local council a freedom of information enquiry. They'll be happy to explain.

thisonehasalittlecar · 16/11/2019 19:13

I'm an (evil fatcat) LL and I think from an administrative point of view it makes sense for LLs to pay council tax. Yes we'd raise rents to cover it but it wouldn't cost the tenants more because they'd no longer be paying CT. Tenants on HB would receive an increase in HB to cover it and councils could close down the whole department devoted to working out who gets what percent reduction based on what claim. It would increase revenue for the councils because owners are easier to track down if they're not paying than a tenant who's done a flit; they would also get revenue from properties not currently generating due to being occupied by students etc. And it would solve the problem of earners being liable for the full whack of CT in flats shared with non-earners

Lincslady53 · 16/11/2019 19:05

In the 90s, the government tried to bring in a new way of charging for local services, based on the person, rather than the property. At that time the argument was that a single person in say a 2 bed house was paying the same as potentially 4 adults in the same size property, so it was unfair on the single person. The problem was that although single people had their bills reduced, the bills for others increased and it resulted in the poll tax riots (it was actually called the Community Charge) So to stop the riots we went back to a property based system, with a 25% discount for a single person in a property. However, although it is based on the property it does pay for local services, and pensions for retired council staff, and redundancy payouts when staff are made redundant. A manager in our rural council recently had a £300,000+ payout when he took redundancy, paid for by the ever generous council tax payers. It is a labour run council.

Billben · 16/11/2019 19:03

It should be means tested

It most certainly should not. People living in more expensive properties are already paying more for the same exact services.

Abraid2 · 16/11/2019 18:59

Op is Jeremy Corbyn brainstorming another policy.