Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do tenants have to pay council tax?

485 replies

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 10:01

It's a domestic property tax. But tenants don't own any property, so they're paying tax on something they don't own. They didn't use to have to pay rates, but they have to pay council tax. Why? NB council tax is not a tax for use of services so that argument doesn't wash. It is a tax where liability is created by the existence of a domestic property. Which tenants clearly do not own.

OP posts:
UhareFouxisci · 18/11/2019 09:02

you don't get to say that something isn't sickening. If it induces nausea in some people they are allowed to describe it as sickening. (some people don't find nose picking sickening, for example, some do, those who don't aren't allowed to dictate the feelings of those who do)

people should generally be allowed to spend their money where they like, but the difference between owning multiple cars, and owning multiple houses, is that when demand for cars goes up the car manufacturers make more cars. there is already high demand for houses in the places where people have jobs, and very limited capacity for new housing in those areas - most new builds are a long bus ride from the town centre. if one person owns two houses in those desirable areas, they are forcing up tee prices and forcing less advantaged people into a rental trap. if there were strict limits on people owning more than one property in a desirable area (perhaps special dispensation for those who need a base in two cities more than 2 hours travel time from one another) then property prices wouldn't spiral out of control, more people could afford their own homes and taxes could go down because there would be less tax income going straight into the pockets of landlords treating other human beings' need for housing as an investment opportunity.

this could also force people to buy their holiday homes in areas which desperately need some inward investment, as these would be the easiest places to be allowed to buy a second property.

Gbtch · 18/11/2019 08:52

Lilyflower1 - well said.

JaneEB · 18/11/2019 08:27

A fair society is one where people are allowed to spend the money they earn on what they want to spent it on.

What annoys me is when people demand social housing of a specific type, such as a large house in the middle of London. If you need social housing then you should take that which is available and be grateful.

If someone that has to finance their own housing wants a big house in the middle of London they have to be able to earn sufficient to be able to afford it, why should someone with quite a few kids they cannot afford and has never worked be able to demand a house in a specific place because they have friends there. If we could no longer afford this place we would have to move somewhere else, (and no it is not a big house) and make new friends.

As for Australia, at a guess there might be a little more land available there which would go a long way towards making housing more affordable.

Derbee · 18/11/2019 08:17

@Doodoobear, I don’t think @Lilyflower1 was talking about tenants, or people like you. They were presumably just pointing out that describing people who have invested in property as “disgusting” is wrong. The people who have the means to invest in property and become landlords could have chosen to spend all of their disposable income on expensive holidays etc. But the PP presumably isn’t standing at airports shouting “disgusting” at people going on holiday.

Doodoobear · 18/11/2019 07:34

It is not ‘sickening’ a person who has paid tax on their salary chooses to invest it in property rather than splurge it on holidays, meals out, pleasure and bling. It is, rather, prudent and sensible, and will keep them from needing the state’s help when they are old.

It is rather sickening though that if you don't own a property you're apparently splurging it all on 'holidays, meals out, pleasure and bling'.
Not rent, gas, electric, water, council tax (which I agree tenants should pay) and work related expenses, but are in a low paid job. I mean of course I enjoy the luxury of warmth in the house after a 12 hour shift and being able to wash in warm water so I stay respectable for work, what a splurge. There's no holidays, meals out or bling here, I am guilty of the pleasure of gas and electric and no bailiffs at the door for non payment of bills. Oh and I pay tax on my salary too.
Wondered when this thread would start having a dig at those on lower incomes for being feckless and lazy. Funny thing is, those who think people like me are like that have absolutely no issues using the services low income jobs provide.

BillHadersNewWife · 18/11/2019 07:17

Lily do you really believe that In a free society an individual can choose what they spend their money on and where they live and in an authoritarian on the state does this ??

I couldn't choose where I lived when I was on a low income in the UK.

Certainly not. And thousands of people can't. Some can't access education to the level needed to compete against those that can in a competitive job market either.

jade9390 · 18/11/2019 06:43

If they did not pay it, it would be included in their rent so would work out the same. As I get a reduction for single occupancy and people on welfare do not pay, landlords would rip people off, if it was included.

Lilyflower1 · 18/11/2019 06:17

“however the greediness of some people owning multiple houses while others have none is sickening.”

There are enough houses to go round in the country and some of them are dirt cheap but they are not all where people would choose to live. You are assuming that people are born with a right to be housed just where they please. In fact they can be but they have to pay to be where they choose. Someone with nothing would be given a dwelling for free by the state paid by taxing others but it might not be exactly where they chose. Those who work and pay tax have a greater chance of choosing where they live and this is perfectly fair as they need to be near where they work and pay taxes for others.

In a free society an individual can choose what they spend their money on and where they live and in an authoritarian on the state does this. It is not ‘sickening’ a person who has paid tax on their salary chooses to invest it in property rather than splurge it on holidays, meals out, pleasure and bling. It is, rather, prudent and sensible, and will keep them from needing the state’s help when they are old.

Where would you end with this philosophy? No one to have two cars? Or pairs of trousers? Or pants?

You need to study Communism under Comrade Stalin and see how joyous state control of property was. You would not be moaning that people were free to spend tax paid money how they chose. You would be complaining that your whole extended family were housed in a filthy, broken down flat in a hideous polluted area dreading a knock on the door by the secret police who would drag you away in the night, torture you and keep you in prison indefinitely without recourse to law.

I understand that people take the benefits of capitalism, truth and freedom, for granted, because many were too young to have lived through the hellhole the Socialists made of the country in the seventies. And in the seventies there were no houses or flats to rent as a rent controlled market made it too unprofitable for anyone except Rackman landlords to make any money.

I would say beware of what you wish for but better advice would be to extend your knowledge and understanding to make more informed choices and have more enlightened opinions.

SheilaBruce · 18/11/2019 06:14

Yes it's a tax based on the value of someone else's asset. But surely you can choose whether to live in a Band H London property or a Band A northern city property? You have an element of control over what you ultimately pay.

Assuming your "Council Tax is only 25% of revenue" mantra is correct, then maybe we should all be thankful that they don't decide to increase it to make it 30%, 40% or 50%. Someone has to pay and government will impose tax when/where it suits. Perhaps you could try refusing to pay, and see where it gets you.

I worked for an inner London borough that has seen its central funding decrease by about 50% since 2010. Council tax does pay for services that are absolutely essential for many residents. Housing, social work, care for the elderly, care for the vulnerable, education, fire brigades, policing, and yes BINS... councils fund the lot.

Council Tax in London also contributes to the GLA, so basically paying for some very swanky offices and some serious schmoozing.

It all adds up ya know.

BillHadersNewWife · 18/11/2019 05:01

SD I don't pay rates....I pay rent...because I'm a tenant. Look...I know nothing about economics but how is it that Australian rentals manage to be completely affordable and wages are decent?

How does Australia do it?

The Australian minimum wage is $19.49 per hour. I'm not particularly well qualified and have never earned less than 28 ph since coming here.

Kids earn the minimum wage...even as a retail assistant I was on 28 something an hour.

28 dollars is about 14 pounds.

I know some things here are more expensive...but somehow, it's easier by far to manage. Our rent is more or less what we paid 5 years ago in England for a house in a nice area with a garden.

But here, we have enough money to pay the bills and have some savings too.

UhareFouxisci · 18/11/2019 04:30

council tax is not a tax on property ownership. op wishes to assert that it is, and use that as a basis for arguing that non property owners shouldn't pay it.

unfortunately whilst everyone is entitled to their own opinion, no one is entitled to their own facts, and the fact is that the residents of each property are liable for the tax, or the owner if it is unoccupied.

now it might be interesting to introduce a progressive property ownership tax. one which had a low rate for the first property you own but higher and higher rates for each additional property owned. but I think it would be a nightmare to administer as it would be fairly easy to create an individual limited company to own each property in a portfolio. if that could be resolved then obviously all the big landlords would divest their holdings which would cause a massive house price crash so obviously if will never happen. however the greediness of some people owning multiple houses while others have none is sickening.

randomchatter · 18/11/2019 04:22

It's a local tax used by LAs to top up their government funding for local services.

I'm sure LAs publish annual reports showing income, where the money came from (local residents, local business, government) and a breakdown of expenditure - schools, libraries, LA staff and buildings, special events, donations, vanity projects and investments. Hmm

SD1978 · 18/11/2019 04:04

@BillHadersNewWife - but every year you pay rates which jump up regardless of property value- what's the difference?

randomchatter · 18/11/2019 03:46

Hefzi

That's the problem with collecting local taxes - It's always going to be unfair to someone.

The poll tax was scrapped because it was recognised as being unfair to a larger % of the population and 'penalised' poorer people !

dreichwinter · 18/11/2019 02:58

It is perfectly feasible Bill, my landlord pays the property tax in the USA.
But the rent on my house in the UK would need to go up if I had to cover this as a landlord.
It works either way but will always be built into costs.
The cost of renting will vary area to area, country to country so it isn't possible to compare directly.
My USA house rent is much more expensive than my UK house even though I don't pay any property taxes.

BingoLittlesUncle · 18/11/2019 02:43

Because if the landlords have to pay the council tax they will simply add it to the tenant's rent. The tenant paying it is simply cutting out the middleman.

CleansUpDragonPoo · 18/11/2019 02:34

@Hisdoeherbuck Sat 16-Nov-19 12:13:36
"Tax is theft, council tax should be scrapped. Police, bin collecting etc should become billed for services."

Streetlights too perhaps? But you'll need them to avoid tripping over all the stuff dumped by fly-tippers with your way of thinking!

BillHadersNewWife · 18/11/2019 02:19

Winter of course it isn't. I'm highlighting that it's reasonable and workable for landlords to pay rates or council tax.

Derbee · 18/11/2019 02:01

How old are you OP?

dreichwinter · 18/11/2019 01:58

I'm not sure moving to Oz is a viable alternative for everyone paying council tax!

BillHadersNewWife · 18/11/2019 01:44

Well considering a 3 bed house in a nice suburb with an enormous garden is the same as I was paying in a similar location in the UK but without the added council tax...I don't really care! Plus I earn twice what I did in the UK.

So there's that.

TooLateThePhalarope · 18/11/2019 01:20

BillHadersNewWife
Cherries you'd better inform the many thousands of tenants here in Australia that they're all "entitled" then! Because we don't pay the Australian version of council tax...the landlord, the owner of the house does!

Do you seriously think the Council tax element hasn't been factored into your rent?

Lanurk · 18/11/2019 00:52

Op you’re full of crap. Tenants use sewage, water, education, local services, refuse collection. Does the money fairy pay for these services? Actually take the time to go on your council website and it’ll have info on what their money goes on instead of opening your mouth and letting your belly rumble.

caringcarer · 18/11/2019 00:46

It is your bin being emptied op with rubbish you put in it. Why should your ll pay for this?

BillHadersNewWife · 18/11/2019 00:37

Cherries you'd better inform the many thousands of tenants here in Australia that they're all "entitled" then! Because we don't pay the Australian version of council tax...the landlord, the owner of the house does!

Maybe we should all avoid being "entitled" and pay it ourselves then? Hmm