Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do tenants have to pay council tax?

485 replies

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 10:01

It's a domestic property tax. But tenants don't own any property, so they're paying tax on something they don't own. They didn't use to have to pay rates, but they have to pay council tax. Why? NB council tax is not a tax for use of services so that argument doesn't wash. It is a tax where liability is created by the existence of a domestic property. Which tenants clearly do not own.

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 18/11/2019 18:22

(And the CA page undermines itself immediately by stating that it’s a property tax, then listing the ways that make it clear it’s a hybrid of personal and property taxation.)

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2019 18:20

It’s got fuck all to do with the valuation tribunal @JassyRadlett, they can give change a property’s band if it is incorrect and that may result in a refund of over paid council tax. Different from a resident wanting £3.50 back because their recycling was missed.

I’m not saying - and neither are they - that council tax is a service charge with refundable elements if the service is not delivered.

But is is factually incorrect to state that this is a pure property tax. Simply saying it over and over doesn’t make it true, and yes, the judicial appeal body for the issue has a tiny bit more credibility in ruling what form of taxation it is than you do.

SiliconHeaven · 18/11/2019 18:04

It’s got fuck all to do with the valuation tribunal @JassyRadlett, they can give change a property’s band if it is incorrect and that may result in a refund of over paid council tax. Different from a resident wanting £3.50 back because their recycling was missed.

SiliconHeaven · 18/11/2019 17:55

Council tax is a system of local taxation collected by local authorities. It is a tax on domestic property.
Source: www.citizensadvice.org.uk/housing/council-tax/council-tax/

randomchatter · 18/11/2019 16:19

BillHadersNewWife

'you must live in an awful area'

You'd think so wouldn't you! I've recently moved back to the town I grew up in so thought I'd feel 'at home' - Greater London and a 30 min LT commute to Central London so property prices and CT aren't cheap. Very different today of course but I find that there are Landlords and then there are LANDLORDS! Some care less for 'the community' than the tenants they moan about.

Often I think that buy to let should require a 70% + cash deposit and that, naturally, more REAL affordable homes /starter homes (private and council run) should be built across the country, so that there is real choice for everyone.

Landlords should be responsible for the upkeep of their properties as well as the communities they're in. If Landlords are based overseas or outside 'the community', they're less inclined to care about things like fly-tipping or the general aesthetics of the street or town.

It's often said that people don't have a right to buy or a choice in where we live but why does anyone have a right to buy to let on the cheap?

Patte · 18/11/2019 15:56

I don't think it really matters who pays it - if landlords did, it would just get included in a higher rent.

Surely though, the single person discount implies it's for use of local services rather than being a property tax?

Usernumbers1234 · 18/11/2019 15:38

When you buy a house in the UK you buy the land it sits on. That land is worth a whole lot more than the equivalent land in Australia. That’s how Australia manages to do it.

Usernumbers1234 · 18/11/2019 15:37

@BillHadersNewWife

Australia doesn’t have high property values because of basic economics.

Look at Australia on the map, then look at the population.
Then look at the UK, Then look at the population.

CleansUpDragonPoo · 18/11/2019 15:32

@UhareFouxisci Mon 18-Nov-19 14:43:41
"You are only able to make money on your spare property because there is another family out there who could have afforded their own home if prices hadn't been able to spiral out of control, but are renting instead, and now face a retirement of extreme poverty because their pensions will never stretch to cover their rent, as a direct consequence of you being able to make your retirement more comfortable in this way.

You'd probably not be significantly worse off if you had sold the spare property when it wasn't needed, and invested the money in growing industries helping the economy to thrive and getting a good return on investment, and so have a decent lump sum to help your sons onto the property ladder when the time came. And if the ownership of multiple properties was controlled as I outlined above, that lump sum for your sons would buy a lot more house too, so your whole family could benefit without having trodden on those more disadvantaged than you to get there.

So renting out a well-maintained property at below market rate which I saved for and bought by dint of hard work and going without is treading on those more disadvantaged? If I'd waited to invest I wouldn't be able to afford to buy either. And as for investing the money in growing industries helping the economy - like what growing industries exactly? Car manufacture? Steel? Royal Mail? Bitcoins? I would have lost money on all of those. But perhaps that's what's wanted, for everyone to be dragged down to the same level rather than trying to work your way up.

I'm not ashamed of finally being comfortable after many years of scrimping, and send best wishes to those trying to provide for themselves like I did. The rest of the 'she's got more than me it's not fair' brigade can get lost.

Zebulon2002 · 18/11/2019 15:02

If the Landlord paid it then he would only add it to the rent for you to pay in effect.

In theory it pays for the local services such as refuse, cleaning, police, maybe some transport

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2019 14:56

I think that owners should be completely liable for council tax. It's a nonsense that they pass this on to tenants.

Why is it nonsense, any more than it is that tenants have to pay for their own electricity, gas, water, contents insurance, TV licence, broadband etc.?

You could go even further and say that, as the landlord owns the kitchen cupboards and any built-in bedroom furniture, they should also be expected to fill them with food and clothes for you. After all, why should you be expected to buy food to put in somebody else's cupboards - just because you are the one who will be eating it all?

The landlord will pay for the buildings insurance, because that's protecting their asset. The landlord will pay for repairs to the fixtures and fittings of the building, because this is maintaining their asset and also continuing to provide in good working order that for which you are paying the rent as agreed. The landlord will pay for any mortgage on the property, because that's helping them to buy their asset. They won't pay your council tax for you, which pays for all of the local services that you as resident will/may be using, as that has nothing to do with the property as an asset and everything to do with the property as a home.

Would you be happy for the landlord to have a key to your home and pop in whenever they like? Of course, not, because it's your home and not theirs.

Some rental properties may have one or more of these included in the rental cost, but your rent will be higher to take account of this.

If you do want all of your living costs (other than food and clothing) taken care of for you and to just have to pay one single bill in return for it, you're perfectly at liberty to book permanently into a hotel. Just don't expect it to cost the same for a month there as it would cost to rent a house or flat.

dreichwinter · 18/11/2019 14:49

It is very simplistic to suggest that everyone renting wishes to buy a house but can't.
I am renting, I do not want to buy a house where I currently live.
I rent my house out to someone who currently doesn't want to own a house where my house is.
The housing market has always included renting and for a variety of reasons this can meet peoples needs.
Renting is my current first choice and I am grateful I can do this.

UhareFouxisci · 18/11/2019 14:43

@CleansUpDragonPoo well in 18th Century America there were some slave owners who treated their slaves well, didn't rape the women or sell off the children, ensured that their slaves were kept warm and well fed, and probably considered themselves good people. But being a more-ethical-than-most practitioner in a morally abhorrent system does not make the system less morally abhorrent. You are only able to make money on your spare property because there is another family out there who could have afforded their own home if prices hadn't been able to spiral out of control, but are renting instead, and now face a retirement of extreme poverty because their pensions will never stretch to cover their rent, as a direct consequence of you being able to make your retirement more comfortable in this way.

You'd probably not be significantly worse off if you had sold the spare property when it wasn't needed, and invested the money in growing industries helping the economy to thrive and getting a good return on investment, and so have a decent lump sum to help your sons onto the property ladder when the time came. And if the ownership of multiple properties was controlled as I outlined above, that lump sum for your sons would buy a lot more house too, so your whole family could benefit without having trodden on those more disadvantaged than you to get there.

A well-balanced economy does not allow people to make more money doing nothing but relying on a massive imbalance of supply and demand to inflate property prices, rather than putting that money to work in investments in real tangible goods and services being traded at a profit.

JassyRadlett · 18/11/2019 14:26

The OP is completely correct about the nature of council tax. I’m a manager in a local authority and I very often have to explain to complainants requesting a’refund’ of their council tax because their bin was missed that a tax is not a payment for an expected service but a government tax on property and therefore refunds are not possible.

Have you told the Valuation Tribunal Service that they’ve got it wrong?

I’m sure they’d be thrilled by your insight that it’s a pure property tax, rather than a personal/property hybrid based on the model of discounting....

BillHadersNewWife · 18/11/2019 13:52

Lilly But, in a free society, as we were, we had the OPPORTUNITY and liberty to work hard and aspire to our own personal goals. We were left alone to pursue happiness.

You say this....

But...do you REALLY think that everyone has the opportunities you had? No.

They don't.

And I suppose you now might say "Ah, but I grew up on a poor council estate...but I worked hard!"

Which still doesn't mean that all the other kids from low income families are less important or that they don't deserve some help or a push.

Not everyone from a lower socio economic background has the same ability to push forward.

Some people find it harder...for a variety of reasons. Issues at home, illness, disability.

Do you think they're less deserving of a stable, affordable home?

BillHadersNewWife · 18/11/2019 13:49

RandomChatter you must live in an awful area.

CleansUpDragonPoo · 18/11/2019 12:15

@UhareFouxisci Mon 18-Nov-19 04:30:43
"the greediness of some people owning multiple houses while others have none is sickening."

I scrimped and saved, went without and did a miserable job that allowed me to buy my own little flat. My OH did the same and when we met years later, married and moved into his bigger flat (widower with 2 DS), we kept mine and rented it out. Fast forward to retirement, having both worked for more than 30 years and paid all taxes and contributions, we each received a small monthly pension and a lump sum. We pooled our lump sums and bought another small flat. I'm one of those affected by the state pension age hike for women so don't get SP for a few more years, I rely on my tiny occupational pension and the rent from my flat to live on.

Both DS are working abroad so we rent out the flats until until their contract ends so they will have a place to live when they return to the Uk. We have had the same tenants for years and charge them under market rate as they look after the properties so well. We had it written into their leases that they will be given six months notice.

We think this is more than fair and a good way of providing for our very old age needs (the dreaded care home!) now we have retired. But hey, I suppose you have the right to your own opinion so go ahead, call me a greedy selfish landlord.

randomchatter · 18/11/2019 12:12

professornangnang Landlords rent their properties for a profit of course they'll pass on this tax to maintain their margins.

There are a lot of homes rented out on my street and I can always tell when someone on the street has moved out - When mattresses, furniture etc are dumped on the street! The LA charge additionally for collecting these large items.

Mumoflil1 · 18/11/2019 12:11

Doesn't make a difference. If the landlords became liable for council tax they'd only pass it on to tenants as in this unregulated market, they can literally charge whatever they want. If you don't like it, vote Labour!

professornangnang · 18/11/2019 11:53

I think that owners should be completely liable for council tax. It's a nonsense that they pass this on to tenants.

SiliconHeaven · 18/11/2019 11:50

The OP is completely correct about the nature of council tax. I’m a manager in a local authority and I very often have to explain to complainants requesting a’refund’ of their council tax because their bin was missed that a tax is not a payment for an expected service but a government tax on property and therefore refunds are not possible.
I don’t agree with the OP that the landlord should be liable, rents would only go up.

Lilyflower1 · 18/11/2019 11:00

"Lily do you really believe that In a free society an individual can choose what they spend their money on and where they live and in an authoritarian on the state does this ??"

No Billhaders, I don't think anyone can do anything they like in a free society. When I first started teaching I could not afford to live where I trained so my DH and I moved over a hundred miles north to be able to afford a place where we could work. But, in a free society, as we were, we had the OPPORTUNITY and liberty to work hard and aspire to our own personal goals. We were left alone to pursue happiness.

This would not be the case in an authoritarian state. And what's more, not only would we not be afforded the opportunity to live as we wished but any dissenting views we held would make us enemies of the state to be persecuted and destroyed. And the state in those sorts of tyrrannous societies is always capricious and vicious. You might think you were one of the 'trusties' whose views were pure and acceptable, but if a party official takes a fancy to your house (or daughter) you have no recourse in law to defend yourself from state violence.

Look at Soviet Russia, Mao's China, Iran, Venezuala, Cuba, Zimbabwe and so on. Whether a left wing or a right wing authoritarian society the method of ruthless enforcement always ensures the same result: misery, torture, rape and death.

Doodoobear · 18/11/2019 10:21

What annoys me is when people demand social housing of a specific type, such as a large house in the middle of London. If you need social housing then you should take that which is available and be grateful.

Well 'taking that which is available' is largely how social housing works. My SHA you bid on a property, you can bid on as many as you like but you will only get offered what you are eligible for and then only if someone else's need isn't greater than yours by a point system. You only get to turn down 3 and you're back to the back of the queue. Demanding will get you precisely nowhere.
And as for being grateful, well I'm certainly grateful that I have managed a full 2.5 years without having to move yet again, change DC school yet again, pay out over a grand in moving fees and bond yet again after an LL has decided to sell, but wants me to stay until the last minute so they get the rent, or refused to do essential repairs that weren't of my making, but then made the house unliveable putting myself and DD in danger, or the one decent LL I had that lost his wife and wanted to move to be with his family and gave me my bond back early so I could put it on another property and even physically helped me move and treated me like a human being rather than a profit margin. LLs like that do exist, but let's not pretend that the tenant is the one in the strongest position here. I moved 8 times in 14 years, none of which were my choice. The last time there was just nowhere that gave me a chance of getting DD to school, myself to work and that I could afford. I was sofa surfing while DD lived with my mother. I got offered a HA place after applying, it was one of several I bid on, the only one I was offered and I took it. I pay the rent by the way, I had to provide a financial statement to prove I could afford it from my income, which is ya know wages. I also needed to provide a lot of the things that are provided in private rented houses like carpets - SH isn't free, it may be cheaper, my rent is cheaper, but then I get less than when I private rented - I was paying to rent things like the fixtures and fittings too - they're not provided in SH, you get them yourself, so of course you'd pay less if you get less. You wouldn't expect to pay the same for a house with white goods, carpets, curtain poles, light fittings etc than one that was a bare shell with none of those things if you were buying.

322yellowcarnations · 18/11/2019 10:10

Op, you should perhaps consider buying a property and then you will have the asset upon which council tax is based and you can stop being so bitter. Incidentally, council property rent is subsidised.

randomchatter · 18/11/2019 09:20

Spot on UhareFouxisci.

We humans need shelter to survive - It's an anomaly that housing is considered an asset in the UK. Especially when it's illegal to set up a makeshift home in a cave or in the woods!

Swipe left for the next trending thread