Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do tenants have to pay council tax?

485 replies

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 10:01

It's a domestic property tax. But tenants don't own any property, so they're paying tax on something they don't own. They didn't use to have to pay rates, but they have to pay council tax. Why? NB council tax is not a tax for use of services so that argument doesn't wash. It is a tax where liability is created by the existence of a domestic property. Which tenants clearly do not own.

OP posts:
honeygirlz · 16/11/2019 11:30

Sorry but if I have to pay £1900 CT for my tiny mortgaged terrace then so should every other fucker, tenant and owner. (Obviously not meaning those who pay reduced CT due to disability etc).

longwayoff · 16/11/2019 11:30

You don't have an argument OP, your statements are absurd and ill informed. Try something else.

TheMidasTouch · 16/11/2019 11:26

You should have put voting buttons OP so that you could see at a glance how unreasonable you are seen to be.

scaryteacher · 16/11/2019 11:26

Having just returned from renting in Belgium, yes the l/l paid the Cadastral, but as tenants we had to pay for everything we paid for as l/ls in the UK. Thus we paid buildings insurance, boiler servicing, water softener servicing, chimney sweeping, gardening costs. There is no concept of fair wear and tear, and leaving a Belgian rental is worse than a military march out, and I've done both. There is also annual indexing of the rent. The tenant pays the utility bills as well, which are far more expensive there.

As for CTax not paying for services, in Belgium, we paid directly for our rubbish collection, as the wheelie bins were barcoded, and you got a bill every so often for the weight of what you'd put out. You also paid rent for the bins. For recycling, you paid for the recycling bags, although collection was free. In other Gemeentes, you paid for the rubbish bags, and couldn't use anything else. The large bags were €60 for 30 bags...plus the differing bags for plastics, plastics metals and cartons, and garden waste. It does add up.

SpamChaudFroid · 16/11/2019 11:22

OP, please would you be kind enough to link to any sources citing that council tax is divided in the way you say - 25% to LA and 75% - somewhere else. Illuminati?

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 11:20

@mumwon No violin small enough.

OP posts:
IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 16/11/2019 11:19

We should all pay more income tax instead and do away with this

In a ideal world that would work better but given so many don’t pay any income tax or claim more back in top up benefits it would be the same people paying again.

mumwon · 16/11/2019 11:19

please note I am not saying all tenants are like this - most are not. But...

mumwon · 16/11/2019 11:18

If tenant moves out & leaves house an unliveable pig sty but there is still a sink in it the ll will still have to pay council tax after one month - even though they might not be able to get into property to start clearing it because tenant has left their stuff in it (sore point, have you guessed?)

TriangularRatbag · 16/11/2019 11:18

The simple answer is because that's the law! Tax doesn't have to be fair or rational and it often isn't. (Although for the many reasons people have given, I personally think an occupancy tax is fair and rational.)

TheMidasTouch · 16/11/2019 11:17

*"People are taxed for residing in a dwelling, not for owning it and there are discounts for empty dwellings."
There are also, at individual councils' determination, enhanced council tax charges for empty dwellings. (e.g. I pay 200% of the charge while doing up an empty dwelling. Some councils charge, for example, 150%).

RunningNinja79 · 16/11/2019 11:15

Why is it such an issue who pays? I don't understand what the problem with tenants paying is Confused

As said previously by a number of posters, surely the its fairer if the tenants pay. Then there is that reduction if required (lone people, students etc).

I quite like having street lights, bins emptied and roads maintained. I like knowing that if something were to happen the police/fire brigade are able to attend. I like it that a gritter comes down the roads in bad weather so I can still get to work and not lose my job. I am a tennant and believe me council tax is one bill I'm happy to pay. It helps pays for my children to be educated in their state schools too. Why should my landlord pay for these services used by me? Why shouldn't I make a contribution to these services? After all I use them so surely I should pay a tax for the privilege?

mindproject · 16/11/2019 11:13

I disagree with council tax entirely. It's a very, very unfair tax. I think the system is too complicated. We should all pay more income tax instead and do away with this.

otterturk · 16/11/2019 11:12

Believe me, landlords are already milked to the point that owning a BTL property is barely worth it.

AJPTaylor · 16/11/2019 11:11

See poll tax riots.

lookatthebabypenguin · 16/11/2019 11:10

Ok, so how would you like your contribution to funding services in your local community to be calculated and charged?

Are you saying you would prefer income tax to be increased and councils to be fully funded centrally instead?

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 11:09

Yeah council tenants are funding everyone. Rent money going to government, council tax going to government. Everyone else is subsidised by them

OP posts:
TheMidasTouch · 16/11/2019 11:06

@ TheyMostlyComeOutAtNightMostly

'Education and police come out of centrally provided funds not council tax Midas - see link above.'
Thanks. Every day is an education. Smile
I was going by the leaflet the council send out with the bill which does state the percentages for each. Maybe it's a little ambiguous as to where they receive the money from.
I also note BBC's website states it includes local police services.

gamerwidow · 16/11/2019 11:05

small point if you are a council tenant you pay council tax so stop blaming LL
This is a good point, all renters private and state pay council tax at the same rate.

jay55 · 16/11/2019 11:04

Landlords have to pay it, if they have a HMO rented by the room. And students don't have to pay, but still use services. It is an inconsistent tax.

gamerwidow · 16/11/2019 11:03

As others have said it's not a properties tax, it's a services tax.
People on HB usually get council tax benefit too so they don't pay the full rate. My mum for example only pays about £30/month of her £90 council tax because she is living on a state pension.

They do need to redo the banding for council tax though imo because some people are paying over the odds and v.v.

mumwon · 16/11/2019 11:03

small point if you are a council tenant you pay council tax so stop blaming LL & as stated by pp the tenant is using services - service that you as a tenant use & make your life better -the LL does not provide them. When you live in shared accommodation the rent is increased to pay for them & if the LL would include the figure within the rent. Consider this: with council tax which you pay as a tenant you can get a reduction if you live by yourself, you are a student & are on certain benefits. If your land lord charged used enough to pay for his council tax your rent would not be reduced. But you know that - don't you?

Berthatydfil · 16/11/2019 11:02

The tax when originally introduced was a mix of personal and property.
Hence the link to property values and also it’s based on 2 people living there - which is why you get the 25% single person discount (50% of 50%).
Also that’s why initially you would get 50% empty property relief.
The person living in the property benefits from the services provided so is generally the person liable to pay.

ChristmasFluff · 16/11/2019 11:02

OP, you are wrong in your assertion that it is a property tax - just take a look at the Wikipedia page en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Council_Tax#The_nature_of_the_Council_Tax

The Valuation Tribunal Service has cleared up many previous doubts regarding the exact nature of Council Tax and states that:

“The tax is a mix of a property tax and a personal tax. Generally, where two or more persons reside in a dwelling the full tax is payable. If one person resides in the dwelling then 75% is payable. An empty dwelling attracts only a 50% charge unless the billing authority has made a determination otherwise."

People are taxed for residing in a dwelling, not for owning it and there are discounts for empty dwellings.

minniemoll · 16/11/2019 11:02

I was renting in 1989/90, when the community charge came in. Our rent went down as the landlord no longer had to pay rates out of it, and it was up to us to pay the CC. So of course tenants paid rates - just not directly to the council!

Do you really think that if landlords had to pay council tax, they wouldn't pass the cost straight on to the tenants? You must have a very rosy view of landlords....