Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do tenants have to pay council tax?

485 replies

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 10:01

It's a domestic property tax. But tenants don't own any property, so they're paying tax on something they don't own. They didn't use to have to pay rates, but they have to pay council tax. Why? NB council tax is not a tax for use of services so that argument doesn't wash. It is a tax where liability is created by the existence of a domestic property. Which tenants clearly do not own.

OP posts:
geordiejock · 16/11/2019 13:13

Council tenants always paid rates, just not in one big payment, it wasn't part of the rent, it was added on top of the rent. I have paid rates and council tax as both a council tenant and a home owner. If tenants didn't pay council tax but the owners did they would just bump the rents up even more.

Bluerussian · 16/11/2019 13:12

I've never before heard anyone suggest that they shouldn't pay council tax because they don't own a property they live in. In days gone by I believe rents could be 'inclusive', ie cover the council tax or rates as it used to be, rents were higher because of that, but certainly I've not heard of that in recent times.

I rented when I was younger and never thought twice about paying council tax, neither did anyone else. Not my landlord's business, they didn't live there. Landlord's responsibility was maintaining the property, fixing anything that went wrong.

Council tax pays for: planning, transport, highways, police, fire, libraries, leisure and recreation, rubbish collection and disposal, environmental health and trading standards - maybe more. A renter has all that, same as an owner occupier and we all have to pay for those services.

MsRomanoff · 16/11/2019 13:12

Road maintenance-car tax

Road lights are just for car drivers.

Road tax is a tax. So why is that tax ok?

steff13 · 16/11/2019 13:09

There's no point in a library that charges a fee, that would essentially be a bookstore.

People who own cars are not the only ones who benefit from roads; buses, bikes, etc., also benefit.

Back to the police; what if someone has a crime committed against them and they can't afford to pay? They just don't report it? Potentially putting other people in danger is the person isn't caught.

The same with the fire department; if my house catches fire and I can't afford to pay the fire department's bill, do I just let it burn down?

weymouthswanderingmermaid · 16/11/2019 13:08

Well this is a bizarre thread Confused

Alsohuman · 16/11/2019 13:06

It’s to pay for the council services you use and the police. It’s laid out how it’s spent on the leaflet that comes with your council tax bill.

Hisdoeherbuck · 16/11/2019 13:04

How would billing for something like police or teachers or road maintenance work?

Schools would bill parents per term,
Road maintenance-car tax
Library’s would charge

it would weed out the unimportant services. If a service didn’t get used, it wouldn’t get funded

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 13:02

@GoodGriefSunshine I agree that this is one of the more bizarre glitches in the system. It can also lead to all sorts of problems for tenants. Years ago i was a tenant in a shared house, under an assured shorthold so not an HMO, so council tax liability rested on the tenants. But there had been over two years various people coming and going, some of them working, some on benefits, some students, all there perfectly legally and signed in/off the tenancy agreement with no irregularities but the council tax situation was utterly horrendous due to differences in liability within the household which also shifted every six months. By the time I got there, nobody knew who the fuck should be paying anything, there were penalties, arrears and judgements all over the place, the entire thing was a mess. I should imagine this is fairly common.

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 16/11/2019 13:01

It sounds as if you won’t be content until your ll goes bankrupt and the bank gives you the house you rent. Idk where you think this free money comes from.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 16/11/2019 13:01

Council tax bands however are unfair in my opinion. A single person in a mansion utilises less council services than a house share of 4 adults in a small property.

The supposed idea is that people should pay for the services that are provided (whether they will use them or not) according to their means - and this is crudely judged with reference to where they live. It is assumed that a single person in the position to be able to own/pay a mortgage for/pay rent for a mansion will be much better off than four adults who 'have to' share a small place between them.

In practice, it takes no account of groups such as the elderly, who bought a reasonably-priced family house several decades ago, are now widowed, children all grown up and left and whose house happens to have shot up in value because of crazy property inflation.

It's the same blunt approach as the idea that, the bigger your car (and therefore its emissions), the richer you are. Never mind that you might be very tall, have a big family, have personal/medical needs which require you to transport bulky equipment etc.

Similarly, there are people who deliberately choose to live in modest houses, maybe shared with several others, because they prefer to spend money on expensive holidays, clothes, lifestyles etc. Entirely their choice, but they get to pay less than they could probably afford, just because they don't prioritise a big house in their spending of what might be substantial means/earnings.

honeygirlz · 16/11/2019 12:56

Look, if it's just about "paying for services", which it's not, because taxpayers aren't purchasers, why don't students pay it? They certainly use services, especially when they all fly tip at the end of their tenancy.

Because most students are either living at home or OOO without an income. This is economics 101.

MsRomanoff · 16/11/2019 12:56

because taxpayers aren't purchasers

What?

HyacynthBucket · 16/11/2019 12:55

It is a tax that pays for local services that everyone uses, like waste collection. It is only fair that those who use the service pay the local tax. It maybe levied on property values (unfairly I believe) but it is to pay for services used. At present the system is very unfair to some - eg. a single, often older person paying the same as a similar house next door with eight people in it.(though single occupants do qualify for a 25% discount).

honeygirlz · 16/11/2019 12:55

£1100pm

honeygirlz · 16/11/2019 12:54

I mean you are already paying their mortgage plus extra usually, so why do renters also have to pay their tax too?.

I’m not a LL, but this is too simplistic. First and foremost a tenant pays to live in the rented property, not to pay the LL’s mortgage. Sorry to state the obvious.

My ex LL bought a 1 bed flat and we then proceeded to pay him £1100 to live there. We paid him tens of thousands over the course of the tenancy so I do get the annoyance that you feel like you’re contributing to someone else’s mortgage.

MsRomanoff · 16/11/2019 12:54

Yes I would be paying for the service if and when I used it.

So how would that work? How do you pay for road lighting?

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 12:53

@longwayoff local services are funded by four revenue tranches, with council tax being the smallest element.

Look, if it's just about "paying for services", which it's not, because taxpayers aren't purchasers, why don't students pay it? They certainly use services, especially when they all fly tip at the end of their tenancy.

OP posts:
steff13 · 16/11/2019 12:53

How would billing for something like police or teachers or road maintenance work?

If I got mugged and called the police, would I be charged for them to come out and take a statement? If the mugger was armed would there be an additional fee? What if they never catch him, do I still have to pay? They could argue that they still used resources, but I could rebut how/what resources were used and refuse to pay.

GoodGriefSunshine · 16/11/2019 12:52

You want to know something really freaking weird. Students don't have to pay council tax. But if you as a non student rents with students YOU will be liable for the entire council tax unless you live in a house of multiple occupancy. So if you are all sharing a house not as a HofMO the one non student cops the lot.

Hisdoeherbuck · 16/11/2019 12:51

@Dashel other countries I have lived in things were billed for, when my car caught fire I got a £500 bill from the fire department.

Hisdoeherbuck · 16/11/2019 12:48

So you would be happier paying for it, in a different way?

Yes I would be paying for the service if and when I used it.

longwayoff · 16/11/2019 12:45

@Goodnightseamer, so what are the nefarious councils spending your cash on if not on services? Where's it going?

DuckWillow · 16/11/2019 12:43

Agreeing with everyone saying it pays for services.

I rent from a housing association. I don't expect them to pay for refuse collection, police and social care etc.

I pay that with council tax and I get a reasonable service for it.

BGD2012 · 16/11/2019 12:43

The council will get funding from central government to help provide social care services which are astronomical.

ifeellikeanidiot · 16/11/2019 12:41

@Cloverbeauty what a nonsensical post. Local councillors dont get paid Hmm

OP- moaning about having to pay tax is never a good look.