Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do tenants have to pay council tax?

485 replies

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 10:01

It's a domestic property tax. But tenants don't own any property, so they're paying tax on something they don't own. They didn't use to have to pay rates, but they have to pay council tax. Why? NB council tax is not a tax for use of services so that argument doesn't wash. It is a tax where liability is created by the existence of a domestic property. Which tenants clearly do not own.

OP posts:
TriangularRatbag · 16/11/2019 14:14

I've lost track of what you're ranting about, Goodnight! But as you seem to accept that any rationalisation of tax is just a superficial explanation, and that the state just needs to raise money as best it can to pay for things that need paying for, surely there's nothing more to rant about. Just pay the bloody tax and move on!

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 14:07

The "payment for using local services" argument might just work if said services were wholly funded by council tax. But they're not. The vast majority of the money spent by local authorities comes from elsewhere.

OP posts:
Bluerussian · 16/11/2019 14:07

OK op, just tell your landlord you're not prepared to pay council tax and he/she will add it to your rent every month. If you're living alone you'll get single person's allowance.

There are areas where council tax is high and other areas where it isn't so bad. You have the choice to live somewhere cheaper if you can't afford anything more but most people like to live somewhere decent.

I'm happy with how my council tax is used.

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 14:04

It really isn't.

OP posts:
nocoolnamesleft · 16/11/2019 14:02

It's a tax on using local services. Which are used by the person living in the property.

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 14:01

Christ, people really do have short memories. Also will swallow whatever they are told.

For the last time, taxpayers are not purchasers. Taxes don't buy you anything, whether services or roads. You therefore aren't "paying for" council services through council tax, the vast majority of which are funded by other public revenue streams anyway.

Historically - and I mean, for centuries, until thirty years ago - local domestic taxation was levied purely on property ownership. As such the amount was based on the value of the property.

Then in 1988 this was converted to a flat per person liability which, following widescale refusal and a degree of civil protest, was again converted back to a domestic property tax which retained an element of personal liability, which is the bit that doesn't make sense, in that the amount is set based on the value of another person's asset.

Rates were never about payment in return for access to local services. Council tax isn't now, effectively, because those services are largely funded through other means. But people are told that they're "paying" for services, even though they're not, and thus the personal element is justified, and I'm honestly amazed at how many on this thread are trotting out such inaccurate justifications.

OP posts:
Witchend · 16/11/2019 13:53

If landlords had to pay, then they'd just raise the rent accordingly. They set the rent, so there's nothing to stop them doing that.
You'll pay exactly the same, so the whole thought is pointless.

Iggly · 16/11/2019 13:52

The alternative to council tax is to increase income taxes and then allocate to local authorities.

Remove council tax altogether- the amount we pay doesn’t go directly to the local authorities, it goes into central government who then share it back out (well they’ve cut the amount they share out massively).

However governments are scared to change council tax after what happened with the poll tax.

JudgeRindersMinder · 16/11/2019 13:52

I don’t think I’ve ever seen such a wilfully ignorant post!
OP if your beef isn’t with landlords, is it with property owners in general?

You come across as having a big chip on your shoulder about property owners. Yes I’m a (mortgaged)property owner, and also a landlord of an un mortgaged property. I pay my way in life. I’m in a relatively comfortable position in life, but my situation is such because of decisions I made from the age of about 12, and I will not apologise for it.
Just spit out your issue

MsRomanoff · 16/11/2019 13:51

peachesforfree

And stamp duty and other property taxes AND capital gains as well.

peachesforfree · 16/11/2019 13:50

So the landlord should pay the council tax where they live (for services they use) and then also for all the services used by all their tenants too?!

steff13 · 16/11/2019 13:45

Maybe wheelchair ramps could be pay per use, like toll roads; put in some coins, the arm goes up, you use the ramp. 😒

museumum · 16/11/2019 13:44

It’s not a tax on owning a property, it’s a tax on living in it. And the council certainly does use the money to collect the bins and grit the roads and maintain the street lighting etc etc which all benefit the residents not absent owners.

HuntingCuns · 16/11/2019 13:43

What a batshit thread.

OP, just tell the Council you don't want to have a rubbish collection. If your house catches fire, you don't want the fire brigade to bother (after all, it's not your house, so why should you worry?) If you're burgled, you don't need the police as you can catch your own criminals, thanks very much. Then you will have no reason to pay your council tax bill at all.

MsRomanoff · 16/11/2019 13:42

Also are street lights really needed?
Yes

Hisdoeherbuck · 16/11/2019 13:41

Suspect you are FMOTL no idea what that means.

Also are street lights really needed?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 16/11/2019 13:35

it would weed out the unimportant services. If a service didn’t get used, it wouldn’t get funded

Just because the vast majority of people in society are fortunate enough not to need a service does not render it unimportant to those who do need it. Would you also say that wheelchair access ramps to public buildings are unimportant because the majority of people are lucky enough not to have to rely on them?

MsRomanoff · 16/11/2019 13:22

There’s no such thing as road tax, it’s vehicle tax.

I know that. I was quoting the poster who says tax is theft but then talks about road tax. I asked why that type of tax would be ok.

MsRomanoff · 16/11/2019 13:21

It’s not, it should be replaced with toll roads

You said car tax

Again, street lights aren't just for cars. They are mainly for pedestrians. So Toll paths?

If someone doesnt feel safe walking around at night, but cant afford to contribute, then they are on a curfew? Do people who pay get given an idea to prove they paid?

As for the police, not sure if the victim or offender should pay, they should probably share the cost.

If the victim cant afford to pay? Or the offender cant? What happens, someone is mugged and wants to call the police, they have to track down the offender and get their promise to pay?

Is a shared service. For which we all pay. Your systems would really screw over the poorest people.

Suspect you are FMOTL, because everyone knows they havent got a clue either

Alsohuman · 16/11/2019 13:19

Road tax is a tax. So why is that tax ok?

There’s no such thing as road tax, it’s vehicle tax.

PurpleFlower1983 · 16/11/2019 13:17

It’s services, police, fire, bins...do tenants not use these?

laughingnow · 16/11/2019 13:17

You sound angry and ill-informed and GOADY

Hisdoeherbuck · 16/11/2019 13:16

Road tax is a tax. So why is that tax ok?
It’s not, it should be replaced with toll roads.

The bills for fire would end up being covered by insurance,

As for the police, not sure if the victim or offender should pay, they should probably share the cost.

Clearnightsky · 16/11/2019 13:14

It’s not property tax!

It’s for council services for the people living in the property.

That is why.

If no one lives there you have a totally different rate.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 16/11/2019 13:13

Surely nobody believes that council-provided services don't need to be paid for?

Maybe we could keep the existing scheme whereby people who own/mortgage their own homes continue to pay council tax, so the costs among the home-owning community are spread and economies of scale can be had (how much would it cost if each house/street had to buy their own bin lorry?)

Meanwhile, the people who, as a demographic, consume the same services and live very similar lives as the homeowners, but just happen not to be in a position to own/mortgage the house they live in could be made to pay for their services separately.

They wouldn't have to pay towards schools if they have no children, towards the fire brigade if they don't ever call them out or for social/residential care if they're lucky enough not to need it - but if they do subsequently find themselves needing an extremely expensive service then, instead of paying a monthly contribution like the homeowners, they could simply be landed with a bill for £100K+ which they would have to foot entirely by themselves - or otherwise have to do without it.

This scheme could really work well in communities and punish those people who, although often working very hard, can't manage to get a foot on the property ladder - make them properly feel like the second-class citizens they should be arbitrarily treated as. We would need to find a name for it, though. How about 'Apartheid'....