Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do tenants have to pay council tax?

485 replies

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 10:01

It's a domestic property tax. But tenants don't own any property, so they're paying tax on something they don't own. They didn't use to have to pay rates, but they have to pay council tax. Why? NB council tax is not a tax for use of services so that argument doesn't wash. It is a tax where liability is created by the existence of a domestic property. Which tenants clearly do not own.

OP posts:
weymouthswanderingmermaid · 16/11/2019 14:58

@Goodnightseamer OP what do you mean that tax payers aren't purchasers?

Elmo230885 · 16/11/2019 14:53

Would you feel better OP if it had a different name... Such as services tax? Council subsidiary payment? Personal usage tax?
This is a very long thread and from what I can take from it you are arguing with the definitions of the words, taking them too literal. The 'tax' is a contribution to services not a purchase of the services.

JavaQ · 16/11/2019 14:52

It is a tax raised in a local area for use in that local area....the area YOU are living in. So suck it up, or, if you feel you are not getting the benefit complain to YOUR local council.

SpamChaudFroid · 16/11/2019 14:46

Whatever you do OP, don't buy a second property! The 5% stamp duty would have you fainting in the aisles.

EggysMom · 16/11/2019 14:46

why don't students pay it? They certainly use services, especially when they all fly tip at the end of their tenancy.

Generalisation much? I'm out.

DontCallMeShitley · 16/11/2019 14:44

Street lights are not just for car drivers, they are to help muggers find a victim, or to help you find your way along the uneven paving in the night time. The paving that the council can only afford to repair when they have their budget for the year.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 16/11/2019 14:42

For the last time, taxpayers are not purchasers. Taxes don't buy you anything, whether services or roads. You therefore aren't "paying for" council services through council tax, the vast majority of which are funded by other public revenue streams anyway.

So what are those other public revenue streams that do purchase services on behalf of everybody if they aren't taxes?

people without assets are paying more tax.

Who says that taxes are only levied on assets? Income tax isn't as people on PAYE have to pay tax on their monthly earnings before they even see the remainder of their monthly income (most or all of which still won't become an appreciating asset). VAT isn't levied on assets. NI is another form of tax and that isn't levied on assets.

If you believe that non-homeowners shouldn't have to pay towards having their personal/family waste taken away, their children educated and the local roads that they travel on repaired, you might as well say that they shouldn't have to pay the hairdresser for a haircut or IKEA for a bookcase or Tesco for their food.

Yes, rents can be very expensive and I completely understand how infuriating it is to be paying MORE each month in 'dead money' than you would for a monthly mortgage payment towards actually owning your own property, if only you could get a deposit and a mortgage - but that's just how life is, sadly.

Just because you don't own a house doesn't mean that those who do own their own homes (or are paying mortgages towards them) should pick up the bill for everybody's daily living costs. That's kind of infantilising towards renters to suggest that they should.

SafetyAdvice0FeedWhenAgitated · 16/11/2019 14:41

This threat is awesome Grin

DontCallMeShitley · 16/11/2019 14:38

It replaced the 'Rates' and covers things you use. Without it you would still have to pay for a household waste collection and recycling, or take it to the dump yourself. Street lighting, you must use that surely. Street bins, Dog waste bins, grass verges, green spaces, sports facilities, public swimming baths.
Look at what is provided by paying it and work out what you don't use, then ask the landlord to pay the rest.

Do you pay the water rates? I have lived in various places, some included it and some didn't but I still used the water, not the landlord.

FFSFFSFFS · 16/11/2019 14:36

Jesus wept. Are you writing a first year politics essay?

I've got bad news for you. You're not going to be acing your course.

Wallywobbles · 16/11/2019 14:36

In France the person living in the property on 1 Jan is liable for the year. This tax is collected nationally. There are also local/village taxes for a different layer of services.

We pay/paid a separate tax for owning a property. The logic being if you are rich enough to own a house you are rich enough to pay an extra tax.

MsRomanoff · 16/11/2019 14:35

I'm saying it doesn't fund everything, so you're not "paying for" services, plus taxes are taxes, not purchase monies.

It's to pay towards it.

Beveren · 16/11/2019 14:32

Your premise seems to be that tenants didn't pay rates but, as people have pointed out, they did.

This seems an utterly pointless rant anyway. If landlords rather than tenants paid rates, it would simply be added on to the rent so it would make zero difference.

alig99 · 16/11/2019 14:31

Can’t understand where you got from the notion council tax not being for services, of course it is, how do you think the council funds libraries, schools, parking wardens, road sweeping/bin collection. If councils changed from taxing properties in their area to taxing people who live in the area, renters would still have to pay.

couchparsnip · 16/11/2019 14:29

One of the other places the council get funding are business rates. A tax based on occupation. The vast majority of businesses rent their properties so should they not pay either? Where would the councils get their funding??

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 14:25

So you rather all council tax goes to fund everything.

No. I'm saying it doesn't fund everything, so you're not "paying for" services, plus taxes are taxes, not purchase monies.

OP posts:
Wonkybanana · 16/11/2019 14:24

For the last time, taxpayers are not purchasers. Taxes don't buy you anything, whether services or roads. You therefore aren't "paying for" council services through council tax, the vast majority of which are funded by other public revenue streams anyway.

Nurse...…!

TriangularRatbag · 16/11/2019 14:23

I mean, everyone is paying more tax than under the rates system, but people without assets are paying more again.

And?? Grin

MsRomanoff · 16/11/2019 14:22

The "payment for using local services" argumentmightjust work if said services were wholly funded by council tax. But they're not. The vast majority of the money spent by local authorities comes from elsewhere.

So it's only ok if it funds all of it.

So you rather all council tax goes to fund everything.

How does that impact your original point?

BlouseAndSkirt · 16/11/2019 14:21

Travellers on council and private Traveller sites pay rent, council tax and for services (water , electricity etc).

Goodnightseamer · 16/11/2019 14:20

Ok. The introduction of personal flat liability through Community Charge was a regressive step the effects of which remain in council tax liability now. Basically, people without assets are paying more tax. I mean, everyone is paying more tax than under the rates system, but people without assets are paying more again. But because councils send out pie charts "showing where your money goes" that's ok, apparently.

OP posts:
underneaththeash · 16/11/2019 14:20

OP it does pay TOWARDS services provided by the council - which tenants use, not landlords.

BlouseAndSkirt · 16/11/2019 14:19

But people are told that they're "paying" for services, even though they're not, and thus the personal element is justified, and I'm honestly amazed at how many on this thread are trotting out such inaccurate justifications

But we all know services need to be paid for.

Council Tax is weirdly administered, true, but am not sure why owner occupiers should pay towards the council infrastructure and people who rent should not?

Drabarni · 16/11/2019 14:17

Travellers don't own the campsite they live on, but they pay council tax the same as you.
Who knows what else LA's do with the money but it pays for services.
We all have to pay
HTH

FFSFFSFFS · 16/11/2019 14:14

But are you disagreeing that they're part funded by council tax? What are you saying that council tax is spent on?