Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Single parent wants to change career into medicine, but has no support.

188 replies

Puzzledbyart · 10/11/2019 10:46

Just out of interest. Let's say we have two primary aged school children (on the younger side of primary). Is it feasible for their single parent to go through the medical school (with a foundation year, they are in 40s, so long out of school), whilst retaining 100% custody of the children? There is no family help nearby, and no substantial savings to pay for the childcare either. Is it realistic at all?

OP posts:
CherryPavlova · 10/11/2019 13:49

Are you serious? If its a childhood dream, how did they get to forty before thinking about it? If it was beneficial to the children then study before breeding rather than prejudice them for selfish daydreaming.

It’s about as un family friendly as imaginable. The military is more family friendly. Medical school is about manageable but the foundation programme isn’t. You’d work very long shifts, including nights for long stretches without a break. You are not able to choose your place of work - you can apply to deaneries but they can be vast. Even then it’s selection on a points basis so unless you are high up the rankings your choice becomes more limited. So apply to South Thames and you might get a year in London and a year in Margate. Not ideal for parents.

fedup21 · 10/11/2019 13:48

That's what is says in the brochures I've seen. Family friendly, fully flexible working, accommodating personal circumstances fully.

Do you have a link?

IWorkAtTheCheescakeFactory · 10/11/2019 13:44

I don't need your approval.

Grin I wasn’t offering any! I asked a question about the current impact on your DC. As you seemed so keen to point out the future (not guaranteed) benefit to them- I thought maybe you were choosing to ignore any current negative impact on them. Maybe you’re not. Maybe there isn’t one. I was just asking the question.

BanginChoons · 10/11/2019 13:41

What about their present?

They cope well. I do everything I can to maximise time with them and minimise upheaval. I'm doing this for them and with them not in spite of them. It means I will be able to buy us a home they can always come home to, save money to buy them a car when they are older, and help them pay to learn to drive it, I can put he heating on in winter and know I will be able to pay for it.

The other option was minimum wage job, no stability, always topped up with benefit, no car in a rural area, always saying no to things, school trips, dance classes, days out.

I've made the choice which is best for us. I don't need your approval.

Puzzledbyart · 10/11/2019 13:41

Are you for real?
That's what is says in the brochures I've seen. Family friendly, fully flexible working, accommodating personal circumstances fully.

OP posts:
IdiotInDisguise · 10/11/2019 13:40

There is no guarantee that she will end up studying medicine just by joining a Foundation course. She still needs to compete against thousands of possibly better qualified applicants.

I would say however that that Foundation year can open a lot of other possibilities that may be easier to manage a single mum with no support.

TheABC · 10/11/2019 13:39

OP, he's not going to get residency. He might get increased contact time, but dragging kids away from their resident caregiver, school and surroundings is not in their best interests.

Focus on it from the perspective of the children's welfare. And give thanks you do not have to support him through this madness. My sister did this (no dependents) and it was insane. My guess is that he will struggle just to keep up with the academic requirements. A lot of students never make it as far as placement.

Hearhoovesthinkzebras · 10/11/2019 13:39

Are parents not allowed to choose family friendly shifts?

Are you for real?

Rosere · 10/11/2019 13:32

@Puzzledbyart we lost 4 coats in one week and a pair of football boots... I do not belong to even a single parents WhatsApp and I've no intention of it. That does not make you a bad parent. It makes you a parent.

IWorkAtTheCheescakeFactory · 10/11/2019 13:31

actually my studying is greatly beneficial to my children's future.

What about their present?

TheMouldNeverBotheredMeAnyway · 10/11/2019 13:30

Once medical school is finished he will be a junior doctor and that would be v difficult with no support as a single parent. I'd point out that it would be very challenging to be a single parent without family childcare in this situation, will the kids have the upheaval of having to move again?

When I applied for F1 and F2 jobs 10 years ago, those with school age children were automatically granted their deanery of choice - but deaneries are big. One covered Kent Surrey and Sussex, one North West England, Wales and Scotland were one deanery each. You then had to competitively apply for jobs in that large region. Maybe it has changed since.

Shifts as a junior doctor are the norm and as you change job every 3-6 months it would be hard to plan childcare. For some jobs only a live in nanny or au pair could work as overnights. So you are working in paediatrics for 4 months which involves working 8-8 often and occasional nights and weekends, then switch to A&E which has as many weekend shifts as weekdays and fairly frequent nights, then you switch to pathology which is 9-5 and you only get the basic unbanded salary and are struggling to afford the expensive childcare arrangements you set up for your previous rotation (typically banding for unsocial hours is 50% of your basic salary on top).

Then you apply for speciality training which is competitive so he may end up moving region again after the first two years.

Rosere · 10/11/2019 13:30

Apologies, went back and read the middle bits.... Sounds all a bit mad If he thinks he will have more spare time studying medicine????

chopc · 10/11/2019 13:29

Trust me the sacrifice is not worth it.

Puzzledbyart · 10/11/2019 13:28

Well that's why I did not want to mention the whole ex/ custody dynamic. I appreciate that the audience is usually sympathetic to the topic starter, but I honestly wanted some independent thoughts.
There are parenting failures on my side, sure. I am working full-time (more than full time in reality) in a professional job. There are forgotten PE kits, overdue dentist appointments, missed sports days, I do not volunteer as a parent help at school, three thousand jumpers were lost since September, there were instances when I was stuck on a broken train and late for more than an hour for collection. Put together as a neat court pack, it does paint me as quite a neglectful parent. Which maybe I am.

OP posts:
Rosere · 10/11/2019 13:25

Anyone getting into healthcare especially nursing or medicine has to go in with their eyes open to the shifts that are expected of them. Especially in the foundation years there will be nights, there will be weekends, there is no wandering off from a cardiac arrest because its 5pm. And there are no exceptions for those with families. And there shouldn't be.

Further down the line there are roles that are more family friendly but they involve rotations and extra study, so to become a GP for instance you're looking at about 10 years training from entering medical school.
Lots of people do medicine and nursing in later life and manage fine, but it is a massive commitment for you and your family.
An AHP course with post graduate entry might be a better option?

yorkshirecountrylass · 10/11/2019 13:20

OP, it may be worth asking him to explain the depth of detail to his plans to the Court and let them make up their own minds that he is utterly deluded. Key questions I would be asking, and apologies because I'm making an assumption based on what you've said about him doing the pre-entry year.

  1. How far into the pre-entry year is he.
  2. What percentage of those on pre-entry get an offer to study medicine at the attached University
  3. How sure is he that he will be in that percentage and what is this based on? E.g is he getting top marks out of the class for all assessments? Not just his assumption but backed up by fact.
  4. Has he got a guaranteed/close to guaranteed offer in writing? If not, when will he have? (If ever!)
  5. Is this offer (if he has one) for the specific hospital and shifts he needs? If not, which hospital(s) and shift(s) does it cover?
  6. Does he have it written in the contract that he doesn't have to do nights/weekends?
  7. What are his firm plans for school holidays, nights, weekends that he can't avoid?
  8. What are his firm plans for emergency cover - either an unwell child or if he is caught late at hospital.
  9. Have the Uni given him a guarantee that these favourable conditions will continue in his CMT/Foundation years as a junior doctor (they won't have!!)

Hope this helps

fedup21 · 10/11/2019 13:18

What are your own working/studying hours like?

Happygoldfinch · 10/11/2019 13:18

I think it might be the most selfish thing they could do. It might well be their dream, but they have responsibilities which have to come first. Get them to read some anatomy and physiology texts, to design a research model quantifying the effect of amino acids on something and such forth, to read abstracts available online (full research usually has to have a subscription) and that might wake them up a bit if the thought of their lonely children doesn't.

BanginChoons · 10/11/2019 13:18

Meanwhile, the child pays the price.
Thanks for that.. actually my studying is greatly beneficial to my children's future.

MedSchoolRat · 10/11/2019 13:18

Sounds like he's just messing with you, OP.
Else I want to ask if he has always been a fantasist.
I don't think I would engage very much. Don't dance to his tune.

Getting Foundation places is tough! They are especially meant for kids who went to lousy schools where no one or almost no one got amazing grades.
Unless you're leaving out details of your own huge parental failings, I should think there are at least a dozen reasons why you can convince a court that it's not in the children's best interest for him to get 100% custody.

TheMouldNeverBotheredMeAnyway · 10/11/2019 13:16

It seems unlikely the mediator would suggest the children move to a different part of the country, with a parent they've had limited contact with to date, just because he says he will have more free time than you.

When I graduated in medicine around 10 years ago I was scheduled for teaching or other activities approx 9-5 each day, and weekends and nights were unusual as a student. Summer holidays I had completely free, other holidays we had some work/ revision taking less than half the holiday. So one workable option would be that he have more contact in school holidays.

The shorter graduate courses though were generally all year round without the long summer break.

As a junior doctor the rota was challenging, lots of long days/ nights/ weekends, and hard to leave on time.

YouJustDoYou · 10/11/2019 13:08

*doable for those without

YouJustDoYou · 10/11/2019 13:07

It's doable for those with children. Those with children need serious family back up - the hours are long, brutal, and last for years. Meanwhile, the child pays the price.

There are other medical-type professions that don't require completely sacrificing all time win the child.

IWorkAtTheCheescakeFactory · 10/11/2019 13:07

So his proposal is that he moves his children across the country, removing them from their main care giver, reducing contact with main carergiver to zilch, and all while he will be undertaking one of the most stressful and demanding career changes a person could do, whilst parenting entirely alone and with no income?

And he thinks that is what is best for his children? And he’s found a solicitor that not only didn’t laugh him out of their office but actually agrees and has taken it to court? Confused

Theresnobslikeshowbs · 10/11/2019 13:02

Full time medical student + full time single parent + prior disinterest in his children = delusional individual

Swipe left for the next trending thread