Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Single parent wants to change career into medicine, but has no support.

188 replies

Puzzledbyart · 10/11/2019 10:46

Just out of interest. Let's say we have two primary aged school children (on the younger side of primary). Is it feasible for their single parent to go through the medical school (with a foundation year, they are in 40s, so long out of school), whilst retaining 100% custody of the children? There is no family help nearby, and no substantial savings to pay for the childcare either. Is it realistic at all?

OP posts:
AgentJohnson · 10/11/2019 17:02

Courts don’t reverse the residency status quo for no reason, especially not for hair brained schemes that are loosely connected to reality. What is in the child’s best interest in moving to a strange place with a uninvolved parent with pie in the sky dreams?

Smile and nod but don’t get sucked into his fantasies.

Lhastingsmua · 10/11/2019 17:00

I don’t think your lifestyle suits studying medicine if I’m being completely frank.

The course itself is not comparable to nursing or midwifery at all, sorry but medicine is much more academic and difficult. It’s on a completely different level. I am in my early 20s and went to university, I have many friends that study/studied medicine in recent years and they would all say that it takes an extreme toll on your mental health.

Placement will not be ‘family friendly shifts’. It could be 12 hour shifts or night shifts, 49 hours a week unpaid.

strawberry2017 · 10/11/2019 16:55

Urgh missed your post where you say it's about your ex! Sorry

strawberry2017 · 10/11/2019 16:54

Can I just say regardless of what you decide to do that I think it's very admirable what you want to do. You are showing your children what a strong women can do when she puts her mind to it and I hope you achieve great things!
Good for you!

katielilly · 10/11/2019 16:32

Will he still try to get onto this course if he doesn't get residency for your DC?
How much of this is motivated by not paying tuition fees of at least27k?

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 10/11/2019 16:29

So , in his 40s with years since he left school, DC and a limited availability for shifts , needing the childcare bursary .

And they'll have 1000s of A-Level students in teens/20s with no ties , the ability to work the shifts , do the travel, not need childcare , brains primed to learn because they've spent years studying .
And will have 45-50 years of working and study potential ahead of them.

Oh, he'll be fighting off the offers Hmm

katielilly · 10/11/2019 16:04

Is this the exH who is qualified in something legal eg a solicitor?

QueenofPain · 10/11/2019 16:01

Okay, just seen that this is a reverse. This man is tripping absolutely balls with his little plan.

OP, I know you said there’d a few things just lately where you could have done better. Are you in a position to perhaps reduce your hours a little and pull your socks up with the other stuff so you can be squeaky clean to stop this man in his tracks of trying to take your kids? What does your solicitor say about it? Do you need a better one?

QueenofPain · 10/11/2019 15:52

For all the student nurses and midwives on this this thread - I don’t think your training is at all comparable to medicine and the foundation years. And I say that as a nurse who trained fairly recently.

Could this person look at a Physicians Associate training perhaps?

Junkmail · 10/11/2019 15:50

I’m so confused about this plan of his OP—I also have a masters in a humanities subject and I have also applied to start medical school next September. However—how does he have “close to an offer”? I am still waiting to hear if I even have an interview? It’s the wrong time of the year for him to be so certain of a place. Also there are only a couple of schools in the country that provide the pre-med course (what I have also applied for) so I don’t know where you live but this could entail for him a substantial relocation. I don’t think that would go well if he is looking for custody of the kids as surely that’s really unfair for them?

Also—I have no children and am under no illusions how intense the course will be (if I get a place!) and I’m already fretting slightly about how much time I will miss out on with my DOGS let alone a CHILD!! This is all so wildly unrealistic. Even if he made it through the uni years then what is he going to do for F1 and 2 years—it’s a lot of work!

I think he’s being unrealistic on a number of fronts but at a very basic level he may not even get on the course. It’s very competitive—I mean I have a similar degree, excellent aptitude test score, a number of years of clinical experience and I’m also trained in a variety of medical related qualifications and I’m still sweating bullets over getting an interview. Pre-med is not the easy route in. So it may be that it doesn’t happen anyway!

YeOldeTrout · 10/11/2019 15:49

Neglected kids don't know what it's like to have their own toothbrush, OP. I think you're safely out of that league.

QueenofPain · 10/11/2019 15:47

“Are parents not allowed to choose family friendly shifts [in medicine]?“

Grin Grin Grin Grin

Oh dear OP!

theboxfamilytree · 10/11/2019 15:40

Honestly, I think it's important to view this for what it is: an attempt to exert control over you. Purely because it allows you to respond in the best way, to protect yourself emotionally and practically, and to ask for the right advice from the right people.

Using court proceedings to hurt and control someone is a common tactic, so you need people in your corner with experience of this. You do not have to do it all alone or adopt a position of culpability. Have you considered speaking to Women's Aid for advice?

I hope you don't genuinely believe that earlier list of examples constitutes failing. If it does, where does disappearing almost entirely from the children's lives for years and then wanting to rip them away from everything they know sit on the failure spectrum?

Verily1 · 10/11/2019 15:36

It’s the out of hours childcare that’s the issue. You won’t get funding for a night nanny/ weekend nanny.

If you have space for 2 au pairs on top of breakfast clubs and after school clubs then ok.

But you won’t see much of your dcs at all and if you have a nasty ex then then could use this against you if they would want custody.

mapleleafshiba · 10/11/2019 15:26

Hi OP. This is really interesting. I'm a junior doctor with a young DD, I also have a physical disability so was given placements as close as possible through medical school (this was before I had my DD.)

It's utterly impossible in my opinion. This whole "family friendly placement promise" is a myth and it's just not viable. You have to travel long distances to meet the GMC requirements of varied placements in different settings. A medical school based in the NW of England for example covers north wales, the Isle of Man and right up to Barrow in Furness. I had the "preferential placement allocation" and the university were SO kind. I still went left right and centre all the time across London. It's tough, it's so bloody expensive and actually the hours needed to revise on top of placement mean i find it laughable hes even considering this.

ALSO. There was a foundation programme at my Med school. It was insanely competitive as there were so few places, despite the entrance reqs looking lower. You still have to sit the aptitude tests and meet the same score as the other applicants to the usual course and honestly, they got some really really good students in that way. Think oxbridge graduates, LSE grads, they really were from excellent academic backgrounds.

I think it's great to dream big and actually I love my career in medicine- it can be super family friendly later on after the early years are done if you're careful about your career path and willing to make sacrifices at work but this really is mad.

And I did chuckle at family friendly shifts once you start work. I have had all my leave requests rejected, worked Xmas day every year since graduation and even missed my Dsister's wedding as they wouldn't approve the leave. There's no such thing as family friendly shifts, it gets SO much worse when you start work.

Waveysnail · 10/11/2019 15:10

Shes doing f1 now

Waveysnail · 10/11/2019 15:08

My friend did. Started when her child was 1. She paid fulltime daycarerplace and also found an evening sitter and a night sitter (two young ladies she paid as and when). When little one started school she used same means.

DoctorDoctor · 10/11/2019 15:05

That's what is says in the brochures I've seen. Family friendly, fully flexible working, accommodating personal circumstances fully.

Many people who have ever applied for a part time degree course will tell you that universities are often good at talking the talk on issues like this, less good sometimes at making it a reality.

Butterymuffin · 10/11/2019 15:03

forgotten PE kits, overdue dentist appointments, missed sports days, I do not volunteer as a parent help at school, three thousand jumpers were lost since September, there were instances when I was stuck on a broken train and late for more than an hour for collection.

All that except the last one is well within the normal run of parenting, and while I don't think I've been an hour late for pick up, I've had a good few instances of being notably late, and sometimes that's been purely my fault - yours wasn't. Social workers would laugh at the idea that this is neglectful. Not to wish to lower the bar, but if your kids are secure, regularly fed and cleaned, know they're loved, have enough clothes, some toys and a bed to sleep in, you're doing ok and better than many.

On the other hand, I can see how quite a few of those things would be hard to achieve for someone in medical school with no income and no other support and no proper experience of day to day parenting to fall back on. But frankly, I think this is never going to happen. He's entertaining a fantasy. Don't let yourself get too frightened by these blatantly insane ideas when he hasn't even made it through foundation year yet.

Starlight456 · 10/11/2019 14:45

You need to base your argument based on the kids are settled . Happy in school . Do you have family around? The support network but an imaginary free time , god knows who looking after them when they are on nights , removing them from their mum.

Unless you are not a fit parent ( losing jumpers and not joining bathe PTA don’t help you qualify) there is not a reason to move them . I would argue if he takes you to court as he is planning to move away it makes sense for the contact order to reflect the changes he is making as 50/50 isn’t possible from that distance.

GettingABitDesperateNow · 10/11/2019 14:31

I think the study part would be ok.

I'd be worried about the difficulties finding childcare around long and changing shift patterns, as well as moving to different hospitals for placements with little notice.

I think you'd definitely need some sort of live in childcare (say a reliable au pair if you cant afford a nanny).

Also I think the physical and mental toll of being a junior doctor is tough.

I also think you need to be flexible - I don't think being a doctor is the kind of thing you can rush out the door as soon as your shift ends because of childcare - ideally yes you should be able to but in reality if the person taking over your shift is ill or delayed then people could die if you just clock off.

I think it would be logistically and physically and mentally very very hard without support. Sorry.

fedup21 · 10/11/2019 14:29

Is he expecting you to do childcare whilst he’s on nights?

Disfordarkchocolate · 10/11/2019 14:25

I have done all of the things you forgot, none of which made me a crappy patent. If missing PE kit or jumpers caused real harm then thousands more children would be in care.

theDudesmummy · 10/11/2019 13:56

I have not RTFT but he has got to be taking the p*. A medical student has a lot of free time? Ha ha!

I am a doctor, I was at medical school many many moons ago, but my stepdaughter is a medical student (third year) right now (albeit not in the UK). I can tell you with 100% certainty that being at medical school (especially after the first couple of years) does not involve free time! He clearly has no clue how intensive, difficult and time-consuming the actual studying side of things is, never mind the hours involved once you get into the clinical years and have to in the hospital at whatever hours you are told to be. I absolutely loved medical school, had the best time of my life there, but part from a bit of hard partying at special times like after exams, "free time" was not a concept.

Being a junior doctor was even worse, in terms of time, of course. I didn't have children, and I was exhausted every day for about six years. I didn't have a child until long after I became a consultant!

Chocolateandamaretto · 10/11/2019 13:56

I know someone who went to medical school with a child as part of a couple, the stress split her and her partner up. She had to move back to close to her parents in order to get through the f1/f2 years. The foundation year and perhaps the non clinical years are one thing but as other posters have said, the clinical years will be hard and f1/f2 impossible without live in help/very close family or friends support.
Also if you end up in one of the bigger areas (north east covers right up to Cumbria for eg) then getting placement far from home is very feasible. You have to be academically top notch to be considered for your first choice, it’s not just competitive to get into med school but all through and beyond!