Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Single parent wants to change career into medicine, but has no support.

188 replies

Puzzledbyart · 10/11/2019 10:46

Just out of interest. Let's say we have two primary aged school children (on the younger side of primary). Is it feasible for their single parent to go through the medical school (with a foundation year, they are in 40s, so long out of school), whilst retaining 100% custody of the children? There is no family help nearby, and no substantial savings to pay for the childcare either. Is it realistic at all?

OP posts:
Joerev · 11/11/2019 07:18

@PurpleDaisies. Ahh yeah. I thought it might. My mum did an access course and there were people on there who did it before their A levels. But I knew one was cutting it close.

But with how PC the world is now. It doesn’t surprise me they would have to change it. It made sense at the time.

Tanaqui · 11/11/2019 05:56

To be fair to the op, I don't think it was meant to be a reverse - she didn't say it was about her, just asked for opinions, and people assumed. I think her first response was "it's not me".

Butterymuffin · 10/11/2019 22:35

He hasn't got an offer. It's all part of the bullshit fantasy. Smile and wave, OP, and let it unravel.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 10/11/2019 22:23

Looking again you say he has an offer ?

Or is this was he's told the OP ?

Lyingonthesofainthedark · 10/11/2019 22:05

I think it's personality dependant, to some extent. I know someone close who coped pretty well, but they aren't easily stressed, and also don't yet have children. I think the children will be older, and they can get an au pair for support, which will help. Being older may be an asset.

I think they should apply and try to find people who have done similar to talk to about it.

doublebarrellednurse · 10/11/2019 19:10

I did my nursing degree as a single parent.

I did not get "family friendly" shifts
I did not get "family friendly" placements

I survived only because my best friend is an absolute legend.

Medicine isn't a family friendly career and during training the person will be treated like everyone else.

Bursaries are more limited than they used to be.

Butchyrestingface · 10/11/2019 19:01

I didn’t think you could train to be a doctor last 35? Has that change now?

That changed years and years ago.

Ah, Brandon Lee, let me count the ways... 😥

I had a feeling this was going to be about OP’s ex. I can sniff a fucking reverse at 💯 paces.

Anyway, your ex sounds like a fruitloop who’s trying to fuck with your mind, @Puzzledbyart. How much care giving responsibilities does he currently have or has had for the kids? I’d be tempted to turn them over for a week and see how he gets on.

CherryPavlova · 10/11/2019 18:41

Looking again you say he has an offer? How is this? Most offers aren’t given out until February usually with interviews between November and February. Is he suggesting he ha a deferred offer from last year?
No such thing as close to an offer - either you do or don’t have an offer.

theDudesmummy · 10/11/2019 18:18

I agree with what @Elbowedout said as well. The age is a huge factor, never mind the children. The quickest he could go from starting med school to the end of training, even if he decided not to become a consultant and became a staff grade or similar, so did not do all the speciality exams, you are looking at ten years of studying/training at the very minimum. So in his mid-fifties he finally gets to the point where he can take, if he likes, a job without on-call or emergency commitments, and more fixed hours, and not be studying at the same time. Even with that level of job (which does suit some people, not everyone wants to become a consultant) there are unpredictable days, and you might be delayed in leaving work, or unable to drop everything to go and deal with a childcare issue. IMHO there is NO medical training or career which is going to work for him in the circumstances you describe.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/11/2019 18:06

Why hasn't he done this before? It sounds as if he's had a few child-free years recently when he could have been making headway. Why didn't he do science A levels at school or much, much earlier, if this has been a lifelong ambition? How much relevant work experience does he have? The application process is brutal and that sets the tone for the next few years, as far as I can see.

Correct me if I'm wrong, knowledgeable people, but I'm getting a sense of a foundation course set up to pull in overseas students and/or affluent UK students desperate to get into medical school. Lots of persuasive marketing material but no guarantee whatsoever of a medical school place at the end of it.

Elbowedout · 10/11/2019 17:56

Attempting to start a career in medicine at this stage of life is madness in my opinion. Medical school and foundation years are the (relatively) easy bit. It only gets worse when you have to start studying for professional exams which make any exams you have done up until then look like child's play. And of course you are studying in your "spare time" around antisocial working hours. There is a reason why lots of doctors have their children relatively late. There is nothing "family friendly" about a medical career. Some specialties are worse than others but there are none that make it easy.
OP, it sounds like your ex is quite deluded. Even taking the children out of the equation, if he wants a career in a hospital specialty he would be looking at starting a first Consultant post at about the same age as most sane individuals are planning their exit strategy. General Practice training takes a bit less time, but he would still be mid to late 50s when he finished. And to think that he could have sole care of your children whilst doing this is even more crazy. It is not impossible to combine medicine and caring for children of course but it is very tough, especially as a single parent. I have several friends who are single parents and have successful medical careers, but they have had support from other sources such as parents and/or live in nannys. And they didn't start when they were already middle aged! Why anyone would willingly put themselves into such a position is beyond me. I can't see any judge siding with someone who has such little insight and I can't see his plan succeeding anyway.

theDudesmummy · 10/11/2019 17:52

I would add also that, even though I was already a senior consultant when my son was born, in the end it made sense for my husband to retire early from his job to be there to do the parenting that I could not do. I don't have the crazy hours that a junior doctor has, but things are not predictable. I am not a trauma surgeon or anything like that, and true emergencies in my job are rare, but I can't always know what time I am going to be able to leave work. I still have on-calls, they are from home but things could happen which mean I have to go in. Someone has to be potentially completely reliably available to drop everything if my son needs picking up unexpectedly for example, or is home ill, I cannot guarantee that I would be able to do that...

The answer to whether he can do this is an emphatic no from me, for a hundred reasons.

MrsFezziwig · 10/11/2019 17:46

Right OP, I understand your motives for posting as you did originally but really you’ve just made the situation much more difficult to understand (and as posters don’t always read the updates you’re going to carry on getting loads of inappropriate advice).

So as I understand:

  • medicine is his lifelong dream
  • but he can’t afford to fund himself so he needs 100% residency of the children so he can get various financial benefits
  • but despite medicine being his dream he hasn’t looked into any of the practicalities of the course as anyone with half a brain knows that medical students don’t have “a lot of free time” and the things that universities promise about family friendly working will never come to fruition. Even if he gets on the course he will be pitted against hundreds of super bright young people so will be well down in the pecking order when it comes to job choice.
Is the course of action so that he can continue to control you or is it that he really wants to become a doctor? If the latter, he’d be better taking out loans for the course and leaving the kids with you (which I presume would be your preferred option also). And the mediator sounds bonkers - perhaps if the situation was described to her as wanting to train as a barrister under similar circumstances she might start comprehending how nonsensical it all is.
PurpleDaisies · 10/11/2019 17:42

I didn’t think you could train to be a doctor last 35? Has that change now?

That changed years and years ago.

wonkylegs · 10/11/2019 17:42

DH is a dr and we've been together since he finished medical school - we have 2 DC
I would say from experience no.
It took two of us to allow DH to have his career and both of us had to sacrifice for that.
The shifts are not family friendly especially in the early years, in theory you may be able to request but they are unlikely to be granted , you need a lot of practical support either by a partner or family because paid is unlikely to be able to cope with the odd hours, short notice and inability to pick up on time. I would also say it's a career choice that can require quite a bit of emotional support too. Patients die, are violent, rude it takes its toll, you will need support.
For example there is no guarantee you will get Christmas off in fact as a junior dr you are quite likely to get rostered on for at least some of the inconvenient period when no childcare exists. Don't underestimate the hours especially as a junior dr - they are not as advertised. Sickness - very hard to accommodate.
In 11 years DH has been to one school play, one parents evening, two swimming lessons and no sports days - not for want off trying others were booked off but he had to cover for colleagues due to shortages

Joerev · 10/11/2019 17:41

I didn’t think you could train to be a doctor last 35? Has that change now?

IdiotInDisguise · 10/11/2019 17:41

Well if she has money to pay a barrister, she may have money to pay a live in nanny.

Sammy867 · 10/11/2019 17:36

The course is intense; the placements, in course assessments, OSCE and MOSLERs. There will be clinical attachments 9-5 most days with study afterwards whilst doing in course assessments and working normally as well (you still need money to live obviously)

The F1 Year in particular was brutal. You can apply for special consideration if you have children Or dependents but it’s not guaranteed. I was working 14 hour shifts most days due to staffing issues and there was no consideration given to timing shifts for parents- the rota usually consists of 3-4 different types of shifts on a team of 8 rotation. This was over 7 years ago now and I would never recommend any one to do it now to be honest as I imagine staffing issues are worse now than it was then.

This is obviously if you pass every exam for every year- in most schools the exams are not cumulative grades like normal degrees- you have to “pass” every single exam along the way or repeat the year else you cannot be deemed to be safe.

Sn0tnose · 10/11/2019 17:33

The first (compulsory pre-court) mediation session was this week, the mediator was an experienced barrister, and she was making very approving noises of his plan. She will have been making those approving noises because she would have understood that it would be unprofessional to call him a deluded idiot, clutch her sides and let him see tears of laughter rolling down her cheeks.

If he thinks he’s going to have sufficient spare time to raise a family, perhaps he’s considering starting his studies at a lower level. Like GCSEs.

PurpleDaisies · 10/11/2019 17:28

Who picks up the slack for all these parents choosing family friendly shifts then?

theDudesmummy · 10/11/2019 17:22

I see that others have also brought up the issue of money as well as the laughable "free time" issue. If he already has a previous degree he can't get a student loan, so I assume he must be independently wealthy if he think he can live for six years income-free and pay the £9000 a year fees, plus all the travel costs to hospital shifts, the equipment and tech, textbooks etc etc etc?

olympicsrock · 10/11/2019 17:18

Also - it’s crazily late in life to train as a doctor imo.

olympicsrock · 10/11/2019 17:17

I’m a doctor. It very much depends on the structure of his course. Mine involved 2-3 years of preclinical ( daytime 9-5) all at a central campus then 3 years clinical 8-5 . These have a few but not many nights. Weekends are rare. For example obstetrics and acute gen medicine involved nights to get relevant experience the rest did not at all. Most universities now mix clinical and non clinical work and depending on which campus he would often travel to campuses. In my opinion he would manage the first 5-6 years if he had good breakfast club from 7 am and after school provision ( at least til 6pm) however once he was a junior doctor he would have lots of compulsory out of hours work and would have no leeway as a parent. Unless your children are over 8 now he would struggle in 6 years time

Disfordarkchocolate · 10/11/2019 17:14

They'll also be competing against a lot of younger students who have spent time volunteering so they have recent relevant experience. He's just being a bully and thanks this is a way to not pay child support for the next 4/5 years too.

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 10/11/2019 17:09

I am quite shocked by this thread as to the naivety of some posters as to what is required to enter medical school and the huge costs, not only in money which are involved. For a start no medical school will consider you unless you have at least an A in A’level Chemistry, or you would have to complete a foundation course and the fees for a medical degree are huge!