Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Single parent wants to change career into medicine, but has no support.

188 replies

Puzzledbyart · 10/11/2019 10:46

Just out of interest. Let's say we have two primary aged school children (on the younger side of primary). Is it feasible for their single parent to go through the medical school (with a foundation year, they are in 40s, so long out of school), whilst retaining 100% custody of the children? There is no family help nearby, and no substantial savings to pay for the childcare either. Is it realistic at all?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Aprilclairelaurent · 04/09/2023 19:38

It’s a lifelong dream and I’m very passionate about it. It’s never been the right time to try so I’m just going to go for it and see what happens now! I’d love to hear from any other single mums who trained as (very 🤢) mature students to hear about that kind of experience. If it doesn’t work out at least I’ll know I gave it a go but I’m pretty determined 🤣

Throwncrumbs · 04/09/2023 16:41

I trained before I had my son(single parent) and found being qualified AND working in a hospital hard going … I would never have coped with training , placements, etc so good luck if you think you will be ok. 🥹

Aprilclairelaurent · 04/09/2023 16:24

Did you do it 👀 I’m 35 and have 3 daughters and just beginning the path to study medicine so would love to hear what happened! Hoping you had success and are now in the thick of studying!!

RumpyBall · 11/11/2019 19:20

Op being late isn’t a massive parenting fail and is not a strong basis for him to be granted full custody.

If he has barely been involved then the only parenting fail is on his behalf.

BanginChoons · 11/11/2019 18:56

@puzzledbyart if the children loved mainly with him (ie. He claims child benefit for them) he would be eligible for dependants allowance, parent learning allowance and the childcare grant. He would also be more likely to get a higher rate if he were to apply for his university's hardship fund.

Elbowedout · 11/11/2019 13:56

I can virtually guarantee that there will be plenty of times when your ex is late to pick up children if he is successful in his crazy plan to study medicine. I don't know a single doctor who has not had this kind of problem on multiple occasions.In fact I would think most working parents have something like this happen at least once, whatever their job. It isn't a massive parenting fail, it is just life. You probably need to put an alternative fall back plan in place in case something similar happens again, but if we all lost custody of children we were late to collect once, I doubt there would be a lot of children left with their parents. Learn from the experience and move on.

Butterymuffin · 11/11/2019 10:53

The train thing was not a massive parenting fail, it was an unlucky unexpected event beyond your control. You'd rung the school! As a pp has said, in this never-gonna-happen scenario where he is a full time single parent AND trainee medic, this would happen all the time - including times that were unsociable when it would be almost impossible to work around. It won't make this less likely for them to be with him. Quite the opposite.

HigherFurtherFasterBaby · 11/11/2019 10:23

Sorry, didn’t read the whole thread.

No he won’t have any spare time, he’s full of shit

HigherFurtherFasterBaby · 11/11/2019 10:21

The best thing your friend can do is look on her area for an Athena Swan accredited University that does Medicine, call them and have a frank conversation about what the Clinical Placement years and Junior Doctor years will be like.

That’s what I did. And no, it wasn’t possible.

Instead, I’ve studied Biomedical Science and will hopefully be working in NHS labs. Close enough to what I originally wanted to do.

IWorkAtTheCheescakeFactory · 11/11/2019 10:16

Being an hour late once Due to a broken down train is not a reason to change residency. It really isn’t. What you need to do now is set up an arrangement with a neighbour/other school parent/family member/childminder to be your official back up person. Give their details to the school as your back up and make sure it’s on their system so you can get a print off and bring to mediation or court to show that that situation will never be an issue again. If that’s what his application for residency is based on then it falls apart right there and then.

What i suspect is that his application for residency is reliant on him gaining a place on the course but his application for the course is reliant on him getting residency of the DC (for the dependant financial support).

Whereas what a normal sane, child focussed parent would do would be to first establish them self in new location, settle into the demands of their course, source childcare and schools and then ask for his children to join him.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 11/11/2019 09:49

I was once an hour or so late picking my daughter up from primary school because my friend's nanny who was supposed to be collecting her forgot. I was a SAHM at the time! No long-term effects, fortunately. It can happen to anyone.

I know nothing about the family courts so won't attempt to second guess what they might think about your ex's pie in the sky plans, but what I would hope is that everyone concerned will see what he is saying is utter nonsense and not in the children's best interests at all. He has no track record of involvement in the children's lives to point to - from what you've said they can hardly know him. He has no experience of the day-to-day grind of juggling work, childcare and all the other stuff of life. He has nothing of substance to accuse you of to justify uprooting them and moving them a long way off, massively reducing their contact with you. Surely it's a non-starter?

bibliomania · 11/11/2019 09:40

I don't know anything about studying medicine, but I do have an ex who tried (unsuccessfully) to get residence changed and my view is that even if your ex managed to set himself up in an ideal arrangement, this would not mean that he would succeed in getting residence changed. The courts want children to be settled, and they don't like disrupting the status quo, providing the status quo is acceptable. Being late once because you got stuck on a train is not a parenting fail.

The best approach is to emphasise how well the dcs are doing under the current arrangements (assuming they are, of course!) . Your exH's living arrangements are, at best, unproven and unpredictable. A court will not be impressed by the fact that he voluntarily disappeared from their lives for a while. His proposals are speculative and massively disruptive to their established living arrangements - it would be pretty extraordinary for a court to think that this sounds like a good change for the dcs.

WaningGibbous · 11/11/2019 09:22

Being late to pick up because you have little local support is easily resolved by throwing money at a childminder who will provide a contract to say that she'll do emergency pick up for you for a retainer. Or you pinky promising you have a neighbour on stand by.

And of course you could ask to see what his back up is for when he gets held up on placement...

RuffleCrow · 11/11/2019 09:17

Unrealistic sorry. And nervous breakdown inducing.

Disfordarkchocolate · 11/11/2019 09:15

Honestly, that is not a massive parenting fail. And the job, and study, he is planning to do will not be local to the children it will involve a move. Did mediation suggest he applies to the med schools near you?

It would be useful to get some emergency back up, even it's the late teenage children of friends, who can do emergencies like this. This sort of thing happens to all parents and it's not a major fail. Crap parents do this because they can't be arsed.

MrsFezziwig · 11/11/2019 09:08

Has he any backup if he got residency? Because believe me given the pressurised nature of studying and practising medicine it won’t be long before he is undergoing multiple “parenting fails”.

Thehouseintheforest · 11/11/2019 09:07

OP , are you the current primary care giver ? Do the children live with you the majority of the time ? Does their father have regular consistent contact ?

I would seriously consider posting a question about this 'residence situation' in Legal. Where a number of extremely knowledgeable family lawyers will be able to give you the benefit of their experience. For my (non-lawyer) perspective... if being late to pick up from school/childcare due to an unavoidable and unpredictable transport issue meant losing my children.. then mine would have been in care for the majority of their childhoods ! This is completely bonkers . The children (I presume) are settled with you ?

bridgetreilly · 11/11/2019 08:57

A train breaking down is not a major parenting fail. It would be sensible, however, to find some alternative emergency provision so that you can explain to the court what would happen if a similar situation arose in the future.

Puzzledbyart · 11/11/2019 08:55

@BanginChoons
I don't think it was the reason for the application. Are there any additional money for students with children? I understand from the thread that everything extra is ring fenced for children-specific cause, e.g. childcare?
I admitted above, I was stuck on a broken train from work (well, technically behind a broken train, with no option to leave and jump into a taxi or something) and was massively delayed collecting the children. I called them to explain, but they still rang the father and that's how it all started. I am not proud of it. I was asked during the mediation whether I would consider taking a local job instead (my job is central London-centric, local jobs are probably min wage for me, as I am not qualified to do anything "portable"), or move closer to where the father is planning to study (same story). Thus panicking a little bit.

OP posts:
LaurieMarlow · 11/11/2019 08:42

Unless I’ve missed something, nothing you’ve described on here is a major parenting fail.

He’s playing on your insecurities. Don’t let him.

BanginChoons · 11/11/2019 08:41

Are you sure the parenting fail is the reason not an excuse for the reason?

What did you do?

BanginChoons · 11/11/2019 08:40

I think mrsfezzywig nailed it. He wants the kids with him so he can claim additional funding while studying.

Puzzledbyart · 11/11/2019 08:34

Thanks, a lot of thoughts that I will try to process. I don't know any details about the offer, the only thing I know is from his (sworn) court statement, which describes it as being nearly a certainty. I know he was going to do this for a couple of years, but we're not in touch (apart from correspondence regarding the children) so I am obviously not privy to any details. It well could be a deferred offer.

My genuine question was whether it is possible or not. So far it looks like the consensus is that possible, but very difficult.

Taking a career break is not an option for me at the moment unfortunately, just cannot afford it. I have limited legal advice, but cannot justify spending £30K+ on it (which seems to be the estimate for the full process from a couple of solicitors I consulted with).
I did not intend it to be a reverse, I just wanted to separate the situation a little bit from the custody issue (which I know is a triggering topic for many). I said a couple of times it is not about me, but people still assumed it is.
He's not independently wealthy, I imagine it is a combination of family help, recent inheritance and loans that will pay for the project. The residence application was filed not because of his plans to study and needing financial support, but after one (admittedly big) parenting failure on my side that came to his attention.

OP posts:
Booboostwo · 11/11/2019 08:17

Do you have a solicitor? It seems to me that your Ex plans to study medicine are a red herring. Before it gets to that he would need to make a case as to why the DCs should be taken away from their resident parent, by a parent who has not had any contact for a while (I think I understood this correctly, he hasn't seen the DC is a while, is that right?) and move them far away from the other parent. I can't see a judge entertaining any of this unless there are allegations of abuse or neglect by the resident parent.

The parenting fails you mention are run of the mill stuff everyone does. Perhaps you should have a fall back system in place with a friend, neighbour or babysitter who can collect the DCs from school if you are again delayed for an hour, but other than that, I can't see as any of the things you mention being neglectful or abusive. Is there anything else going on here or is your Ex just bonkers? If he is just bonkers I suggest you let your solicitor handle him directly.

PurpleDaisies · 11/11/2019 07:31

I don’t think it’s anything to with being pc. We’re all working longer and longer. Graduate entry courses last four years. Even if you start work at fifty, you’ve still probably got nearly twenty years to give to the nhs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread