Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Husband not supportive of my need for maternity leave

609 replies

Bellyfish1 · 04/11/2019 08:26

I am a freelancer with one regular client who currently pays me for 4 days' work a week. I am also 31 weeks pregnant and worried how to manage maternity leave.
My husband is also self-employed and earns much more than me but is not supportive of me taking full time maternity leave and thinks I should try to keep on working through even the first months post-partum.
This will be my first baby but DH has 2 kids from previous relationship. Should be noted that his ex went on indefinite maternity leave although she will have received mat leave pay from her employer for the first few months.
As our finances are completely separate despite being married (owing to his trust issues since first partner left him), my husband expects me to continue to support myself through this pregnancy and beyond - it is also becoming clear that he expects me to pay for everything that will be needed for the baby.
This WAS a 'planned' pregnancy in that we were ttc for 2 years and even had IVF (failed) although when I did fall pregnant it was no longer expected and has been a minor miracle considering my age (42) and history (7 early miscarriages).
I have no assets as I lived abroad from age 25 to 35 and have never been able to get on the housing ladder, but I earn enough to get by.
My husband owns the house we live in and we share the bills. His reason for not letting me pay towards the house and getting named on the deeds is that he wants it to be for his children from first marriage, which I fully accepted, but now we have a baby of our own on the way I was hoping things might change.
In short, I feel very vulnerable and anxious and completely unsupported by my husband. I know he won't let us starve but this pressure to keep working (he thinks I should juggle things so my clients pay me for results rather than days worked) and my fear of not having my own income is ruining this time for me which I had dreamt of for so long.

OP posts:
Oliversmumsarmy · 05/11/2019 12:53

Actually op the idea of you and your spouse buying a bugger palce jointly is a good idea. No need to split rooms and you can both be names and will give you security.
Would that work for him? It's a good compromise

But it is just an idea that has already been dismissed by him.

They maybe married and op maybe pregnant but a one night stand has more of an honest relationship that the op and her husband.

Spanglyprincess1 · 05/11/2019 12:26

I sought legal advice pre living with dp and he has no entitlement to my house but we aren't married. Don't take the advice on here as golden that you have a legal. Claim, get advice.

Actually op the idea of you and your spouse buying a bugger palce jointly is a good idea. No need to split rooms and you can both be names and will give you security.
Would that work for him? It's a good compromise.

Ref house isnt relevant. Your current circs are the important things to fix as the house is a nonissue really. It isn't the big that is abusive... What IS abusive is not working together to provide for your joint new baby. That's not on.

TatianaLarina · 05/11/2019 12:09

Well actually that's not true either. It was an asset owned pre marriage that she hasn't contributed towards either repairs or mortgage. So depending on length of marriage etc then legally she isn't automatically entitled to it.

She hasn’t contributed as she’s not been allowed to because he wants her to have no claim on it.

If they divorced after, say, 10 years it would have been the marital home all that time, it would also be the child’s home. So yes she would have a claim on it.

If she hasn’t been married long, has made no contributions, has her own property as ‘advised’ by her DH - her claim is more oblique which is exactly why he set it up this way.

TatianaLarina · 05/11/2019 12:01

I am divorced and own my house which I live with my kids. There is no way I would agree to someone moving in, marrying them and then losing my kids inheritance. I’m sure men feel the same.

And you would make sure any new child you had had no access to your previous kids inheritance?

Surely you would want to split the inheritance between your earlier kids, your new one and its father - should he be left to bring up that child alone?

Stephminx · 05/11/2019 11:57

@Bellyfish1

You say you are not ready to accept your husband is abusive and that reading this thread is distressing for you. The advice being given is based on the information you provide, so I think subconsciously you already know exactly what the situation is.

Might I suggest you go to your family, speak to them about what is really going on and make some decisions on how you want to proceed.

Then maybe when you are ready, come back to get advice on next steps.

Winesalot · 05/11/2019 11:56

SpanglyPrincess

Of course, she should have limited claim to an asset owned before marriage while the marriage is still new. However, this is about her DH not allowing her to even make suggestions about improving their living arrangements to suit a newborn. She cannot seem to get damp fixed or a working dishwasher...

Frankly, it might be a far better and fairer solution to move as she suggests and for her to treated as an equal the new house. He can then do with the other as he likes.

And if they stay married for a long time- she probably would get consideration for that asset. They are married. Just because she might not earn as much or pay as much, she probably contributes to the family just as he does.

Storsteinen · 05/11/2019 11:51

I am divorced and own my house which I live with my kids. There is no way I would agree to someone moving in, marrying them and then losing my kids inheritance. I’m sure men feel the same.

Well yes I agree with you and I won't be marrying someone and have them possibly take half of my flat from me.
But this man has married the OP and agreed to have a child with her and she is now pregnant. If he did not want to support her properly then he should not have done this. He's saying she has to pay for all the baby things herself. It's all manner of wrong.
They should now be thinking about moving home so the baby actually has it's own room. He won't pay for a plumber for the dishwasher.
So although I don't think she should be able to divorce him and take half of the house, she could divorce him and get something in the settlement and have child support paid.

If he was not prepared to support her and his child and make suitable arrangements to protect OP should he die, then he should not have got married.

Xenia · 05/11/2019 11:50

Beans, yes same here. No new partner would get a penny of my house and in fact I am so happy not having a man living here I think it will be me and the children forever so no chance of messing up their inheritance so yes I see the husband's side here but I tihnk we would need both side's views to be very sure what is going on here. It seems weird to me he didn't marry his partner and yet did this time but with some kind of possibly non binding pre-nup presuambly because he was prepared to risk his assets and loves her much more than his first partner and mother of his first children. Hard to tell.

Interesting that he is not prepared for her to tae on outside help. Wow - that is ridiculous. One reason I earned 10x my hbusband by the end was that we both took on full time outside help so we could maximise our earnings.

NoSquirrels · 05/11/2019 11:38

OP, sending you Flowers.

You’re right we don’t know him and it’s not the full picture. It sounds awful though - damp untreated (why?) a dishwasher you’ve bought unplumbed in (what reasoning could there possibly be for that?).

Whatever else he is, he has serious financial issues that are causing problems.

He needs to address those.

It is not ‘princessy’ to insist on that.

And as to your business, that is your decision:

He is not happy for me to take on the expense of paying for outside help. He would prefer me to try and at do the minimum, hope that they won't notice and then return fully asap.

It’s got nothing whatsoever to do with him how you run your business.

You make the decision, you forecast your income based on your decision, then you inform him how much you can contribute to living costs whilst on maternity leave. Not the other way around.

And I don’t know why you have to shoulder the cost of big ticket items like a pram.

He’s being absolutely awfully unreasonable if he’s not being abusive. If you believe he’s not abusive then you should be able to lay it all out and tell him how awfully he’s behaving. And he should listen.

Beansandcoffee · 05/11/2019 11:26

I agree @spanglyprincess1.

I am divorced and own my house which I live with my kids. There is no way I would agree to someone moving in, marrying them and then losing my kids inheritance. I’m sure men feel the same.

However OP your H has other issues apart from the house which you need to focus on and leave him.

Spanglyprincess1 · 05/11/2019 11:26

I missed the room splitting thing. I did work with a small bby I wouldn't advise this at all!! If your doing work I'd advise pre brith. Dishwasher is a godsend... I'm getting one when we change our kitchen and I can't wait
Can his dc not share and baby hav eown room (smallest) from 6mths?

lottiegarbanzo · 05/11/2019 11:21

The room-splitting thing. Are you are saying you live in a house, not a flat, with only one bedroom? Or is it that bedroom(s) are allocated to DH's other dcs, for when they visit?

This bedroom, is it huge? Big enough to be partitioned to form two decent-sized bedrooms?

When will this occur? Babies usually go into their own bedroom at six months. Sometimes a bit older. This bit of building work needs to happen within the next year. Has your DH budgeted for and planned this?

The same DH who won't pay a plumber to install a dishwasher you've already bought. A dishwasher that will make life with a baby much easier.

Does your DH really expect to be living in a house with a baby in it, in a year's time? His actions say otherwise.

Spanglyprincess1 · 05/11/2019 11:20

Agree with pp the chat will show you their true colours and help you make a decision!

Spanglyprincess1 · 05/11/2019 11:19

Well actually that's not true either. It was an asset owned pre marriage that she hasn't contributed towards either repairs or mortgage. So depending on length of marriage etc then legally she isn't automatically entitled to it.
Right to reside for a period and her child would have rights to it as a share with siblings. But legally its not just 50 % as married, its a starting point.
Also morally I don't think op has a claim on an asset she hasn't contributed to which was owned pre marriage. Its a bit more grey area than people think esp if its a short marriage - and I think they married relatively recently (although I may have mis read that).
His pension, joint savings etc then absolutely yes.
He also of course should support her during mat leave its his baby to. The house is a non issue tbh the lack of support etc when vulnerable is an issue!

Autumnfields · 05/11/2019 11:16

@TatianaLarina very good advice too.

I sat down and had a financial ‘chat’ with DP a couple of times. I was reasonable, non confrontational. I wanted to feel that we all had a stake in our home as a family, I wanted a pension, I wanted to come to some arrangement about all of this and was not asking DP to provide it, just to consider options, for example I wanted to let out a room in order to enable me to stay at home longer and pay for some repairs and build a small pension while I wasn’t working. Said we could go to a solicitor about the house.

He showed me an ugly side that was shocking. He exploded in a a rage as if I’d physically pushed him off a cliff.

Try it and see how your DP reacts?

TatianaLarina · 05/11/2019 11:14

I don’t agree that you should get a share of the house. Sorry op but I really don't

Well the law doesn’t agree with you so it’s irrelevant.

Spanglyprincess1 · 05/11/2019 10:59

I don't agree that you should get a share of the house. Sorry op but I really don't. But you child should. Mat leave half yes. Contribute to bills only when working yes.
Have your own savings etc. Yes.
And you dp should pay for his own life insurance!

Auntums post is very very true. My dp jumps for his exw but not for me. I very spectacularly threw my toys out of the pram around 7 mths ago and it nearly broke us but he respects me now and dosnt take what I do for granted anymore.
Sometimes it's okay to lay down the law on certain issues.
Sounds silly but one of my pet peeves is cars I drive a 7 seater which I bought to accomadate our family (his 3 kids and my ds) he bout a 3 seater small sportish car just after.. Okay. Our cars won't last more than a few years now and I've said next time he needs to get a 7 seater and I have smaller car and then we will swap after that. As fair and its for his kids. Flat no as he dosnt wnat to and not cool. I told him that's his decision but I will Not be buying a 7 seater and he will have to find a way to accomadate his family!!!! I know its sounds silly but it's sums up an entitled attitude!!!!

TatianaLarina · 05/11/2019 10:49

Such great advice from Autumn OP.

TatianaLarina · 05/11/2019 10:46

If you don’t want to believe any of us - sit down with him and detail exactly what you want in all this - fair claim on the house - financial contribution to it and name on the deeds, including fair claim in his will, maternity leave at your discretion, 50% contribution from him on all the child’s expenses and a joint account for this, reimbursement for 50% of the wedding costs, and end of his financial control of your outgoings etc. Then stand back and see what happens.

Autumnfields · 05/11/2019 10:02

What hurts is how generous and supportive he was with her yet how reluctant he seems to be to offer me the same opportunity to bond, recover, be a mother as he afforded her. I think I have always seemed very independent and he liked that.

This actually gives me shivers down my spine. My ExDP did just this. I thought how great it was that finally he had me, a woman who had a good job and didn’t lean on him for everything. Unlike his Exwife who never worked in her life and basically took him for everything he had.

Wow how wrong I was. Exwife did get a very, very generous man. And I didn’t. However my DP managed to do less for me BECAUSE HE RESPECTED ME LESS THAN HIS EX WIFE. Sorry to shout, I find it heart breaking just to say this. DP still loved that I am self sufficient, however he, for whatever reason, never set out to work as a team with me, the way he had with his wife. And the more he got away with not being a team, the more he liked it.

And what they start out with. With us, not trusting us and not being part of a team. It doesn’t get better as they ‘trust us’. And we start jumping over hoops in order to alleviate their stress over money, like you are doing now, considering work with a newborn! CraZy. We avoid in any way, resemblzing their ex wives in an unconscious way of proving how much better we are. I know because I am that person.

However it just gets worse. Your description of your DP not wanting to sort out damp or your dishwasher? Do you know what that means? He doesn’t care if his newborn baby lives in dangerous unhealthy conditions. He doesn’t care how much harder it is day to day with a baby for you without a dishwasher. He doesn’t care about you. He doesn’t want your stuff in the house.

I am not allowed anything of my own in the house. When I have become miserable over this, DP would ‘allow’ me to choose the colour of the paint in a room. Being a SAHM with a baby, it’s so important to feel nested and have some comfort over your environment, that I was pathetically grateful for being allowed to choose a colour. Yet as soon as you have his baby OP you are contributing to everything, the house. Everything.

I too told DP I did not want to claim the house up until I moved in, and that I did not want to interfere with this kids inheritance.

However by having their child you need to start also building your own inheritance for your kid and yourself. Like me, you may realize that ALL THE ASSETS YOU ARE CONTRIBUTING TO LIKE THE HOUSE ARE BEING BUILT TO GO TO HIS CHILDREN AND NOT YOU. Thank goodness you are married. I wasn’t. So at least you do have some protection.

And another factor you haven’t considered. Now my step children, despite me being quite generous and caring for them, also see me in the way DP does. As totally disposable. They treat our child as if he has nothing to do with me, insist that they see him in their Mums house with DP regularly, and are now as entitled as their mother over money and compete for finances although they are adults. DP would rather give them everything and me nothing as he doesn’t have ‘trust issues’ with them.

I know you think we are different. We are not. I still love DP as he’s incredible charming, outwardly lovely and caring, earns a very high wage and has a gorgeous house. None of it is real though. Not for me anyway.

Please very carefully consider getting out now.

If you don’t get out now? Do not let him look after your baby. Get good health insurance. Make repairs to the house. Get the dishwasher plugged in. Enjoy your newborn and grow your family supports. Do not become financially independent as that will go against you and it will take you away from your baby when you need to bond well. Start a journal, with no emotion, of everything you are told not to do or made to feel ‘is a good decision’ by DP over things you know instinctively are wrong - like damp, deeds of house, going back to work. Just list what is said and keep password protected on your laptop. Watch carefully how he interacts with his kids, and his ex, and your family. Just observe.

And first and foremost make you and your baby the centre.

FairportConvention · 05/11/2019 09:54

Gah mumsnet not number!

FairportConvention · 05/11/2019 09:53

Op if you won’t do it for you, do it for your baby. Read up on how essential good bonding is with a primary caregiver, for all aspects of a baby’s wellbeing. I am not exaggerating when I say that it sets your child up physically and emotionally for life.
You owe your baby that. Please please don’t risk this period being damaged by you suffering under this mans abuse. I had pnd with my second as a result of emotional abuse and it ruined my first year with dd2 (and really affected Dd1, who was three at the time, for many years). And my partner was great to the kids. Just not to me. And later when I found number I learnt that great fathers DO NOT abuse the mothers of their children.

OkayGo · 05/11/2019 09:45

Op; run.

Everything you have written about this man indicates abuse.

JenniferM1989 · 05/11/2019 09:27

Are you going to make a claim for MA and CB and take some time off OP? When on MA, you can keep up with contact days, you can essentially work 10 days over the course of your leave and be paid for them without forgoing your MA.

So if you take say 3 months off, you can work for your client almost one day a week and not lose your right to MA. Double check on this though

NeverTwerkNaked · 05/11/2019 09:26

This is a man who is not just horribly abusive he is also very calculating.

Please get some proper legal advice and also please get support from women's aid or similar

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread