Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Husband not supportive of my need for maternity leave

609 replies

Bellyfish1 · 04/11/2019 08:26

I am a freelancer with one regular client who currently pays me for 4 days' work a week. I am also 31 weeks pregnant and worried how to manage maternity leave.
My husband is also self-employed and earns much more than me but is not supportive of me taking full time maternity leave and thinks I should try to keep on working through even the first months post-partum.
This will be my first baby but DH has 2 kids from previous relationship. Should be noted that his ex went on indefinite maternity leave although she will have received mat leave pay from her employer for the first few months.
As our finances are completely separate despite being married (owing to his trust issues since first partner left him), my husband expects me to continue to support myself through this pregnancy and beyond - it is also becoming clear that he expects me to pay for everything that will be needed for the baby.
This WAS a 'planned' pregnancy in that we were ttc for 2 years and even had IVF (failed) although when I did fall pregnant it was no longer expected and has been a minor miracle considering my age (42) and history (7 early miscarriages).
I have no assets as I lived abroad from age 25 to 35 and have never been able to get on the housing ladder, but I earn enough to get by.
My husband owns the house we live in and we share the bills. His reason for not letting me pay towards the house and getting named on the deeds is that he wants it to be for his children from first marriage, which I fully accepted, but now we have a baby of our own on the way I was hoping things might change.
In short, I feel very vulnerable and anxious and completely unsupported by my husband. I know he won't let us starve but this pressure to keep working (he thinks I should juggle things so my clients pay me for results rather than days worked) and my fear of not having my own income is ruining this time for me which I had dreamt of for so long.

OP posts:
Lovemenorca · 06/11/2019 13:11

I am right

The Beneficiary can be anyone
The policy holder can’t be someone else who is also the recipient

It’s called Moral Hazard

Xenia · 06/11/2019 13:06

Actually I tihnk you are right in practice except in cases where there is an insurable interest - spouse, work partner etc.

"In most cases, it's only possible to buy life insurance for your spouse or civil partner, although you may be able to do so for someone else by proving that an 'insurable interest' exists on your part were this individual to pass away. In simple terms, this means reasonably demonstrating that you would struggle financially if the insured person were to die.
What is Insurable Interest?

Insurable interest is a legal requirement for all insurance policies at the time the policy is taken out. The Economic Times defines insurable interest as 'the reasonable concern of a person to obtain insurance for any individual or property against unforeseen events such as death and losses'.

In UK law, insurable interest extends to the life of spouses and civil partners, but not between other immediate family members including:

Parents and children
Children and parents
Siblings
Cohabiting couples

Although the English and Scottish Law Commissions have tried to clear up this complex law by increasing the limits of insurable interest, it's currently not possible to buy life insurance for anybody other than your spouse or civil partner in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. Scotland is an exception, where children have an interest in the lives of their parents if they have an obligation to provide maintenance. Another exception is where two friends purchase a property together. They usually have an insurable interest equivalent to the amount of the mortgage.
Deed of Assignment

One way around this issue is for people to assign their policy to someone else. A deed of assignment is a legal arrangement that transfers the ownership of a life insurance policy from the existing owner to a named beneficiary. As with all transactions of this nature, both parties need to be present to ensure the document conveys what it needs to.

The law assumes that the person buying life insurance would only name a beneficiary within their policy if they wanted to protect them financially. There's usually no requirement for any beneficiary to prove insurable interest at the time the deed of assignment is completed.

Other options include adding provisions in a will or placing the policy in a trust.

As these options are likely to have different tax implications, you should always seek advice from your legal adviser."

Xenia · 06/11/2019 13:02

You may well know more than I do but surely the law already deals with your point - you cannot profit from your own wrong so if you kill your wife you dont' get the insurance money etc.

Also don't these kinds of policies - keyman get taken out for the benefit of the survivor in a business - www.legalandgeneral.com/life-cover/microsites/businessprotection/business-protection-products/key-person-protection/

Lovemenorca · 06/11/2019 13:01

I am divorced. I have a life assurance policy. My ex husband is the beneficiary if I die BUT the policy is in my name and I took it out. I just named him as the beneficiary.

Lovemenorca · 06/11/2019 13:00

They can’t take out a life assurance policy on someone else and be the recipient of the policy.

Why? Because it would be in their interest for that person to die.

I work in insurance. This is the truth.

Xenia · 06/11/2019 12:56

Loveme, people CAN take out life insurance policies on someone else . It happens all the lime. Eg those who may be in the process of divorces are advised by their lawyers to take out a life policy on the husband. Most small businesses with 2 partners take out life policies on the other people. It is very normal

hangingabout · 06/11/2019 12:56

OP - life shouldn’t have to be this hard. If your DH and father of your unborn child has no concept of supporting you at this time, then what is the actual point of him? Really?

Why should his first two children have been able to have their mother around, but not this baby? Have you asked him that? Why does he not want what’s best for this child?

How can you have a baby with someone who won’t even share a bank account with you? Or support you through basic maternity Fgs! It’s too much.

I don’t mean to sound facetious, but does he have any mental health issues? What is actually wrong with him? It’s just so bizarre to make me wonder if he’s becoming ill. I’ve genuinely never heard of anything like it in my life.

You shouldn’t be having to argue with your own husband for the mere basics of survival for you and your child! Who does this?

When I was pregnant, my DH never even thought to pressure me about what my plans were about going back to work. We had joint finances whether I was working or not. He wants what’s best for the DC obviously, and in his mind, that’s being able to have their mum around. Hes always been proud to facilitate that and he’s just glad I’ve prepared to put my career on hold to do that. That’s enough for him. Why involve childminders or day centres if you don’t need to? I haven’t worked for over a decade. When I do start working again eventually, it won’t make much difference because all the money will still be joint anyway.

Your DH is peculiar in the extreme. You had to pay for your own wedding??? Now he won’t even get the dishwasher plumbed for his pregnant wife??? Bloody hell. Don’t you ever really kick off and just tell him, rather than ask (not that you should have to). Maybe if you just walked out and went to your mum’s, it might jolt him onto planet Earth? You can’t go on like this, you really can’t. Get your family inside. If you really must stay with him, shame the hell out of him! What’s stopping you? Tell your family. Tell his mother. Tell your friends. Time to get real here. By keeping quiet you’re allowing him to get away with this and it’s abuse, make no mistake. He should be bending over backwards to help you to feel secure and healthy and preparing for the birth and all that will follow. Don’t settle for anything less. The must be something fundamentally wrong with him.

gwenneh · 06/11/2019 12:43

Colour me skeptical but I don't believe a word of what he says. It's all words.

^^ This. It's all words, and he will come back with reasons why none of the above can/will happen. He just needs time to make up the excuses.

Lovemenorca · 06/11/2019 12:34

No one can take out a life assurance policy on someone else

Storsteinen · 06/11/2019 12:19

The garden studio is a brilliant idea - but wonder who will end up paying for it?

TheWernethWife · 06/11/2019 12:07

OP, my friend got a garden studio from a company called Extra Rooms, think they are in Nottingham. A guy came and checked out the site, friend then chose which one, it came about 9.00 am and was up and running that evening.

She had to sort out the electrical supply before it arrived.

It looks brilliant.

Wishforsnow · 06/11/2019 11:41

So if he has the home office where do you work? I thought you said you work at home also or are you just in the kitchen or dining room?

Storsteinen · 06/11/2019 11:23

By taking out the policy herself SHE is in charge of it, not him which means he has no say on where the money goes, if he takes it she is reliant on him doing the right thing

Ah ok, that`s why? What happens if they split though? Would she be able to cash in the life insurance policy?
Would she be better off putting the money into some other kind of investment?

AutumnRose1 · 06/11/2019 11:16

"I have no idea why YOU are paying to take out life insurance on HIM.
He should be taking that out on himself and naming you as his beneficiary should he die.
If you take out life insurance on him and you split - what happens then? Will he continue to pay the life insurance premiums and then his next wife or partner benefits from what you have paid in?"

I wondered this too.

now I've seen that your parents can help out, I'm even more puzzled why you would stay with this man.

ithinkmycatistryingtokillme · 06/11/2019 11:13

By taking out the policy herself SHE is in charge of it, not him which means he has no say on where the money goes, if he takes it she is reliant on him doing the right thing

Storsteinen · 06/11/2019 11:06

I have no idea why YOU are paying to take out life insurance on HIM.
He should be taking that out on himself and naming you as his beneficiary should he die.
If you take out life insurance on him and you split - what happens then? Will he continue to pay the life insurance premiums and then his next wife or partner benefits from what you have paid in?

Colour me skeptical but I don't believe a word of what he says. It's all words.
Absolutely ridiculous that a grown man needs to be "sat down" and told to contribute to his child nor that he needs it pointing out that the baby will have to have a room of its own.
He should have been saying "Listen, OP, when the baby is x months old, it will need a room of its own so what do you think about making my office into a room for the baby and I'll set up my office in..... (wherever appropriate).

I think this situation will get worse not better and you'll be back on mumsnet in 6 months asking for advice again.
Get an escape plan in place now should his empty promises come to nothing.

AutumnRose1 · 06/11/2019 10:53

OP sorry if I missed it, but have you got friends and family and a place to go? Or enough money to rent alone?

I can't see the dishwasher as being relevant, you're rearranging deckchairs on the Titanic instead of getting in a lifeboat.

Oliversmumsarmy · 06/11/2019 10:46

He has agreed to a lot of what you asked for but atm it is just words.

You are still having to pay for his life insurance and you still don’t have a stake in the house.

I must admit that would worry me.

Supposing in 18 years you split. You could end up out of the house with a bit of savings and not much else.

You would be too old to get a mortgage and house prices will be double/treble what they are now.
To end up in rented for the rest of your life how would you manage?

Do you have a pension fund that would cover rent and living expenses?

Whilst he might do all the things you have suggested ultimately you will pay in other ways

Motoko · 06/11/2019 10:33

Did you do any reading about financial abuse?

MrGsFancyNewVagina · 06/11/2019 10:16

Make sure you get receipts for anything you pay towards, with your name on it. Don’t let him be aware of this, because I wouldn’t believe a word that comes out if his mouth. I’m cynical but I believe he’s stringing you along until the baby is born and his name on the birth certificate, then the more serious abuse will start. But that’s your risk to take.

Autumnfields · 06/11/2019 10:12

Sounds very sensible and considered. Although I’d be thinking of taking 6 months off at least.

The only way, if you really want to possibly salvage your marriage is by clearly acting and showing him what a reasonable marriage is. By going back to work very soon you are in effect hiding your needs from him, and he will be comforted that this was all your decision.

You must not take action E.g. returning to work soon - out of fear that he won’t support you. He will support you. And he will learn to respect you as the other of his child. If he gets angry. So what? Not your problem he’s not stepping up. You can then go to your parents and be supported by them and benefits. Much better than struggling to find a childminder. Almost all women take a good few months completely off.

Spanglyprincess1 · 06/11/2019 10:01

We got an ex display one randomly so it was heavily discounted. Can't remember who with.
Shop around though and you can grab a bargain esp in January in sales and slow time of year for them.

Bellyfish1 · 06/11/2019 09:40

Already considered a garden office - hadn't seen one for so little. Can I ask which company you used @spanglyprincess1 ?

Must be cheaper than splitting rooms and far less disruptive.

OP posts:
Bellyfish1 · 06/11/2019 09:38

Good idea @NearlyGranny
Hadn't realised that would be enough. Thank you.

OP posts:
NearlyGranny · 06/11/2019 09:25

If you plumb in the dishwasher and fix the damp at your own expense, bingo! There's your stake in the house. He's a canny financial abuser but he's a fool if he let's you contribute there. Keep the paperwork. He might be assuming you won't bother or even be planning to make it disappear, so photograph or screenshot everything and send to your own and possibly parents' email for safe-keeping.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread