Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Husband not supportive of my need for maternity leave

609 replies

Bellyfish1 · 04/11/2019 08:26

I am a freelancer with one regular client who currently pays me for 4 days' work a week. I am also 31 weeks pregnant and worried how to manage maternity leave.
My husband is also self-employed and earns much more than me but is not supportive of me taking full time maternity leave and thinks I should try to keep on working through even the first months post-partum.
This will be my first baby but DH has 2 kids from previous relationship. Should be noted that his ex went on indefinite maternity leave although she will have received mat leave pay from her employer for the first few months.
As our finances are completely separate despite being married (owing to his trust issues since first partner left him), my husband expects me to continue to support myself through this pregnancy and beyond - it is also becoming clear that he expects me to pay for everything that will be needed for the baby.
This WAS a 'planned' pregnancy in that we were ttc for 2 years and even had IVF (failed) although when I did fall pregnant it was no longer expected and has been a minor miracle considering my age (42) and history (7 early miscarriages).
I have no assets as I lived abroad from age 25 to 35 and have never been able to get on the housing ladder, but I earn enough to get by.
My husband owns the house we live in and we share the bills. His reason for not letting me pay towards the house and getting named on the deeds is that he wants it to be for his children from first marriage, which I fully accepted, but now we have a baby of our own on the way I was hoping things might change.
In short, I feel very vulnerable and anxious and completely unsupported by my husband. I know he won't let us starve but this pressure to keep working (he thinks I should juggle things so my clients pay me for results rather than days worked) and my fear of not having my own income is ruining this time for me which I had dreamt of for so long.

OP posts:
DistanceCall · 04/11/2019 20:09

I think all my requests are fair but they are baulked at by DH. It is a trust issue. I am patient and trying not to panic because I hope that with time he will realise I am not out to fleece him.

Come on, OP. He has trust issues but is willing to marry you and spend loads of money getting you pregnant? If he truly had trust problems, he would NEVER had agreed to such a commitment unless he had ulterior motives.

I have suggested we open a joint account which we contribute to equally (I from savings, he from income) to provide for the baby. He doesn't think this is necessary and would prefer to just get things as and when.

Because that way he gets to micromanage and control you, and keeps you under his thumb financially.

Childcare shouldn't be an issue as I work from home and he is often able to work from home, so I don't see why he thinks he should cut his hours unless for an ulterior motive - especially given how precarious he has otherwise stated he feels his income to be.

He's going to claim that he's the main carer and get custody of your child. Which is exactly why you need to get out of there BEFORE your child is born.

Please wake up, OP. There's a lot at stake for you here.

Bellyfish1 · 04/11/2019 20:02

I will reply as I do think this is how my husband sees the situation.

To clarify: he earns almost double what I earn although he does have high outgoings (child maintenance, higher tax, liability insurance etc.) so probably not very much more as net income.

The house is modest. Although he is a solicitor, he is a sole practitioner with generally low-value cases. The mortgage is tiny. It costs less per month than the amount I contribute to food and 50% of bills. IF I were to be put on the deeds and start paying half the mortgage, I would not expect to receive half on separation, just the amount I contributed plus half of any increase in value since I started contributing. I have made this absolutely clear. I just want the security and sense of being part of a team, whilst also wanting to feel more at home and so that I can feel more assertive in asking to make changes/improvements to the property. I do make suggestions but they are quickly discounted as extravagant or unnecessary (like getting the SH dishwasher I bought plumbed in, or damp-proofing a dodgy patch of wall).

I earn enough to be entirely self-sufficient and to pay off any debts each time I get paid although not enough to save. If I were to pay towards the mortgage, I would make easy sacrifices and be happy to. I am not 'subsidised' except that I have a roof over my head. I don't live in London so local rental rates would take up about 25% of my post-tax income (nowhere near 75%). Contributing to the mortgage would set me back less than 15%, unless (as I think we should), we either paid off the mortgage early, together and then bought somewhere needing fewer repairs (and with an additional bedroom to accommodate the newborn when it's ready for a room instead of splitting ours). That way we would feel on a more equal footing and my husband would be free to 'ringfence' an amount for his first children, to make sure they are not disadvantaged by my involvement.

I think all my requests are fair but they are baulked at by DH. It is a trust issue. I am patient and trying not to panic because I hope that with time he will realise I am not out to fleece him.

As for first partner (they didn't marry), she certainly didn't fleece him. His trust us around being left and having the children taken from him. From what I understand, she was on maternity leave (paid by employer and then became sahm supported by him) until she left, with children aged 2 and 4. He paid her rent when she first left until she married someone new.

What hurts is how generous and supportive he was with her yet how reluctant he seems to be to offer me the same opportunity to bond, recover, be a mother as he afforded her. I think I have always seemed very independent and he liked that. I now need to be able to depend or at least be supported through loss of income while I bring our child into the world and he is struggling to accept this.

Perhaps he feels his income is not reliable. This is possible. But he frequently has these fears and yet his business is growing year on year. I think he fears I will lose my main client, but I think that is only a real danger if I give them unrealistic expectations as to my return date and don't find and pay for temporary support to ensure the services they receive are almost uninterrupted. He is not happy for me to take on the expense of paying for outside help. He would prefer me to try and at do the minimum, hope that they won't notice and then return fully asap. I find that whole situation deceptive and stressful so have refused. He thinks this is evidence of my lack of money-savvy.

I have suggested we open a joint account which we contribute to equally (I from savings, he from income) to provide for the baby. He doesn't think this is necessary and would prefer to just get things as and when. As the main food shopper and the one expected to buy the big hits (pram etc), I am bound to pay for the vast majority of baby's upkeep.

Childcare shouldn't be an issue as I work from home and he is often able to work from home, so I don't see why he thinks he should cut his hours unless for an ulterior motive - especially given how precarious he has otherwise stated he feels his income to be.

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 04/11/2019 19:40

He’s not ‘giving her’ rent free accommodation. They are
A) married
B) she’s having his child

C) she is contributing toward the cost of the house by bearing a disproportionate amount of the running costs. She is paying half all the bills despite earning less.

D) He pushed for the marriage not her, then dumped the cost on her by saying he only wanted the cheapest possible piece of paper.

He has quite cleverly stripped her of any savings or the ability to save whilst gaining no stake in the house.

She would be better off with a rental agreement which at least gives her some rights.

Autumnfields · 04/11/2019 19:10

He’s not ‘giving her’ rent free accommodation. They are
A) married
B) she’s having his child.

He’s not let her pay towards the home and he’s a solicitor and he knows that is clear evidence. Even though she’s going to have their baby.

If they were not married and she were not having his child then yes, he would be providing a roof. However even in childfree non married couples they usually acknowledge that both are contributing to the household and there is a substantial polling of resources, even if one persons contribution is more. Couples who keep all finances separate and one keeps the house while the other lives in it, often have a weaker core as one person is protecting their assets to the detriment of the relaitonship.

Winesalot · 04/11/2019 19:09

Petty. Isn’t marriage supposed to be a partnership? Subsidizing? Mmmm! What about if the wife is on a much lower wage and all this is leaving her with not enough to live on. What about her having to buy a bucket of a car to drive her and baby around out of her own money? How is this looking after your family if the car breaks down on a motorway in the snow with a young baby. Subsidizing??

PettyContractor · 04/11/2019 19:05

I find people have a general tendency to treat what the other person does contribute as non-existent, when inviting others to be outraged at them not contributing to certain selectively highlighted expenses.

This man is apparently abusive because he expected OP to spend a couple of hundred of her own pounds on a stroller. That he might be providing accommodation worth a couple of thousand pounds a month is apparently not something that needs to be included in the picture.

PettyContractor · 04/11/2019 18:57

Seriously? Are you missing that fact that she is funding half of a marital home in which her DH intends to deprive her of any interest

She said she's not paying towards the home because he won't let her, as he doesn't want her to have a claim on it. (Although if they're in the UK and married, I can't see how this will make a difference, except maybe if they divorce after a short marriage.)

He wants to keep 100% of the house that he alone is paying for, for himself in the first instance, and in the long term for all his children. Reasonable not to want to give some of the house to someone who has contributed nothing towards it, unreasonable to think the law will let him, in the long term.

He didn't want to pay for a wedding that was more elaborate than he wanted. Reasonable. Maybe a bit tight not to treat her, but this is in the context of a relationship where she is being subsidised by him.

He doesn't want to to pay for what child expenses? Childcare aside, babies don't really cost much. So unless it's childcare/loss of earnings he doesn't want to cover, this is an insignificant issue. Especially in the context of a relationship where she is probably being hugely subsidised. (If he is providing 100% of housing for everyone, that might be 75% of total basic cost of living, in London.)

He doesn't want her to go into debt for child expenses. Leaving aside what these mysterious expenses are, I would be appalled if found myself married to someone so feckless that they thought putting consumer goods on a credit card was an acceptable thing to do.

He doesn't want her to give up work. He is unreasonable if this is really about not wanting her to take a few months maternity leave. I wonder if his real issue is that he's worried that this is the thin end of a wedge where OP is going to unilaterally decide that she is going to become a SAHP/kept woman. Something it sounds like his ex may have done.

Autumnfields · 04/11/2019 18:51

All those warnings about him lining himself up for more custody, more control, financially being on top and wearing you down are right.

I am you but with a 6 year old child. I could have, should have left when I was pregnant. He had sudden ‘cold feet’ when I was pregnant and after promising me marriage and my name on the deeds to the house - these were delayed and delayed. In the meantime he basically turned his family against me, and yes guess what I’m living surrounded by his family, miles from mine.

I have no claim to the house. They go to his kids who now like everyone think I’m awful. Facing very difficult custody battle. My child is being manipulated and I have job or support as I’m in the middle of nowhere.

I’ve got a great solicitor and I’m fighting it.

But yes, I wish I’d gone 6 years ago. My life would have been so much better. However I was financially and emotionally very trapped, I had nowhere to go. And that is when we are totally at their mercy.

hazell42 · 04/11/2019 18:49

You know in your heart of hearts that this is all wrong, but you are hoping desperately that it's not.
Hope is a good thing, but delusion is not, and I think you know you are deluding yourself
God knows, I get it. A lot of us do. we think if we can only find the right words to explain it, he will understand.
But he does understand.. it's you that is labouring under the false assumption that he is fair and good.
You are wishing him to change, and its possible he can. But not by wishing it, and certainly not by YOU wishing it
He has nothing to lose atm and you have everything to lose. he has no incentive and it seeks no inclination to change at all.
In your heart of hearts you know this
Be brave and acknowledge it out loud and prepare to move on. With or without him.
You are going to be a mother you do not have the luxury of living in dreamland any more.
Your child needs you to provide a secure and stable home. If you cant do it for you, do it for them.

Tun55 · 04/11/2019 18:46

I assume you work from home? Tell him if he manages to do nights with the baby (every single night), you might consider returning to work after 8 weeks. If not ask him to fcuk off. What a jerk! Utterly shameless!

MsPepperPotts · 04/11/2019 18:41

Stop paying anything towards the household bills and shopping and save as much as you can.
This is not going to end well whether it's now or you hang on in there a few more years....

The stress of being with someone who treats you like this creeps up on you over time affecting your mental and physical health.
It also eats away at your self esteem.
By the time you realise it will be too late and you will be a shadow of your former self.
It is very very likely that his behaviour will get a lot worse when the baby arrives.
He won't change OP. It's his way or no way. This is not how genuine people treat their partner/wife/mother of their child.
He is truly awful but it's so difficult to see when you love him.

gonewiththerain · 04/11/2019 18:40

Think Very carefully about how you would feel to only see your child once a week
If you’re happy with that stay if you’re not go.
Go to your parents or just go anywhere he’s highly unlikely to get 50 50 or custody if he’s not living with you and the baby
Could you afford to fight a custody battle?

How would you feel about your child being brought up by him alone?

I love my child in a way I could never imagine, a powerful primitive love I would do anything for him and give everything I have to protect him.

At the moment you can’t imagine this love or how hard or how amazing life will be with your baby because no one can until they’ve got the baby.

He’s got a plan. You need a plan

Don’t worry about loss of face for a short marriage or being a single mum happens to all sorts of people and most people go through at least one difficult patch in life and plenty of relationships break down.

But if I were you I’d go now

Xenia · 04/11/2019 18:23

I just read the first and this page.
In law in England a pre nup (if you ahve one) has indicative force onely and has to be fair, both sides need solicitors, it must be entered into a month or two before the wedding and both sides must disclose everything before it will be enforced. I suspecft that did not happen.
So let that to one side.

Tomorrow go on line and look up registering your right over the matrimonial home www.gov.uk/government/publications/notice-of-home-rights-registration-hr1 That registration at the land registry means that if later your husband ssought to remortgage or sell from under you anyone buying would have notice of that and it could not go ahead - so it gives you power.

I have some sympathy for the husband here actually. I want my children to get everything but I protect that by not moving a man in even and I would not take the ristk of marrying again as no matter whose name things are in unless there is a fair pre nup fulfilling the requirements I set out above it is not binding.

So on the question asked I was taking business calls the day after our twins were born at 40 weeks and back at work the week after. With the 3 older babies back at work after 2 weeks of annual leave. So yes loads of us do that and I earned 10x what my husband did - I recommend it - go out there and out earn him and then look at where the power lies!

Rubyduby26 · 04/11/2019 18:20

I haven't RTFT but he doesn't sound like a good man. You are his wife and are carrying his child. When baby is born the last thing you need to be stressing about is getting back to work. You will need to rest and adjust to being a new mum!

I think he has some serious issues and needs professional help to sort him out. His response doesn't seem normal to me. He should be listening to what you want and not just dismissing you and blaming it on HIS trust issues!

Good luck OP and congratulations on your pregnancy Flowers

Cornettoninja · 04/11/2019 18:19

Previous posters have give you much better practical advice than I ever could but I will chime in to say that all the stuff that you’re mildly aware of now but think you don’t really mind will become magnified x100 once you have your baby.

Even the easiest baby is like a whole new full time (and then some) job, even the adjustment to being responsible for this completely defenceless creature is a head fuck. I went into motherhood with my partner of fifteen odd years and it almost broke us. We’re just getting back on track just before dd’s forth birthday.

It wasn’t just him because I changed completely too. The goalposts moved and all of a sudden things we thought we would have been on the same page about were battlegrounds with both of us too wrapped up in defending our sides to give in to the other.

That was going into parenthood as a team in a good place. It’s got the potential to break you in your situation and I would really urge you to take control now rather than at a time when you’re likely to be pretty vulnerable.

PicsInRed · 04/11/2019 18:16

He married OP so that he would have PR at birth. This means he can take the child and OP would have to file child arrangement to have the child returned.

Remember, for this dick, this baby exists soley so that he can prove to family court what a magical Dad he is ... so that he can wreak vengeance on his ex by wrenching his first-family kids from their loving mother.

He has a plan and OP's place in that plan concludes at birth.

Irisloulou · 04/11/2019 18:06

Unless you signed a deed of trust, which you didn’t, the email he forced you to send is worth nothing.

As his wife you will be able to make a claim on the house, however the length of marriage is important. A short term marriage would give you less of a claim.

If he’s a solicitor he’s fucking stupid not to have drawn up a deed and gone joint tenants in common. ( tenants in common can be disregarded after a medium term marriage, but the deed of trust would have protected him)

Honestly I’d leave him now, before the baby is born. He may reassess being a dick, and step up to the plate but I doubt it.

Newborns are exhausting, mostly as you don’t get to sleep and hAve a body that’s knackered. The idea of working is crazy, especially If you don’t really need the money.
My first baby left me very ill, it was weeks before I could even walk....work.....not bloody likely. My second, c section, that’s major surgery!

My Ex DH was awful when I was pregnant, major red flags. I ignored it, battled on. However I never got over his lack of love and compassion.

Volvemos · 04/11/2019 18:02

You’re being cornered. Don’t let yourself be cornered.

Oliversmumsarmy · 04/11/2019 17:55

Might be totally off the mark here but
the house you live in op, is it quite a nice house and does the thought of starting again in something lesser seem like a step backward.

If it is you have to remember it is an illusion.

You don’t own it.

You don’t even own a part of it.

Stay and at best you will live for the rest of your life with low level of abuse.

If you outlive your husband then his kids will be mithering you to get out of their house and you will end up on a tiny flat or on the streets on old age.

Or you have the baby and will be frozen out of your child’s life and end up on your own paying him maintenance

Or you can get your act together and move out before the birth and start divorce proceedings.

You will be in charge of yours and your child’s destiny and you will get a part of the house, maintenance and be able to recover in your own time.

Coercing you into sending an email to say you won’t have anything to do with the house makes the email null and void.

You do realise what he did in making you send that email was illegal

ThatsMeInTheSpotlight · 04/11/2019 17:53

Everything he has done, has been deliberate. From waiting until you'd moved in to force you to pay for the wedding; to not putting your name on the house but making it about his DCs (rather than about him protecting his asset) so he could emotionally manipulate you. He's continuing to do it now by saying he'll take time off work. He knows that will put pressure on you and he also probably has no intention of actually being hands-on. He's just giving you more work (looking after him too!) more stress (worrying about finances) sabotaging your plans for that time (by ignoring your wishes and just doing as he pleases).
Your idea of staying away for a week, having some space and gaining some perspective, is a good one.
Your DH is not a good person, never mind a good husband.

Bellasblankexpression · 04/11/2019 17:47

This is actually the worst thread I've read on mumsnet in a long time.
Especially since the OP continues to say he's a good man.

You need to SEE it OP, he is not. He's a manipulative wanker who's taking you for a ride and at this rate, you won't properly realise until it's too late.

Go to your parents for a week, read and reread this thread. Think about how he's ticking all those boxes for custody. Stop seeing him through rose tinted glasses.

I really hope this doesn't end badly for you but I fear it will.

Manicpixiedreambitch · 04/11/2019 17:47

This makes such chilling reading. Good luck OP, you need it.

MarchingAnts · 04/11/2019 17:39

Looking after a newborn is a 24/7 job. There's no way you'd be able to work for at least the first 3 months! And after that, if you do start working, you'll need childcare. It's extremely unfair of him to suggest otherwise.

hangingabout · 04/11/2019 17:38

I just can’t comprehend how any husband in his right mind would actually, in all seriousness, state that he fully expects his wife to fund his child by herself, it’s just beyond belief.

Even teenagers who find out they’ve become fathers via one night stands have to accept that it’s morally incumbent on them to contribute financially. And they have no relationship to the mother - maybe he barely knew her name! This is the man you are married to, not some random!

Going through IVF is no picnic, I’m sure. You’ve already gone through a lot. And now this.

I’m so sorry. He won’t change. Nobody - you nor his mother - should need to state the obvious to him. Understanding a baby needs its mother in the early weeks / months is basic stuff. I just can’t imagine my DH or any man I know who would make their wife feel guilty and like a liability for the crime of bearing his child. It’s truly shocking.

Awaywiththepiskies · 04/11/2019 17:35

The more I read, the more I see why his first wife left him, and why he thinks she "fleeced" him. I wouldn't be taking his word for anything that happened in the first marriage.

AnyFucker had it right - you're being financially abused, with a side-helping of emotional abuse, and a sprinkling of gaslighting.

I hope you find a way out of this, OP - you really need to confide in a friend who knows you and your husband. We might be a bit "off" on our assessment - we don't know you both.

But you know what - if someone thought that my credit card debt (and oh lord, my overdraft!) were evidence of me being bad with money, when I'd been independent and self-supporting to the age of 42, I'd be furious. It would be the end of the relationship - well, it wouldn't even have started.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread