Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the acting in Harry Potter is just awful?

228 replies

LookingForAlaskas · 20/10/2019 20:25

Not watched the films in ages and the third one was on tonight.

It honestly felt like some parts were like a drama class in school. Very cringe.

OP posts:
LittleCandle · 21/10/2019 08:14

I don't mind the films. I didn't expect them to be great art, so of course there is some bad acting - show me a film where there isn't. I think the biggest travesty was casting Micheal Gambon (hugely over-rated and utterly unsympathetic) as Dumbledore, but to be fair to the man (which I am not very often), he had to follow the Sublime Richard Harris, who absolutely embodied Dumbledore. Given that Gambon is such a poor actor, I suppose he did the best he could, although he should have read the books to get a handle on the character.

BeyondMyWits · 21/10/2019 07:37

It is a childrens story, the kids watch and grow with the characters - my "kids" love it - they were roughly the same age as the characters when watching the films. They don't give a monkey's about the acting - they get caught up in imagining themselves into the story.

I liked Alan Rickman, David Thewlis, John Hurt, Maggie Smith, Natalia Tena and Raph Fiennes - oh my he makes a good bad guy...

there is an endless list of the greats of British theatre - some acted well, some not so well... (some of the characters were written pretty badly to begin with.)

Triglesoffy · 21/10/2019 07:18

You’ve been watching the wrong films then.

thatmustbenigelwiththebrie · 21/10/2019 07:12

I have never watched a film with British child actors where I thought the kids could act. American kids seem quite good at it. British children always speak in a terribly affected and wooden way that sounds nothing like natural speech.

Isitsafe32 · 21/10/2019 06:56

@NaviSprite they spotted him in the theatre because his mum or dad are/were big names in the theatre business I believe so I am sure that had something to do with it! I don’t think it was a random ‘oh that kid looks like HP’. Would explain things Grin

GobletOfIre · 21/10/2019 06:47

DR is terrible. In the earlier films, if he has to show emotion, he’s shot so you can’t see much of his face. You can see it in the train carriage where the dementors board.

TheCanterburyWhales · 21/10/2019 06:27

When I teach creative writing modules, I use HP as what not to do.
Clunky dialogue
Plot holes as big as the one in the ozone layer (none of the kids from wizarding families knowing that Tom Riddle was Voldemort's real name? That would be like kids in "our world" not knowing that Mr Claus's name was Santa.
Her sentence structure is predictably wooden Every noun has its adjective, every verb its adverb. And they are invariably the same ones throughout the saga. Now, I know that was how it was done in "rosy-fingered dawn" days, but I'm sure JK has a wider vocabulary than "oh, they're running! Must add a "breathlessly" there!"
Etc etc.
Name repetition instead of pronoun use.

The list of stylistic clunkery is endless. I don't blame JK, but she needed a better editor and she needed one to actually pull her up and tell her that occasionally, less is more . The first three books are fairly well-written for the age group they were aimed at, but once she started the two-year churning out of doorstopper volumes, her writing went haywire.

Don't get me wrong, there are wonderful bits, fabulous. But she needed to plan better, (in order to avoid the millions of questions she had to answer to explain things that don't make sense, we've all seen and read the "ah, but she wanted it to look like that really!" stuff) and she needed more time.

Her name choices are inspired however!

Buddytheelf85 · 21/10/2019 04:31

Emma Watson butchered the character of Hermione - turned her from a smart level-headed girl into a hormonal irrational drama queen. Just awful.

Yes! But she has to have done it under direction.

It just makes me irate though. There was a strong, sensible female lead character in the book, and in the films they make her a trembling, weepy, hormonal drama queen. Because girls.

Durgasarrow · 21/10/2019 03:56

Yes, they are terrible.

SquatBetty · 21/10/2019 03:53

Seems a bit mean slagging off kids' acting but the Weasley twins were fucking dire actors

overnightangel · 21/10/2019 01:11

“Emma Watson butchered the character of Hermione - turned her from a smart level-headed girl into a hormonal irrational drama queen. Just awful. ”

Ironically enough you’ve just described Emma Watson’s personal trajectory

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 21/10/2019 01:09

No-one tops Percy Weasley for all out woodeness. Why he wasn't redubbed baffles me. Just shocking.

overnightangel · 21/10/2019 01:09

Read the first 4 books before seeing first film, had to knock it off.
Harry is a working class kid in the books but given posh kid makeover for American audiences and a “Briddish accent”.
Didn’t bother of the books as the films are so bad so no idea what happens in the end, presumably Voldemort is Darth Vader’s father or something. 3rd book was great, 4th was meh, can’t comment after that.
Daniel Radcliffe is a great actor now though

minesagin37 · 21/10/2019 00:57

They are no Christian Bale are they? In my view they never really progressed into great actors either. Bless them.

DuckWillow · 21/10/2019 00:42

I don’t mind the films and when these threads turn up am always amazed at everyone who thinks the children were so awful. I didn’t think they were that bad. I loved RG and Tom Felton was great as Draco.

DR was okay too, I always thought Emma Watson was the weakest but she was outdone by the Weasley Twins, appalling actors both of them.

ItIsWhatItIsInnit · 21/10/2019 00:38

Emma Watson butchered the character of Hermione - turned her from a smart level-headed girl into a hormonal irrational drama queen. Just awful.

I remember watching the films as a teen and already hoping for a remake.

Shame because the adult cast were stellar.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 20/10/2019 23:49

The child acting wasn't great at the start. I thought some of it was how the characters were supposed to be played though. HG was supposed to be stiff and a little snooty . The twins were supposed to be really irritating and hammy

Liked it over all.

Rachie1973 · 20/10/2019 23:29

The twins. They were just embarrassing to watch

Gingaaarghpussy · 20/10/2019 23:27

This is why, after the first film, I stuck to reading the books. My imagination is way better. Grin

Iamthewombat · 20/10/2019 23:24

The child actors were uniformly embarrassing apart from the kid who played Draco Malfoy. He was the only one who was actually believable and who wasn’t hammy.

Seriously, how hard is it to find kids who can act? Was the catchment for those films ‘kids who already had agents’? Maybe the casting directors should have toured regional drama groups. That is how Stephen Graham (Line of Duty etc) was spotted: he was in a school production of Treasure Island.

It’s a toss up between Ron and Ginny Weasley for worst actor. Although they were hard put to it by the Weasley twins.

neonglow · 20/10/2019 23:21

And yes to the shoelace scene!! Wtf was that about, was it supposed to be sexy or something 😂

PumpkinKing · 20/10/2019 23:20

Well Michael Gambon, imo, is the most miscast of all the characters. I simply cannot understand how anyone who has read the books can think that his portrayal of Dumbledore is anything but a travesty. He utterly ruined the films for me, he doesn't look right or say a single line the way the book Dumbledore says it.

I read that Gambon never read any of the books so he could follow what the script and director told him and not be influenced by events that hadn't yet happened in the films. Hence we have HARRYDIDYAPUTYANAMEINDAGOBLETAVVFIYAAH???

neonglow · 20/10/2019 23:16

I thought a lot of the adults were great... Hagrid, Umbridge, Mcgonnagal, the first Dumbledore, mr and mrs Weasley etc etc

Agree about Ginny, just wasn’t right for the part and couldn’t realky act, the Ginny/Harry scenes just felt so weird as there was absolutely no chemistry.

BadBadBeans · 20/10/2019 23:16

@Honeyroar I also thought RG was the worst. His 'She needs to get her priorities sorted' in the first film makes me cringe! DR was terribly wooden to begin with but I felt he relaxed into it as the films went on. And I actually thought EW was super.

I don't get why people think that the books are badly written either. There are plot holes, yes, but the actual prose and storytelling is excellent, I think. And I'm a fiction copy-editor so I'm reaaaaaasonably qualified to make assessments about novels! I just don't understand quite what is so supposedly terrible about the writing. Anyone care to enlighten me?

TerribleCustomerCervix · 20/10/2019 23:04

Richard Harris was incredible.

I can understand Gambon wanting to add his own spin on things, but he fucked it