Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the acting in Harry Potter is just awful?

228 replies

LookingForAlaskas · 20/10/2019 20:25

Not watched the films in ages and the third one was on tonight.

It honestly felt like some parts were like a drama class in school. Very cringe.

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 21/10/2019 09:18

I empathised with @TheCanterburyWhales about the writing. I read the books to younger family members and I remember thinking, if I have to read the phrase, “...said Harry coldly” JUST ONE MORE TIME this book goes out of the window. Yes, an adverb for every verb.

I think the book @Fizzypoo means might be A Wizard of Earthsea. Although I always thought that JK Rowling ripped most of her ideas from the far superior Diana Wynne Jones. Now there was an imaginative writer who didn’t patronise children.

SorrowfulMystery · 21/10/2019 09:16

It'd be interesting to see how many Irish kids of that era are called Seamus Finnigan, etc etc. Not suggesting for a second Jk was racist, just that she could have done better.

I've no particular problem with Seamus's name, it's that while the only thing JKR tells us about him at the start is that he's sandy-haired I don't think we're even told he's Irish initially the films turn him into a fairly offensive stereotype. The novels don't depict him blowing up literally everything he points a wand at, or have him trying to turn something into rum (seriously? He's eleven!), but the scriptwriters/directors clearly view 'Irish' as code for 'boozer who's always blowing stuff up'. Hmm

I've always thought the problem with Michael Gambon was that he started off playing Richard Harris more than Dumbledore, and then got stuck with an accent and some mannerisms which probably didn't make a lot of sense to him. Plus Dumbledore just doesn't hang together as a character at all I think JKR tried to develop him from batty headmaster who gives mildly zany start of term speeches into someone powerful and flawed, but it just doesn't work. Plus you're up against the eternal problem of children's books how do you set things up so that 'good' adults don't just solve the problem for the child heroes? (And JKR had to figure out to why Dumbledore wasn't able to give advice and spy from his portraits after his death, too...)

Jason Isaacs was a total genius in Death of Stalin. As was Rupert Friend. And Simon Russell Beale. How can the divine SRB not have had a part in HP?

Icecreamsoda99 · 21/10/2019 09:11

I liked Michael Gambon better than Richard Harris as he seemed a more believable charecter while RH's Dumbledore seemed to be away with the fairies, I couldn't actually see him running a school. I actually think Dumbledore is a really difficult charecter to bring to life, so many opposing facets to his personality. Hermione was completely rewritten for the film into having zero flaws while Ron was made into the daft sidekick. I too hope there will be a TV reboot in the next ten years!

TaliZorahVasNormandy · 21/10/2019 09:09

The only good Harry Potter films are the ones with Jason Isaacs in.

Fucking love Jason Isaacs!

CalamityJune · 21/10/2019 09:08

The books are far superior than the films, though 1-4 are in a different league to 5-7 imo.

I'm on a self imposed Potter ban now until DS is old enough to read them.

historysock · 21/10/2019 09:03

Emma Watson in particular was very wooden throughout. I don't think she improved much start to finish really.

AndAnotherNameChanger · 21/10/2019 09:02

Wow, autocorrect really had a field day with my post:
*most of the adults...
*but DR and EW...

  • I find it bizarre
AndAnotherNameChanger · 21/10/2019 08:59

I thought noisy if the adults were good, bit DR and EW were terrible. I give it bizarre that they have acting careers off the back of them when, having seen HP, the presence of either is enough to convince me NOT to see a film. Mind you there are plenty of other older actors with successful careers to whom the same applies so clearly there are plenty of people around who either don't care about the quality of the acting or disagree with me.

TheCanterburyWhales · 21/10/2019 08:58

i think the problem Michael Gambon had was that in he was plummeted at the point where JK suddenly decided that she was going to turn Dumbledore into a, frankly, weirdy abusive slimeball as the saga went on. The directors must have been "where is she going with this?" and not quite knowing what to do with the character.
By the time we hear about the sister (thank fuck that load of tripe was left out of the films) and Aberforth and the goat (say what?!!!!!) the Dumbledore family was just absurd.

I was musing on this before, and I think there's a spot of non-intentional racial stereotyping as well. Not just the blatantly stereotypical Durmstrangs and Beauxbatons but at Hogwarts itself. Token black kid "need a name, think of a famous black person that 20 years ago kids might know! Jordan!" It'd be interesting to see how many Irish kids of that era are called Seamus Finnigan, etc etc. Not suggesting for a second Jk was racist, just that she could have done better.
Harry looks totally unlike the description in the books Has the least messy hair in Hogwarts and his eyes arent green.

Abouttimemum · 21/10/2019 08:50

They’re all class imho. Love those films. Even the dubious acting.
I’m still not over Alan Rickman’s death. Love that man.

HeyMissyYouSoFine · 21/10/2019 08:48

I’m waiting for the day when they are reproduced as a high-quality television series

Hmm - me too now you've put the idea in my head.

I find the first two films nearly unwatchable - but don't mind the later ones there not the greatest films out there but they are not the worst.

The books do have something - a good story rather than great writing maybe- and they've got one of mine reading so I'm glad she wrote them.

riotlady · 21/10/2019 08:47

@ItIsWhatItIsInnit they all turn into weepy drama queens in the books too, around book 4/5- all the stuff with the Yule ball etc and Harry kissing Cho while she cries over Cedric. Which is not a complaint, on my end- I think JK does quite a good job of portraying 14 year olds!

Brefugee · 21/10/2019 08:46

I just want to say that I love Jason Isaacs.

@LaurieMarlow - same. But since that coat-shedding scene in Death of Stalin I can't watch him in Harry Potter. I want him to mince and he doesn't

Brefugee · 21/10/2019 08:45

I just want to say that I love Jason Isaacs.

Fizzypoo · 21/10/2019 08:38

What's the book series called that was written before HP and I've read before on here was just like HP but better? Something about islands and magic schools?

Matildatoldsuchdreadfullies · 21/10/2019 08:38

I always felt Gambon was playing Richard Harris playing Dumbledore, rather than playing Dumbledore, IYSWIM.

LaurieMarlow · 21/10/2019 08:35

I expect it won’t be long before they’re remade in some format.

I can’t watch the fantastic beasts films because they’re such a blatant exercise in cashing in.

TheGoogleMum · 21/10/2019 08:31

Yeah the acting is part the reason ibdont rewatch often even though I love Harry Potter! The books are great. Would love to see them remade very faithfully to the books (I always note when things are missed out or different in the movies) as a cartoon /anime style series.

lazylinguist · 21/10/2019 08:30

Yes the kids are pretty awful, but I love it anyway. The only one that bothers me is Gambon though - he is all wrong as Dumbledore, as previous posters have said. Not only weirdly-delivered lines, but just totally plays the character the wrong way (though I guess that must be largely due to directing).

Pantalaimon88 · 21/10/2019 08:28

The worst line for me is in PS when Harry is looking at Snape and says “say Percy, who is that talking to professor Quirrell?”

It sounds so stilted and awkward, probably because no one has started a sentence with “Say, name?” In the UK for about 50 years. It’s like something from Enid Blyton. So that’s on the screenwriters.

InfiniteSheldon · 21/10/2019 08:27

Worth watching for Rupert Glint alone he was an awesome child actor.

Biancadelrioisback · 21/10/2019 08:25

I struggled with all the kids. I didn't mind Draco and I didn't mind Ron, but the rest just were blargh! I do think it got better as it went on, but shout out to that ridiculously awkward 3 way hug in HPAPOA when they think buckbeak was beheaded.

Matildatoldsuchdreadfullies · 21/10/2019 08:25

Oh, and Kenneth Branagh as Gilderoy Lockhart hammed it up fantastically. He looked like he was having the time of his life.

Matildatoldsuchdreadfullies · 21/10/2019 08:23

Favourite exchange in our household:

“Don’t you think you’re too old for all this Harry Potter malarkey?”
“Who asked your opinion, you filthy little mudblood.”

Ellabella989 · 21/10/2019 08:21

I agree with pp’s that the acting got slightly better as each film went on. The first few are embarrassingly awful. Ron was ok but Harry, Hermione, Draco, the Weasley twins and Ginny were horrendous