Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I feel like I hate my child- abusive ex & parental alienation/ family court

108 replies

faffooo · 05/10/2019 11:00

I know iabu. I need help.

I am devastated. When my ds was little, I left his dad due to extreme emotional, coercive, sexual and psychological abuse. I was a shadow of my former self and couldn't say boo to a goose. It was like coming out of a cult, that was the reach of his control.
I got to a place of safety and did all the right things. Freedom programme, parenting courses, reporting the abuse etc. This was before the law changed re coercive control.

Slowly I rebuilt my confidence, my ds and I had a wonderful period where I could be the nurturing mother I yearned to be and he blossomed, even though he had some problems with separation anxiety. He was an amazing little boy.

Then ex took me to court for child contact.
This is where it all went wrong.
It is seen as more important to have contact with father than the toxic abusive stuff. I had to be seen to be supportive of the relationship or I'd be considered abusive.

Now ds sees his dad regularly and he is not the child he should be. He's now 8 and repeats all the abusive stuff his dad said, in the same voice. He hits me and tries to control every movement I make.
I remind him calmly that we use kind words in this house but he screams at me and wishes I was dead, and that he will celebrate. He destroys the house if I don't do as I'm told.
I know therapeutic parenting works, I've done it. But it gets undermined again and again when going to ex.

I am starting to feel my love trickle away and just want to get away from this awful toxic atmosphere.
I have gone to Ss and school and all they offer is more parenting courses. There is no solution to the elephant in the room- ex.

I wish I had never had him. I am so sad and miss my beautiful boy. I can't go on like this.

Thanks if you've got this far.

OP posts:
MiniMum97 · 05/10/2019 19:09

Have you thought about going to your MP. There have been many many similar threads. The courts should not be allowed to be used as tools by abusive men.

And I agree you should definitely submit the SS evidence.

faffooo · 05/10/2019 15:32

Thanks everyone.
I've managed to exercise and eat something. Self care has been low on the list.
I'm angry at myself for losing it with ds. Worried it'll scar him. I won't be his safe person.
I have a lot of work to do to make it up to him and mend it.

I just don't recognise myself.

OP posts:
RhinoskinhaveI · 05/10/2019 13:52

I agree that his bad behaviour could be interpreted as evidence that he feels safe enough with you to just let everything 'show'
because he's a child he's not intellectually sophisticated enough to grasp and rationalize the way that he is being manipulated by his father, but his unconscious mind knows that something needs to be communicated to you and acting out is a way of doing this.

Puzzledbyart · 05/10/2019 13:41

Did not want to read and run.
I so feel for you, OP. My story is similar, only that the children are a bit younger. They are also acting up massively after every contact (no overnight contact in my case, ex cannot manage it, he's too important to do the boring stuff). I certainly don't hate them, but I do feel somewhat worthless as their parent. "Mum is not right in the head", "mum will soon have another baby with another daddy and will send you to a children's home", "mum only loves money and I instead love you", "you will soon come and live with me in a big big fantastic castle and will have your own pony" (all videoed and submitted by himself as a proof of his close relationship with the children, by the way) - but it was dismissed as "differences in the parenting approach". Last time I was taken to the court for an emergency hearing when ex was 18 hours late for the scheduled contact time, and somehow that still resulted in a couple of hearings and a massive waste of the court's resource.
I even started thinking about having another baby, through a sperm donor, so that it is only "mine" and no one is poisoning their attitude against me. I realise how weak and sick this sounds.

NaviSprite · 05/10/2019 13:28

I'm so sorry you're having to go through this OP and I have little practical advice to your awful circumstances. As a PP has said, the damage being caused by your Ex is also being inflicted on your Son, he's not mature enough yet to see through his Dad so he's parroting his behaviour because he's probably trying to show his worth to the parent that left. DH did this, it was different as his parents were as amicable as possible, but because he spent most of the time with his Mum, his Dad became almost saint like in his mind. He would take out all of his frustrations on his Mum but never question his Dad.

When we spoke about it recently he said that he thinks that because his Father was the parent who he had to travel especially to see, it scared him because if he didn't become the 'perfect son' to appease him, his Dad might leave for good. He didn't see the hurt he was inflicting on his Mum and that was in a situation where both parents tried to be fair.

As for his unsupervised access, have you considered taking him back to court with good representation on your side? I've never been through the court system as an adult (I did as a child but don't remember much of it). I know that there is funding for legal aid if you don't have enough to cover the costs of a solicitor:

childlawadvice.org.uk/information-pages/legal-aid-for-family-law-matters/

And I think the CAB offer advice, but I obviously don't know what avenues you have tried already.

You're doing so well and sound like a loving Mum to me, a loving Mum who dislikes the behaviour being implanted in her son's mind and who wants him to be free of this awful form of manipulation, for both your sakes.

I have read about how the courts minimise domestic violence in these cases and it's actually made me sick to see how womens rights for protection are still so backwards! I hope you can find a way to come through this OP and hopefully, after your Ex sees that it's not affecting you (it is of course but he should never have the satisfaction of knowing that) and that you're keeping on the high road in this situation, he'll run out of steam.

Have there ever been any instances of violence towards/in front of your DS? From what little I understand that is taken more seriously than the mother reporting abuse against herself (which is awful for women who are/have been through such a terrible ordeal). If there is a way to prove that your Exes vile behaviour is having impact on your DS to a point where it's negatively impacting HIS life (such as behaviours at school, grades, getting into fights or anything like that) maybe the courts would take that more seriously.

If they try to comment that 'it'll get better when the routine is set' as a fob off at least this time you can say, that it demonstrably not better now the routine is set, because his behaviour is getting worse the more he is exposed to his 'Father' and so you want access to be supervised?

I wish I could offer more, keep going OP you are so so strong, well done and keep the light on for the little boy you used to know, he's still in there and with the way you have said you handle the situation, he will know in time what your Ex has done.

It doesn't help much when you're in the thick of it, but I would suggest that your DS is acting this way because out of all of the confusion, you are his only true constant. So he is pushing you in all the wrong ways to see if you're going to leave too. It's almost like a self-destructive defence mechanism. His life changed, he can't see it from any other perspective other than that yet, so the one real 'safe space' he has with you, is what he is scared of losing the most. Flowers

RhinoskinhaveI · 05/10/2019 13:26

Faff, to your ex this is all just a game, he is just using your son as a pawn with which to score points over you, I think he will get bored of this game as soon as the downsides start to outweigh the benefits for him.
so what are the benefits and the downsides of the current situation for your ex? Does he genuinely enjoy spending time with your son, or is it more a case that your son is a hindrance to the life he would prefer to be living?
is there any way to make all this just not worth his while?

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 05/10/2019 13:26

faffooo - I'm so sad for you. I have several friends who are in similar positions and you're absolutely right, the system is a disaster for women like you who have escaped from abuse but have a child.

It makes me so angry that you and my friends have to go through this shit, and that your DC have to go through it too. Chances are that your DS is so conflicted and he can't take it out on his Dad so has to take it out on you, because there's no one else. I KNOW that's totally unfair but it is a common reaction.

Is there any way you can access child counselling for him, because it sounds as though he could really do with someone he could tell his true feelings to.

I hate the court system, the way it's all geared towards abusive fucker fathers being allowed full access to their DC, despite the risk to their wellbeing, and the ongoing abuse towards the mothers. And you're 100% right that this is another way for him to control and abuse you - it's nothing to do with your DS, and everything to do with hurting you more.

The court system REALLY needs to wake up to these problems.

The only other advice I would have for you is to remember that your DS is now a victim of your ex as well, not a perpetrator. He's being abused too, just in a different way. And although there is this idea that you should never badmouth the ex, I don't entirely agree with that - at some point your DS is going to work out what a nasty fucker his father is, and it's going to rock his world and his feelings about himself - I feel it's better that you help him to understand that his father's behaviour is not pleasant or right, and that it's his father who chooses to behave like that, not anyone else's fault. ESPECIALLY that it's not DS's fault, or your fault - it's his father's choice. Even if he shouts against you, if you calmly and neutrally convey that information to him in an age-appropriate way, it will sink in.

I hope that you can find a way through this - counselling for you might be useful as well, so that you can offload all your feelings away from your DS, but I know that it's not always that easy to access it.

RueCambon · 05/10/2019 13:24

True. Agree, it is a kindness to set your son straight. He needs to know you're a good person. I'm sure you are creative,empathetic, intelligent, focused. You will get through this. These psychos are vacuums and they feed off the drama of destroying a good person.

Doyoumind · 05/10/2019 13:16

OP your situation is so similar to mine I could have written parts of your post myself, so I feel for you.

I don't have any advice because I understand how the system works and how impossible it is. I think the only solution - which is one of the only things you can control - is to try and get some counselling for yourself to help you deal with these feelings and have some strategies to be able to deal with the situation with your DS.

Counselling for your son might be good but I guess that won't happen if your ex has a say.

PicsInRed · 05/10/2019 13:15

If he says "Daddy said this about you", you are perfectly within legal AND moral bounds to gently, in an age appropriate manner, correct the facts.

It's in fact a kindness to correct lies which are upsetting your child because he hates to think badly of you.

Abusive men count on women saying nothing, ever, even to defend themselves - whilst these bastards defame and slander us to every listening ear within radius - including to our own children. It's time to speak up. Flowers

faffooo · 05/10/2019 13:11

Supervised contact- we started with that. It is not permanent and is staggered with a view to full contact.

OP posts:
faffooo · 05/10/2019 13:09

I also have to say, I am not meant to discuss court proceedings whilst it's going on . It is over so I think I'm ok now, not sure where I stand if he takes me back.
Family court is secret and I could be in contempt. So seeking help is hard whilst you're in it.

OP posts:
RueCambon · 05/10/2019 13:08

I know I'll be criticised for agreeing with @TheDarkPassenger but it did cross my mind as well when I was in these shoes. Go to the west of Ireland. Change your name to something like Sarah White. Or some expat part of spain, or even Gibraltar, or somewhere where you could start again without sticking out like a sore thumb.

faffooo · 05/10/2019 13:05

Child's views- ds was asked whether he wanted overnight contact in front of ex, at the observation. Ds said yes as he didn't want to hurt his feelings.

If the contact was healthy I'd support it. I know I will never win at reducing or stopping contact. It's not how it works.

I need to survive and be healthy for ds until he can decide for himself. I'm finding it so hard at the moment.

OP posts:
GrandmaSteglitszch · 05/10/2019 13:05

ss on my 'side' and wrote to court with their concerns. Unfortunately they don't like being told their job and solicitor advised not to submit as it would put their back up.

This sounds appalling. How can that be right?
I suggest submitting all evidence you have, from professionals involved.
Not submitting it clearly didn't help.

ahagwearsapointybonnet · 05/10/2019 13:03

Is there a possibility that you could push for supervised contact only, even if you can't get contact stopped? Sounds like the supervision improves ex's behaviour. (Apols if you've already tried that!).

RueCambon · 05/10/2019 13:03

This is no help to you but my heart goes out to you reading this. If he drags you back to court, insist that the letter be submitted this time. HOpefully the fact that you held it back the first time will show a judge that you weren't gleefully producing it. Brew

faffooo · 05/10/2019 13:01

Category it's because cafcass are in fact social workers and wouldn't want outside ones coming in to tell them their job. I told ss the situation but in cafcass' eyes it's biased as I'm the only source of info. Cafcass have to be 'balanced'.

OP posts:
TheDarkPassenger · 05/10/2019 13:00

Honestly, I would up and leave and change names and basically run away. I’m all for the law and stuff but sometimes, like your situation, you just gotta do what you gotta do.

yesteaandawineplease · 05/10/2019 12:58

Sad this system is despicable that it puts the rights of the father to see his child over what's in the best interests of the child. it isn't in a child's internet to have to see an abusive parent. agree with the pp also that I don't understand the logic that an abusive partner will be a good parent. beggars belief.

GrandmaSteglitszch · 05/10/2019 12:57

he gets angry and says he hates ex and he hits him and being forced to go is horrible.

It sounds as if he's angry with you for not letting him stop seeing ex.
As a child, of course he doesn't understand why he's being made to do this.

I confess to knowing nothing about this but wonder if you can get counseling for DS that would reveal how he feels about the contact with ex.
Aren't courts meant to take the child's views into account?

faffooo · 05/10/2019 12:56

Thank you so much for your supportive words. I feel so ashamed of myself.
I have strong moral values of compassion and kindness and I feel sick that this situation is changing me. I feel disconnected from my values. Values I want ds to learn.

I am an intelligent, creative person. I can't seem to navigate my way out of this.

OP posts:
category12 · 05/10/2019 12:55

I'd try to find ds a mentor or counsellor and hope he discloses the physical abuse to them.

category12 · 05/10/2019 12:53

I find it mindbending that you were advised not to take forward the SS's letter of concern with the court. Aren't they supposed to be the experts? Confused.

I'm so sorry you're going through this. Your ds is being abused and I'm so sorry that the court are enabling it.