Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for honest opinions of vbac after emcs.

117 replies

Rubberyduck · 03/09/2019 14:26

Crappy first birth, 4days long resulting in failed forceps and ecms. Me and DS then had septicemia so we had a 10day stint in Hosp. I am now expecting no.2. Mw said straight up 'you will want another csection then' we have a consultant appointment in a few weeks to discuss the choices. DH seems keen to have a elective c section as it would be 'easier' to plan around our 2year old obviously worrying we will have a similar long experience. I am concerned about recovering from surgery with 2 little one's.

Experiences please?

OP posts:
beccarocksbaby · 03/09/2019 20:39

I'm having this same debate, 33 hours failed induction, sepsis and 14 days in hospital, external pacing etc.

I wanted a home birth this time but MN have talked me out of it (I posted in another forum about it), I'm still considering a VBAC though but it scares me.

My last birth was 13 years ago so a lot has changed I imagine in that time including my body.

Mumoftwoyoungkids · 03/09/2019 20:18

I had a VBAC. It was great. Bloody hurt but was great.

My odds were good though - I was fairly young, very healthy and the reason that my first birth was a C-section was baby related rather than my body related. I had also got to 9 cm dilated with my first birth before the clock ran down and so my body knew what to do up until that point. (And I very much had a “second birth” ie much quicker and easier - up until 9 cms.)

Teachermaths · 03/09/2019 20:14

@Rubberyduck

Thanks for this thread.

I am facing the same decision. I'm leaning towards VBAC due to the horrendous recovery from EMCS. I took 5 months to heal Sad

I just can't make my mind up and sort of hope the consultant will find something that forces me either way.

1CantPickAName · 03/09/2019 20:11

I had a vbac after emcs. I had limited recovery time after the 2nd as had to get back to work swiftly (self employed) so I did a lot of research. I was very surprised to read the high percentage of emcs that happened if you were induced with your second baby, if your first was an emcs. I stayed very active during my second pregnancy, I took raspberry leaf tablets from 37 weeks and I had planned to use the birthing pool at the hospital when the time came. I also had an appointment to book a cs if I hadn’t gone into labour by my due date. As it happens, I went into labour at 38weeks and my baby was a very quick, unplanned home birth. 2 hours in labour and I was up washing floors and cooking dinner later that day!

Good luck ☘️

OrangeSlices998 · 03/09/2019 20:10

Having gotten to fully dilated is a helpful factor for a VBAC - if you want one of course. Ultimately, don’t make a decision based on MN or people’s experiences here, what matters is the evidence (look up the RCOG guideline for VBAC if you haven’t already) and speak to the consultant and/or midwife about your own risk factors and decide based on that. As a former midwife, I’ve seen lots of successful VBACs and some that weren’t, based on lots of factors. One thing to bear in mind is that opting for a VBAC obviously doesn’t guarantee it. And an ELCS doesn’t automatically mean you’re absolutely risk free either, you could still bleed heavily, for example.

Good luck, whatever you decide

Chocolatecakes · 03/09/2019 20:08

I had a vbac for dc2 with continuous foetal monitoring and it went really well and I would do the same again. Saying that I had spoken with the consultant and midwife before hand and was100% sure it was the right choice

Thisismyusernamefornow · 03/09/2019 20:06

My first was 48 hour labour and ended in emcs when I got to pushing stage and wasn't progressing plus the pain relief had only worked down one side.

Fast forward 3 years I had a very quick labour with planned natural birth. Start to finish was about 5 hours, gas and air and a very quick push.

Recovery was not much different to the first time to be honest. A very different experience to my first labour though. Some of it was managed by more realistic expectations.

Hiredandsqueak · 03/09/2019 20:01

I had three VBACS after ELCS no problems at all tbh and much preferred the easier recovery. Had continuous monitoring, with two I had syntocin drip as waters went and no contractions and one I had prostin as was ten days overdue but all deliveries were unassisted.

Rubberyduck · 03/09/2019 19:21

Thanks. I am 33 and my bmi is just over 30. Having not had a successful vaginal delivery despite being fully dilated according to online NHS advice there is less than 40% success rate for vbac. Something to discuss with the consultant.

OP posts:
Mejse · 03/09/2019 18:18

My first was back to back and arrived by emcs after getting stuck.

I went back and forth about what I wanted once I was pregnant with my second. I had similar feelings to you about the previous birth, like I had failed and that some how having a vbac would fill this hole. On the other hand I knew what to expect with a csection and I would be able to know the date, which would make childcare much easier.

The consultant appointment was very reassuring, I decided on a vbac and we went over what would happen in different scenarios.

Once I went overdue the doubt started to set in and I was worrying that it would be the same as last time. Also not knowing when it was going to happen was stressing me out.

I went in on the Wednesday and was at 4cms but nothing progressed so I was sent home. I cried and said that I was starting to feel like I should have just gone with an elective so the midwife booked me in for an appointment in the morning to discuss my options.

The next day I was still having the same mild contractions that I had the day before. At the appoinment we agreed that I would come back the next morning to break my waters then see how things went. She said she needed to check me before letting me go and I was at 6cm by that point so they said I couldn't go home.

4 hours later I was holding my baby. The vbac ended up going very smoothly and he was out after 15mins of pushing (its easier if you were fully dilated the first time round).

I do have to say though that once he was there I was just happy he was there safe, the way he got there didn't matter in the slightest. Having a vbac wasn't a fix to what I had been feeling.

cantkeepawayforever · 03/09/2019 17:40

It is a long time ago now - DS about to go off to university - but DD was a 'textbook' vbac after DS was an emergency c-section.

We have a habit of moving house around due dates, so having moved when DS was 6 weeks old (and yes, I did lie on the operating table thinking 'and I'm due to move to another country in a month and a half...how is this going to work???') we were also due to move 2 weeks before DD's due date. I know that, with everything that goes around a house move, the stronger and more mobile that I could be post delivery, the better.

It really helped that there was a clear reason for my CS with DS - he had (still has) an exceptionally large head, and simply got stuck. We're talking 'head the right size for a 6 month old, way off the centile charts' here, not the odd cm or two.

So we had a clear plan, put together and documented with the initial consultants and then reviewed by the consultants in the new hospital after we moved. DD's head was scanned in a late scan. If it had been large, I would have had an elective section. If it turned out to be average, I would have a trial of vaginal labour, with a very low threshold for going straight for c-section.

DD's head was 50th centile, which gave me huge 'yes,I can do this' confidence going into labour. She was born about an hour or so after we reached hospital, absolutely textbook delivery, and I was home within 24 hours.

[Then she refused to feed and DS got first severe croup and then a really scary chest infection and we ended up in and out of medical care for quite some time, and I ended up with PND and hallucinations due to sleep deprivation, but the BIRTH bit at least went to plan!!]

2beautifulbabs · 03/09/2019 17:24

I had a vbac birth with my first and it was a horrible experience I had to be induced because my DS didn't want to arrive was two weeks overdue and was put on the hormone drip having had my waters broken because of the failed induction resulted in a long drawn out labour with lots of pain killers and then finally going to theatre for forceps which almost failed and went to go onto an emergency c section I lost over 2 ltrs of blood and ended up with a 3rd degree tear and having a birth experience which wasn't all that great the amount of stress and upset it caused

My second birth was a planned c section and it was amazing i was so calm and with it the staff were amazing and I got to cuddle my DD and actually remember her birth wasn't out of it on drugs and we were all home within 24 hours I finally got to experience a happy birth

So please don't feel like you've failed in any way there are so many things that can go just as wrong with a vaginal birth it's not always smooth sailing and the most important thing is mother and baby are good not how the baby arrived all the best OP with the rest of your pregnancy Smile

MitziK · 03/09/2019 17:23

My vbac was fine. In on Thursday, came home on Friday (because madam took her time in coming out, so they offered me a bed for the night to have a kip), was doing the school run and carrying the pram up and down the five flights of stairs to and from the front door on Monday.

It just felt so normal, compared to the experience of a planned section, wound infection, pain and trying to BF with a grouchy, jaundiced baby, an incision that reopened two days later and a generally shit hospital.

Had it been like that the first time, I'd have had my second about five years sooner, as it took me that long to even contemplate the idea again.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 03/09/2019 17:23

I think it's so personal. My first sounds like yours, long labour with a back to back baby, failed forceps and then an emcs at full dilation. I still don't consider myself to have given birth to him and I really struggled emotionally with that. It felt like I'd failed motherhood 101 and that I didn't deserve him so I tried to leave him in NICU (I was rather ill at the time).

I flip flopped all over the place with dc2 and in end, having been told that my issues likely stemmed from my flatter than optimal pelvis/his giant head I booked an elective as this baby's head was also measuring 90 plus percentile. I went into labour ahead of my section date and ended up with a lovely semi elective section where I got to see her come out and have skin to skin virtually straight away. The bottom line for me was I just couldn't go through that again, all that pain, the NICU stay that dc1 ended up with, the uncertainity, the guilt and whilst it might have worked, there was no guarentee. As it happened, dc2 came out so wrapped in the cord (around her neck, arm and torso about 3 to 4 times) and was already starting to show signs of distress with each contraction, they said even if she could have made it through my pelvis, I'd more than likely ended up with an emergency section prior to that.

I was lucky with both as I had 2 very easy physical recoveries and with no issues/infections.

Was your septicemia due to your waters have been gone a while? Mine were 81 hours from breaking to dc1's delivery and that's why he went to NICU.

Frustratedandworried · 03/09/2019 17:19

My 4th DC was a VBAC however a very risky one given I was only 34weeks, had an EMCS 19months before and was induced using the hormonal drip at a reasonably hefty dose ..all of which I have been told are indicators NOT to have a VBAC.

The delivery itself went well although little one was born with sepsis and pneumonia and we almost lost him as a a result of other negligence Hmm

SweetAsSpice · 03/09/2019 17:15

EMCS after a failed induction followed by an ELCS. DS was also 2 whilst I was pregnant. Wasn’t interested in entertaining the idea of trying for a VBAC with the various complications, and didn’t want to end up with another EMCS.

ELCS - although I was really sick after (which is no fucking joke with stitches across half your body) recovery was significantly quicker. I knew my limits this time and was prepared with all of the recovery items.

Whilst pregnant I taught 2 year old to climb in and out of bath, on and off toilet, on and off step up high chair, etc with the use of a step to minimise the temptation to lift them/pick them up in those first few weeks.

Haworthia · 03/09/2019 17:10

Speaking as someone who had 1. a waterbirth and 2. an elective section, have the elective section. I swallowed all that guff about natural births being amazing and empowering and assisted/caesarean births being horrors and, frankly, it’s a load of bollocks. I would have ten c sections over one natural labour.

My natural birth ended in third degree tear and the recovery and postnatal care was horrific. Begged for an elective section for #2 because I was so terrified of another vaginal birth and it was a dream. It was fantastic. So stress free. I walked into the operating theatre healthy and well rested (as opposed as battered and sleepless after X hours of labour) and everything was just textbook. Recovery was no worse than a third degree tear. It was arguably slightly easier, and the midwives took better care of me afterwards too.

MerryChristmasHarry · 03/09/2019 17:04

In your shoes, I'd think about the factors that would influence my odds of a straightforward VB and about the risks and benefits in my situation. So how old are you, what do you weigh, do you want more children. The older and heavier you are, the less likely a straightforward VB is, on average. Also one of the main risks of CS is small increase in future risk of pregnancy loss, which might matter a lot to you or not at all.

These are all only on a population level, so there's no guarantees of anything, but it's worth arming yourself with info about risks and benefits as they apply to someone with your characteristics.

SunshineCake · 03/09/2019 16:55

With kindness, you are being daft thinking you have failed DS1. He doesn't care how he was born!!

SunshineCake · 03/09/2019 16:54

I had an unexpected emergency section. Baby number 2 was born 2 1/3 years later and it was assumed I would have a section and could without fuss if I wanted. I told my consultant I didn't want one so he said I didn't have to but one was booked in anyway for five days after my due date.

I naturally went into labour at six days late and dd was born. Stupid midwife pulled the cord which snapped so I ended up in hospital for two days. Purely because f the snapped cord I had a retained placenta and one isn't allowed home for 48 hours after a procedure.

Twenty months later I had baby number three. I was given a set time to get him out or it would be a section. I got him out fifteen minutes after the deadline but my scar nearly ruptured. Midwife advised us to have no more children.

I am utterly convinced the scar issue was due to the botch repair and needing another operation after baby number one.

I would say the choice about VBAC or planned section is usually down to why the section was needed in the first place. I remember a neighbour having baby number two had a section with number one and was told she'd never be able to give birth vaginally due to the size of her hips. Baby number two was not a section.

whattodowith · 03/09/2019 16:47

You haven’t failed anyone, there are no medals awarded for birthing a baby from your vagina! You tried, it didn’t work and an EMCS was the safest option.

Imo an ELCS would be far safer, I wouldn’t risk a VBAC but it’s completely up to you.

Rubberyduck · 03/09/2019 16:44

Thanks all. I do think DH has been traumatised by the process so I am thinking of him too. He was back and forth like a yoyo those days and he was obviously very stressed.

I have my consultant appointment later this month so will do some reading before then. I appreciate you all sharing your experiences.

Best of luck to those in the same position.

OP posts:
acquiescence · 03/09/2019 16:20

I had a vbac after an emcs. I declined continuous monitoring unless there was a clear reason, it wasn’t necessary.

My labour was around 7 hours from first contraction, he came too fast to get in the birthing pool or have an epidural. I had a 3rd degree tear which wasn’t pleasant but healed very well. This meant I needed an epidural after giving birth to be stitched up properly. I had a mild prolapse which I found very stressful in the early months. I don’t regret it despite these issues and am pleased that I was able to experience a drug free natural birth. However there is nothing wrong with an elective c section, but it needs to be your decision. My husband was also keen for me to have an elcs because it would be ‘easier’ and he found the experience of my first (36 hour) labour more stressful than me by the sounds of it.

Knitclubchatter · 03/09/2019 16:19

Dd had a beautiful vbac, she really wanted a vd as her toddler loved being picked up/carried. She couldn’t imaging how she’d manage post-op so thought vbac was the way to go.
Lives in London, went into labor rush hour on a weekday morning. By the time she made it to the hospital she was probably fully dilated, a bit of faffing about with putting in an epidural and the little one was born 1:10 minutes after arriving at the hospital. It was a beautiful delivery. Dd reached between her legs and (with a little help) delivered the baby herself.
But I agree it’s a person choice to try it or not and it doesn’t work out for everyone.

Metempsychosis · 03/09/2019 16:12

I had a forceps VBAC. Fairly messy birth, but a quick recovery and no long term damage done. TBH though, if I knew then what I know now I’d have gone for ELCS.