Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think creates mentally healthy children?

133 replies

Trickedia · 01/09/2019 22:24

I don’t know if that’s worded correctly. But I hope you get where im going. What do you think is important to create a happy home that children can thrive in & grow into confident/happy adults?

I have 2 young children & am terrified of screwing them up (due to my own screwed up childhood.) I don’t want them to grow up with issues. I want them to make the absolute best of themselves.

I know nothing is guaranteed, but what do you think is important?

A calm/predictable home & family?
Lots of Encouragement/praise?
Knowing your family are always there for you?

... they’re the most important thing to me & I want to get this right. I don’t ever want them to feel the way I did.

Mumsnet has such wisdom at times & im hoping for some pearls!

OP posts:
Silverbirch2 · 28/04/2022 17:17

I think the biggest thing is resilience. Things will happen- they wont be first, wont be invited, they wont included and wont be good enough at some point in their lives. They need to keep going, learn to fail and continue- persevere.
I'm a teacher, the amount of children who cant cope with being the first/best so give up and then blame mental health issues is worrying!

Littlemissprosecco · 28/04/2022 17:05

My grandma said this to me when I had my first…
” listen to the little things when they are little, don’t dismiss them. Then they’ll tell you the big things when they’re big.
For to them……they were always the big things”
Sadly she never met my other two, but those words really ring true

zingally · 28/04/2022 16:48

Boundaries, routine and consistency.

StarDolphins · 28/04/2022 14:41

I didn’t have a good childhood (alcoholic mother with MH issues that I couldn’t go to with anything - I even hid having nits from her until I was infested because I was too scared to tell her)

so I am utterly determined to give my little girl the opposite- a stable, consistent & loving home where I hope she can tell me anything - I find affection doesn’t come naturally but I force myself to show it & I always tell her (& show) how much I love her.

I think being able to cope with life’s ups & downs is important to teach & to be treated right by others.

playing (especially outdoors!) is a big thing for me too!

Enb76 · 28/04/2022 14:06

My one piece of advice is when offering praise, instead of just saying you're are proud of them, say that they should be proud of themselves for whatever it is that they have achieved - it will mean, in the long run, that their self-esteem will be built on what pleases them and not what pleases other people.

I do tell my daughter that I'm proud of her but when she's done something amazing (in my eyes this happens often) I tend to say something along the lines of... 'wow, that's amazing, you should be really proud of what you've accomplished here. All that hard work has really paid off.'

notanotherbloodystreetparty · 28/04/2022 14:05

Being born outside the UK and its education system.

The UK is 69th in the world for children's mental health.

69th.

That is more than parenting or genes or luck.

That is a messed up environment in which children are being brought up. Research suggests it is the education system with 100% exams at 16 and 18 with very high stakes.

nokidshere · 28/04/2022 14:01

What do you think is important to create a happy home that children can thrive in & grow into confident/happy adults? I have 2 young children & am terrified of screwing them up (due to my own screwed up childhood.) I don’t want them to grow up with issues. I want them to make the absolute best of themselves.

There are lots of great thoughts on this thread, all of which may or may not work in your home.

However, it's really important that you know, regardless of what you do or don't do, that your children aren't you. They are individuals and that's really important. They could have the best childhood in the world and still have issues, the best education and role models that money can buy but no motivation to do anything. Or they could have the worst childhood and reach great success & happiness.

You are not the only influence on your child, and external influences can often have greater impact than your own, especially during the teen years. In reality it doesn't matter what you want for them, they will be who they will be and all you can do is love and support the person they become.

Be careful that you don't have unrealistic expectations of them or they might end up feeling your disappointment if things don't work out as you have planned (even if it's just in your head).

Jinglebin1 · 28/04/2022 10:36

MsAwesomeDragon · 01/09/2019 22:36

I think love and stability have a lot to do with it.
Knowing your parents will do anything in their power to help you with any problems you're having.

Then a lot of it is down to luck as well. I have 2 dds, and both of them suffer from anxiety to some degree and the older one (19) has also suffered from depression as well this year. I think they have both had fairly decent childhoods, with an awful lot of love and stability in their lives. Sometimes their own personality/genes override anything you can do.

Dd2 started showing signs of anxiety as a baby/toddler, being very distrustful of any adults outside her immediate family and not talking/smiling at anyone. She had selective mutism (an anxiety problem) at the age of 3!!! Honestly there was nothing we could have done to prevent that, it's not as if she'd had anything other than loving and engaged parents, and a wonderful childminder, so her toddler years were very, very stable, but she was still incredibly anxious. She's 9 now and is coming out the other side of the selective mutism, having had a lot of input from preschool, school, childminder, us. She talks to everyone at school, childminders house (regulars only), Brownie's (I am snowy owl, so it's easier), etc. She still doesn't often talk in bigger, busier situations, won't talk to staff in shops etc, but we're working on it, small steps and bribery.

These are all signs of of autism...

TinyChipolata · 03/09/2019 08:55

Keep a division between children and adults.

I see a lot of people who think they are "open and honest" with their children, only they are taking it too far.

Children below a certain age don't want to know about how you're financially struggling or about your marriage problems or about all the horrible things that happen in the world.

Obviously you have to explain to some extent - "no you can't have the toy, we have to pay for the car to be fixed this week" but no need for a 45 minute explanation of your finances or of all the ways your husband is annoying you.

Some things you can't hide, and nor should you, but I'd say 75% of the stuff I've heard parents "explain" to their child, they should have kept to themselves.

In my experience, kids don't want to know, they don't understand the full context of most adult issues, and it leads to anxiety as they feel powerless

FudgeBrownie2019 · 03/09/2019 08:27

Being heard
Being loved
Being given boundaries

I think having happy parents who have positive relationships with those around them makes it more likely they'll model those relationships. And I think helping them fix their mistakes rather than guilting them for them makes life so much better; we've had a bit of a shitshow over the last week from DS1 who is 13. Rather than guilt or shame him, we worked out a way to put it right and moved on. I'm hopeful that he's learned far more than he would have from a bollocking.

The other thing for me is always being their biggest fan. Not in a braggy way, because nobody wants to hear braggy parents. But in a quiet "you've got this" way. I let mine push themselves and take risks and make decisions when it's suitable because I believe that they're smarter and stronger than we know.

thatlldodotpig · 03/09/2019 08:18

I'd add to the book recommendations 'Simplicity Parenting' - can't remember the author, but a good insight into how to create a stable base for kids

BertieBotts · 03/09/2019 06:54

And I agree it's not about shielding or preventing every bad feeling or experience, it's about supporting them through those so that they learn good skills to deal with the hard times too.

But obviously you can't prevent everything but I think all of this would give them the best chance.

BertieBotts · 03/09/2019 06:51

I'd suggest that three books would be worth reading; unconditional parenting by Alfie kohn, why love matters by sue Gerhardt and no bad kids by Janet lansbury. Maybe how to talk so kids will listen as well and taking children seriously (I forget the author).

NotAProperGrownUp · 02/09/2019 23:02

Love, support, information.
Negotiating boundaries as they get older. Giving them the information to help them make good choices. Letting them experience (safe) consequences of poor choices.
Being open to discussion - answering questions openly and easily.
Encourage an understanding or the wider world beyond the family and community.
Modelling an ability to say sorry when you mess up.

CheerfulMuddler · 02/09/2019 19:51

I agree with most of what's been said on this thread. (Except the point about being a sahp - the research says being in childcare makes small differences to children - both positive and negative - but any differences even out by about seven.)

Be warm and loving, but provide clear consistent boundaries. Let your kids run around and take risks. Give them as much freedom as you can trust them with. Allow them to make mistakes. Support them to do things that scare them.

Provide as many loving adults in their lives as possible. Give them a chance to do a hobby they choose for themselves. Accept them for who they are and help them be the best version of that.

And recognise that you aren't trying to shield your child from shit. Shit happens. You could give them a perfect upbringing, and they still get hit by a car aged ten and ends up with crippling PTSD. You are trying to teach them how to deal with shit when it does happen, as it inevitably will.

And look after yourself and your relationship too. If you and your partner are happy and secure, that makes a huge difference. Growing up in an unhappy family is very hard, no matter how good at parenting your parents are.

StormBaby · 02/09/2019 14:52

Thanks @Cakemadeoffruit and @milliefiori, I guess we can only try our best. Sad

looselegs · 02/09/2019 14:16

Suitable boundaries at every different age- and stick to them. Kids need to feel secure and boundaries really help.
Talk to them- don't make any subject taboo.
And listen to them, so they know they can talk to you.
Don't 'big' them up too much. Don't keep telling them they're amazing/wonderful all the time, and after they do everything. It makes them self centred . Praise them where its needed- when they've worked hard at something and done well for example, not just for tidying toys up. DO NOT be afraid to tell them if they've upset you, or done something you're not happy about- that's life: it's not always going to be a bed of roses. Likewise, they need to learn that sometimes they have to do things that they don't like doing, or don't want to do, but it's tough. We go through life having to do things we don't want to do that we can't get out of.
And no means no!

UnaCorda · 02/09/2019 14:05

Be able to apologise and to admit when you're wrong (not necessarily the same thing).

Cakemadeoffruit · 02/09/2019 13:03

@stormbaby please don't say you have failed, you haven't! Far from it, you were able to change the pattern from your childhood and that is quite simply amazing and something you should be proud of. Not all mental health issues are learnt, and all the skill sets and learning in the world can't change chemistry. You can only continue being there for them Flowers

milliefiori · 02/09/2019 12:15

@StormBaby - we try our best though. Like you I had a very difficult childhood - was mainly neglected, so I overcompensated and am a bit like the mother a PP said is disastrous, who makes her her child's emotion the centre of the universe (guilty) Blush. I've been back pedalling to try and undo this.
And my dad, horrible though he was, was actually trying to be a better parent to us than he had. He hated boarding school so he insisted we went to a normal local comp. Didn't work for me at all, but his aim was well-intentioned.

StormBaby · 02/09/2019 12:12

Honestly a few years ago I thought I had it all right and was a bit smug. My children were happy, well adjusted, doing well at school. They were all encouraged to be themselves and follow their dreams etc. I'd split from ex-h but we were still good friends, Co parenting well 50/50 and I have a calm, happy, chilled out life. Ive always worked hard to provide for them and we live in a nice town with good schools.

However, I now have 3 kids with issues as they've got older. I don't think you can get it right really. It's a sad state of affairs but ultimately they're human beings, there's only so much you can do. I had an abusive childhood with a psychotic mother and I've tried my best to be the complete opposite and have failed.

nevernotstruggling · 02/09/2019 11:59

I only know what I do with my girls. Feeling stable is everything and I tell them daily I will always be there..
Back along dd1 didn't get picked for something and was very upset. I needed to think about it for a while but in the end I told her that as an adult you remember the times you did get picked much more and the times you were overlooked will fade. Sure enough she won a writing prize soon after that only she could have been picked for. She said 'you were right mummy x doesn't matter any more this is better'. I think a strengths perspective can work really well

Ponoka7 · 02/09/2019 11:57

"Planned pregnancy in first place so the child is wanted and welcomed by both parents."

Unfortunately I've known IVF babies who've been abandoned by one of their Parents.

Herocomplex · 02/09/2019 11:50

AmIright - yes you are. Praise for effort and improvement. Instead of ‘you’re so clever’ it’s better to say ‘ I can see you’ve really thought about that and come up with a clever solution’
In that way children trust their process and ability to solve things, rather than just the generic and rather meaningless ‘clever’.

AmIRightOrAMeringue · 02/09/2019 10:59

I'd actually say not too much praise. Stuff one read says to be realistic in praise and specific. For example 'I saw how hard you tried prqcticing for your spelling test' is better than saying 'you're fantastic at spelling' as they know they were good on the day and it puts pressure on them and gives them a fear of failure and expectation of always needing praise to do something. Apparently!