Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think creates mentally healthy children?

133 replies

Trickedia · 01/09/2019 22:24

I don’t know if that’s worded correctly. But I hope you get where im going. What do you think is important to create a happy home that children can thrive in & grow into confident/happy adults?

I have 2 young children & am terrified of screwing them up (due to my own screwed up childhood.) I don’t want them to grow up with issues. I want them to make the absolute best of themselves.

I know nothing is guaranteed, but what do you think is important?

A calm/predictable home & family?
Lots of Encouragement/praise?
Knowing your family are always there for you?

... they’re the most important thing to me & I want to get this right. I don’t ever want them to feel the way I did.

Mumsnet has such wisdom at times & im hoping for some pearls!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DollyBook · 28/04/2022 23:05

Silverbirch2 · 28/04/2022 17:17

I think the biggest thing is resilience. Things will happen- they wont be first, wont be invited, they wont included and wont be good enough at some point in their lives. They need to keep going, learn to fail and continue- persevere.
I'm a teacher, the amount of children who cant cope with being the first/best so give up and then blame mental health issues is worrying!

I too am uncomfortable with this sort of statement although there is some truth in it. Each child has a different genetic predisposition, different levels of ability and different family set ups in terms of wealth, privilege, family's social and cultural capital etc. Those who are not so blessed in regards to these factors operate from a huge deficit. A child that has undiagnosed dyslexia or is neurodiverse has to manage so many more social challenges, kids are mean and will make them feel unvalued and often adults, while well meaning, can be quite ignorant about children's unique challenges.

Encouraging kids to keep going, not give up, work hard is all great but if the world is persistently challenging for a child due to their personal circumstances, it's the world that needs to become kinder and more enabling. I hate the 'be kind' advertising slogans everywhere but in a kind society people look after each other, there will be support and assistive structures for disabled children, access to food and basic needs are met reliably and without humiliation. Parents today face many challenges, time poverty if both are working and economic poverty if parents are not in work. Workplaces have become insanely demanding and ridiculously inhumane so working parents' mental health is often not great.

We are all in this together, you don't just teach a child resilience you make resilience happen.

People need the ability to cope in order to deal with life's stresses. When an individual believes he or she has the resources to respond effectively to the challenges they experience and develop resilience and confidence. We as parents but also society as a whole need to provide these resources by putting well thought out support structures in place. This does not mean everyone has got to be a winner all the time but it means having a context where we experience connection and support.

When children experience challenge after challenge they will burn out and develop PTSD.

5128gap · 28/04/2022 20:52

MangyInseam · 28/04/2022 20:35

I do think stability is big for kids.

Praise can be over-done - there is some good research that suggests that it can actually make kids feel less secure.

I agree. The praise needs to be authentic and deserved, otherwise it loses value.
I think its also very difficult for people who've had their mediocre efforts and achievements praised to the hilt, when they inevitably enter an environment where certain standards are the expectation, and not everything they do receives a round of applause.

MangyInseam · 28/04/2022 20:35

I do think stability is big for kids.

Praise can be over-done - there is some good research that suggests that it can actually make kids feel less secure.

notanothertakeaway · 28/04/2022 20:33

Zombie thread from 2019, but still relevant

Children need to feel safe, settled and secure. Predictable routines are helpful. And consistent boundaries

Praise effort, not results

Criticise behaviour, not the child

Share some of your own disappointment, and how you dealt with it eg "I was a bit upset today because X. To make myself feel better, I did Y"

Encourage them to read

Sport is great for resilience. Sometimes, you do your best but the other team are better. And next week, you go back and try again

Badger1970 · 28/04/2022 20:23

I think it's routine, stability and boundaries.

I made plenty of mistakes bringing mine up, but they're healthy grounded and happy adults. I couldn't ask for more than that.

There's no such thing as a perfect parent - just being one that your DC can trust is enough.

5128gap · 28/04/2022 20:18

Trickedia · 01/09/2019 22:38

It’s hard isn’t it to find the balance between parent & friend? I want them to always come to me with anything & not feel judged but equally I want them to respect me & the rules.

It’s probably something lots of people find hard to balance, I know I can be to soft which isn’t necessarily terrible now, but when I have 2 teenage daughters I might regret it 🤦🏼‍♀️

Be authentic and genuine. You are not a stepford mum, you are a person with your own rights, values, and ethics. When they cross your boundaries or make you feel disrespected or hurt, or do something you disagree with, let them know and let them know why.
Have as few rules as possible, make them about personal safety and respect and consideration for others (nothing else matters when it comes down to it), but make them non negotiable. Impose sanctions when they're breeched.

wonkygorgeous · 28/04/2022 19:45

Connection with caregivers. Feeling they are heard and they have a voice.
A parent sincerely apologising when they get it wrong.
Feeling valued.
Parents modelling good behaviours including communicating with each other.

DockOTheBay · 28/04/2022 19:22

I think the most important thing is a secure attachment to a parent figure.
It goes hand in hand with all sort of important things - good self esteem, strong trusting relationships.

Brieandcamembert · 28/04/2022 19:16

Stable home environment. Having boundaries, structure, routine, discipline but being able to challenge yourself.

Above all else though having calm, mentally healthy parents.

anon2334 · 28/04/2022 19:15

The home us very important so all you've mentioned but sadly the system isn't all that great here. School is too pushy and often a big reason for mental health problems in children and the rat race of the parents. Other countries thrive bette, starting school later, not pushing their kids or putting pressure on them yet its not talked about. Finish magazine did an article on this and and UK was bottom of the list. Their school system Is amazing where kids play until their around 7 then formal learning. Apparently works wonders for mental health

Wandamakesporridge · 28/04/2022 19:12

The very fact you’ve asked this means I think you’ll be ok!

I have 3 kids including teenagers who so far (fingers crossed) seem to be fairly level headed kids. We have had severe mental health issues in the wider family so I am very aware of the devastation it can cause, so your question is something that resonates with me and that I have often pondered.

I agree with the poster who said that we shouldn’t expect to be happy all the time and our mental health can go up and down in the same way as our physical health. I think there is a danger amongst children of thinking that if you feel sad or anxious that this is wrong and you have a mental health problem. All emotions are valid, the problem is only when these emotions overwhelm us and we can’t live our lives.

Anyway back on topic. My tops tips;

For a start a stable home, where they feel safe and loved.

Be willing to learn - read parenting books (but you don’t have to agree with it all!); look to other parents who you feel are doing a good job; be aware of how you were brought up (what did your parents get right / wrong?); and if your parenting techniques aren’t working, be open minded to change them.

Routines, boundaries, rules all help kids feel safe - but don’t be a tyrant!

if you have a partner, work as a team, agree on parenting between you, and both of you must be willing to discuss / compromise

Don’t burden your kids with too many of your own worries. That’s what your partner & friends are for.

You are their parent, you don’t need to be their best friend too. You are their advocate, their rock, their role model. Not their best mate.

Take an interest in them and their likes. Spend time with them doing things they are interested in. Praise their efforts. Show you enjoy being with them. This helps their self-confidence so much.

But also keep your own friends and interests (not so easy when they are small) as I don’t think it’s healthy to be solely focused on kids.

And don’t panic when things don’t go to plan.. the only guarantee is just when you think you’ve cracked it, something will come along to throw everything off balance again! I just try and think of it as life’s ups and downs.
If they are struggling, that’s ok - life is not easy - your job is to work out how to help them develop the skills they need to cope with life’s struggles.

Finally have fun! Be silly! Laughter is a great tonic.

JuicyBuffersElasticNut · 28/04/2022 19:01

TheGlitterati · 28/04/2022 17:57

Oh and please never share money worries. It makes me so sad when I hear children say ‘oh I must take good care of this because my mum really couldn’t afford it’ or ‘my mum said she couldn’t afford for me to have xyz’. I find it heartbreaking. Kids should be kids.

However, it's also important for children to learn the value of things.

changeyourusernameag · 28/04/2022 18:51

The environment you grow in needs to be right then everything else will follow

SanLor3nz0 · 28/04/2022 18:27

I couldn’t disagree more re resilience. Ill
informed twaddle.I have 2 children under Cahms.They are the most resilient kids I know. Life events, circumstances and genes play a big part. Suspect smug parenting could do too.

Oblomov22 · 28/04/2022 18:02

I too like that resilience post.

Newgirls · 28/04/2022 17:59

Silverbirch2 · 28/04/2022 17:17

I think the biggest thing is resilience. Things will happen- they wont be first, wont be invited, they wont included and wont be good enough at some point in their lives. They need to keep going, learn to fail and continue- persevere.
I'm a teacher, the amount of children who cant cope with being the first/best so give up and then blame mental health issues is worrying!

This is so wise.

they won’t always get their way. Or get the friend. Or be chosen for a play or a team. We need to be ready to help them move past that and put it in perspective

TheGlitterati · 28/04/2022 17:57

Oh and please never share money worries. It makes me so sad when I hear children say ‘oh I must take good care of this because my mum really couldn’t afford it’ or ‘my mum said she couldn’t afford for me to have xyz’. I find it heartbreaking. Kids should be kids.

Onionpatch · 28/04/2022 17:54

I am a believer in attachment theory. I think children need to feel safe their needs will be met.

I also think mental health isnt something you either have or dont have, just like physical health. Across a whole lifetime most people will experience some poor mental health. So i suppose giving your child tools to find support and help themselves would be good too.

TheGlitterati · 28/04/2022 17:54

Always listen and let their feelings and thoughts be heard so they don’t feel like they’re in a dictatorship, that they are an equal member of the family.

No hitting.

don’t shout at them for expressing their feelings. Encourage them to find their voices and express it in a better, safer way but let them express it.

always talk to them with kindness and respect. Manners at all times. If you wouldn’t talk to your friend / boss like it, don’t talk to your children like it either. I don’t do this one very well, I often get frustrated and angry and snappy. But I’m working on it.

Newgirls · 28/04/2022 17:51

To add to all this great advice

Choose a happy school that’s right for your child. That’s not necessarily the most academic or will impress your work colleagues. If you can help them find something that interests them outside of school. Only needs to be one thing. But something fun rather than exhausting. Scouts/drama whatever

Oblomov22 · 28/04/2022 17:50

I'm saddened by the poor MH amongst teens. Particularly boys not talking about stuff, expressing their emotions. Dh goes on MH training courses at his work and we've talked about it with the boys. How it's pointless to worry about things outside of your control. Talking helps. Things seem massive at the time. But a year later, often better. Not many things are insurmountable. Watched the Roman Kemp programme about his best friend committing suicide. MH is so important. I think if you've never had MH issues there's probably a good chance your dc won't.

duvetdayforeveryone · 28/04/2022 17:46

BanginChoons · 01/09/2019 22:42

I have conversations as opposed to rules.

But surely you must have some rules, like always wearing a seatbelt and brushing your teeth?

Oblomov22 · 28/04/2022 17:43

I don't believe in trying to be their friend. I'm not their friend. They'll have loads of friends. I'm their mum. It's a totally different role.

Oblomov22 · 28/04/2022 17:41

It's complicated. Nature and nurture. A loving family with supportive parents, who are emotionally open and know about MH, helps.

But more than that it's the child's personality. I know confident parents who have good self worth and good self esteem themselves, but all 4 of their children are different personalities, all with different levels of self worth and non anxiety.

707smile · 28/04/2022 17:25

Trickedia · 01/09/2019 22:24

I don’t know if that’s worded correctly. But I hope you get where im going. What do you think is important to create a happy home that children can thrive in & grow into confident/happy adults?

I have 2 young children & am terrified of screwing them up (due to my own screwed up childhood.) I don’t want them to grow up with issues. I want them to make the absolute best of themselves.

I know nothing is guaranteed, but what do you think is important?

A calm/predictable home & family?
Lots of Encouragement/praise?
Knowing your family are always there for you?

... they’re the most important thing to me & I want to get this right. I don’t ever want them to feel the way I did.

Mumsnet has such wisdom at times & im hoping for some pearls!

Genetics play a big part, as do factors outside of a parent's control, such as stress and illness within the family, bullying at school, having to move house or have other significant stressors. The death of a parent in childhood is significantly associated with poor mental health in adulthood so first of all realise that you could do everything right and they could still end up with psychological issues.

In terms of the family environment all of the things you've mentioned do contribute to good mental health but also teaching resilience (so that they can overcome life's challenges).

Remember also that they might go through periods of poor mental health and that's okay, that doesn't mean you've screwed them up, that means that you can support them back to good health, just as you would if they were physically unwell.

Swipe left for the next trending thread