Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why we aren't one of "those" families

419 replies

Mypetsnails · 14/08/2019 08:09

Sort of lighthearted. This is going to sound SO daft. But do you ever notice the families who seem, well, better at family-ing than everyone else?

We went to a thing at a National Trust place at the weekend. Took a picnic and sat on the big green. Right beside us there was this family that had a three sided shelter type thing which they'd popped their baby and picnic in to protect them from the sun. They'd brought tennis racquets and these gorgeous kids and their equally beautiful parents were taking it in turns to whack a ball around/sit in the shelter thing. They had a picnic cool bag the size of my kitchen, no idea what they brought but it was probably nicer than my tragic cheese sandwiches Grin

Then there's the beach. We're trying to stop our towels blowing away, and the alpha family have a wall of windbreaks, a body board, and a barbecue.

DD is actually friends with a child from such a family, and they also have a really organised hallway with special named slots and storage systems for all the children's outdoor things. Plus the mum has a boot storage thing with a first aid kit, plasters, and spare clothes in it.

There's obviously nothing stopping me buying little shelters, bodyboards, and shoe storage for my hallway, but it's more that it wouldn't occur to me? And I don't know why? I used to play at a tennis club twice a week, why on earth don't WE bring racquets with us?

Does anyone know what I mean? I was a very solitary only child, and my parents didn't do a lot of child friendly things with me, so maybe it's a bit of a hangover from that - I remember feeling that my family and home was very different from other people's but when I tried to express why to my mum, I said "they have big tins for their biscuits and we just put ours into the cupboard" Grin

OP posts:
MsTSwift · 15/08/2019 17:18

At wild swimming spot in Spain it’s a bank holiday. Families have gazebos hammocks tables chairs and whole delicious Spanish lunches in cool boxes. We cannot even begin to compete Grin

BarrenFieldofFucks · 15/08/2019 17:08

I'm well organised...if I'm not it stresses me out. Each to their own etc

KateUrrer · 15/08/2019 16:52

There is a vast difference between well organised and the stressed out perfectionist.

TatianaLarina · 15/08/2019 16:40

My mum used to need everything to be perfect, I'd swear she thought there were hidden cameras / judgemental relatives watching our every move in public and at home, it was all a performance. Nothing was really fun, it was all low level stressful all the time, very stressful at peak perfectionism times like Christmas and family holidays, with the tears and emotional blackmail to perform gratitude, enjoyment and perfect family relationships ramping up as we got older.

You’re conflating organisation with control, perfectionism and emotional manipulation. They’re not necessarily related. And organisation doesn’t have to mean army level discipline.

It’s because I like to be chilled and relaxed that I don’t like disorganisation as it just creates extra, un-necessary stress.

drsausage · 15/08/2019 16:08

I'd think a wild swimming spot is a freshwater lake with grassy banks as opposed to the sea/ beach, or a or swimming pond (non chemical "natural" but human managed outdoor pool, forgotten the proper name). Can't be that wild if there were so many people looking at the family though!

Ah, OK, I guess we'd call that a 'swimming hole' perhaps (in the US).

theresnotthatmuchtoit · 15/08/2019 15:44

CSIblonde that's just it though - who wants to live in a family run like an army unit?

My mum used to need everything to be perfect, I'd swear she thought there were hidden cameras / judgemental relatives watching our every move in public and at home, it was all a performance. Nothing was really fun, it was all low level stressful all the time, very stressful at peak perfectionism times like Christmas and family holidays, with the tears and emotional blackmail to perform gratitude, enjoyment and perfect family relationships ramping up as we got older.

Organisation is necessary with preschoolers but too much organisation and perfectionism and unrealistic expectations of "familying" are stifling and stressful for the children too as they get older. Spontaneity should increase and luggage decrease once nobody is likely to tantrum/ need a nap or pee themselves...

CSIblonde · 15/08/2019 15:36

Some people are just naturally organised & it's automatic, so not a chore. Those who aren't are just different & that's fine unless it bothers you or is so bad it causes real upset or issues. Personally I don't like a make it up as you go along attitude (which a ditzy friend has) as it means there's always something forgotten or missed which is un necessary stress you could have avoided. (what's that Army "five P's"? Proper preparation prevents poor performance? )

theresnotthatmuchtoit · 15/08/2019 15:32

I'd think a wild swimming spot is a freshwater lake with grassy banks as opposed to the sea/ beach, or a or swimming pond (non chemical "natural" but human managed outdoor pool, forgotten the proper name). Can't be that wild if there were so many people looking at the family though!

I wouldn't be so sure "everyone" was envious, there are plenty of other points of view on this thread!

I was more over organised when the children were little. Very organised indeed if going anywhere by public transport, less so but kept everything we could possibly need in the boot if driving.

Once kids are all reliably toilet trained it's pleasanter for everyone involved to be more relaxed and travel light!

drsausage · 15/08/2019 15:10

What is a wild swimming spot? How's that different to a beach?

Basecamp65 · 15/08/2019 11:48

Made me laugh - we regularly go to a wild swimming spot near us and last week had this experience - we have trailers to carry everything from the car, massive cool bags, inflatable kayaks and paddleboards, water shoes for all of us, changing towels, chairs bbq etc youngest has lifejacket and kids have wet suits to use if it gets a bit cold. We always meet another similar family and have a great time - everyone else's kids look on enviously at our kids activities. We just sit there glowing with smugness at being the envy of everyone.

2 days later we were sat on the beach with cheese sandwiches in a plastic bag and kids swimming in their pants getting dried on our hoodies.

I think most families have a certain amount of both in them - things they do regularly they have kit for and know exactly what to take but other things they just wing it.

youarenotkiddingme · 15/08/2019 11:34

But I will add even though my friends are impressed with my organisation and think I'm on it.

I always spot people 'familiying' better than me Grin

youarenotkiddingme · 15/08/2019 11:32

I can be that family. (Well it's only ds and I!)

When we go to the beach I had picnic rug, towels each, large spades and buckets, blow up body board, picnic bag and beach tent.
Ds would entertain himself for hours and I'd read, chat to him and paddle/swim with him etc.
But tent was bought in Oct in sale, spade etc £1 from Asda, towels - again summer sale and cool bag the same (from sainburies so prob looked posh!).

But he knew no different. We had very little money so that was his days out and he enjoyed them. Plus we did it a lot so I'd got it down to a T!

I grew up camping holidays so I also was use to the chilling in space and making my own fun. Also hours in cars travelling.

But I can assure what I may look like when out and about - all organised and prepared isn't necessarily how my everyday life passes day to day.

DDIJ · 15/08/2019 11:14

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

drspouse · 15/08/2019 11:12

I would have coordinating storage space but as DH would ignore it for some "system" of his own... there is no point.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 15/08/2019 11:07

NB coordinating storage space in the hallway is a great idea. I've never gone that far, but our constantly messy shoe-rack gets on my nerves. As for inventorying the week's meals on a chalk board, I just cook them and bung them in the freezer. There's such a thing as going OTT!

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 15/08/2019 11:04

I'm naturally quite an ordered and tidy person - HOW some of my colleagues work with their desks and shelves in the state they are I don't know. DH and DC are the messiest people ever and drive me barmy!

Yes, in the baby stage we were THAT family with the sun/wind shelters and bags and bags of equipment on the beach. Now that phase is over and its a relief not to have to plan everything like a military operation. Nowadays all we take are the obligatory buckets and spades, ball, kite and a sand-free rug. Our cool bag doubles as a picnic basket (courtesy of The Range).

I pack a day or two before leaving for holidays, but have usually sorted all the laundry and ironing some days before. (DH packs his own stuff; we both pack for DC).

I do laundry on holiday if there are facilities available, and unpack and put everything away the moment I reach home (hides face in shame).

verticality · 15/08/2019 11:01

I don't think any of the stuff you are mentioning matters one iota.

Your kids are growing up in a lovely family, surrounded by love and with few material worries. That makes them some of the luckiest kids on the planet.

I'm sure you are doing a great job, and you have everything you need already. Just because it doesn't look like a shot out of a catalogue doesn't mean it's inferior in any meaningful way.

NotQuitePerfect · 15/08/2019 10:56

@rose789 you’ve made my day Grin

Oliversmumsarmy · 15/08/2019 10:24

I can never understand the people in theme parks who as soon as there is a drop of rain the plastic kagool comes out. Surely if it rains you get wet. We watched a family in the long queue change umpteen times as the rain stopped and started.

We always felt sorry for those children who weren't allowed to play in the water and fountain play features.

You would see them wandering past looking longingly at ds DD and me soaked to the skin running in the water and there patents dragging them past with the comment that they couldn't go in as they hadn't got a change of clothes.
Neither did we but either the sun dried us or we went home wet

BarrenFieldofFucks · 15/08/2019 09:40

I take pineapple and watermelon. 😁

Adversecamber22 · 15/08/2019 08:59

I’m organised. To the poster who was amazed bags and shoes were packed and in the hall ready to go on the morning of your friends holiday, why wouldn’t you do that. DH is from a very disorganised family my Mother’s parents were both in the military so they had a very organised household, it’s one of the influences she had on me that I’m glad of.

When dc were little I always had a bag of spare clothes in the car plus wipes etc.

The last bike ride I went on with DH we had a bento box, decent cutlery, plastic backed picnic rug. A flask of water with china cups and tea bags and milk in small bottles. I do take a ready made flask if hiking but this means the tea hasn’t been sat stewing.

Our three suitcases are on the spare bed, we fly in a week. Washing and decisions on clothes were made a couple of days ago. I expect all packing to be done by end of the weekend.

I never understand the expired passport threads, we check ours every time we book a holiday.

babba2014 · 15/08/2019 08:59

I was like you with my first but we soon learnt how to be better equipped for days out.
Simple things like taking a bucket and spade to the beach. We would be the family without one. Now that parks have sandy areas, we not only have our bucket and spades ready but a lunch, water, drinks etc lol. However we don't go too fancy with the food. Simple sandwiches are enough but on certain occasions we may have a feast of samosas and pastries.
We aren't the type to have windbreaks etc because we don't go out when it's too windy and don't have the space to store all these extra items but we never used to think of taking toys, balls etc to play and now we will try to remember. It's down to experience or even having extra hands which we don't have. If you are now noticing about yourself, it's you waking up and being able to prepare better next time like we did! It's all good.

Wtfdoipick · 15/08/2019 08:44

Ok I don't use a wicker basket because a backpack is easier to carry but we are unfortunately that family, but only on quiet beaches.

It's mostly fluke, we have the gear due to camping so may as well use it, if we head to the beach we will be there all day so want to be comfortable and have shade. I'm too lazy to make a picnic so more than likely will just pick up bits like cheese, ham and a baguette with fruit for snacking on.

We can do it spur of the moment as we can grab everything in minutes and head off (unfortunately yes the child will probably be dressed in Boden my mother insists on buying it) my response to mud is that's what washing machines are for, the muddier the better.

transformandriseup · 15/08/2019 08:38

Every time we go to our timeshare there is always a family who bring out orange/melon segments to eat by the pool.

transformandriseup · 15/08/2019 08:36

My DH is like this (he is a scout leader). Thank goodness though as my family were super disorganised and I inherited it from them. It’s like OP said, you just don’t think of the things that come naturally to other people.

Before I’ve put my DD in her car seat my DH has a bag with her spare clothes, picnic for us, coats all packed and he is sitting in the car waiting to go. It’s really embarrassing on my part Blush