Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Please let me warn you about the New Kadampa Tradition. It is a Buddhist cult

62 replies

cultwarning · 04/08/2019 14:11

For the sake of your families and friends I need to warn you about how this group operates. They claim to be welcoming to everyone but they will take your money, your energy and they certainly won't be welcoming to you if you question them or disagree with them.

The "guru" or leader Geshe Kelsang Gyatso has not been seen for 6 whole years yet everyone involved is expected to worship him/ keep statues of him and ONLY read books by him and him alone.

The people who run the centres use people (especially rich and young people) and are deeply unpleasant people who expel people once they are exhausted and penniless.

Recently, a young psychologist has tried to leave the religion and has been subjected to defamation of character and people in the NKT have as gone as far as to set up a website (under a fake name) in order to destroy her reputation. They have used her father's death to make out that she has various mental illnesses, it is shocking how like scientologists they are behaving.

If you have a child or family member is attending these centres please point them in the direction of this comprehensive report on the way they operate as a cult.

newkadampatraditionreport.org/2019/08/04/a-third-and-final-version-of-my-writing-on-the-new-kadampa-tradition/?fbclid=IwAR3btZJyhz48yNlbdVQcFaQ-s6Ng3cg7G243P0Ss7m0XEZSzql_g18v4qwU

OP posts:
RuffleCrow · 07/08/2019 10:12

People who blindly follow any belief system have to typify those who question it as 'dangerous' @Armadillostoes it's classic DARVO. I grew up in a family of 7th Day Adventists and Catholics so i'm trained to notice these things.

cultwarning · 06/08/2019 16:40

www.icsahome.com/aboutus

Here’s a link ^^ to the institution of Cultic studies, it contains lots of useful information about cults and their definitions.

I just really hope that people will see how dangerous the NKT are when/if you dare to speak out against them in any way whatsoever.

This psychologist isn’t the only one. If you google Nick Gillespie NKT you will see that be too was slandered/threatened terribly by the NKT after he left and tried to write a book about his experiences.

OP posts:
RuffleCrow · 06/08/2019 13:35

I strongly disagree @Armadillostoes

It's well established that even Christianity was, to begin with, a small jewish cult - one of hundreds at around that time in the holy land.

Lifecraft · 06/08/2019 13:27

There's clearly a big difference between a religion that demands money and won't let you leave and something like the Church of England...

Yes, time. The C of E has had 500 years since Henry VIII to of fleece millions of people and is now so fantastically wealthy, it doesn't need to hold people hostage.

Armadillostoes · 06/08/2019 12:59

Ruffle-that is really not true in sociological or anthropological terms. People are 100% entitled to think that all religion is damaging, but the nature and kind of risks deom cults are very different.

RuffleCrow · 06/08/2019 12:27

With religions and cults it's a matter of degree.

Cults tend to play the short sell, religions the long game. Potayto, potarto.

Having said that, I do believe in God in some form and I do attend church. I'm pretty wary of anyone who claims to have 'the answers' though.

Armadillostoes · 06/08/2019 12:18

The people on this thread describing all religion as a cult are uneducated bigots and very dangerous. To suggest that people who go to the mosque or church on a regular basis are no difference from members of a tightly controlled and abusive group is insulting and irrational. Read something academic on the psychology of cults and how they operate and educate yourself about hate speech before posting drivel online.

Mrstraveller · 06/08/2019 11:55

I pulled away from it when I had a bad experience at one of the Centres. I decided to start the Foundation Programme and went to a centre in a University City. Lots of young people obviously. I didn't like some of the conversation going on about the whole Shugden thing and then went we went into the meditation room, I accidentally put my book on the floor as I was sitting cross-legged. I was told off in front of everyone by one of the residents who had been very loud in the Shugden discussion and the teacher said nothing. It was the absolute opposite of kindness and compassion. Just in normal life if you have a problem with someone in a group situation you speak to them separately and don't seek to embarrass them in front of the group. The whole motivation was wrong and I just felt there was something very off at that centre if one of the residents was allowed to get away with bullying/humiliating a visitor, even in a small way.

I left that day and never went back to the centre or proceeded with FP. I have been to a different centre for the odd meditation class but I completely drew away after that bad experience.

It was very disappointing to find out about the whole Samden thing. I would never have guessed! Naive me.

cultwarning · 05/08/2019 21:28

@Mrstraveller oooh yes. Just a quick google would tell you what happened there- better than Corrie- eek!
You're right some people become very very fervent adherents. I know one person whose family rejected them because they were one religion growing up and this person switched to NKT buddhism and this person completely cut people out of his social circle/ life if they weren't whole heartedly a follower of Geshe Kelsang. It's amazing/worrying how some people have to be so extreme. Very sad too.

OP posts:
cultwarning · 05/08/2019 21:21

@BrightYellowDaffodil Good for you! Yes I met some lovely people too during my time within the "tradition" (barely 30 years old!) and it is even sadder that so many lovely people are sucked into it for so long. particularly the people who are at a point in their lives where they are grieving or people who have come from difficult back grounds and they feel they are being offered a stable pseudo family life but unfortunately the "love" is completely conditional and dependant upon giving over your whole self to them that's why you aren't allowed to read books by other authors/ "gurus" they want to control every narrative and they want you to be looking at life through their lens so they have ultimate control over you.
I am happy for you that you got out when you did and that you have your own mind.

OP posts:
Mrstraveller · 05/08/2019 20:46

I went to Losang Dragpa Centre a few times on retreats (a long time ago!) and also to a Spring Festival at Conishead Priory. Later I heard Losang Dragpa had been shut down as an “impure centre”. There are people who become involved and suddenly become very, very fervent adherents.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 05/08/2019 19:16

I’m not surprised. I went to a NKT Buddhist centre for several years - the centre’s teacher was (and is, I’ve seen her since) one of the kindest, gentlest, and most compassionate people I’ve ever met. She, and the other nuns, were very kind to me when I needed someone to talk to, particularly when I’d gone to a meditation session for company more than anything because my grandmother was dying.

But I couldn’t bear being told that I shouldn’t read anything other than Geshe Kelsang Gyatso’s interpretation of the Buddha’s teachings, or their opposition to the Dalai Lama (who always seems like rather a good egg and certainly not deserving of such vitriol). I questioned something a couple of times and came up against a wall of “Don’t ask such questions”.

So I stopped going and took up my own meditation practise, as well as reading for myself (I recommend Thich Nhat Hanh, as well as the Dalai Lama). Which was a shame because I very much enjoyed the teachings and pujas.

cultwarning · 05/08/2019 18:51

*comparitively

OP posts:
cultwarning · 05/08/2019 18:50

Yes and they set their disciples against the Dalai Llama under the name The Western Shugden Society but they pretend it’s not created by The NKT.
They also protest outside the DL’s talks.
Very dangerous cult indeed. I was in the religion for over a decade and have met a higher concentration of horrible people within it than our competitively!

OP posts:
suze108 · 05/08/2019 18:39

They are primarily associated with the Dorje Shugden controversy.

VenusTiger · 05/08/2019 18:07

There isn’t a religion I know of that doesn’t pass a bowl round asking for money

Speaktruthshamedevil · 05/08/2019 17:24

Thank you for creating this post, as you say most people quietly walk away. By posting here you are making yourself a target, how long do you give it until the ahem “Buddhists” start posting in retaliation? We used to call them the KGB! I lived in a centre for 4 years so know what it’s like.
Pretending to be someone they are not and causing misery and upset, sounds about right!

cultwarning · 05/08/2019 16:35

@Avalo I’m sorry this happened to you. It is classic cult behaviour to the letter that people stand by and justify what they are seeing/ turn a blind eye.
Something ought to be done though to protect vulnerable people from being duped out of their money, time and happiness.
This person/s posing as Dr Robert Harrison has caused (the real Dr) endless torment on every level and still calls himself a Buddhist! At least if you set out to defame someone, put your name and face to it.

OP posts:
cultwarning · 05/08/2019 16:32

@Didiusfalco Yes but they rely on people just drifting away silently. If anyone complains about anything publicly they are hounded like dogs and they won’t stop trying to destroy them until the person has been silenced or sadly (in some cases) ended their own lives.

OP posts:
Avalo · 05/08/2019 16:25

It’s sad that they destroyed the psychologists reputation but not surprising. I had the same thing happen to me and they are still at it now.
I left over 10 years ago and the toxic members that were particularly obsessed with me and attempted to possess and control me have never gotten over it.
Shame on those bystanders who enable the abuse for want of an easy life.
The desperation to destroy my happiness and wellbeing is staggering, interesting from a psychological perspective though.

Didiusfalco · 05/08/2019 15:21

Hasn’t this been the case with this organisation for years though? There’s a centre round the corner from me and I’m sure this was something I heard about at least a decade ago.

Brahumbug · 05/08/2019 15:15

Certainly the Catholic Church fits the definition of a cult. Controls every aspect of your sex life, tick. Claims to be infallible, tick. Corrupt and abusive at every level, tick. Claims that they are the only source of truth and salvation, tick.

cultwarning · 04/08/2019 22:02

@BiBabbles Thanks, I agree and it is good to know who these people are and who is most vulnerable to their clutches.
I have seen so many women waste all of their fertile years on this organisation, being worked to the bone lest they end up in 'the hell realms' for not accumulating enough 'merit' only to be completely spat out when they become too ill to slog for them. Then there's always a fresh supply of new young and willing -victims- for them to eat alive.
When people ask "what happened to so and so / ex nun / monk' they are told oh they "fell off the path".

It's actually so damaging.

OP posts:
BiBabbles · 04/08/2019 19:29

There is a big difference between large organizations, all of which end up with issues of corruption and power abuses and cults which use BITE tactics where the corruption and power abuses is pretty much all that exists. An organization can be horrible or have horrible members or have daft beliefs and not be a cult (not that there can't be cults within religions, but I really don't think we can put the CoE - even with it's corruptions - into the same category).

This group does sound like a cult, and I do think some use what is often viewed as 'alternative' religions to target young people. and drop people's guard. It's sad - in a too many people are horrible sort of way - but it's good to know about when and how these groups are.

cultwarning · 04/08/2019 18:52

Yes, I suppose there's so much room for abuse when people give their power over to a religion and let a flawed (ego maniac usually) human take the steering wheel. BUT I feel that Buddhism is often seen as more of a philosophy than a religion, so usually religion wary people are people are easily tricked.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread