Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Please let me warn you about the New Kadampa Tradition. It is a Buddhist cult

62 replies

cultwarning · 04/08/2019 14:11

For the sake of your families and friends I need to warn you about how this group operates. They claim to be welcoming to everyone but they will take your money, your energy and they certainly won't be welcoming to you if you question them or disagree with them.

The "guru" or leader Geshe Kelsang Gyatso has not been seen for 6 whole years yet everyone involved is expected to worship him/ keep statues of him and ONLY read books by him and him alone.

The people who run the centres use people (especially rich and young people) and are deeply unpleasant people who expel people once they are exhausted and penniless.

Recently, a young psychologist has tried to leave the religion and has been subjected to defamation of character and people in the NKT have as gone as far as to set up a website (under a fake name) in order to destroy her reputation. They have used her father's death to make out that she has various mental illnesses, it is shocking how like scientologists they are behaving.

If you have a child or family member is attending these centres please point them in the direction of this comprehensive report on the way they operate as a cult.

newkadampatraditionreport.org/2019/08/04/a-third-and-final-version-of-my-writing-on-the-new-kadampa-tradition/?fbclid=IwAR3btZJyhz48yNlbdVQcFaQ-s6Ng3cg7G243P0Ss7m0XEZSzql_g18v4qwU

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
alltoomuchrightnow · 11/08/2022 14:02

Sounds like extreme people giving others a bad name
Buddhism is not a religion

Emmaforrest2019 · 11/08/2022 14:01

@Rahrahrahrahannoyed ...they won't listen my friend - they need something or someone to take out their emotional deficits on......you’re wasting your time!

Emmaforrest2019 · 11/08/2022 14:00

@rightonthyme ....apparently not! :)

Rahrahrahrahannoyed · 11/08/2022 11:55

Not all religion is a cult and I'm wary of things like that, I'm also a member of the Kadampa Buddhist centre and they are far from being cultist, thay are very open minded for one, which would go against this. If we come to them with a problem in life, e.g. about a person who is making our life hard they help us think about why that person has done that and that the person must have been experiencing some suffering etc. They are open to new concepts and we talk about other ways of life and consider if they might be beneficial. Nothing is hidden. There is no pressure to come back or remain. There is no passive aggressiveness it is a peaceful place with no agenda and they forgive people's human flaws. Honestly, it's far from a cult.
I pay a monthly subscription to attend teachings, but I'm not tied into it.

rightonthyme · 11/08/2022 11:45

^Emma this is a zombie thread

Emmaforrest2019 · 11/08/2022 11:02

Some of these posts are hilarious!!! I mean, you lot need to ask yourselves why it took so long for you to ‘realise’ that you were in the midst of an evil cult??? So I guess you’re right and the scores of thousands of people who DON’T feel the need to whine either just move on or are perfectly happy with their choice of a path. I mean, really…..get some backbone and stop moaning.

AyrshireAmbler49 · 24/01/2021 11:58

.

Likeazombi · 07/08/2019 22:54

There was an article on BBC radio news a few days ago about a young woman who had been murdered by another member of the church she attended, which sounded very much like a cult to me, she was isolated from her family and university peers to the point that nobody had reported her missing until weeks later.
Nobody in the church had missed her enough to wonder where she was either..
Very sad story all round. Her name was Joy.
Church was the black Israelites or some such, something to do with 12 tribes and their descendents being the only holy people and all white people are devil's.
Just to point out there are probably very many more cult like organisations preying on vulnerable people than most of us realise.

Armadillostoes · 07/08/2019 22:50

Rufflecrow-Ignorance is always dangerous.

Your laziness/stubbornness doesn't change the factual reality that all religions do not start out as cults in the sense described. You don't know/understand the actual meaning of the word in that context.

Your suggestion that "intelligent" people wouldn't get drawn in is just laughable.

Your comment about shame is just weird and I suspect that you are projecting some if your own insecurities.

But as I say, the fundamental problem here is that you have no clue what you are talking about and no desire to find out. You have zero interest in whether your vacuous comments might be damaging. All in all, pretty sad.

lisasimpsonssaxophone · 07/08/2019 22:32

I also feel like I have to add that although the CofE as a whole doesn’t necessarily qualify as a ‘cult’ in my eyes, I have seen some very cult-like evangelical CofE youth groups in my time. I went along with friends to a couple of meetings at their youth group when I was a teenager and it was terrifying.

lisasimpsonssaxophone · 07/08/2019 22:27

My friend was in a Buddhist cult for a couple of years. I don’t want to go into details because it feels wrong to share details of someone else’s life, but watching from the outside it was very, very scary. I don’t remember enough about the organisation she was involved with to know whether it was the same one, but it sounds very similar.

Something that always rubs me up the wrong way is when people are very anti-religion but then say ‘oh but Buddhism’s ok, that’s just about having a peaceful lifestyle isn’t it?’ As with all religions I’m sure there are plenty of Buddhists who benefit positively from it and aren’t in dangerous cults, but it just worries and angers me that people seem to assume Buddhism is ‘different’ from the others and somehow gets a free pass when people are criticising religion. I’ve never understood it.

I seem to remember even Dawkins in the God Delusion saying that Buddhism was excluded from his criticism because it’s really just a ‘way of life not a religion’. I really wish I could tell him about all the stuff I witnessed with my friend which was EXACTLY the kind of stuff he criticised other religions for in that book.

RuffleCrow · 07/08/2019 22:18

You're quite big on shame, aren't you?

There's nothing 'dangerous' in pointing out all religions start as cults. Just because they're all technically cults doesn't mean some aren't currently more dangerous than others. You should credit the people you're worried about with some intelligence.

mindproject · 07/08/2019 16:34

I've told DD never to join the army, the police force or a religion.

Armadillostoes · 07/08/2019 16:30

Rufflecrow-You obviously don't have an answer to any of my points then? You clearly can't be bothered to find out what this debate is all about, even when a link has been provided for you. You also don't give a monkeys about the impact your comments might be having in the world-effectively down-playing the risk which cults in the technical sense pose is neither intelligent nor responsible.

But the attempt at sarcasm and the flowers indicate that you know yourself to be put of answers. Shame.

RuffleCrow · 07/08/2019 16:12

Riiight @Armadillostoes Hmm

Sounds like comprehension isn't your strong suit. Never mind Flowers

@vasya - i guess once a cult gets to a certain size and amasses enough wealth, power over and acceptance by the general population they can loosen their grip a bit. Look at Scientology in parts of the US for a modern day example of that transition from cult to religion. I think US law now protects it under the constitution whereas certainly when i first heard of it that wasn't the case. And i've heard of scis marrying non-scis recently too - not sure if that's new.

Shalom23 · 07/08/2019 16:07

That's an excellent report, thank you for sharing. Much food for thought and expertly written.

vasya · 07/08/2019 15:18

i'm careful not to get sucked in too much

You don't have that option with a real cult. You're either wholly in or wholly out.

corlan · 07/08/2019 15:14

Are these the people that protested when the Dalai Lama came to speak in the UK a few years ago? I don't think I have ever seen a group of people so passionate in their vitriol ( and I work with teenagers!) They came across as being completely unhinged.

MidnightAtTheOasis · 07/08/2019 15:08

There is the potential for cult-like sub-groups even in the C of E, under the control of rogue charismatic (small c) leaders. But that doesn’t mean that all religions are cults, it means that sometimes mini-cults spin off from a normal religion. It’s an extremely important distinction to make, and stating that your Auntie Gladys going to chapel on a Sunday is just as much a cult victim as a troubled 17 year old running off to join the Moonies is really not helpful.

NiceLegsShameAboutTheFace · 07/08/2019 14:40

There isn’t a religion I know of that doesn’t pass a bowl round asking for money

Well, yes. But, other than by doing so, how do you suppose the Christian organisations (cited because I have an understanding of their operations) pay for the clergy and the upkeep of the buildings?

Armadillostoes · 07/08/2019 14:35

Rufflecrow-none of that in any way relates to the point that Denirosknee, myself of the OP have made. You clearly have not read up about what cults in the sense are are describing actually mean, and just want to focus on you and your experiences. In doing so, you are potentially obscuring the real dangers people want to flag up.

cultwarning · 07/08/2019 14:32

I just can’t believe that I didn’t see any warning signs that it was a cult until now.
I had no education about cults as a kid so I fell hook line and sinker for the whole thing.
My parents used to worry and I became pious and disconnected from people but had no idea that I was slowly replacing my real friends and family for a “spiritual family”.
I’m going to do my best to warn my DD about becoming involved with a cult when she’s older.
My new rule of thumb is don’t part with a penny.
No one should be able to commodify your spiritual life.

OP posts:
RuffleCrow · 07/08/2019 13:10

I'd disagree with that actually.

One of the things that first struck me about the church i attend was the youthful charisma of the clergy there. In fact it's very common in the evangelical (fastest growing) wing of the C of E.

The other thing which struck me was the constant pressure to sign up to all the various groups and activities and to tithe (give money) as much as possible and through direct debit and the hard sell on what the money can achieve.

As you might imagine, i attend for anthropological reasons as much as spiritual ones and i'm careful not to get sucked in too much.

denirosknee · 07/08/2019 11:54

I'm not a Christian myself (or religious at all) and I am definitely not saying that Christianity doesn't have major corruptions which are ongoing to this day, but OP is obviously using 'cult' in quite a distinct way here.

There isn't a hard and fast distinction between cults and regular religions, but there are some distinct features which help identify cults. Things like having a charismatic, living leader who claims special powers / insight / divinity; pressure to make quick decisions about belonging to the organisation; isolation from friends and family; brainwashing; and extreme difficulty or disincentives to leave the group. If a group exhibits some or all of these traits, there's a good chance it's a cult.

It's pretty obvious that mainstream Christianity - let's say the Church of England - doesn't fall under that label. Once upon a time there was a charismatic living leader, but that is no longer the case. There are a handful of men and women who are seen as leaders and teachers, but there is no cult of personality in respect of an individual. Members of the CofE are encouraged to give money, but they aren't required to, and there are no minimum spends (unlike in scientology, for example).

CofE members aren't required to cut off contact with their families, or to move to CofE designated living areas.

The CofE doesn't brainwash it's followers. In fact, in the modern age, debate and discussion about what Christian teachings mean and how they should be interpreted is a hugely important part of the Church. There are many interpretations and schools of thought that all coexist reasonable peaceably under the same umbrella.

If you want to stop going to church, the CofE won't threaten you, or contact your employer to suggest your mental health is compromised, or blackmail you, or set out to ruin your reputation.

You don't have to 'sign up' to be part of the CofE. You can attend church as much or as little as you want. You can be an involved member of the Christian community, or never attend anything at all.

I think it's very unhelpful to people actually concerned about cults to conflate cults with all religion. If you want to make a point about how you think religion is damaging or unhelpful or backward then go for it. But by claiming it's all a cult, you're really not aware of the specific distinctions that make cults so harmful for those trapped in them.

Armadillostoes · 07/08/2019 10:28

I think that people are getting confused about terminology here, but I am reluctant to derail the thread completely. A couple of points though and I will leave it:

  1. People are entirely entitled to regard religion or a particular faith as dangerous, negative or bad. But that doesn't mean that "cult" is an appropriate label to convey that @ Rufflecrow.

  2. It is true that "cult" used in the sense you refer to in relation to the beginnings of Christianity within Judaism or, say the historic "Cult of Mithras" is something entirely different, and in no way negative.

If you read the link which the OP has provided you will hopefully understand why "cult" in this context is something quite specific. If you genuinely care about people who are at risk from this kind of damage, then you won't keep undermining awareness raising by conflating this with other things. Of course if you DON'T care about victims of cults in the technical sense or their families, and just want to keep banging a general anti-faith drum and down-grading the significance of this particular form of abuse, you have a right to speech free and are entitled to do that. But I would suggest that that isn't a very caring or responsible approach.

Criticise whatever form of religion you like, but in my view, don't confuse people about the very specific nature of risk presented by "cults" in the sense outlined in the link.