Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - bossy, critical DH? Can such men change and how?

114 replies

pseudonomer · 02/08/2019 21:20

Could I ask, does anyone have any experience of a bossy husband in the sense that you were able to get him to see it for himself and change for the better? I’ve been in therapy for a year and I’m seeing things differently, yet I still love my DH very much and sometimes wonder if I’m being narcissistic and spoilt. Ultimately he would do anything for me. He’s very kind in many ways and totally honest. But he’s a workaholic and can be very critical and overwhelming. We are mid 40s and have 3 DC. Does anyone have experience if such a dynamic shifting and, if so, how? Thankyou.

OP posts:
DonPablo · 03/08/2019 13:21

He's got you exactly where he wants you hasn't he? He has exacting standards that you can't ever achieve, a reason to be annoyed with you when there isn't any and you're walking on eggshells to make sure you do no wrong.

This isn't a healthy and happy relationship at all. Where's the fun? The respect? The feeling that you're in it together? The feeling that you've both done amazing things to get to where you are? The sense of team? What's all this teaching the kids?

You say you're not ready to leave, but the alternative is continuing to be miserable, never good enough and eventually battered down to a point where there's nothing of you left.

Speak to a friend or family member, someone irl. Start putting money aside, start investigating life on the other side so that when you are ready, you're good to go.

pseudonomer · 03/08/2019 13:13

I do talk to the kids, yes. They’re very open with me. My youngest did tell him recently that she finds him too stressed and it worries her. He found that very hard to take, but he has spoken to her since and apologised and he says he’s going to change. He had promised this to me as well, since his recent blow up. We’re just going to try and reflect his behaviour back to him as it happens. That’s why I was asking if change is possible.

OP posts:
cottonwoolsnowmen · 03/08/2019 12:58

You can go on Freedom without leaving him - and they'll never tell you to leave him.

Do you at least tell the children "no, dad shouldn't have treated you like that, it was wrong and I'm sorry it happened" or do you cover up for him and minimise it?

pseudonomer · 03/08/2019 12:57

He is honest that he watches porn when he’s away and I was very upset about this at first. But he assured me he doesn’t watch violent stuff because he’s not into that in any way, nor anything even with men in it at all because he said why would he want to look at that.

OP posts:
pseudonomer · 03/08/2019 12:52

Angelina - he has a very high sex drive yes, but I wouldn’t say he’s coercive in that area. He understands about my past and he’s good about that. This morning he woke me up wanting sex, but if I really hadn’t felt able to, he wouldn’t have sulked.

OP posts:
pseudonomer · 03/08/2019 12:46

I will look at the Freedom Programme. Sorry, I’m not ready to leave him at this stage. I have thought about it at times, but I have to be honest. All have said is true but I can’t give the entire picture. I’ve been there for my kids every day of their lives and I have tried to balance everything out. It’s not perfect, but there are loads of positives too. I just can’t explain it all on here.

OP posts:
CallmeAngelina · 03/08/2019 12:46

Another question: what about sex?
Are you evenly-matched there? What would happen if you weren't in the mood or refused him?

cottonwoolsnowmen · 03/08/2019 12:32

I'm sorry but you are kidding yourself about the impact of this on your children. Children are always affected by living with coercive control.

He is abusing them too, and it will affect them for life, just like your childhood abuse.

Just because he tells you and them that he loves you in between abusing you doesn't stop it causing serious damage. Coercive control is a crime for a reason.

Are you going to look at the Freedom Programme? It's just info, not therapy. You don't have to share or talk, you can just listen. Freedomprogramme.co.uk

Your children's home should be somewhere they feel safe and protected, not somewhere they're always walking on eggshells and never know how they will be treated or what will be acceptable today compared to yesterday.

It's not safe now. If he loved them he wouldn't be inflicting that on them. Actions speak louder than words.

AnyFucker · 03/08/2019 11:54

Between you both you are fucking your kids up.

Do you acknowledge this?. The template of how relationships work that is being played out to them is extremely damaging. A som will grow up to treat women like shit. A daughter will grow up to let men treat her like shit. Is this ok ? Is this how you envisioned bringing up a family ?

Whosorrynow · 03/08/2019 11:48

He is using you to prop him up because he doesn't want to do the hard work of looking at himself and being honest, he is crushing you just so that he can keep going.
There is probably no point explaining all this because he will spin everything to suit him, he has had 20 years of practice moulding you into the shape that most suits him

pseudonomer · 03/08/2019 11:35

I don’t know if I’m ready to take advice or not. I mean, I am, but I also feel at a loss. I’ve been with him for 20 years, so basically my entire adult life.

Due to the therapy, I have been able to tell him (in his more receptive moments), that his moods and demands are too much for me. I’ve said it’s not that I’m nor sympathetic to his stress, but can he not see that it impacts everyone in the house. I’ve told him it overwhelms me and I’m anxious all the time. Also that me doing this or that will ultimately not help him, it only aids him to keep spinning out and it’s a destructive pattern. He’s been very successful at work, but can’t see that and any kind of failure terrifies him. He just can’t cope with it. I think he’s an extreme workaholic so that he doesn’t have to ever stop and think. His father had mental health problems. His brother has been treated for post-traumatic stress and was very ill for a while. So I feel like my whole life is trying to pacify him, but really it’s hopeless if he won’t take steps to change himself..

OP posts:
Whosorrynow · 03/08/2019 11:26

He treats you like a slave and you agree with him because you follow his script and treat him as if he is the master
Write your own script and tell him to fuck off
What does he have on you, what is it that makes you obey him?

AnyFucker · 03/08/2019 11:21

I don't think you are ready to take advice.

One year when the kids were small, we went on a UK family holiday.

I left the kids coats behind on their beds and it rained all week. My husband just laughed, shrugged and drove us to the nearest shop to buy new ones.

Another time he didn't pack any underwear for himself. No harsh words were spoken in these situations. No blaming or guilt tripping was done. The ( minor) problems were solved with minimum fuss and life went on.

This is how it should be, op. Your husband is abusive.

fedup21 · 03/08/2019 11:21

God, it’s exhausting reading your posts-he sounds so difficult to life with.

Do you work?

53rdWay · 03/08/2019 11:17

He got angry on the morning he was leaving as he felt I was prioritising taking DD to the GP rather than assisting him. He shouted at me “I NEED SUPPORT!” And he said, “you’re my wife, act like it.”

This is really worrying. So not only does he think his ‘support’ matters more than anyone else in the family, including his child seeing a doctor, he also thinks “wife” means “someone who puts me first 24/7 and exists purely to make my life easier.” This is how he thinks.

An assertiveness course would be a really good idea, whether you end up leaving him or not. It probably won’t change him but it might help you believe that you matter as much as he does, and it will mean you’re modelling better things to your children. It’s doing them no favours to grow up learning that this is what relationships look like.

pseudonomer · 03/08/2019 11:12

No I definitely couldn’t speak to him like that! To be fair, he doesn’t swear at me either.
The thing is, I can’t accuse him of being lazy because he does work very hard and always did (if anything he does too much), so this is why I feel as if I can’t ever just say I can’t be bothered. It’s feels selfish to me somehow and I doubt myself.

OP posts:
Whosorrynow · 03/08/2019 11:04

As he would ask me what I'm doing and why I'm ignoring him
I would just reply fuck off you nosey cunt

Whosorrynow · 03/08/2019 11:03

He tells me that I should want to help him out and if I don't it shows I don't love him enough
then again if someone said this to me I would just laugh at them and if they persisted with this line of reasoning I would challenge them to defend it and they wouldn't be able to
But I still wouldnt want to live with the fucker because the constant power struggle just gets annoying

Whosorrynow · 03/08/2019 11:00

In my experience when you live with someone and they have a very dominant overbearing personality it can be very hard to improve the situation if you're someone who has a lower threshold for getting stressed.

Topseyt · 03/08/2019 10:51

If my DH tried to tell me where to shop and why he would be told to either accept what I buy or get on with it himself.

Nor do I pack for him when going away somewhere or going on holiday, and if he wanted me to polish his shoes for him he'd be waiting a very long time, because it wouldn't be happening. We each pack for ourselves.

Your H sees you as some kind of a lowly servant. I wouldn't be able to live like that. Ex-military, except he hasn't left it behind. He is barking at you as if he is a Sergeant Major and you are one of his troops.

I'm unsure whether your therapist is right about his ego being fragile. Maybe it is, but it is also massive. He is very selfish.

pseudonomer · 03/08/2019 10:41

Angelina - sorry to answer your question - last night I felt as if I needed to go to bed as he would ask what I’m doing and why am I ignoring him.

OP posts:
Comtesse · 03/08/2019 10:32

He is your husband not your boss. He sounds like an abusive bully. No one should make you feel like you should check the bins at 6.30am on a Saturday morning.

pseudonomer · 03/08/2019 10:26

AnyF - Thankyou. Yes I did read about the “Demand Man” recently and it does fit him, pretty much. If I think back, he was like that from the beginning, but it’s definitely escalated in recent years. On the other hand, he is very good to me in some ways. I don’t feel as if he doesn’t love me or that he’s doing it consciously. He tells us that everything he does is for us - that’s why it’s hard to challenge. He tells me that I should want to help him out and if I don’t, it shows I don’t love him enough. He shouldn’t have to ask, it should come naturally or there’s something wrong.

He’s never been violent and I can’t imagine it coming to that, but nevertheless, I do recognise that I don’t feel able to challenge him or take the piss in the way other couples might do. He’s too on edge. He tells me I’m being aggressive if I try and push back in the moment.

Yes it might be better to have a female therapist tbh, but I’ve been seeing this one for a year now and put quite a of work in regarding my childhood etc and I’m not sure I could start again.

Yes I do think he uses his stress as a form of control. That’s exactly it.

OP posts:
smartiecake · 03/08/2019 10:10

It sounds like your husband has extreme views of what your wifely role is, and this extends to him being lord and master of all and you and your children treading on eggshells to keep him happy and jump to his demands.
This is no way to live, not for you and not for your children. You deserve better OP all of you.
In my eyes he is being abusive, emotionally abusive. Its a horrendous way for you to live. So what if you have a nice home? Is it really nice when you and the children are subjected to his moods and you are constantly pre-empting his next whim? That sounds like an awful home to me.
I think you also need to find another counsellor - "fragile ego" my arse! Your H sounds like a pompous dick who clicks his fingers and expects little wifey to come running. You sound scared of him and his reactions. He has conditioned you that way. Checking the bins at 6.30am? That is how he has made you.
You and the kids can continue to be conditioned by his behaviour but this would be very damaging to you all. Find a new new counsellor and start getting copies of financial documents and keep them secret. I hope you can see that you don't have to accept this and you have choices and can have a life without him if you want to.

Comtesse · 03/08/2019 10:04

If my husband said “you’re my wife act like it” when I was cleaning his shoes I would feel very tempted to throw them at his head. His being on edge all the time (SO SO stressed) is another way of controlling you. He is not more important than you or your children whatever he tells you. Flowers

Swipe left for the next trending thread