Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - bossy, critical DH? Can such men change and how?

114 replies

pseudonomer · 02/08/2019 21:20

Could I ask, does anyone have any experience of a bossy husband in the sense that you were able to get him to see it for himself and change for the better? I’ve been in therapy for a year and I’m seeing things differently, yet I still love my DH very much and sometimes wonder if I’m being narcissistic and spoilt. Ultimately he would do anything for me. He’s very kind in many ways and totally honest. But he’s a workaholic and can be very critical and overwhelming. We are mid 40s and have 3 DC. Does anyone have experience if such a dynamic shifting and, if so, how? Thankyou.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mimimi1029 · 09/09/2023 09:10

I know this is a very old thread but I was wondering how things worked out for you? My sister is in the exact same situation, is in denial, loves him very much and they have kids and planned a future together... yet everyone else sees it's not healthy...

Wonkybanana · 11/10/2019 21:20

Kjs331979 please start your own thread. This one hasn't been posted on (before you) for a couple of months and your post won't be seen.

Sewrainbow · 11/10/2019 21:01

He got angry on the morning he was leaving as he felt I was prioritising taking DD to the GP rather than assisting him. He shouted at me “I NEED SUPPORT!” And he said, “you’re my wife, act like it.”

To which this Survivor riposts:
"You're a father, act like it. Start prioritising your daughter's health over your bad temper & poor organisational skills".

This says it all... I was going to offer thoughts about how to deal with this but tbh I think you need to build the strength to leave. Whether you dc are boys or girls the examples you're setting them about adult life are really bad. Please go, he might not hit you but that doesn't mean he isn't abusing you Sad you are worth more than this...

Kjs331979 · 11/10/2019 20:44

Hi I need advise I think my husband is a gas lighter and a narsassist. He has a son who is 19 and left college in July he has no interest in finding a job from what I have seen when he comes to stray, he smokes dope and lives with his mum. My son who is 18 works full time runs a car egg. What i want opinions on is if inam right at going mad that my husband thinks it's ok to give his son 100 a week to do nothing and yet my Lad works all week to earn 200? He says it's his money and he can so what he wants he pays for the food in the house and the car insurance and broadband I pay everything else and he earns twice as much as me he doesn't give me money to do what I want with. He is very good with his mouth and knows how to turn things round and has a problem with alcohol. Any advise please x

Allli · 04/08/2019 19:03

Lots of good advice here for you (and others in the same position). He seems to think you’re his PA, or indeed “Batman” (army term from Last century referring to someone who was an assistant). You’re soooo much better and much more than he realises. I hope you now know that from all the posters on here and can think about what changes can accomplish. If it’s possible to make any and stay in a relationship with a control freak. Just please be careful though, he may flip if you try and say leave him, and although he’s not been violent so far.....
Hopefully you will find a way to be happy.

cushioncovers · 04/08/2019 13:42

It's difficult to hear the truth op when you're not ready for it. Been there. Stayed with abusive exh for many more years than I should have thinking it was the right thing for the kids. Friends and family had tried to say a few things to me but I didn't want to hear it. Eventually I hit rock bottom and got divorced and once the dust had settled the relief was immense. Good luck with whatever you decide op.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 03/08/2019 23:45

I was reading along and thinking, well OK he does have some very abnormal behaviour but he might have compulsions, anxiety, and other serious mental health problems. Until I saw this:

He would interpret that as me ... trying to push him over the edge.

And at that point it all changed. He thinks that if you are disobedient enough he is entitled to go "over the edge"? And that it will be your fault for pushing him? Well that is a terrible threat to you. And it truly is abuse.

No wonder you walk on eggshells around him. Whether he is technically sane or not, he is dangerous and threatening. If I was in your place I would be walking on tippytoes as well. And I know it's very difficult and you love him and you are only just starting to see how twisted he is.... but I hope that in time you will tippytoe very carefully towards the exit and get yourself and your children to safety.

dollydaydream114 · 03/08/2019 23:13

Oh, you poor thing.

Honestly, everything you've described is absolutely abusive, controlling and completely unacceptable. It doesn't matter that he tells you he loves you. Lots of abusers do that.

I can see you're in a very difficult situation and that this is hard to come to terms with but all I can say is that I hope you do start to see your husband for what he is and manage to get away.

mussolini9 · 03/08/2019 23:02

Hello @pseudonomer

Caught up with the full thread today & wrote a huge long post addressing several points, messed up the 'send' routine & lost the blooming lot.

I won't attempt to reproduce the screed & try again as I get that you are feeling understandably overwhelmed now.

So this is to wish you courage & fortitude as you take your own time to mull over some of the responses & how you feel about what steps you can comfortably take. Please keep seeing the therapist, he will help you untangle all the strands of thinking that I am sure your post here has engendered.

As someone who has been there, & come out the other side in one piece & SO much more content in life ... if you feel you would like to reach out to a MN poster by pm, you are very welcome to contact me for a little support & handholding.

Stay strong & put you & the DC first. You have given DH 20 years, you have earned the right to think about you, the children, & what makes you happy.

Flowers
AnyFucker · 03/08/2019 22:56

What was too much ? The bits where the reality of your children's upbringing is brought home to you ?

Painful, isn't it ? It's a lot more painful for them though, because they have no choice about what they are exposed to.

pseudonomer · 03/08/2019 22:24

Thankyou so much

OP posts:
pallisers · 03/08/2019 22:12

Good luck OP. Hope your work with your therapist will help you reach the life you want.

CharityConundrum · 03/08/2019 22:05

OP - I just re-read my post and realised that it sounded quite aggressive and I am so sorry as it was an expression of my anger at how your husband treats you and absolutely not me having a go at you. I really hope that you find the strength to make some changes and find happiness. You really do deserve it.

CallmeAngelina · 03/08/2019 21:48

Good luck with it all. Flowers

pseudonomer · 03/08/2019 21:40

I’m sorry but I can’t reply to this anymore.
I shouldn’t have posted here because some replies have been too much. Thankyou to everyone who took the time and I do appreciate that Flowers

OP posts:
pallisers · 03/08/2019 20:56

He got angry on the morning he was leaving as he felt I was prioritising taking DD to the GP rather than assisting him. He shouted at me “I NEED SUPPORT!” And he said, “you’re my wife, act like it.”

Quite apart from how abusive this is to you, this is a shocking example to give your children. They are going to grow up with a very distorted view of how husbands and wives should behave. You can talk all you like to them, as openly as you want but they will still internalise the message that is being played out every day in their home. Don't tell me your children don't notice how nervous you are, your checking the rubbish, his orders to you, his humphing around if displeased, his shouting at you - you cleaning his shoes for him for god's sake.

My dh works in a very senior role in a very stressful industry and travels a lot. He packs his own bags, cleans his own shoes (jesus the thought of him telling me to clean his shoes - he'd rather eat his shoes), gets himself out the door all by himself because he is an adult. Your dh has mh issues imo but whether he does or not his relationship with you is toxic for you and your children.

When he apologised to you today what did you reply? Because the normal thing to reply would be "an apology isn't going to cut it. You spoke and behaved to me in a way no one should and our children were exposed to something ugly and abusive - yet again. sorry isn't enough. What are you going to do to make sure you don't lose control like that ever again"

What did you say when he spoke about the supermarket? The normal response would be "that's interesting but I do the shopping so I'll be making that choice, thanks"

Personally I couldn't waste my one life checking the rubbish, walking on eggshells and cleaning my husband's shoes. I bet you are relieved when he leaves on a trip and are nervous about him coming back. think about that.

CharityConundrum · 03/08/2019 20:34

He tells me that I should want to help him out and if I don’t, it shows I don’t love him enough. He shouldn’t have to ask, it should come naturally or there’s something wrong.

But that only works one way though right? He doesn't have to prove he loves you by jumping every time you click your fingers and doing the menial jobs that you give him? He doesn't have a list of chores that you will berate him about? He doesn't have to change his routine to suit your whims? Because only one of you is required to show love like that, he just shouts and rants and makes you all feel like shit, but that's ok because he is sometimes not awful. He's fucked up and he's fucking you and your kids up too. I hope you are it before you're all too far gone.

pikapikachu · 03/08/2019 19:46

It makes you wonder what he thinks the role of a husband is apart from providing sperm to make kids and money.

CallmeAngelina · 03/08/2019 18:38

I wonder what would happen if , next time he petulantly shouts, "You're my wife. Act like it." You respond, "You know what? How about I'm no longer your wife and you fuck right off for DARING to speak to me like that?"
You need to find your anger, OP.
Thanks

pikapikachu · 03/08/2019 16:21

You can force him to change. The only person who can do that is him.

The only control you have is your reactions to him. It's not your fault that he's a workaholic and abuses you and the kids. Take the I love yous with a pinch of salt. Abusers do this to stall the date that you leave them and to have you doubting how bad he is.

pikapikachu · 03/08/2019 16:17

Most abusive men aren't shouting "I NEED SUPPORT" to their clients and friends because they know it's unacceptable behaviour. I bet your h knows that others wouldn't stand for his nasty abusive ways.

It sounds like you're not ready to leave yet but the longer you stay, the more likely that your kids will end up in similar relationships because you've made this situation normal and forced to hear/see/experience this extreme behaviour. It's not bossy - it's bloody frightening that you're checking the bins for plastic and obeying his unreasonable demands. I bet your 10 year old doesn't go round shouting for you to polish her shoes or shop at inconvenient places.

tobee · 03/08/2019 14:19

When I've read similar threads to this before, with a controlling dh, and the dw defends him by saying he provides for us and works hard for us so we have no worries etc, the examples of generosity given are also controlling because they are on his terms. Things he deems are providing for the family.

AnyFucker · 03/08/2019 14:11

Sobering words @dangerfloof

I too am in low contact with my mother. My patents only live 3 miles away but I rarely see them. I cannot bear their company...him because he is a dick I lost respect for when I was about 8 and her because she put her appeasing relationship with my abusive father above the emotional well being of her children

Just like op is doing

Dangerfloof · 03/08/2019 13:58

I was a child in a similar set up. My mother finally got us away when I was 14. I'm telling you this so you can better judge how it affects your children.
So we walked on eggshells., I was always nervous, I figured out early on that whatever I did/didnt do would never placate him, so I didnt bother to try. But still I was a nervy mess. He could come home over the moon that the day had gone well or incoherent with rage. I was a skinny child, living on nerves makes me not eat to this day.
So to now:-
I jump at every loud noise, I even startle when I hear someone coming but it's a minute later that I see them.
I live on the edge still, all the time. If something triggers me I go into fight or flight and then am like that for the rest of the day. It's no way to live.
If my DP is angry at something (pretty rare tbh) i go into myself because i am petrified of i dont even know what.
I dont like being alone in a room with a man, not even the most trusted man ever. I have no choice obviously sometimes but I can feel my heart racing and my shoulders get ever higher.
If anything goes wrong at work even if it's not my fault I catastrophise it for days sometimes.
If I hear loud voices or sharp words I stay the hell out of whatever it is.
And I could easily go on with all the things I do that are directly related to living with a bastard for 14 years of my life, but the biggest thing I will tell you, I went no contact with both of them. I haven't spoken to them in decades. I wont ever again. Just seeing them I think would trigger a nervous breakdown in me.
I know you say ok I understand him, but why your mother? Because she let me live like that for so long. I don't care that she too was suffering at his hands, she could and should have left sooner to protect me.

53rdWay · 03/08/2019 13:32

He probably COULD change if he wanted to yes. Most abusive men could, if they wanted to. The problem is that the underlying attitudes that make them abusive - in his case, that he is the most important member of the family and you as his wife exist to serve his needs - are the same attitudes that mean they don’t want to change.

You say he’s promised to change. What practical steps is he taking to do that? Counselling? Self-help? Ditching some of his needlessly stressy work commitments, or his hobbies that you must facilitate? Or has he just vaguely promised to try being a bit less snappy with you all?

Swipe left for the next trending thread