Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you open a shop? Should I?

133 replies

Lilyofthefields · 31/07/2019 08:30

Just that really.

I have an idea and a place in mind but I don't even know what questions I should be asking, let alone the answers.

I have zero experience of running a shop or business, although I briefly worked part time in a petrol station / village shop back in the 90s. I don't really know where to start.

I am 39, work part time for £42k, have no kids, no mortgage and no purpose in life.

OP posts:
MrsSpenserGregson · 31/07/2019 11:12

Don't do it OP.

I own a shop - have done for 7 years - and am slowly winding it down. (If you advance search my user name you will see that I have posted on threads about high streets etc before).

This is going to sound horribly negative, but this is my experience talking! Here goes.

Your idea is lovely, but you say you have a high student population. They will only be in your town for probably 35 weeks of the year. They are also notoriously tight with money as they don't have any!

Pensioners are very tight with money as they are terrified of not having enough to fund their care when they are older.

Young families talk the talk but when it comes down to it they go and shop in Primark and Aldi, not in the independents.

People bang on and on about how they want a thriving independent high street but when the chips are down, people want the cheapest option. The cheapest option usually means the smallest possible markup for the retailer.

You say you earn £42k part-time. You will not earn anything like this amount with your idea. You cannot run a shop on a part-time basis; at the bare minimum you need to be open Monday-Saturday (you could possibly be closed on a Monday or a Wednesday but if people come to your shop and you're closed, they won't come back). So many times Ive read on here the fact that people don't shop in independents because they're not open in the evenings or on Sundays....

The actual costs you will incur will be:

  • Rent
  • Business rates (you can find the rateable value on the letting agent's details - then you can cross-reference this on your local council website to find out what the actual business rates will be)
  • Refuse collection (businesses have to pay separately for this)
  • utilities (these are charged at higher rates than residential accounts) - electricity, water, sewerage, internet, phone...
  • Possibly maintenance for your premises - many business leases are what is called partially repairing or fully repairing leases. Google these. You will be shocked
  • depending on where you are, there may be other tariffs/taxes to pay to your council based on your rateable value or your turnover - do you have a BID (Business Improvement District) that you'd need to pay in to?
  • insurance - buildings/contents/public liability / employers liability
  • staff costs - wages, pension * these are huge even if you're just paying minimum wage *
  • accountant / payroll (I do my own book keeping but I pay an accountant to file my tax return)
  • stock
  • shop fittings, equipment etc
  • marketing costs - you'll either need to spend hours and hours per week on instagram and facebook, or pay someone to do it for you - plus possibly flyers, advertising in local magazine etc
  • website
  • tax and national insurance

Once you've factored in all the above, you then have your profit, and this is where you can pay yourself your own wages (that is, if you're a sole trader. If you register as a limited company, it will be different and you will probably take dividends and then pay tax afterwards). The most important piece of advice I was ever given was by my accountant who said "don't forget to value your own time adequately"

You will face constant criticism from customers who walk into your shop and don't like what you're doing/selling. You will need to be really nice on all your local facebook groups and not disagree publicly with anyone. You will need to be really nice to the local business groups / community interest groups / every man and his dog in order not to get any bad reviews on social media. You will end up working many many hours per week and earning about £1 per hour after all your costs are covered.

You work part time for £42k. Enjoy it!!!!!

flapslack · 31/07/2019 11:11

One thing the scoop shops don’t seem to cater for is allergies.
With a seed and nut allergy in our household it would be a big risk to shop in these places because of the contamination risks.

Kolo · 31/07/2019 10:51

Don’t give up on your idea based on a few MN posts! It does sound like a great idea, and they are becoming more popular. But I do agree that sort of plastic-free shop needs a particular demographic, where people are prepared to pay more for the ideology.

I think the idea of a market stall or a van is a great idea, to test out your idea, make connections with suppliers and other retailers at a much lower initial outlay. You could gain lots of experience from that at a lower risk and build up your business from there. You could even do it alongside your PT job for a while.

4 years ago I left a public sector career if been working in for 2 decades to run my own business. Not a shop, but still with premises and staff and overheads. It wa scary as hell, handing my notice in, but I’ve not looked back. You can’t throw the towel in when things look rough, I’d say to stay in business one of the key skills is the ability to step back and think outside the box. So if sales aren’t going well, identify the issue and address it? Or diversify? So doing cooking workshops or something to bring in income and expand business.

Luckybe40 · 31/07/2019 10:51

I really wouldn’t OP, I own a small artisan style shop( bakery actually) and you can’t even imagine HOW much work it is. 100 hour weeks, (no joke!) barely making minimum wage if your lucky, hidden costs that eat away at your profit, a huge amount of responsibility, business rates, waste removal, staff, staff holidays, stock, ordering stock, health & safety, dealing with staff, (the hardest bit!) no stress free holidays, covering shifts, parking permits, shitty customers, and potentially losing it all. SadThe demographics don’t sound great and no parking isn’t Ideal. Just bear in mind a business is deemed successful if you keep .10p off of every £1.00 you take. What are your forecasts like? And when you do your forecasting, half the amount you “think “ you’ll take because that will be the most accurate forecast!?

Jog22 · 31/07/2019 10:22

If so this has been there for years but it's in a quite affluent middle class liberal green area alongside artisanal bakers etc.

Jog22 · 31/07/2019 10:17

Is it this sort of shop?
www.scoopawayhealthfoods.co.uk/

ForgotwhatIcameinherefor · 31/07/2019 10:14

Saw one of these shops on TV recently. Can't remember if it was maybe Eat Well for Less? Sorry. Then shortly after that I went to visit Sheffield University and there was one inside their university buildings, so may be worth checking that out since student clientele mentioned.

Personally, I am confused as to why PPs are talking about your customers buying in bulk. Isn't the whole idea of shopping in zero waste shops yes reduce packaging but ONLY BUYING WHAT YOU NEED so therefore I'd be using your scales to buy my recipe's requirement of almond flour and chia seeds for my healthy loaf bar - if I wanted a large quantity I'd use the same packaging and carbon footprint as was required to get to your pristine dispensers in the first place so would buy online for best price. Or am I missing something?

Another one here wondering what you're doing part time for £42K please?

Whatsnewpussyhat · 31/07/2019 10:04

If you earn so much working part time, is there a reason why you can't/don't work full time now? Setting up your own business will leave you very little on the short term and by 24/7.
Do you have money saved as a back up?

gubbsywubbsy · 31/07/2019 10:04

I wouldn't unless you have a very very USP... I have worked in retail all my life and run my own business ( very successful and sold on) and I wouldn't at the moment , however you don't seem to 'need ' much money and if you are going to do it then give it a go but don't sign anymore than a year lease ( ideally 6 Months ) and give it a go.. make sure you have an online service as well( use eBay / Instagram etc to sell too)

PooWillyBumBum · 31/07/2019 10:04

If you're passionate about it, what about starting a co-op? Get together like minded individuals, everyone commits to X shifts:

www.truefood.coop/

Maybe one day it could become profitable, with an adjoining veggie cafe or similar?

Sceptre86 · 31/07/2019 09:55

I would stick with your part time job tbh as that is a great salary. Otherwise how about re training or finding hobbies to give you a bit of a boost?

RosaWaiting · 31/07/2019 09:51

£42k part time.....I want to know how to do that!

PooWillyBumBum · 31/07/2019 09:51

Could you do some market research? I would LOVE a shop like that to open near me, and I wouldn't mind no parking - I'd cycle so I can add more shine to my eco halo. I know there is one in Bournemouth doing well - a friend of mine (who is on a low £20,000-something income) does most of her shopping there - on her bike!

Loyaultemelie · 31/07/2019 09:51

There's one of these opened in a city nearish us, I would love to see more as we are never in the city and have worked so hard to minimise our plastic and single use consumption. From what I hear it's doing well but there is easy access to parking. I'm a member of several groups on fb etc and that would be the key to getting your services known.
Some other things to consider are the type of footfall (so is it a shopping route or more bars and restaurants for example)

Hygiene, work in advance with Environmental health to see what will be required then there's no nasty surprises.

If you are working with a contractor for pest control ensure they have the right credentials or do your own course and record how you have followed protocol.

Financially you will take a big hit but make sure to keep records and get a good accountant knowledgable in small businesses.

Do as much prep in advance so business plan, how accounts and stock controls will work, stock rotation, best place to buy wholesale (surprising differences) how you will cover emergencies etc

BikeRunSki · 31/07/2019 09:50

There are independent shops closing all over the place in my village! £42K pt sounds like a good deal, I’d stick with that.

Solongtoshort · 31/07/2019 09:46

I read Tesco or Sainsbury’s are running a trail doing this. Sorry to be the bring dad news.

Kidworries · 31/07/2019 09:45

Check business rates before anything else. And check if you can get reduced rates. Depending on the council and the size of the property you might get small rate relief which is a reduced rate or rate releif which means no rates but if it's over a certain size then you pay the full amount. Rates are what kill most businesses.

Check the population.
You will need contents insurance.
Check the lease if it is full repair lease or if the landlord is responsible for repairs
Get yourself a good accountant and solicitor.
Check energy suppliers and water
Internet/phone
Waste disposal. You will need to organise this.
The landlord may charge a service charge and building insurance payments.
If you need stock delivered check the delivery van can get to a point to deliver. I.e back door. Is there room to drive to the back door etc

If its anything to do with eating inside i.e a cafe etc then you need specific toilets/disabled tpilet. You need to check with the council regarding their requirements.

Also if food you need to meet hygeine standards.
If you need extractor fans etc then you need planning permission and if it doesn't have the correct use on the building you may need to apply for change of use.

Too many things but if you are committed and can afford it then go for it

Sparadrap · 31/07/2019 09:40

Could you employ someone part time to run your shop while you are working at your lucrative part time job? You could work in the shop late afternoons and weekends until it takes off.

Another alternative is to run it (possibly part time) from a van. We have one that follows the farmers markets round the area. They are called Incredible Bulk if you want to look them up.

I’d be very wary of setting up anything too risky for the next few years though. I agree with others that it looks like supermarkets are going to be doing more of this. But conversely there are going to be a lot of people with less disposable income over the next few years. Food prices are set to rise and so you need to do a lot of research into wholesalers and how affluent your area is.

Good luck with it all x

Weezol · 31/07/2019 09:38

Are you prepared to work at least sixty hours a week for, if you're lucky, minimum wage for a year? That's the reality of a new business.

I suggest you try and find some retail/bar work alongside your current job. Do that for a year, save like mad and then revisit your idea.

Bellasblankexpression · 31/07/2019 09:37

Starting as a market stand as previous poster suggested might be a really good idea OP to test out the market?

Lilyofthefields · 31/07/2019 09:34

Thanks @WhataLovelyPear I have set up and lead a couple of worthy endeavours, I play in an informal Netball league and I am a minor player in a large local dance/social scene.

Well, thanks for the feedback everyone. I asked for advice and I got it - kindly and honestly in most cases. The main hurdle are the local demographics and competition I think. I realise that it's a case of IABU. RIP Weigh To Go

OP posts:
Sindragosan · 31/07/2019 09:34

There is a zero waste shop in a town near me, but it's in the posh area of town, on a street with good footfall, and a 'nice' set of shops including fishmonger, butcher, deli etc. Its in the kind of area where people have enough disposable income and time to consider environmental impact and its fashionable around here to be going plastic free with your fancy reusable cup and so on.

Sadly, ethics cost money and time, and I can't see a shop that costs more doing well if people in the general area are counting every penny.

Rivkka · 31/07/2019 09:31

I think if you focus on purely the environmental aspect it might do okay but I think your market needs to be wealthier people. Not like the old days where it was cheap but more for those it's a higher disposable income upping to pay more to cut out plastic.

Location will be the key to success or fail.

Students only want cheap so don't target them.

gingersausage · 31/07/2019 09:28

I don’t see how it will work in a student area. Students mostly can’t be arsed. Even the ones who start the term with lofty ideas of cooking are living on Pot Noodle and Dominoes by January.

WhataLovelyPear · 31/07/2019 09:27

My advice is don't do it. A better option would be to address the lack of purpose in your life first. Your part-time job gives you security, so don't throw that away. Start finding things to do in the time when you are not working: volunteer at a hospice or the local hospital, volunteer for a befriending scheme, take up a new sport.
The shop sounds like a high risk attempt to fix the aimlessness, but if you chuck in your job and the shop fails, you'll feel even worse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread