Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Irlen syndrome is a load of rubbish?

120 replies

GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 19:04

My daughter finds writing really difficult and her school have a dyslexia testing kit, which suggests she is dyslexic (not an official diagnosis).

They have also determined she has something called Irlen syndrome or 'visual stress' which can be alleviated by using green tinted transparent plastic overlays on anything she is reading. The SENCO and various support staff have recommended I have her eyes tested by an Irlen specialist who can provide her some special tinted plastic glasses in just the right colour for her. Given that this is quite pricey and not available on the NHS I did a bit of research on the internet before going ahead. A recent meta-analysis of the data found 'no evidence of treatment effectiveness has been achieved'. It seems any positive effect is placebo.

www.researchgate.net/publication/332205658_Irlen_syndrome_systematic_review_and_level_of_evidence_analysis

And an article in the BMJ saying similar www.bmj.com/bmj/section-pdf/763087?path=/bmj/349/7972/Views_Reviews.full.pdf

I'm not a scientist and maybe I am missing something, but it seems wrong they are pushing an expensive treatment with no evidence to support it's efficacy. I have raised it with the head, but he thinks they are right and I am wrong.

OP posts:
underneaththeash · 01/07/2019 20:48

Behavioural optometry has some overlaps with Irlens/patten glare/scotopic sensitivity but it’s more to do with exercises. It’s not available on the NHS and also doesn’t have a very strong evidence base behind it. But, again does work for some people.

Foxyloxy1plus1 · 01/07/2019 20:40

I agree with SadOtter. If your child feels it helps, then it helps, but I wouldn’t spend money on expensive glasses unless and until you are sure that the overlay is really useful.

What will be useful is ensuring that there is the facility for her to have the support she needs for exams. That might mean extra time, a scribe or use of a computer instead of hand writing.

terraform · 01/07/2019 20:34

I got referred for Irlens testing by occupational health at my work and I went along with it just to tick a box as basically I thought it was a load of tosh based on the reading I'd done. I did a timed reading test with / without a coloured overlay and was something like 23% faster (the 2 texts were just a load of jumbled words with standardised difficulty). It actually makes a massive difference, I was so surprised!

I feel like an idiot wearing purple glasses at work and only wear them when there's nobody around. It has really improved my reading rate and reduced eye strain though.

ravenshope · 01/07/2019 20:34

I guess it might not show improvement in reading speed, but could improve eye muscle pain and discomfort, stress from trying to make the letters stop moving etc?
For me, the visual relief is what is important.

SadOtter · 01/07/2019 20:27

I use purple overlays, they help me, it stops my eyes hurting and the headaches, same way as wearing sunglasses on a bright day does. I did have tinted glasses but have to say they weren't actually worth the cost and annoyed me, because they made everything purple tinted not just the writing.

If the overlays work that's great but I wouldn't personally be paying for eye tests and glasses until you know if the novelty of the overlays is going to wear off and if they are actually making a difference (I've worked with a few children who just wanted coloured paper and said it was helping when there was no improvement in their work at all and they got bored of it after a few weeks) if you were planning to fork out for any testing I would prioritise getting an official diagnosis for the dyslexia as that would mean extra time in exams, extra support etc, which is a lot more useful than coloured lenses.

GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 20:26

@Chloe9 the only thing I found about funding for Irlen syndrome treatment on the NHS says it will not be funded because 'no scientific evidence to support the existence of such a syndrome has been found.'

and

'Two review papers and a randomised prospective controlled trial on the effect of tinted lenses on reading ability did not show significant improvement in reading.'

www.enhertsccg.nhs.uk/sites/default/files/documents/Jun2017/Guidance%2037%20-%20Mears-Irlen%20Lens%20Syndrome.pdf

OP posts:
Squeakymoo · 01/07/2019 20:21

I had my child assessed for dyslexia at Bloomfield Learning Centre in London - this wasn't offered by the school at the time so we paid privately. Once we had the assessment they also recommended that teachers write on the white board in purple rather than blue or black, this helped the writing from moving or becoming fuzzy - this was met with negativity from some teachers who stated they didn't have a purple whiteboard pen - so even though pens were provided by the school my child took them to all lessons so the teachers couldn't use this as an excuse. Hopefully these small things (that don't affect the learning of other pupils) are better taught to teachers now. At the time my child encountered quite a few issues with certain teachers who couldn't or wouldn't accommodate small changes and treated my child either like an imbecile and talking down to her or by brushing her off - luckily she is quite feisty and was able to stand up for herself and potentially other pupils and state clearly and repeatedly that changing the colour of the whiteboard pen didn't affect the learning of any pupils and could assist her and potentially others. She also had a lilac overlay and was allowed to write her homework in purple pen and to change the background and font colour on any computer - they did have to be changed back at the end of each lesson but we also got a laptop supplied which she could use. I don't really care if it is considered claptrap I just know it helped her and also made her stronger by repeatedly and sometimes forcibly telling teachers that changing colour didn't change anything else in the curriculum.

SolsticeBabyMaybe · 01/07/2019 20:20

It's pretty obvious to people who have it that it's real! So if these things help people who actually have it - that's what matters surely? Not whether it SOUNDS strange to people who don't understand it?

BTW when they tested me for this (IQ test for suspected dyslexia) I didn't know scotopic sensitivity was a thing, or know the relevance of the overlay tests etc so no reason for me to have any 'placebo'

GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 20:18

IdaDown, the ed psych that works at her school doesn't assess dyslexia, they don't have time, they have more urgent matters to attend to. DD does get extra help with her writing, she has difficulty with hand writing, spelling and copying things out. I try to help her at home to practice writing, I'm not sure how much good any of it does.

Thank you for the links bigKiteFlying, I will check them out.

OP posts:
SolsticeBabyMaybe · 01/07/2019 20:13

@Shoppingwithmother I was talking to the poster who said 'it sounds a bit woo-ish' - even after all the other posters talking about personal experiences of having it.

bluebluezoo · 01/07/2019 20:07

My rule of thumb is if the NHS don’t fund it, it’s because it hasn’t been proven or there is no good evidence to suggest whatever treatment is better than any existing.

It may be, as pp have said, the nhs don’t fund the glasses as a sheet of green paper is equally effective.

But the NHS do (or should) constantly review their treatment protocols and best practice. Whether funding allows that is a different matter, of course.

bigKiteFlying · 01/07/2019 20:06

She had green pads to write on and she find writing equally difficult on green or white backgrounds.

Is it hand writing - then look at right from the start or if older speed up - slopes and pens and grips can also help.

If it's spelling - apple and pears

We did tend to find it could end up with we do this group/intervention so all all problems we encounter look like this solution rather than looking what the specific problem with our child was - though that could just be our children's schools.

IdaDown · 01/07/2019 20:06

It is completely inappropriate for an unqualified person to offer an armchair diagnosis. This can lead down the wrong or narrow diagnostic path.

The on-line tests are also not appropriate to diagnose.

If staff suspect your DD of having a learning difficulty, then your best course of action would be to find an Ed Psych who is qualified to test, score and diagnose.
Or, a Clinical Psych with specialty in SpLDs.

Your DD could have a number of difficulties ie

  • dyslexia - would benefit from dys friendly font and spacing amongst other measures
  • tracking issues - would need to see a behavioural optometrist
  • poor muscle tone in hands
  • dyspraxia
  • other medical condition etc...

An appropriate qualified professional is key.

Shoppingwithmother · 01/07/2019 20:06

I wouldn’t call it ignorance, Solstice - the whole point of the thread is questioning the scientific validity of something. Surely it is more “ignorant” to unquestioningly accept something for which there is little evidence?

Chloe9 · 01/07/2019 20:05

I got Irlen glasses on the NHS nearly 2 decades ago. I had the coloured overlays etc. They stopped funding it because it's expensive not because it's not real.

Talcott2007 · 01/07/2019 20:03

And again - if my personal experience was just a placebo effect - I don't really care - it worked for me. It's just coloured plastic sheets/or tinted lenses in glasses. Can't do any harm to explore it

Talcott2007 · 01/07/2019 20:01

This is a real thing - I actually have it - it was called scotopic sensitivity syndrome when I was a child. Diagnosed by an optician initially after I told my DM that the reason I refused to read or do any work at school about how words were moving and running away from me (she thought I might have a brain tumour with all all the strange stuff I was saying I was seeing) I ended up with pink filters a few months later (pretty sure she went down the private route to get this sorted so quickly) and went from being assessed as having a reading age of under 3 years to a reading age of 11 years in the space of a term. Now I am just one person so I can't comment on mass studies by it completely changed my life. I avent actively thought about it for years and dont wear filters now because I have learnt to see through the condition but it's still their especially if I am tired. PM me if you have any questions.

Birdsfoottrefoil · 01/07/2019 20:00

I had more sympathy for homeopathy after reading Ben Goldacres book - I have no doubt that it is a placebo effect (and some regression to mean) but the placebo effect is a real effect (still don’t think the NHS should spend money on it). You do feel better if you take a placebo vs nothing, even if you know it is a placebo. So coloured overlays may be both a real and a placebo effect. Don’t spend much money on it though.

ravenshope · 01/07/2019 19:57

This is how I see text:
www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=irlen+syndrome+simulation

Yorkshiremum17 · 01/07/2019 19:57

My son is dyslexic and has good and bad days reading. On bad days a yellow overlay just helps to stop the words moving around. He doesn't need it all the time, but on days he's tired it really helps. As mum to a kid that struggles, I don't care what the science days, the overlays help and if it makes it easier for him then he can have one. He refused glasses as he doesn't need them all the time.

SolsticeBabyMaybe · 01/07/2019 19:52

Wow, some ignorance here!

It's not 'woo'. I have it!

I never actually got any overlays or anything (diagnosed at uni) but the difference between reading text printed on pure white paper, and coloured paper/older books is massive. When I am stressed/under pressure, I try and read but all I can see is bright coloured lights around the letters on the page. Changing the background/printing stuff in colour/changing to dyslexic fonts are the only things that help with this.

ravenshope · 01/07/2019 19:52

As someone with Irlen's, it certainly isn't a load of rubbish.
From what I've understood, there may be a lack of research into treatment options but that doesn't mean the condition doesn't exist.
The NHS eye clinic I attend acknowledges the existence of Irlen's. It's considered a neurological rather than an eye issue I think.

bigKiteFlying · 01/07/2019 19:52

We looked for research papers and found it all a bit sparse and unconvincing -few years ago.

DD1 first primary suggested this - they did a test decide she was better with one colour which they ten didn't have any of and just gave her a red strip.

Still I was keen to try anything that might help - so tried different coloured backgrounds and overlays. The overlay strips did have big black line and we eventually concluded it was that that was helping.

We then move on to eye exercise – which again not sure they did a hell of a lot.

Think best thing was more phonic practise -and the program dancing bears that had a blue piece of card with cut out corner which meant just the word being read was visible.

Stressedout10 · 01/07/2019 19:47

Sorry she not he

GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 19:47

Yes, my daughter does use the overlays for reading, I don't mind that. Her reading is fine with or without them though. She had green pads to write on and she find writing equally difficult on green or white backgrounds. I don't think the school should be advocating spending a lot of money on expensive eye exams and glasses if studies show they don't work.

OP posts: