Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Irlen syndrome is a load of rubbish?

120 replies

GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 19:04

My daughter finds writing really difficult and her school have a dyslexia testing kit, which suggests she is dyslexic (not an official diagnosis).

They have also determined she has something called Irlen syndrome or 'visual stress' which can be alleviated by using green tinted transparent plastic overlays on anything she is reading. The SENCO and various support staff have recommended I have her eyes tested by an Irlen specialist who can provide her some special tinted plastic glasses in just the right colour for her. Given that this is quite pricey and not available on the NHS I did a bit of research on the internet before going ahead. A recent meta-analysis of the data found 'no evidence of treatment effectiveness has been achieved'. It seems any positive effect is placebo.

www.researchgate.net/publication/332205658_Irlen_syndrome_systematic_review_and_level_of_evidence_analysis

And an article in the BMJ saying similar www.bmj.com/bmj/section-pdf/763087?path=/bmj/349/7972/Views_Reviews.full.pdf

I'm not a scientist and maybe I am missing something, but it seems wrong they are pushing an expensive treatment with no evidence to support it's efficacy. I have raised it with the head, but he thinks they are right and I am wrong.

OP posts:
WombatStewForTea · 01/07/2019 21:59

I'm a teacher. Recently (in the past 5 years) I've taught four children diagnosed with Irlens.
All I have is anecdotal evidence, but since using overlays/coloured paper/glasses (and these chn have used all or a mixure - and not all have the glasses) all children have made massive amounts of progress and gone from working below age related expectations to working at age related expectations from diagnosis to end of KS2 or maybe its just my amazing teaching?? Seeing as there's no evidence

Balcanoona · 01/07/2019 21:57

as long as it works who cares?

because "it works" is opinion and anecdote.

If your child benefits from an overlay, that's good. But Irlens is a commercial company with vested financial interest in pushing diagnosis. All companies want to get into schools - because you have a captive audience of millions who will do anything to help their child. Why do you think microsoft and apple offer education editions? because once you hook the child, you as a company are set for life. And as a teacher I get angry that parents are being offered a "solution" to what may be a far more complex issue. Or, no issue at all.

GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 21:56

The other thing is that most people seem to be using the glasses and overlays for reading, my daughter doesn't have a problem with reading, just writing.

OP posts:
GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 21:55

BishopBrennansArse I will repeat, again, my daughter uses green overlays and paper, they cost as you say a few pounds, I don't mind, I bought her green overlays for home. The school want me spend £100 on getting her eyes tested by an Irlen specialist and the resulting glasses. I have not once used the words 'woo' or 'bunkum'.

OP posts:
Flaskfan · 01/07/2019 21:51

I often wonder whether I skim read because of irlen's. I struggle reading slowly, so have to.kind of run.with the words. I have a blue or sepia background on devices and I can feel my eyes relax into it. Old, tatty books are better than shiny white ones for me.

I do have massive problems with glare and get ocular migraines. So I think it's more of a brain thing. My spelling's always been spot on. Handwriting is...challenging.

BishopBrennansArse · 01/07/2019 21:47

Has anyone said spend hundreds of pounds? You've had suggestions of using coloured paper and overlays which cost a few pounds. I can understand not going for full testing but calling it all woo and bunkum when suggestions costing a couple of quid have been made?

Serialweightwatcher · 01/07/2019 21:46

My son is dyslexic and was diagnosed by an opthamologist when he was about 8 years old as having Irlen's - at every appointment he was asked to read a mixture of words (not sentences so he couldn't guess) and was so slow and unsure - as soon as the lady put the overlay on the paper he read it like he was on stage and me and DH couldn't believe what we were seeing. We didn't bother with the glasses as they were far too expensive and she said they weren't totally necessary as long as he continued to use his overlay - unfortunately his dyslexia isn't great and he won't accept help because he's too embarrassed and also stopped using his overlay when he started High School for the same reason, but it is definitely a thing

BishopBrennansArse · 01/07/2019 21:45

Irlens isn't one of the things my kids have, but each has multiple complex needs.

To be fair if something helps them it helps them, I go with it. I don't care if people think it's woo or bunkum if it helps it helps.... I don't go around sniping about scientific studies I just as a parent want to help my kids.

But if causing a ruck is your bag instead, OP, why not start a thread like yours where you're critical of absolutely everything other than science?

Missingthesea · 01/07/2019 21:44

My DGD is diagnosed dyslexic and she finds that a blue overlay works best for her in making the letters sharper, even though she's a girl......

PookieDo · 01/07/2019 21:44

Just reading this I am seriously wondering if an overlay would help me. I have always just thought because I have astigmatism and am very short sighted that struggling to read text was just part of that
I have taken to changing my laptop and phone screen to an orange colour (not many options) so I can read things! I ask the optician every time and no one really tells me what this is! I always struggled to read numbers, I also struggle with anything that is lines as they jump out at me and really confuse my eyes Confused

GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 21:41

I'm not dismissing placebo out of hand, I just don't want to spend 100's of pounds on it!

OP posts:
Jetstream · 01/07/2019 21:37

I am dyslexic and although I’ve no reading problems when I am tired words jump around the page. Also, black print on a white background can give me a ‘rivers and streams’ problem. I learned about it from my sister who was studying print media at the time. It happens when the spacing between words and sentences seem to be huge, making it harder to read.
I’d a dyslexic classmate who wore tinted glasses as he found it hard to read. The words used to fall off the page, he’d a memory to die for and even the lecturers were jealous of hs mental abilities.

LittleWalnutTree · 01/07/2019 21:36

There are many studies which show that placebos actually do work so don't dismiss the placebo effect out of hand.

As long as it works, who cares?

bigKiteFlying · 01/07/2019 21:28

The optician had observed that he was struggling with tracking and picking up letters from other lines

I do think that was an issue for DD1 - as I said a line under the sentence or the card with corner out used by dancing bears definitely helped DD1.

If you can afford a private ed psych report might be worth it – dysgraphia, dyslexia and dyspraxia are all options but knowing the actual underlying problems would be very helpful. It was always too expensive for us quotes we got were £450 to £600.

We’ve spent a of time on fun activities to strengthen muscle control – beads, clay – cutting – the primary board was a huge source of information when we needed it a few years ago.

The slope was a game changer for DS -few years later he no longer needs it – DD1 still grips too tightly so it's still ongoing process of slow improvements.

IncyWincyGrownUp · 01/07/2019 21:27

For what it’s worth, she has a full dyslexia diagnosis too, and the practitioner who did that recommended the visual stress clinic as another port of call to help my child’s brain make sense of the information being sent to it by the eyes.

Nanamilly · 01/07/2019 21:27

Also, Isleepinahedgefund why do you think I started this thread if not to explore it?

I suspect you deliberately started it to cause a rammy.

IncyWincyGrownUp · 01/07/2019 21:26

My daughter has had her assessments through the NHS, and will receive her colorimetry testing through them too.

You might think it’s bollocks, but it’s bollocks that works for a lot of people.

GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 21:16

I think the problem is as Balcanoona says anecdotes are not data, and the data I have found suggests coloured overlays and glasses don't work (other than as a placebo). I agree with the pp who suggested my money would be better spent on a dyslexia or possible dyspraxia diagnosis.

OP posts:
GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 21:09

Also, Isleepinahedgefund why do you think I started this thread if not to explore it?

OP posts:
GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 21:07

Tawdrylocalbrouhaha you haven't misunderstood.

Isleepinahedgefund if you had read my previous post you would have seen that my dd uses green overlays and paper (not that it makes any difference). According to Irlen syndrome theory (invented by Helen Irlen) can't just buy glasses in your preferred overlay colour, you need a different colour for the glasses which requires assessment by a trained Irlen practitioner.

OP posts:
SudowoodoVoodoo · 01/07/2019 21:05

DS finds coloured glasses and paper very useful. We've only just had the dyslexia and dyspraxia identified since the start of the financial year after he turned 8, but when in y2, his teacher did some initial checks with overlays then we went to the optician.

Halfway through y2, my very bright, astute child was still limping his way through stage 3 books. His teacher couldn't believe the transformation as when a certain colour was placed on the page and he suddenly read fluently for the first time. The overlays allowed her to bump him up two levels straight away and moving on quickly again.

We'd already been to the opticians a couple of times, after he failed the pre-school screening, and in y1 when he couldn't read the board. Both times and at a routine check since, there is nothing "wrong" with his eyes. The optician had observed that he was struggling with tracking and picking up letters from other lines (and presumably had with the pictures at the pre-school check.)

He can cope better in the absence of the tints now, but he has that experience of knowing what letters look like which is a greater advantage in decoding than he had before.

He has a lot of sensory issues anyway and anything that helps him manage life and the education system is a good thing. Getting him up to an age appropriate standard as quickly as possible is a good investment towards his future sucess rather than struggling for years and accruing additional problems with his self esteem.

Balcanoona · 01/07/2019 20:57

www.abc.net.au/news/2019-06-26/irlen-syndrome-medical-eye-condition-controversy/11218184 don't forget a whole range of dodgy ideas have made their way into schools by so called experts - my favourite being "brain gym" which recommended breathing through the nose because it's closer to the brain and oxygen will arrive faster (um .... lungs, then blood ....)

Isleepinahedgefund · 01/07/2019 20:56

I have Irlen syndrome.

But yeah - why would you explore something that might help your dd?

You don't have to pay for the assessment, which is expensive. School will have the overlay sample pack. She can pick her preferred colour/s. You can buy the glasses in a range of colours pretty cheaply now.

Biggest issue i had was computer screens - I get migraines from most monitors/laptop screens. Getting a work laptop with an extremely high pixel density genuinely changed my life.

But yeah - it's all made up 🙄 I feel sorry for your DD that you're not even willing to explore it.

Nice to see posts from so many fellow Irlens!

Tawdrylocalbrouhaha · 01/07/2019 20:54

OP do you mean the school have said their tests indicate your DD has dyslexia, but they aren't going to pursue that? And they have advised you to pursue an expensive Irlens diagnosis, while leaving the probable dyslexia undiagnosed?

I'm hoping I've misunderstood!

Balcanoona · 01/07/2019 20:52

The danger with Irlens is that it could mask a more serious underlying order, does not prepare students for life beyond the classroom, is diagnosed by people with a vested interest (ie they're selling the overlays) and is not evidence based. Anecdotes are not data. They are stories. Feeling good about helping someone by giving them an overlay is about as selfish as it can get. I teach, I work in a school where 10% of the kids were diagnosed with Irlens, and strangely boys never wanted pink overlays, and girls never wanted blue. And funnily enough, children who demand their worksheets printed in orange or purple never remember to bring their overlays and oddly, can read their phones and computers just fine. Its bollocks pushed by someone who wants to make money by exploiting parents who are desperate from help for their children.