Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Irlen syndrome is a load of rubbish?

120 replies

GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 19:04

My daughter finds writing really difficult and her school have a dyslexia testing kit, which suggests she is dyslexic (not an official diagnosis).

They have also determined she has something called Irlen syndrome or 'visual stress' which can be alleviated by using green tinted transparent plastic overlays on anything she is reading. The SENCO and various support staff have recommended I have her eyes tested by an Irlen specialist who can provide her some special tinted plastic glasses in just the right colour for her. Given that this is quite pricey and not available on the NHS I did a bit of research on the internet before going ahead. A recent meta-analysis of the data found 'no evidence of treatment effectiveness has been achieved'. It seems any positive effect is placebo.

www.researchgate.net/publication/332205658_Irlen_syndrome_systematic_review_and_level_of_evidence_analysis

And an article in the BMJ saying similar www.bmj.com/bmj/section-pdf/763087?path=/bmj/349/7972/Views_Reviews.full.pdf

I'm not a scientist and maybe I am missing something, but it seems wrong they are pushing an expensive treatment with no evidence to support it's efficacy. I have raised it with the head, but he thinks they are right and I am wrong.

OP posts:
Shoppingwithmother · 02/07/2019 09:21

My concern is that all parties involved have something to gain from Irlens being “a thing.”

The children get extra time in exams etc, which gives them an advantage over their peers of similar academic ability.

The parents prefer to believe that their child has a “syndrome” rather than they are just not very good at academic work.

The practitioners make a lot of money from the high fees they charge from unnecessary tests and coloured glasses.

It seems very easy to get a diagnosis and in some schools it’s becoming almost an arms race. If a lot of your friends suddenly do better in their exams because they have half an hour longer to do it than you do, then you will want the coloured glasses and extra time too.

I don’t think schools should go along with this based on evidence which is flimsy at best.

Nanny0gg · 02/07/2019 08:57

It wasn't that long ago that dyslexia wasn't a 'real' thing either and many LAs didn't recognise it.

ravenshope · 02/07/2019 08:57

My tinted glasses are from an "intuitive calorimeter" not Irlen's per se. I got them years ago and for the test and lenses (they are varifocals), it cost £400. They are now the wrong prescription but still better than the right prescription non-tinted. I can't afford new ones.

ravenshope · 02/07/2019 08:55

lljkk
I magnify the page so the text is way bigger. I turn down the brightness and I wear tinted glasses. The words still move about and I miss/misread stuff but it's good enough.

GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 23:47

Thank you for the link parietal the article concludes;

'it is unethical to continue to promote and offer this as a treatment. The burden rests heavily on proponents to conduct large rigorous studies if they wish to persist in their claims, and then to abide by the results of those studies.

Otherwise Irlen syndrome (by its various names) will continue to exist as a medical zombie, alongside homeopathy, psychomotor patterning, acupuncture, subluxation theory, and other unkillable nonsense.'

This sums up my concerns.

OP posts:
parietal · 01/07/2019 23:29

here is a scientific assessment on Irlen syndrome

sciencebasedmedicine.org/irlen-syndrome/

(tweeted by the great Dorothy Bishop the other day, who is an authority on pseudoscience in developmental disorders).

GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 23:20

Soontobe60 My daughter had the screening you mention. Sounds like she won't be able to get an assessment in her new school either. If parents get a diagnosis privately will be school be able tailor interventions to the diagnosis? My daughter gets extra help with spelling and maths ATM.

I can see that the overlays really are helpful to lots of people here. For my daughter I really don't see any difference to her reading when she is using hers.

OP posts:
Littlebird88 · 01/07/2019 23:13

In scotland mears irlen syndrome is a recognised condition using evidenced based practice in the nhs.
overlays and glasses paid for by the nhs.

lljkk · 01/07/2019 23:09

Those of you with Irlens, how do you read MN threads ok? I find if I invert colours on screen then too many other things look awful, become impossible to use. But otherwise, MN is very start black on start white. It's glaring for sure.

Soontobe60 · 01/07/2019 23:04

My daughter has had her assessments through the NHS, and will receive her colorimetry testing through them too.
Which NHS area are you in? In my area, the NHS will not fund this, it's a private appointment through a trained optician only.

OP, in most local authorities, educational psychologists are not able to test for dyslexia. As a Senco I can screen for risk of dyslexia, and sold then base interventions on the results. Far too many parents think that if their child is slow to read, they are dyslexic. They may just have a moderate learning difficulty which will affect their learning across all subjects.

Boopeedoop · 01/07/2019 23:03

My daughter has it. Was diagnosed aged 7. She is classed as severe. The glasses have been worth every penny so I think yabvvu. She went from the reading age of a 5 year old to the reading age of an adult within a term after getting the glasses. She can't make out stairs without her glasses. She can't use an escalator or walk in a straight line.
Constantly spilling things.

They've helped her in no end of ways. I didn't even know that she used to feel nauseous and get a headache watching TV. She thought everyone felt like that until she started using her glasses.

The full irlen test takes hours. It's intense. They try many combinations of colours to find just the right shade. They aren't just tinted, they have UV filters too. And when she looks through them, she doesn't see tint at all. They are as clear as normal glass. White is white, blue is blue. I look through them and see everything tinted in the colour of the lense.

IncyWincyGrownUp · 01/07/2019 23:02

Irlens isn’t the be all and end all. They’re the noisiest private company, but visual stress is the generic term and can be treated within the NHS if your PCT has a department or you’re willing to try to be referred to one that does.

The only cost we will incur for my daughter’s glasses is if she chooses a frame that will need a bit of extra paying for - the same as if she was just having standard glasses made and just fancied something a bit more fancy. The testing, the colorimetry, and the lens tinting will all be free from the clinic.

Walkaround · 01/07/2019 22:46

Ps you are describing a child with a lot of the symptoms of dyspraxia.

Walkaround · 01/07/2019 22:41

GherkinTherapy - I would save your money for a proper assessment by an educational psychologist. The LA ED Psych will be refusing to assess all sorts of children who would benefit from it, because they will be focusing on the most severe cases only. You can bet a thorough Ed Psych report would give you a lot of useful info.

Woodman03 · 01/07/2019 22:40

My son was diagnosed at 11 now 17, we went up to I think from memory Durham university to see a professor who was doing research. First off they gave him passages to read and measured how many words he could read in 1 minute they did this several times and got an average. They then repeated the exercise with different overlays, (different pieces of text) many times with varying shades. It was dramatic the difference it made his average with no overlays was 38 words per minute with the optimum shades of overlay he was reading 76 words per minute. He described it without the overlay the words were floating around the overlay stopped this. We then took this information to a local opticians that specialised in Irlen they did their own test and came up with the same conclusion. We bought these optimised glasses I think including the test it came to about £300 his latest pair were about £175 as we didn’t go through all the testing.
A fashion conscious 17 year old wouldn’t wear these coloured glasses unless hey gave a real benefit. His school work fell into place once he had the glasses, primary school excluded him from sats now doing A levels.

BishopBrennansArse · 01/07/2019 22:40

If you don't think the extra expense is necessary don't do it, but don't dismiss the entire thing just because you don't want to spend the money.

bigKiteFlying · 01/07/2019 22:39

While I'd do apple and pears first - they have placement tests though mine all started near start of book 1 which was a shock and you need to buy both the teacher book and work book.

Spelling Made Easy series by violet Brand might also be worth a look. Currently using Remedial Spelling to try and find and plug where the current holes are - and red hot roots is also useful longer term.

GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 22:33

Yes, dysgraphia is certainly possible, she also has a lot difficulty with learning sequences like days of the week, and with maths. She is excellent at learning lines (for drama). She really struggled to learn to ride her bike and after years of swimming lessons still can't really swim, but is excellent at climbing!

OP posts:
Walkaround · 01/07/2019 22:31

Well, it stands to reason coloured overlays won't help all people with dyslexia. If you're bothered by what experts think, plenty of experts think the term dyslexia is unhelpful, anyway, because the term covers such a wide range of symptoms and probable causes (and thus no one effective method to help improve all the possible symptoms). As such, if you find coloured overlays do not help your dd, then don't bother with expensive testing for tinted glasses, as it is likely to be a pointless waste of time for you, but also don't poo poo the idea for others for whom it may actually work. There is enough evidence that some people find coloured overlays genuinely helpful.
As a matter of interest, why have they settled on green overlay for your dd? Is that the colour they had lying around? And if that isn't working, why are they pushing for you to spend money on glasses?

BrightonBB · 01/07/2019 22:29

Extra time in Exams should NOT be given. However, it is possible to have the Exams copied on to coloured paper (both the question booklet and the answer booklet) as long as it is the Normal Way of Working.

mynameisMrG · 01/07/2019 22:28

@GherkinTherapy if your DD is struggling more with writing than reading is it possible she has dysgraphia rather than dyslexia?

GherkinTherapy · 01/07/2019 22:27

I think it is the ed psych rather than the school who is unwilling to assess. We are moving over the summer and she will be starting a new school, if they are unwilling to assess her maybe we need to save up to get a private assessment.

Thanks you for all the links bigKiteFlying I'm looking at them all, they are very helpful.

OP posts:
IdaDown · 01/07/2019 22:17

Gerkin - if your DD has a SpLD or related condition, it is vital to have an assessment.

  • to find out if / what, your DD has.
  • it’s severity
  • action plan for DD / you / teachers to follow, to improve & help DD’s learning. The recommendations will form part of a formal assessment report.
  • ensure accommodations are in place long before exams

If you rely on the goodwill of teachers and no official diagnosis then you have no formal framework. You can’t ‘insist’ the teachers follow specific teaching modifications in class or accomodations in exams.
And you run the risk of implementing useless or poor aids in the hope they may help.

I’m with Tawdry - I’d be very concerned that school think your DD has a learning difficulty and are unprepared to formally assess, whilst asking you to spend £ on what should be part of a larger assessment.

bigKiteFlying · 01/07/2019 22:11

I've been properly diagnosed with dyslexia and dyspraxia and even when tired words don't jump around on page or merge.

I know other people with similar diagnosis who do have that issue – so I have no problem believing either their experiences of the conditions differ to mine or there’s something else they have I don’t.

We tried coloured overlays with DD1 they made no difference - we did research and there wasn't a lot of strong evidence for it – so at that point we moved on to other options.

So I’m with GherkinTherapy I’d be a bit dubious that I was being expected to pay out of my pocket for further testing on something that doesn't seem to be having any effect on my child and isn’t supported by strong research data.

www.spelfabet.com.au/ - it’s Australian with aussi spelling and sounding but there lots of info about reading and writing problems
www.spelfabet.com.au/2018/06/dyslexie-font-coloured-overlays-and-irlen-syndrome/ –
www.spelfabet.com.au/2016/10/controversial-dyslexia-therapies/

The work books were useful to DD1 as well.

confusednorthner · 01/07/2019 22:10

My ds In in yr 6, all through school he struggled with writing and reading. The headteacher was convinced he was dyslexic by year 4 but had no funds apparently to test fully so we went for a private screening. It was the screener who said he wasn't dyslexic but suggested there was a Irlens/ visual stress issue and recommended Irlens east. Think we paid £40 for a initial screening and he started using a overlay and coloured paper. I'll never forget him using overlay first time and hearing" oh the words aren't joined together "! School were amazed at improvements and we initially had coleromety glasses from local optician which helped as well but he's now got the Irlens lenses which he loves. I'll admit I did wonder if it would be worth it but without them he can't read the board or a car number plate put them on and he can.
Completely uninitiated by me dd was tested at school and they've supplied her with overlays and coloured paper, her handwriting has improved dramatically...
I can understand people not getting it but if it works don't fight it! I know a friend who is completely against it and despite her ds school giving him a overlay she won't let him use it as she doesn't believe in it and doesn't want him labelled which is crazy!

Swipe left for the next trending thread