Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to have realised until now that Joey Maynard’s ‘displaced organ’ was a prolapse?

956 replies

QuaterMiss · 28/06/2019 09:08

I know there is or was an enormous Chalet School thread but I can’t spend six weeks trawling through that.

Fascinated to note (because I’ve been reading the complete synopses how all the CS women taken seriously ill either went straight to the San or journeyed - over days - for a consultation with Sir James Talbot. It was he who diagnosed said ‘displaced organ’. At which point Joey had iirc nine children. May be wrong, lost count.

(I read and reread the entire series over my first three decades.)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
PhilSwagielka · 30/07/2019 20:32

I headcanon Eustacia as autistic. That might be me projecting onto her though. I always thought she got a raw deal.

Doubleraspberry · 30/07/2019 20:01

I have decided that the books which do not contain people falling off precipices or into lakes or out of cable cars are v. dull.

Where do you stand on books in which someone falls backwards into a box and has to be sedated?

LaurieMarlow · 30/07/2019 19:56

I have decided that the books which do not contain people falling off precipices or into lakes or out of cable cars are v. dull.

So true Grin

I have also decided that Thekla was unfairly chucked out of the CS. She only stated that she hated Jo

She also ate raw bacon. I’m undecided which is a worse sin in the eyes of the school.

Jemima232 · 30/07/2019 18:54

I have decided that the books which do not contain people falling off precipices or into lakes or out of cable cars are v. dull.

I have also decided that Thekla was unfairly chucked out of the CS.

She only stated that she hated Jo Bettany.

Nothing wrong with that. But all the mistresses were so outraged that not only did Thekla hate Jo Bettany but had also got out of bed during the night which is against the school rules that there was nothing else for it.

Thekla had to go. The nasty little Prussian. She should not have aspired to the Chalet School anyway. Girls who cannot stay in their beds all night long without getting out in order to tell other girls that they hate Jo Bettany should have gone to St. Scholastika's.

Papergirl1968 · 30/07/2019 17:14

They are strangely addictive though.
I’ve almost finished Mystery but it is very short. Quite good though.

QuaterMiss · 30/07/2019 16:10

I’m not! I utterly refuse to collect any more possessions to fall in love with and inevitably, eventually lose. And, even now, I’m dipping into Althea (much sparkier than Two Sams, perhaps EBD was at a low point with the latter) when I ought to be doing something serious. I’ll be glad when I reach the end and can reclaim my life!

OP posts:
dottycat123 · 30/07/2019 12:49

On ebay currently there is a set of 29 hardback chalet school books, some with dust jackets and titles not reprinted by armarda. bidding is at £112 today, I expect they will go for much more. I am so tempted.

funnelfanjo · 30/07/2019 10:47

Yes, that seems very likely Doubleraspberry. It’s difficult to read the voice that she gave Eustacia with that thought in mind, but then this was nearly 90 years ago and thankfully things have moved on since then.

Doubleraspberry · 30/07/2019 09:56

I pick up exactly what you did, Funnel. My guess is that EBD encountered real life people like the original Eustacia and then fictionally ‘fixed’ one into Stacey.

funnelfanjo · 30/07/2019 08:12

Just reread what I wrote last night and wanted to clarify - Eustacia seemed to be written as someone on the spectrum might have been understood/presented at that time. It annoyed me that all her perceived character flaws were then fixed by an accident in EBDs typical plot device.

It annoyed my because a) it is an overused plot device and b) it seemed to imply autism is something you can and/or want to fix. And then I realised I was possibly being over sensitive, and maybe Eustacia was just written as someone with the self awareness of a brick wall.

Just a book funnel, just a book.

funnelfanjo · 29/07/2019 23:45

Just finished Eustacia. Was thinking - surely on the spectrum? Difficulty with social interactions and following rules at all times seem to punt in that direction. But then she has one of EBD’s regular accidents that miraculously change horrible people to be lovely, so no, she’s just the wrong un that the CS fixes that crops up in each book.

Maybe I’m reading them too fast, but I’m tiring of reading about continental children being trained to obedience from birth, and that girls need only aspire to be wives and mothers as soon as they leave school. Was that a middle class thing in the twenties and thirties? My own female ancestors were of more working class background but they all recognised that if you had the brains and/or luck to go to a good school, then you should grab the opportunity and make of yourself what you can.

Papergirl1968 · 29/07/2019 22:54

Feud, I mean!

Papergirl1968 · 29/07/2019 22:54

I just finished Fued. I enjoyed it, especially the starring role of the two cats. However the nativity play at the end went on for ever!

SchrodingersUnicorn · 29/07/2019 21:57

@Parker231 please could I have the dropbox details too please?
Double please there, terrible grammar but it's worth two pleases so I'm leaving them both!
I am so excited about this.

ScreamingValenta · 29/07/2019 20:51

I feel sorry for Blossom, getting told off for obeying an order.

Yes, that really annoyed me. She was supposed to have used her common sense to realise that Herr Laubach wouldn't be around in the afternoon. Imagine if he'd really sent for her, she hadn't turned up and she'd tried to use that as an excuse. She'd have been slain!

QuaterMiss · 29/07/2019 20:43

Nah ... I imagine most of us have read most, if not all, of the books - and their charm lies somewhere other than in cliffhangers about minor characters. It’s not the same as spoilering The Archers or Line of Duty!

OP posts:
Doubleraspberry · 29/07/2019 20:32

I just came to post apologies for what is actually a spoiler but I think it’s possibly hard to spoil Two Sams! Sorry nevertheless.

QuaterMiss · 29/07/2019 19:46

Thanks both! Grin Am battling on.

Have been reading that episode with Joey’s report of the driver’s death. Apparently it was all for the best because his mother had just died and he wasn’t close to anyone else ... HmmHmm

The thing with the names is just pants.

OP posts:
NewSchoolNewName · 29/07/2019 19:24

Two Sams is not one of the best ones IMO. I don’t recall Margot appearing much in that book.

It also has a terrible example of how to break bad news.

Nina, old Chalet School girl and piano genius, has been in a car crash. The driver of the other car dies (his first and last appearance in the books), and Jo is given the task of breaking the news to an injured Nina. And when Nina asks how the other driver is, Jo says “He is quite well now” Hmm Hmm Hmm

FFS, Jo!
If I were in Nina’s position, my response to that would have been along the lines of “what a relief, I was worried that he was badly hurt”.
But Nina’s faster at guessing Jo’s true meaning than I would have been in that situation.

Doubleraspberry · 29/07/2019 19:06

I’m not sure I ever bothered to reread Two Sams so this post comes to you from the 90s but I seem to remember it is unmitigated tosh, largely based on the bizarre premise that people with similar first names will be related.

Jins · 29/07/2019 18:15

I don’t see Winona Ryder playing Jo. She’s closer to my image of the Robin.

Amanda Hale perhaps

Flurgle · 29/07/2019 16:58

I loved those Pennington books.

TailsoftheManyPaws · 29/07/2019 13:38

No idea about the Chalet School chaps, but the 'young Patrick Pennington' is spot on!

Flurgle · 29/07/2019 12:53

Adult Jo- Winona Ryder?

QuaterMiss · 29/07/2019 12:48

Thanks, will look.

Does Two Sams get better? (Have forgotten the synopsis.) Ten pages in and I’m bored - there’s no pressing event or exciting character so I’m not seeing the point of its existence.

What I do want to hear about is Margot’s decision making process for her chosen career. If it’s not in this story I may move on to the next.

OP posts: